Couldn’t say it any better Obi These are absolutely brilliant So much time and effort put into these From one Pink Floyd fan to another thank so much And great timing for Saturday afternoon beers too as always
There aren't many bands out there that can come close to the sound and visual effects quality of a Pink Floyd performance in the 80's and 90's. It is truly an awesome experience!
I recommend you to check this newer and improved version I released a couple of months ago: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-G3C4FK6OseM.html Cheers.
Mr. Nicholas Berkeley Mason Mr. Richard William Wright 😢 Mr. David Jon Gilmour Simply 3 Monsters 🎵🎼🎶🎹🎤🎸🥁💪👊😎🤘 Simply The Best Version This Song What a Solo 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🎸💪👊😎🤘
Я рад, что тебе понравилось. Я рекомендую проверить улучшенную версию этого ремастеринга, которую я опубликовал совсем недавно. Привет. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-G3C4FK6OseM.html
I had no idea that the "original" live recordings had been, altered/tampered/augmented etc. As a casual to moderately interested fan of Floyd since my 1st Dark Side LP as a kid, I really appreciate this. Thanks so much for your hard work and attention to detail.
Glad you're enjoying the channel and thank you for your kind words. Regarding the live recordings, every live work has arrangements/improvements being Floyd or any other, I don't think any band publish a live show in real raw conditions, you need to always need to make certain adjustments. In the case of DSOT 2019 reissue, the changes in the sound are pretty evident, even was known prior to it's release back then that there was even channels and instruments re-recorded. In my experience (since I don't consider myself a "regular listener" anymore, since I normally disassembly all the tracks to make my own remixes which let me access details that otherwise I couldn't), and I can think that they made collages from different shows to produce the official ginal releases, obviously it's just my opinion and could be wrong, but I think that's the case. And that's not a critic at all, I think that's a way to bring the public the better possible experience. Cheers and happy week.
Obi: thanks so much for this. After a day in NZ swirling around Delta and vaccine competitions (!!) the lyrics is just so prophetic. What are we doing to ourselves?? Grew up on pink Floyd - this never fails to still emotion and your version is no exception - wonderful
Extremely happy you've like this one Dave, and yes, this song is really strong, lyrics and music (specially guitar) are a massive hit to the senses. More of this "Nassau Extended Unreleased" is coming very soon, I'm cooking the final details. Thank you very much for the comment and support, stay safe!
Awesome brother. You are a legend!!!😊👏👏👏👏👍🥳🥳🥳 thanks for all your hard work. You are awesome. Thanks, thanks, thanks. Keep these beautiful works of art coming please. We are so blessed to have your work and these gems shared.🥳👍👏👏👏👏😊😊😊🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇
Thank you very much for the kind words. If you haven't yet I recommend you to check the newer and improved version from this one I published recently in the channel. Cheers! ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-G3C4FK6OseM.html
Hahaha Glad you're enjoying over here and thank you for the warm words Max. I hope to be releasing more of this series very soon (still part of my editing equipment is out of service). Cheers!
The soundboard is from the 20th of august 1988 and the actual footage and audio recording chosen for the release was from the 19th of august (I believe it was from the 19th). You can see the difference in the long solo of which major parts were always being improvised by David Gilmour and thus unique with every performance. As far as I know only an audience recording has been circulating from the 19th.
Well, 1989 release is very different from the latest 2019. This latest, in my opinion and experience after have had yet disassembled second by second several of it's songs and with others still in progress, in that they made a sort of "collage" for the mix with footages from several nights for much of the songs. I think that one of the reasons must have been the technical issues they had those nights, specially with David and Rachel's mics (even you can see in this video with the remastering I've made how David reacts when in the beginning of the lyrics his mics sounds very low and in background and then he looked to his technician to his right side like asking "wtf?", one thing that with the offical soundtrack pass anawared). Off the way, there's also a reason for that rumor that they used the 19th audio and was the fact that for that day wasn't never a soundboard source circulating. Another interesting point is the hard postprocessing this official soundtrack has, in my opinion that is to smoothing that mix I've mentioned before, since the sound balance of each nigh was pretty different. Anyway, all this is an interesting topic, that was my main point on dive on these. Cheers and thanks for the comment!
