Performer Reacts to TAEMIN 'Guilty' MV | Jeff Avenue 

You May Also Like Taemin on Suchwita reaction: www.patreon.com/posts/suchwita-with-92049776

Not many people know this, but Taemin has a master degree in film and music from one of the top universities in Korea. He revealed back during his Criminal era that he collaborated very closely with the MV director literally brainstorming together to create the perfect visual concept for the video. So I’m pretty sure his creative input continues. This concept is so Taemin, it screams Taemin - so dark, sensual, dramatic and poetic! It couldn’t have been created without him and his sensitivity.

Only Taemin can do this. So much grace, elegance, fluidity, but so much intensity and strength. It’s like his dance is a mix of his duality - beauty and strength. I agree, Taemin is art. I can’t even imagine any other artist who can pull this off so perfectly

This concept seems to be so complex, his mind is extraordinary. We can’t just call Taemin an idol, he is an artist who digs deep into human emotions when performing. I’m so proud of the artist he has become.

The dance team for this comeback is completely stacked. Rian, Simeez, Noze, Rozalin, Haeun Kim, and Suzy Hong as backup dancers. Choreographed by Kasper, with contributing choreo by Bada Lee and Shuri.

Taemin has talked about the literature that inspired this concept: Erotism: Death and Sensuality by Georges Bataille and Demian by Hermann Hesse. The fans are also seeing influences from Lord of the Flies. But the director said that his sole inspiration for the MV was Demian. Love that Taemin decided to do things his own way with his own colors. I don't see anyone else doing this concept, or even the way in which he does it. Just stunning! Great reaction, thanks for giving so much love to his work.

He's THE soloist. There's no one like Taemin.

Taemin is art! The full package he can sing like an ángel , insane dancer and crazy stage presence!! The legend and the king taeminie ❤🤴🏻so proud of him !

Yes, Taemin kills with his vocals, I am so delighted with the instrumental and his voice acting, a masterpiece. His hand moving under his shirt will become a new trend. Taemin is the one who always breaks standards and does what is not expected of him

Thank god the ACE is back.. was about to leave kpop hearing the same concepts over and over again.. but he came and set the standards again. He never dissapoints.. This man is so amazing.. the whole world should experience his genius.. the song is breathtaking, mesmerizing, ART pure.

I m not shawol, but I m so proud that SM and even the whole kpop industry still have an exordinary artist like taemin. I was so shocked and touched when watched the MV. The song, the choreography, the expression...I was not surprised when I got to know the choreographers are Kasper and badalee. BRAVO!! This is the most sophisticated music work of Kpop this year in my opinion.

Quick fun fact. Minho his Shinee member was his trainer for those abs. He trains him whenever they are at the gym

Taemin is The king of Kpop. The Best soloist out there in My opinion

Y2k fresh. It's a general concept. Not copied, none of this is copied. Taemin made it his own. Artistic, dramatic, nostalgic. Louder, Jeff, for the people at the back! 🙊 Taemin rarely ever follows trend by itself. It has to resonate with his identity. 5:20 thanks for this react, Jeff.

Ok, so...Taemin talked about how he took inspiration from the book "DEMIAN" written by HERMANN HESSE The Story of Emil Sinclair's Youth. There is a quote that he recites : “The bird fights to get out of the egg. The egg is the world. Whoever wants to be born must first destroy a world. The bird flies towards God. That the name of God is Abraxas.” Who is Abraxas? Abraxas is Demian's answer to the problem of a God who represents an arbitrarily selected half of the world. Abraxas is a deity who serves to unite the entire world, the light and the dark, the godly and the devilish. He does not represent either; rather, he is the affirmation of both. So in the music video Taemin is the egg, the bird and finally Abraxas (represented on the head with feathers). From the storylne in the video it is shown how a group of young people are conditioned to a way of being and acting and finally to commit m*rder. Taemin is in this contradiction of feeling love and hate. He is in a place that conditions him how he should be, how to dress, how to feel. By loving another person he is committing a crime, because that is not what he was conditioned to do. But at the same time that love is part of something bigger, a kind of game snce e wants to break from this conditioned world and love. Taemin is shown as the two entities, the good and the bad, the one who loves and the one who betrays or maybe, the one who hates. Hw wants to do things his way, so there is a certain mischief and chaos in his way of being. Who can condenm him? He finally leads the others in the institution so that everyone reveals themselves, destroying everything that trapped them and becoming the entity, Abraxas. As you said, for Taemin his 'identity' is very important. Much of his work is related to his beliefs, his convictions and way of being and thinking. Thank you for the reaction! You expressed many of the things I also feel about Taemin 💞

Taemin brought world-class art, you know many idols have only been releasing reggaeton this year. Taemin came to give catedra to the industry. the best solo artist ever and I don't argue with anyone.

