After leaving out the cinema, i cannot get this film out of my head Up: Return from the 2nd time, love it even more and still, can get it out of my head
@@krishpache7271 exactly. Bro was intimidating as hell. When he was telling the guys in the circle really specific details about them with the soundtrack BLASTING in the theater. Man it was GLORIOUS
Yes. That was the highest form of art, the greatest science fiction novels brought to life in the finest possible way. Villeneuve has paid Herbert his proper due. They are both geniuses in their own right.
@@EneaAndAleasWorld970 that's the same guy who acted in Wonka and Call me by your Name! And he's just 28... He's developing an incredible range as an actor
Why? Since Paul is a Harroken... since he was supposed to be a girl & married to his cousin Feyd, then their son was who the Bene Gesserit intended to be the Kwistaz Haderach.
@@nationalsocialism3504but the harkonnens are animals, they act in their base instincts with no restraint, look at the Baron's gluttony or Rabban and Feyd Rautha's constant executions. Then they are all killed like the animals they are, look at the Baron, he was killed without a thought with a single, strike to the brain. Feyd Rautha was killed just like Paul's grandfather, in a fight between a hero and a ruthless animal. At the very least, Villeneuve saw the Harkonnens as animals, but so do I.
It may sound crazy, but somehow it changed me. I’ve never heard of the books and part One made me very curious. Then I read Dune and Messiah in 3 Days and rewatched the movies …Part Two two times in Cinema and hell… what is going on. I feel like a child, who has seen colours for the first time and now it’s part of my life. Last time this happened was LotR. Sometimes things do this to you. Sometimes it’s a book, a song, here it is DV and you simply feel his love for this project. Hope Timothee gets an Oscar for this role, he is breathtaking.
Same!! I’ve watched Part 2 four times now and I’m still eager to watch it again very soon, I haven’t had a reaction like this to a movie in a long time 🙌
I love how you contrasted the arrival of Atreides on Arrakis with Paul putting his hand in the box. The box is a metaphor for Arrakis and there was only pain in it for the Atreides. The Reverend Mother said that an animal caught in a trap will gnaw off its own leg to escape. Paul Atreides was the animal caught in a trap and he gnawed off his own leg (lost his soul to a terrible purpose) to escape that trap.
But didn't Paul resist and pass the test ? He didn't remove his hand and proved he was more . He also chose Mua'dib , the desert mouse name to prove his worth
Him passing the test is more about how he exceeds the bene gesserits expectations. He is still very much in a painful trap which he cannot escape and in order to regain some control he actually does fall into the only way out he can manage (which is to cut off his “arm”) and lose himself to the power around him.
@@kartikeyatomar9847 And that came at a cost (the jihad). Paul passed the Gom Jabbar test but ultimately failed to walk on the golden path (which is literally Gom Jabbar on a macro scale). His son on the other hand....
Paul speech had me shaking in my seat. I almost stood up and scream “Addaam Reshii A-zaanta! (Long live the fighters!)” and “Lisan Al Gaib!” 🙇🏻♀️ All the seats in the cinema are vibrating, also the entire cinema is shaking when they played the “Gom Jobbar” theme.
I love the feeling of when you know something is going to be great, yet it still manages to surpass those expectations. This is a feeling I experienced for both of the Dune films, and now, this edit... You continue to absolutely outdo yourself with each and every video you put out. Absolutely masterful my friend, the litany of fear sequence already had me in awe, and that final act is pure greatness. Keep up the great work SWFT!
My only exposure to Dune is the films, but I definitely feel like Paul will end up becoming a cautionary tale of how a dictator rises rather than a hero....he's heading down a dark road
Good observation. Keep enjoying! Try the first book, but don’t go further if you want to still go with the film experience without any outside perspective
I love the editing choice here when Liet-Kynes asks Paul learned the intricacies of the stillsuit, while including clips of him researching about the Fremen. It shows the delicate balance between actual natural ability and the appearance of natural ability that the Bene Gesserit used to control populations. Incredible work here.
The scene I can't stop thinking about is the one where he gives out that damn speech in the ring. He delivers it so smoothly, and the writing is SO GOOD!!! Stilgar: "You need to kill me, it is the only way" Paul: "I point the way!" Oh. My. Messiah.
After watching the film I immediately told my friends to watch it too! It was such a MASTERPIECE! I could not get the movie out of my head. LISAN-AL GAIB!
The Dune movies of Villeneuve will be subject of discussions for decades to come, true masterpieces. I can't describe my joy that my favourite sci-fi books came to life in such a breathtaking way.