@@TheForce_Productions If you listen to the audience bootleg from the 19th it is evident that it's actually the one used in the official release. No rumors needed for or against that. It is preety much what it is except that the solo is a little shorter for a couple of bars. Nothing dramatic. In the beginning David's vocals are a little low but, this is a mix issue not a technical issue imo. And again, it's a different night. :-) Listen to the long solos carefully, you'll hear the obvious differences in the improvised parts.
Yeah, me not just listen the solos since i'm a guitarist as well. And as I said before, that's just my opinion. Even watching closely the official release with it's audio/video is easy to spot diferences in between what is sounding and what is in fact David playing is several parts along the movie, not only in this song. Was knew that several things were even re-recorded in studio after and was also widely knew that they had issues in the original nights, an example of that is the first part of The Great Gig In The Sky, where Rachel's voice couldn't be recorded and that's why for the releases they used the first segment of the Versailles gig. But that is that, all are opinions. Thanks anyway for the interest.
@@TheForce_Productions I just listened to the bootleg from the 19th, I haven’t heard it in quite some time and I must admit that it‘s not exactly what is on the official release. I take back my claim 😄. I haven’t noticed it before probably because I heard a bad audience recording. It’s interesting what you that they did a collage. It‘s sounds now a bit like it. I know they did it on Pulse for some songs but I never assumed they did on DSOT. I‘m a guitar player too 😃. It is a very interesting topic for sure! I have been listening to PF for thirty years. Cheers!
You know? Just before I've start diving into these DSOT experiments, I thought exaclty as you said in the beginning, but just starting to dis-assembling the songs (second by second literally) and analizing details trying to "match the puzzle" I've started to spot a lot of weird things, things that not match there and also not even match with the tempo of the songs... Is very large to write over here cause I've been hours and hours turning around it. And yeah, it's a interesting and wonderful matter so far. Cheers mate guitarist!
Thank you so much for this. Much obliged. My god this is very topical today with COVID-19, Nature is very angry and the environment is screaming for help.
Hi friend Obi!! How are you? Boy, very good video. Thank you for putting Rachel in the spotlight many times. I liked the "blink of an eye" at 8:35... whoever received it was without sleep. 😉Big hug! !! Take care!!👏👏👏
Hello Fer! Yesterday before publishing thought that, such lucky guy that who got the chance to attend to one of this tour shows and to be in first row just in front of Rachel, can you figure of that? Life is unfair lol! Cheers my trend, have a nice Saturday!
@@TheForce_Productions I've read many comments (Facebook) from fans who had the opportunity to receive (or imagine they received) a wink or wave of the hand from Rachel. Everyone was mesmerized by her. 🥰Good week friend!!!😉
Such a dream! Hopefuly aliens get down here for once and teach us how to travel to past, I guess you'd know where to find me lol! Happy new week over there!
I bet she does that to men to spite them. Almost saying - Dream on, but you can't have this. I wonder if she can still pull that off today that she's in her 60's. What a lovely woman.
Now i don't remember ever hearing all those vocalizes while they performing Sorrow in any of the 6+ shows of the MLOR 88-89 tour legs I attended but I can say that in any case in this new listening to the song (these vocalizes) are quite a lot appropriate in the context of the lyrics, really. Well done Obi Wan ! Superb remastering job too ⇑⇑⇑ ;-)
Thank you very much! And you right, these vocal arrangements are pritty particular, since they were performed a lot by the backing girls all over these Nassau shows, but right after they delete almost everything for the post-production, only leaving just a few, I think because some of them were in the video takes; and maybe because I've noticed that they were having problems with the mics, specially Rachel's. If you liked this, more is coming soon... Cheers and thank you once again.
@@TheForce_Productions ...about Rachel's mic problems... yes, you're right, in a SBD rec I picked @Yeesh*** a while ago you can clearly hear that Rachel's mic line had big problems as her voicing level was almost null... what you can hear of her singing was just picked by ambience mics and/or Margy's and Durga's ones; I think it was more a problem of mic return line to the mixing board than of a mic failure 'di per se'. Have a good day ! ps: I'm looking forward to watch at/listen to other wonderful works of yours. ;-)
Uff, that really sucks. You have some good, safe and efective workarounds solutions out there to that useless interruptions, specially if you're sunning on android. Greetings.
