People's Initiative is 'unconstitutional,' says ex-SC justice Carpio | ANC 

Finally Carpio has spoken 👏

Loud and clear. They must now stopped the PI. Di ito papasa sa Supreme Court.

Thank you Justice for the very clear explanation.

No charter change is needed if the Philippine economy is doing great. Why tinker with foreign ownership limitations? Is the government had someone or groups in particular in mind?

Congress and Senate cannot vote separately. Even a simple law on renaming a street would require separate vote from the Congress and Senate. Constitutional amendments pa kaya

Atat kasi maging Prine Minister ni Romualdez.. alam kasi nya wala syang panalo pag tumakbo syang president

PI di na papasa pag naquestion ito sa SC. Kahit makuha pa nila 3 percent ng vote it is questionable.

Nagsayang lang cla ng pera dyan sa PI.

I'm in favor of changing the Constitution.. but not with the current Congress led by Romualdez. They must also be transparent to the people on what actual laws they will change and how it will benefit the country

Good job Justice carpio hope mga Congs is listening ang learn

Alam po ng House of Representative na hindi puedeng gamitin ang Petition for CHARTER CHANGE thru People's Initiative, moro-moro lang po yan at wasting of time and money to DIVERT the ISSUE of LIQUIDATION by way of CERTIFICATION na ginagawa ng KONGRESO. Kesa po mag-ubos ng oras at pera ay mas mabuti pang MAGPA-GENERAL AUDIT na lang ang LAHAT ng Tanggapan ng LEGISLATIVE BRANCH OF GOVERNMENT para malaman ng Taong Bayan kung SAAN at PAANO nila ginastos ang Bilyon-Bilyong BUWIS ng mga PILIPINO. Patunayan nila ang katapatan nila sa tungkulin at IBASURA ng KONGRESO ang CONCURRENT RESOLUTION NO. 10 na nagpoprotekta sa kanila para maglustay ng PERA ng Taong Bayan.

Si martin lang naman ang may gustu niyan..para hanggang kapatayan niya prime minister pa rin..

No PI CHACHA OR CONSA NEEDED IN PHILIPPINES. WE SUPPORT DUTERTE

Thank you justice Antonio Carpio for the authority of a process of change charter, GOD the philippines

Dapat hinto naiyan Charter Change. . .

PI simply means political initiative

Justice Carpio was the ponente in Lambino vs Comelec, he is the best authority to decide on the Constitutionality of what Congress is pursuing.

Mga taong sumusuporta sa PI , kasi sila sila rin makikinabang by any means .. gumagamit pa ng ibang tao para lang maapprove ito

Sulong p i pra s pagbbgo d kpakanan ng pngsrili interest lng ....

Dapat yong nilostay na pira ni tambaloslos ibalik sa kaban nang bayan.Patawan sya nang parosa naaayon sa batas malinaw corruption ang nangyayari.

Mali nman kasi ang dpat ang tawag is People of Martin Romualdez initiative

Lahat na lang Mali..😂 maharlika fund then this people’s initiative..😂

Justice nakausap nyonaba yung pamelya ng manga trebo trebo sa pilipinas kong naebegay naba sakanila yung total budjet amen

Nagagalingan ako kay Marcos, inuuna niya ang napakalaking problema ng bansa.

ung taong laging kontra.

So kung ganon wala ng silbi ang taong bayan dapat wag na tayong mag elwction lahat wala ng expuration sa lahat ng lolitico pag namatay asawa o anak ang papalit

That’s the style of BBM ! He is a traitor ❤😂he should stop that

Isa rin yung carpio na yan nakalagay nga sa batas ang peoples initiative tapos sasabihin ni carpio na unconstitutional grabe ang mga ito na mga tinik talaga sa pag unlad ng bansa

Huag na tumaya

Carpio for Senator

People initiative is the voice of the people itself

Tambaloslos talaga yung martin romualdez

Well said