Taemin is my absolute favorite soloist of all time. And I absolutely agree with you that the initial concept photos had me worried that it was chasing trends away from what makes Taemin, Taemin. I am so very glad we were both dead wrong.

Taemin is a masterpiece

This is the first song I've listened to of his, and I'm amazed. It's totally my vibe.

This isn’t kpop any more, this is fucking art. Taemin deserves more attention, he is absolutely incredible and expressive in his art.

The 2000 concept was the SHINee concept in View, the artistic director of New Jeans was in SM.

The interesting thing is, New Jeans' producer is the original producer for SHINee and Taemin;s ACE album. There is even a Taemin's photo on the wall in her house until lasr year.

When Taemin did that ascending belt on Killing Voice?! I can't believe he didn't sing the whole song there OR on Lee Mujin! I really hope Taemin performs a stripped down live vocal Guilty SOON

Jeff: Taemin is a God!! Me screaming like there is no tomorrow: AAAAMEEEEEEEN!!!!!!

the vocals are IMMACULATE ✨👏 his voice only gets better and better !

TAEMIN is an Artist who explores life. Musically, visually and intellectually.

Having an artist take you on a natural high to experience what you didn't know you needed is Taemin. Just let him take your hand, you don't even need to know where you're headed. All of his journeys are epic.

Taemin is pure art

I will quote "okay so that makes sense because Taemin is a God” from now on thanks

I’m absolutely blown away with this comeback! I knew Taemin will come back strong, but I’ve never imagined something so epic, so dramatic and so insanely artistic! Jeff, thank you so much for pointing out how his vocals immensely improved! It was my first thought when I heard him sing during his fan meeting back in April (straight after he came back from the military) - he sounded so relaxed, so round and even stronger than before, I was blown away with his voice. Taemin said he practiced his vocals a lot during his break and I think we can all agree that it shows! Also thank you for pointing out his uniqueness and how he was able to play with this otherwise popular concept/aesthetic and make it totally his! I have to say the amount of hate thrown at him by certain people was absolutely disgusting and so disrespectful. He didn’t deserve any of it and those people who throw baseless accusations should really think twice before becoming blinded by their hatred and lies! Taemin is a great artist, truly one in a million in this industry and he deserves all the respect and appreciation.

No one could be like TAEMIN TAEMIN is the different level forever. His vocal is so insane This comeback is perfect

Amazing reaction! I’ve been watching the MV nonstop. I’m sure someone has already said, but Taemin is heavily involved in everything with his music. He said this one was the most Taemin. It’s so so good!

I believe the "Y2K" fashion in the MV was meant to refer back to Taemin's early debut days, as SHINee debuted in 2008. This is clearer in Taemin's MV trailer (SPOILERS AHEAD*****), where even in the first shot, Taemin is with 4 other boys, and I believe they were meant to represent SHINee. Also, in other shots, Taemin and the other actors and actresses were dressed in schoolboy/school girl uniforms, which I believe to be Taemin's commentary on how the Kpop industry treats the Kpop idols. There were even some close-ups on actors/actresses which had a similar hair cut to Taemin's Replay bowl cut. Unfortunately, the MV barely touched on the narrative that was introduced in the MV trailer. I was hoping the MV would develop the story further. Regardless, they are ALL masterpieces, Taemin and his team keep on outdoing themselves, it's insane!

taemin is truly one of a kind 🔥

THE KING OF KPOP SOLOIST IS BACK Y’LL!!!!!!

I've been waited for your reaction on Taemin, as always :) Thank you, Jeff! Taemin is THE art, for real 💙And yeah, Taemin is always in charge of his art - from the songs to the idea of the whole comeback and MV. This comeback, also, based on the philosophic book that Taemin personally read before ❤‍🔥

J’ai beaucoup aimé votre analyse. Il n’y a pas de mots , c’est splendide,magnifique, je n’imagine personne d’autre que lui pour faire ça . C’est intense, gracieux, élégant, fort. Il a tellement de talent, de beauté, sa voix , sa dance!! Exceptionnel ! Taemin on t’aime! ❤️🥰🇫🇷

He delivered what I exactly needed from him. Idk how he manages to put out something new and different but also has the classic sexy sultry taemin sound. This might be one of the best K-pop song/performances I’ve seen ever since jimin’s Lie.

