I think it depends on the show. Most of the time she's actually singing, but the backing track is just really loud compared to her. I suggest you watch the last show of her "Never Find My Place" tour. That has her best live vocals imo
@@joemama1712 ur implying that her music is witchcraft, but it's not. idk where you got witchcraft from, as a practitioner of it myself this is nothing like it. i was just further explaining that she doesn't do it. u look like a fool rn