Don't worry who is the modi the past chaiwaala... Pk is the person who made him pm.. See what will happen if Pk joins Congress.... The sleep if modi & it shah will be gone away...
@@jaihanumanji1122 So he was not with Congress also... And For 2024, 2 P are going to silently play there role, Pawar & Prashant kishor... If Mamta banerjee can win bengal wirh 72% share of hindu.. Besides Modiji cry in every election rally... Mamta banerjee won becuae of prashant kishor...
@@jaihanumanji1122 still seats increased... This is the strategy which even Prime minister even don't know how to win miracle election... Because prashant kishor is only the miracle... Cobra ko bhi pani pila diya.. One thing is very clear The person who was having Solution of every problem in 2014, has become problem for everyone... And if you feel that you don't have any problem, problem means serious problem, then wait & watch you will also have serious problem from him.... Come ahmedabad you will know reality... Don't see Gujarat from Google
I am from Telangana and probably one in that 45% Hindus who didn't vote for BJP. But now I am leaning towards BJP at the centre as it has got clear cut nationalistic policies, be it 370, CAA or UCC, which none of the opposition parties even dare to provide a counter logical and reasonable argument. And these issues are very real and relevant. PK is only looking at it from data perspective but there's ground level transformation happening with the Indian voters. This is a new India which will question and won't take things lying down. Ye public hai, ye sab jaanti hai.
Thats great....wish some day 5 mid n southern states which have gone so language centric...never let themselvez integrate with India...wish some day Tamil nadu/Karnataka/AP get their rightful stake in national politics....but THEY RNT INYERESTED SIMPLY!!!
@dattu reddy2001 we muslims are in india by choice, our forefathers did not leave , they fought for independence. All this hindu-muslim communalism is money and power.
Prashank Kishor (1st half of interview) : You don't need to project a PM face for the opposition front nor the leaders of the several opposition parties to come together for mounting an effective opposition. Prashank Kishor (Part A of 2nd half of interview) : Opposition parties should not come together without a credible PM face...as it will be counter productive. Prashank Kishor (Part B of 2nd half of interview) : You don't need to project a PM face for the opposition front or the leaders
@SRN If you watch him closely over many interviews, you would realize he is big fan of the great Indian democracy and he just wants to strengthen it by strenghthing opposition. And I think thats a great service to India as a culture and nation. By the way I support BJP for next at least 10 years for infrastructure development not for democracy. For democracy BJP remains a threat on long term basis. For short term they might end up consolidating and strenghthing power of Centre which is very necessary for now for India.
I am from tamil nadu , first time I am moving towards BJP. I do not see any major corruption, good laws for improvement of nation, focus for army, article 370, peaceful ram temple, water distribution scheme, new roads and bridge near China. Reduction in stone petting in j& k. N.E given due respect. Tamil Nadu fisherman are protected by this government from Lankan.
@Mission Impossible Such a funny rhetoric with no knowledge uhave made. Hindu Mahasabha which is ancestors of RSS made coalition governments with Muslim League in many provinces specially in biggest states Sindh, NWFP and Bengal. 🤣🤣🤣
@@sidhanttiwari1915 ah majority who owns major businesses, industries, schools, financial sectors, political sectors etc are minority. Wah! Bjp who won one sided election in 2019 having 99% of their ministers as pro hindu are in minority 😒 saffronised brain constantly fed with saffron nonsense.
@@anthonyabhinav8727 Hmm bhai,wo aise hai jo jitne wala hota hai uska unko credit dete ho to harne k liye v do 😀😀 jha v election ho wha pr ye jrur hote hai 😀hmm barkha,bhut bre aadmi hai jo neta bnata hai tmne bola,kisi common man ko neta bnaya ho to bolo,Mai iski Puja kru 😀
Arvind... Really? Don't you think she was rushing through question.... I mean pk is the most astute mind and he does not generally avoids question.. He may not be blunt but he answers everytime... So i thought she was a bit impatient and in rush
PK you are my ideal when it comes to save countries integrity. You have started understanding root of country so nicely. I wish and pray everything comes better and your congress journey makes a better place India to live. Falls narrative today with ruling government had made our life miserable. Our own brother and sisters are fighting on nusience rather spreading love. Please save our country, please boost congress with new ideas.
