PERSIAN & BALOCHI 

Perfect way to put it man

But its not indic

@@arikboke3853 it is very Indic in its eastern parts where it borders Saraiki and Sindhi regions!

​@@kamrankhan-lj1ngI thought balochi was western iranian dialect not eastern. I searched it on google it said northwestern iranian language.

بلوچی ها از نوادگان پارت ها در مناطق شمال شرق ایران بودند که به جنوب کوچ کردند

Wow, thanks! :D

@@ilovelanguages0124 BRAHUI & TAMIL Dravidian languages please example words

​@@ibrohimh9976 farsi language family.

​@@ibrohimh9976 vice versa, rather.

@@kamrankhan-lj1ng Iranic language family 👍🏼

@@ibrohimh9976 you mean Tajik and Farsi are both dialects of Persian

@Adolf Hitler Tajik is infact a dialect of persian sorry not sorry 😁

This is probably recorded from a Balochi speaker of Pakistan. Balochi in Iran has a little bit of a different accent and sounds less like a Hindi accent

This is basically how I sound speaking balochi ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-pv1tmzk5cFw.html (the baloch man)

Im a pakistani baloch and it's because our school teachers are Urdu speaker

@@weatherforecast6864 no you are a baloch who lives outside of Balochistan. Teachers in Balochistan speak Balochi.

It depends on region,The Baluch of Pakistan has Urdu influnce (Karachi) Baluch of Iran (Sestan Baluchistan) speak in Rakshani dialect not urdu ,Makurani Baluchs speakers both bordering side Pakistan and Iran has different accent due to regional influence by Persian and Urdu. In Afghanistan and Turkmenistan Baluch people has Rakshani dialect which also influenced by Dari and Turkic languages.Baluch of Kerman has an accent so it has nothing to do with Indic or Urdu.

Very true. There is a Punjabi-like language embedded within Balochistan, along with the border areas along Sindh and Punjab themselves.

That language at the border between Balochistan, Sindh, and Panjab is called SARAIKI. It is the native language of the southern and western half of Panjab as well.

It might be influenced by Sindhi language and dialects

True

Its indo scythian

Or nuristani with dardic language

What is the point of it? They are both different languages of different branches with very limited similarities.

​​@@suikzaxa9593 So what? I remind you he compared Greek with Albanian and Armenian (which are supposedly more close from each other than we think according to the not so supported Graeco-Armenian hypothesis). He also compared Tibetan with Mandarin. He even compared Mandarin with Japanese and Korean. Not to mention he compared Yoruba and Igbo (that despite belonging to the Nigеr-Congo family of languages, they are already really far from each other) with Hausa, which belongs to the Afro-Asiatic family. They are way more similar than the ones I previously mentioned.

You know why? Because Balochi, Gilaki, Mazandarani, Kurdish, Luri, Laki, Talyshi, Semnani are all part of the Northwestern Iranian language group! Farsi is Central Iranian. If you actually listen to Mazandarani they speak like Luri from Lurestan. Specifically the Luri spoken in cities like Khorramabad and Andimeshk as well as Dehloran in Ilam!! And actually the accent that you hear in Mazandarani songs is similar to Kermanshahi Kurdish accent and way of speaking. But Mazandarani is EXTEMELY similar to Luri. And most of their words and pronunciation are the exact same!

@@iranianwarrior yes I was shocked how similar luri sounds to Gilaki

Baluchi is quite interesting language,it has tons of similarities with Avestan as well.. Balochi...Avestan...English Sat...Sata..Happy Cat...Cat...A well Zer..Zered..Sea Draj...Draj..Long Praah..Prah..wide Hawr..Awra..cloud Hosk..Huska..Dry Zan/zan..Dan...word stack of knowledge Pac...Apac..open Zamat..Zamatar...Son in law. Aap..app...water Balochi is much more closely related to Kurdish than it is to its close neighbour Pashto.

​@@StOryMiNd398 Avestan , do you mean avar? Also yea as per history we migrated from Aleppo and fought the pashto from here and the pure Balochi only remains in the rakshani range

@@gamerhashaam3343 Not sure who is pure but the dna data shows totally different results of who are Baloch. Not all Balochs are closest to this DNA but most of them are from Makran region (divided between Iran and Pakistan). The 4 Skeleton of ancient Iranian neolithic farmers found in Western Iran matches the DNA of Makran region (i mean closest percentage 62% ++) the DNA data results are available on many online international sites second after Baluch are Mazandarani with 42%.