I looooove Guilty, and the whole album is a vibe!! The wait was worth it!! Thanks for the reaction, loved hearing your thoughts

Thanks for your reaction to Taemin's art, Jeff 💜 Well, you can blame Minho for working Taemin out to this degree, pushing him as Taemin said. I think it was in Taemin's unboxing where he said he felt sad for the boy he portrays in the mv. I'm looking forward to his explanation of the concept and narrative. Taemin just needs to start making full-out films or short films for his music. He studied film after all. This piece is definitely art, cinematic, so beautiful. His voice has matured since the military, a result of his hard work after his return and all he endured in there. (I thought the t-shirts and shorts reminded me of View.) His voice is haunting and mesmerizing, ah Taemin 💜 I love the long skirt outfit and the tan outfit he uses to dance in the water.

My interpretation of the MV is that he is trapped in his mind because of the trauma of being in an orphanage/some kind of institution when he was young to make a parallel with the lyrics of trapping someone in a toxic relationship, hence the teenager he sees and his younger look for the 1st part of the MV, and this is where the kind of y2k clothing comes into play. I really admire how they managed to integrate the trendy fashion of now into a concept that fits the song and Taemin.

I was like you. I knew he was going to release an epic mini album but at the same time I was not convinced with the visual concept of the album...but after the short videos started to be released day by day on Instagram I felt the dark that has always characterized him. He has never had a bright concept. I should have known!!! Haha. now with the music video, the photos of the album make more sense to me.

I cannot WAIT for the dance practice of this....

Taemin is King of Kpop ❤️

Your reaction was literally me when watching this MV for the first time 😭

The way you explained how companies use what trending and basically get inspired by one another was just perfect. Thank you for that. And love your break down of the music vid. ❤

In Taemin, we believe 💎✨

Wow, taemin is art

Taemin's vocals has really improved for sure but I also think people don't realize how good of vocalist Taemin is in general unless you listen to his bside or ballads from his solo work and Shinee's discography where he has much more vocally intensive lines! From debut to 2013 he worked really hard on improving and since then just getting better and better.

Thank you for your commentary; many of your reviews have resonated with me. The entire music video is like an inner monologue and dialogue of both parties in a twisted love affair.

Ok i havent watched this video but all im gonna say is im sure you’d love this. Lets go

i'm sorry but i did NOT get any "skater boy" vibes from the concept photos AT ALL 😅😅 for me it's very coming of age and innocence meets temptation kind of concept SHINee did that way before NewJeans, especially in View era. SM in general used to do that a lot tbh

He did say that abs is a requirement 😂 but so far only Winter (other than the dancers) did it with him like this…you you should check that out cuz they ATEEEEE 🫠

THEE Lee Taemin is ART personified 👑💯💎

Taemin needs to hear your reaction!!!🥺

So proud of Our TAEMIN Boys 🥰💖🫶👏 They deserve the Best ! This album IS a real mastepiece🔥🔥🎁

We have missed you so, Taemin ❤ Watching you outdo yourself with every comeback is a delight.

AHHH Ive been waiting for you to see this!!!! ITS SUCH ART! TAEMIN IS A GOD! He's back and it's just....perfection.

IT'S SO GOOD ❤

What the hell did he do? (to his body?) He went to the gym with Minho. That's what. :D He worked out with that man.

LOOOOL This reaction was hilarious!!

what a beautiful music video ❤️ absolutely incredible🌟 THE ACE

Thanks for you reaction Taemin is really something I love that song :)

Taemin said the song and video concept came from a 1957 book he had read that inspired him, 'L 'Erotisme by French philosopher George Bataille. George Bataille expressed his desire instrest to explore complex emotions.

Taemin is walking art

Gracias Taemin por existir

Studio Choom coming! King Taemin is back!!!

there is no one like taemin! no one can think like him he is so artistic in simple words he is a legend

I wish people could read was really ha]ing in this video it will break your heart its about his past he is letting go of all the pain and guilt he has carried he is being set free finally we love taemin we are always by your side

I'm so happy my bias is back, and he is amazing! This song is so deep, and thanks for your reaction, Jeff! I can't wait for the dance practice!