I actually loved that he took some elements of the old Dune Movie. As faulty as that movie was. It had some amazing Dialogue Moments. Taking the good elements, while combining it to the loyalty of the Books. Made an absolute Masterpiece of a Film
I have seen a lot of edits this year, but this one has to be the best. I felt chills unlike anything I had felt before during The Prophet Chapter. You would have won the best edit/tribute award, if there was one.
I’ve rewatched the final act of dune2 so many times. His rise, his speech that’s both inspiring and chilling, the battle, “grandfather”, the duel, “lead them to paradise”. Fucjing hell chalamet did a hell of a job
Beautifully made dude,the pacing & editing on this one is kinda insane 🙏 I'm not joking when i say ive watched the film 4 times & i just can't seem to get it outta my mind The film truly is perfect
Man... and thats mostly shots from the trailer for Part 2. Imagine what you can do when more of the film comes available. Amazing work. Also, at 7:31 does Paul use the voice in a very subtle way? His voice seems different from normal. I`ve saw the film twice already, but the German version doesnt sound so subtle strong at all.
@@antoniojuan9549 Is it cause he uses it to enunciate to large crowds? Or is he trying to influence them? 🤔 Or is he so OP he just uses it naturally when speaking loudly?
@@thalmoragent9344 in the first movie like the old one there was this like same talk and he made the lady back step with the voice so i do think he used it
Seriously this movie is literally from the outer world. I mean I've gone to see it 5 times including today at the cinema. And I still can't wrap my head around it, that's how great and cinematic it is. And this magnificent edit puts everything in 1 prospect and am still gasping sooo good 😮🤔😳🤩
The first movie caught my attention, the second instilled loyalty to the franchise. It was so insanely good, in every way, a truly epic story told with excellent visuals and dialogue
Overall, I think these movies were pretty faithful to the source material. Although the one thing that is missing a lot is Paul and Chani's relationship. I understand that they have to cut stuff out and change things from time to time, but I almost feel like they changed too much with Chani as a character. _MID-ISH SPOILERS FOR DUNE PART 2 AHEAD_ In the book, she is Chani Kynes, daughter of Liet Kynes. She and Paul initially bond over the fact that the Emperor and House Harkonnen are responsible for the deaths of their fathers. Chani is Paul's biggest supporter, his confidant, and so much more. He might marry Princess Irulan to maintain control of the empire, but his heart always has been and always will be Chani's. His marriage to Irulan is a purely political thing. It's Chani that Paul has children with. It's their children that are his heirs. Chani is to Paul what Jessica was to Leto: pretty much his wife in all but name. The movie made it feel like Chani was on the outside looking in. Like him marrying Irulan was some sort of personal betrayal when it was anything but that. Paul doesn't love Irulan. He never has, he never will. Chani is still his partner, his confidant, and the love of his life.
The change between book and movie is kind of jarring but exists to give the audience a view that helps them to see the horror in what is otherwise a really exciting revolution. Easy to get swept up in political/religious/ideological fervor and not realize how terrible the consequences could be until it’s too late. Chani helps to serve the same purpose as Paul’s visions: a grim reminder that revolutionary wars are still wars.
Bravo, I really like all the transitions you have done in this project, it's really amazing. An interesting way to add subtitles to this video like this. Good job!
7:32 "I am Paul 'Muad'Dib' Atreides, Duke of Arrakis, known as Usul, leader of the Fremen, bloodline to the Harkonnen and the Kwisatz Haderach, some may know me as the Mahdi but everyone will soon know me as the Lisan al Gaib. Follow me and I shall show you the way to the Green Paradise of Dune."
I know Denis wanted to fulfill Herbert’s initial plan of having Paul as more an anti-hero, but honestly I couldn’t see him any other way but a hero reluctantly accepting his fate to do what needed to be done which in then made Chani seem more like an anti-hero in the way she couldn’t see that Paul truly didn’t want to cause any pain and massacre but had no other choice which if she truly loved him for who he is, she should support him regardless of her beliefs as she was present for everything and saw how he didn’t want to accept the role of Lisan AlGaib.
This is one of the interesting moral questions the series asks. It's made pretty clear that the Holy War was the best outcome Paul saw, but he still manipulated the Fremen and caused countless deaths throughout the Imperium. In my opinion it still makes him a villain or, at the very least, an anti-hero.
Chani is right. The Fremen will leave their home to throw themselves at Paul's enemies, the great houses, and many will die. They're being manipulated and used. When the dust finally settles they may no longer exist.
My psychology paper final on Harter’s construction of the self and Bronfenbrenner’s ecological perspective is due at 12:00. I can’t wait to finish my final… turn it in and then enjoy a SWFT edit!