Fun fact is that Farsi rendition uses Arabi word Khata! Whereas Balochi rendition uses Farsi word Gonah (gunah in north Indian and Pakistani languages)

even more fun fact is that this channel deliberately chooses most diverse possible cognates to show dissimilarity between even very very similar languages!!!

@@kamrankhan-lj1ng Exactly! They could have just used the same words for Farsi because the exact same words are used in Farsi as well. So basically they chose to use Arabic loan words instead of actual Farsi, and that makes it a complete knockoff! This video is highly inaccurate

Ur wrong, they deliberately use non-Persian words to make them different and put Persian in a weird light

It's crazy to think that Persian borrowed "xəta" from Arabic while Arabic borrowed "gonah" from Persian but in Arabic it's pronounced (junaḥ/جُناح) Basically Arabic and Persian both use each other's words for the same or at least similar meaning lol

Maybe he can also compare those creoles with Papiamento, which has some Portuguese influence.

@@ElHeraldoHispano other languages ​​that are also compared, is the French Guiana creole and Lanc-Patuá/Karipúna, a French-based creole language spoken in the Brazilian state of Amapá

No, baluchis in iran do not have this accent

There are many accents in Balochi language, this one is probably from karachi that’s why

Balochi has 3 major dialects. All the major dialects have there own accent. The one used in this video is the dialect of coastal areas of Pakistani and Irani Balochistan and this is how it sounds. The rakhshani dialect is the least desi dialect of Balochi, which is spoken near Pakistan Iran border and Iranian Balochistan capital Zahidan

This dialect of balochi is spoken in Mand Gawadar and Turbat. You will find a different accent in 100 kilometre if you go to balochistan The Most Extreme ones is Regi one from Zahedan. He was talking to me and i didn't understand a word he said to me.

@@shahji5119 sarhadi baluchi also is the least desi sounding one

More balochi words Maat pith brath like sanskrit mata pita brata

Soghand promise

Where you live ? Do you live in Sindh?

@@hopidopi yeah

There are even more similarities between Iranic and Slavic languages!

Not really

Balochistan is really free😊

Which one Iranian afghanian or pakistanian😂

​@@shedadbaluchall of them!!! It should be independent country... Baloch are suffering in all three countries

@@JassiJussi-ef5sd Baloch from Iran & Afghanistan should join Pakistan

Baluchistan belongs to Afghanistan

@@kasyakyoubfgamindikisborat The Kurdish Languages 🇮🇶

Uyghur is not Iranic language but it along with Uzbek has huge Persian influence!

No it doesn't stop the cap

@@waleedahmed5021come on, it really does sound like Hindi/Urdu until you pay attention

Sahaad to haamare zubaan mein vi hein. Chakho gi ?

Yes

It's very similar to old farsi

​​@@andrewsanders7636Not at all, only Modern Persian is very similar to Old Persian.

@@texmexexpress what about parthian or parsig ? I'm assuming you know Balochi I would like to hear your opinion on this matter

@@texmexexpress modern farsi has no intelligibility with old parsi it's better if you read the Behistun inscription yourself

Persian has a very soft accent.

@@texmexexpress For me it's stiff.

@@GipsyK6345Then get checked by an otolaryngologist.

They are essentially the same.

This is Fârsi; the Dari vowels are a little bit different.

Dari is Farsi (Persian). If you mean the accent, it’s Tehrani accent

Both are literally the same language. Dari is just the name given to the Afghan dialect of Persian

@pluto There's no whole language anyway, and that's why Persian is just better and more practical than those languages which stay pure due to its speakers dwelling outside of civilization because it's more flexible and good sounding.

@Heil Hitler Persian is a full language. You can still look up the true Persian words for the Arabic words that are found in Farsi. This is why we have the Shahnameh and so many other things. The Shahnameh was written entirely in pure Persian, without any Arabic words as a means to preserve our beautiful language.

@Heil Hitler Persian is not an Arabic dialect.

@Heil Hitler What you think are Kurdish words are Iranian words because Kurdish and Persian are both Iranian languages and share one common root.

@Heil Hitler It’s funny that you say that because Dari is a dialect of Farsi.

Baloch Is Close To Sorani Kurdish

Yes. Eventually.

They are a world apart despite both being Eastern Iranian. Even Pashto and Pamiri languages are quite different.

😂 cry cry parooosii central asian