I guess it could be about the mental repercussions of being in the military and living your everyday life as a tool for a fight between governments in which you have no voice, spending all your time and energy learning the most efficient ways to kill people you do not use. nor do I want to hurt (could the phrase "loving you is a crime" be about having empathy and compassion for the "opposite side" in the war) and the loss of childhood and innocence it would cause. We see Taemin looking very anxious while holding the gun at target practice and even taking it out on himself through self-harm (because of guilt??) he (or someone else I can't say) then sets the target on fire at 5 :20, possibly as a rebel?? Throughout the MV there is also a theme of everyone being in uniform or boring clothes, so this is juxtaposed with super expressive outfits like Taemin in a skirt which could be a commentary on how the military steals your self-expression and sense of identity, since you have to wear a uniform, shave your head and follow orders. The first scene is quite indicative of both the loss of childhood (children's photos drawn on the wall) and the loss of self, as Taemin is sitting in a room full of colorful clothes while wearing a very simple outfit. This is just my theory, I have no intention of speaking for Taemin, especially when an anti-military concept would be very controversial and would result in a lot of hate for him. That hurt expression is unforgettable. It's a strong shock and stimulus. Taemin was the first K-pop artist I was exposed to (and became obsessed with) and he became my first prejudice (now ult) for exactly this reason. Always with you, Taemin. 🫰😍

Estaba esperando tu reacción. La mejor. Narraste su danza .Nos enseñaste admirarte su voz hermosa Y...quedates como todos los que vismos este arte. Fascinados y sin respiracion . ❤😮

Taemin se lució totalmente, parece un cortometraje, nunca había visto tanto un vídeo ❤ que orgullosa estoy de ser shawol y stanear a puros manes con talento!

been waiting 🎉

I knew you would react to this!! ❤❤❤

I have the same thought as you Jeff. The minute the concept photos posted I couldn't hardly believe Taemin would hopped on to the trending concept like okay he's going with a simple, viby and summery not his artsy stuff. Comes the cb dudeeeee flipped the concept tfo. I mean how can someone uses something existed but never seen? I shouldn't have jumped to my own conclusion Taemin do what Taemin best, to shock you.

Taemin on dingo killing voice is 😍🥰😘💎🔥.. yes he said he wanted it to b cinematic… MV related to Shinee n himself also experience from military 🫶🏼

Taemin💯💯💯

Omg I love your reactions, it's like you freaking out there and I freaking out here

This is my first time seein teamin. fuck me, he is an art.

I was eagerly awaiting your reaction!.... Thank you for reacting and the praise❤

Amazing and talented soloist artist 👏I love you so much taemin 🥰❤️💎

His vocals has seriously improved during the past 2 years. His vocals SHINE in this comeback.

Waiting for this❤

Love you jeff❤

Makes me thinks a lot about taemin's whole career in the industry, when he started sherlock, view, his whole solo career as well as his time in the army. The MV is so dark I feel like

I absolutely love how each time Taemin embodies the concept of a song! Initially the song Guilty was wtitten as story of adultery from the point of mistress expressing guilt for loving married man but feeling unable to stop, but of course Taemin did took the song and added his unique colours and layers. Many idols in kpop nowadays are almost crucifixed by fans if caught dating someone, so it might be understandable that an Idol may feel guilty for falling in love and trapped by standards set by industry and fans, which Taemin is rebelling against in a video. Also, as religious cristian he continues to explore man's journey towards sensuality, walking on that thin line of right and wrong, pleasure and sin. I'm sure there are tons of other interpretations to it, one thing is clear: king Taemin is back, and continues serving increadible works of art only he can deliver🎉 it was very dark and boring without him ❤

Studio choom coming out soon!!!

Jeff, you are so funny, I love your commentary, professional and emotional ❤❤❤

Taemin es arte no hay otra explicación

First of all you're gorgeous. Secondly, I love the way you broke this down.

I’m obsessed with this song

@ 2:59 did you mean the abs? Because, YES, he kills me with that every time I watch the MV 😅

Taemin is an amazing artist. And your reactions are always so professional (I love the emotional side of them as well ☺️) P.S. I know it's not nice to ask like this, but I am still waiting for Jeff Avenue to react to Jeff Satur😁😄🤣

I’m hoping for an album reaction ❤️ Also, jeff, he did an appearance on lee mujin service & killing voice !

Finally, Album of the year mv of the year, every detail in it is worth pointing out. It's an artistic masterpiece

Yes this is art

yaaaassss TAEMIN

Actually, this reminds me of Advice and Criminal both musically as well as the artistry in the movement and music video

I'ts about toxic love the song, great amazing choregraphy, video clip, dance performance, beautiful voice, I'm crazy about the new Taemin. And so sexy , hot waouh. I want to see more in this style 💜💜💜