I have Pumpkin vibes on my nails now and it’s anything but underwhelming. When I saw your swatch I was shocked cuz it looks nothing like what’s on my nails. Maybe try it on your actual nail because I have had compliments and oohs and ahhhs everyday from people. I’m not kidding. It shifts like crazy and it’s bright and deep and just all you see in the bottle.
I got Cadillacquer, Dreamland, Hit the Bottle, Indie by Patty Lopes & Phoenix. Mistress by Phoenix it’s magnetic btw idk if you forgot, I love it both cat eye and velvet