Glad you've liked it! Sure, Turning is in the oven, but take time to achieve good results; still can't believe that only took me two weeks to finish this... Cheers!
I'm in a pleasant shock. I've heard many versions of this concert, and each has a completely different sound. How do you do that!? you are very cool, thanks!
Glad you like it! Well, I guess this "unreleased version" and the other two I've published until now must be the closest you can hear regarding the original live performances back in 1988, into the dry sound (even though with some technical problems in this one) and without those post-processings used for the official releases, specially 2019 version. How? I take much time to try improvements and experiment, trial an error. Thank you for the comment!
Рада что тебе понравилось. Я рекомендую эту самую текущую версию, которую я недавно переработал. Привет. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-G3C4FK6OseM.html
Well, I see Sorrow as an energetic way to front sadness, I think it's one of the darkest songs I've ever knew, but at the same time it has that guitar that's like a punch in your brain, and even more in 1994 tour. Hope you've enjoyed this one, cheers!
Obi Wan, I came across a song of PF where the backing vocals sang OOOH-WAAH, but I can't find it anymore here on U-tube. Which song is that?? I'm listening to avery performance...Do you know which song that is? Thank you...
Hello there! Subs aren't build-in into the video, just disable them from RU-vid settings or pressing the button [CC] on screen whenever you want to hide them. Cheers!
Maybe it's just my sound setup but when David starts singing at 3:09 it sounds really muffled and all during this version of the song his voice just does not sound as powerful as it is in other videos. The percussion always seems to be the focus. I love Obi Wan Kenobis work but not a fan of this one.
Hello there. There was a couple a factors of incidence here; one is that you mentioned about David's voice channel, which is due to the original sorround environment the band used for the live performance, where his voice was sent mostly to the surround channels which were lost in my 2.0 soundboard copy of the show. Second, this was quit time ago when I just started this project series and I had a very old limited computer incapable to perform certain things today granted and neither wanted to modify as much the original track. That said, if it took place today I'd easily make the proper corrections to David voice, who knows, maybe for the 5.1 version, will see. Cheers!
Thanks Obi for this great video 😍 but I’m too curious to watch the other performed songs in DSOT like comfortably numb! Is there any unreleased version for “Comfortably Numb”?
Happy you've liked this one. Yes, i'm working on several things, including C. Numb, but all of this takes me a lot of time, but time to time you'll see it over here nextly. Thanks for the comment!
Why are the vocals so low? There is also very little bass. The rest of the music sounds excellent. I want to love it, but these 2 flaws just make it too hard for me to enjoy one of my favorite PF songs. For me, the sound is just way better on the Pulse DVD, even though it’s only Dolby Digital.
First things first; what have to do Pulse (being Dolby Digital or not) to this? This is not an official release (nor video nor audio). I based my remaster/edition in an audio that came directly from their soundboard, but this master is a STEREO capture from their SURROUND layout back then in those shows; the vocals and other instruments were sent through the missing channels in this capture, that's why you notice those details. Anyway, I'm already working on it's revisited version which will be also in 5.1 surround as my latest publishings, and then those details you pointed out should be solved along other improvements.
@@TheForce_Productions no worries. I was just curious why it sounded so different than what I was expecting. I only mentioned DD because old-school compressed DD is pretty subpar quality compared to compressed DTS or lossless formats. I wasn't referring to 5.1 vs stereo. I get that this is not an official release. I was asking about the technical limitations for the differences, which you've kindly explained. I appreciate it. FWIW, 2 channel vs 5.1 doesn't matter that much for me in a concert. I'm far more concerned with full range (20Hz-20kHz) balanced (meaning levels of various instruments) audio, audible/clear vocals and decent bass (if it's to be expected from the source material).
No problem. Back then when I did this remaster I had an very old and limitated PC that didn't let me so much margin to add such improvements as I'd wanted but now with new hardware I'm revisiting some of that footages that deserves an upgrade, just like this song that btw I also love. Regarding 5.1 you right, for music is kind of relative but anyway I find it as an added flavor the detail to placing certain instruments/sounds in different spaces (just like they used to in their shows), and I assure you that that makes a great difference in the final result mix, it's really something huge that you can only notice when experimenting with it. Anyway, hope you enjoy the revisited version when I release it, as I said before i'm working with it right now. Cheers.
Hola, bienvenido y gracias por el interés. Mirá, posilibidad por supueeto, pero ahora mismo tengo un montón de cosas a medio preparar, y con el tiempo para mi suerte o desgracia, cada proyecto se vuelve más detallado y complejo porque con cada uno voy aprendiendo cosas nuevas y eso hace también que cada vez ponga el foco en muchos más aspectos al mismo tiempo y en definitiva, cada uno cada vez me toma más tiempo, y sumale que tengo una PC que ya ni se como funciona y que tengo que reemplazar si o si... Por eso no te voy a mentir, en el futuro inmediato está complicado pero en el mediano bien podría ser. Saludos Felipe!
Hey I noticed the Comfortably Numb ending solo is also longer than any of both released versions, each one has it's own stuff... Are you gonna do that one too?
All those details are exactly my point on doing this, just give some time and you'll got it over here. The force is strong in me but my PC is yet in the dark side of the technology... Lol! Cheers!
"Officially" they shoot one night, but based on certain details, I would tell you that they filmed all the shows and later used takes from all, depending on the songs and it's parts; and it's pritty obvious I think, if you gonna make a movie and wanna make sure to do it right, you'll assure to get all the possible footage in case of need them, cause you'll need it. Cheers!
I think to remember the same, but right now i have not the data of the exact equipment they used. I'll make some research and I'll try to add it in the description later.
I've adapted and edited these videos using the same gig where the movie itself took place. There'll be more nextly, as soon as I recover part of editing equipment which is out of service right now. Cheers!
Well, completely I don't think so but anyway all the releases have cuts and editions over, but the last 2019/2020 was the most modified by far. It has in some cases re-recorded drums, guitars, keyboards, backing vocals and even David voice that in some cases wes re-recorded or maybe used their own records from some other shows. If you check my "unreleased" versions and right after the officials you'll immediately spot a lot of that things. More is coming, all is in the workshop right now. Cheers!
Hola! Justamente Sebastian, durante todas las cinco noches de grabacion de los shows de Nassau para DSOT tuvieron muchos problemas especialmente con los retornos de los micrófonos de David y tambien de Rachel, esa es una de las razones por las que para los lanzamientos oficiales se hicieron "collages" de varias noches para muchas de las canciones y hasta se regrabaron en estudio canales completos. Fijate que en el video en esta reedicion que hice podés notar que cuando David empieza a cantar y la voz suena muy baja y de fondo, el inmediaamente mira a su técnico a su derecha como preguntando "qué pasa?" y dos tomas después Nick tamben está haciendo lo mismo; esto en la versión oficial pasa desapercibido, pero de esta forma es más interesante para poder ver y entender estos detalles puntuales, es un poco la razón de hacer todo esto. Saludos!
@@TheForce_Productions Excelente! Muchas gracias por la explicación! Es notable como el mal trabajo de algún sonidista que falló puede arruinar todo un recital...
Bueno, yo no creo que se trate de un mal trabajo, ellos entre luces, sonido y robótica en el escenario tenían una parafernalia inmensa y a veces ocurren fallas. En la gira 94 por ejemplo, varias veces tuvieron problemas con los lasers también, cosas que pasan. Saludos!
Permiso y agradeciendo el comentario de Sebastian que da cuenta que la voz de David está efectivamente más lejos... esta versión involuntariamente resalta de manera espectacular al resto de los músicos, y aprovecha la instancia de apreciar la calidad instrumental y la tremenda percusión latina de esta maravillosa canción... mi canción favorita en música y letra... UN ABRAZOTE!!
The name it's just a commercial frame and nothing else. If you enjoyed this one, I recommend you this newest revisited version, where I improved several details. Happy Sunday. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-G3C4FK6OseM.html