This man is epic!!! .... Clear,precise, yet objective .... Whichsoever party acquires him, will win!! Ms.dutt .... Hez a pro ma'am .... You cannot cajole or bully this man!!!
DEMOCRACY WORKS PROPERLY ONLY WHEN THERE IS A STRONG OPPOSITION . CERTAINLY INDIA NEEDS A STRONG OPPOSITION . I WOULD SUPPORT ANYONE & EVERYONE THAT HELPS IN BUILDING A STRONG OPPOSITION .
@@Innocentabhi12 even if your cage is made out of gold, it's still a cage. Taiwan is a democracy just opposite to china and they seem to be living a better life. Read more, listen more kid.
Imagine One day Breaking News "PK Joining BJP". Thats days it will be great to See Barkha ,Rajdeep,Srinivasan n Roy,Arfa,Thapar n Gang..tataa Bye Byeee....
India definitely requires a strong opposition. However the opposition needs to be honest and provide an alternative. As of now no opposition leader is trust worthy or deserves to lead the opposition.
According to PK: Hyper Nationalism, Hindutva, Welfare, out of these 3 if you can counter 2 of them you have a chance to counter BJP. SO TRUE!! Now, look at AAP, ignored commenting on CAA/NRC, terrorism, china, Pakistan, etc (Hyper Nationalism). Focussing on welfare (bijli, paani, education) and hindutva/religion (organizing religious visits for all religions, AK reciting Chalisa, going to Haridwar, etc,) See a strategy, go AAP.
@Mission Impossible wow...u clearly hate someone. Hate is not good for the heart dear friend. Come out of your fear and embrace everyone as equal, you will lead a more peaceful life.
If you are silent on CAA/NRC and Delhi riots then there's no point in being the opposition. If your vote is against Hindutva then it should be for the Congress but if you want to defeat BJP just for the sake of it then go to Kejriwal
One of the most experienced interviewers in India keeps asking questions like a Coffee with Karan interview rather than engaging in an exploratory conversation. Such a great respondent she had and all Barkha did was - one quality you admire , one weakness, one leader you think will be the face...
It's indeed a Great lesson to listen to the brilliance of Prashant Kishore. He's, certainly a realistic analyst. He's very clear about the brazen and fragmented political scenario.
The discussion is based on the premise that "BJP has to be defeated in 2024" with out really talking about why? Vision, strategies and mechanics apart, why should BJP be defeated in 2024?
I think it was Barkha being fixated around defeating BJP. Prashant was pretty clear, he wants to create a strong opposition, not necessarily with the intention of defeating only Modi. He mentioned it in the beginning of the interview. There is a difference between the two, whether the opposition unites only to defeat or do they have an alternate vision as well that strikes a cord with the people.
Bcoz bjp is most anti national party... Bciz BJP is a party of most dangerous goons Bcoz BJP is the real tukde tukde gang of indja.. Bcoz BJP is the divider in chief... Bcoz BJP has disrupted the communak harmony of indian societies.. Bcoz BJP has killed the base of democracy.. Bcoz modi is no less than hitler Bcoz BJP is the 2022 east India company.. Bcoz BJP is a party of benefiting onky few Richs on cost of millions poor indians.. Bcoz BJP is infesting hate in young generation.. Bcoz BJP has put india at shame n embarassment on all international platforms... List goes on n on
That is because they are miss using powers ..look at your media ..pathetic ...look at how bills are passed in parliament. ..without dialogue ..when happens then is farmers protest etc ...look at how bjp misused State emergency to disintegrate a state into two parts and convert it into UT. ..unconstitutionally and undemocraticely only because of so much power ...look at how ED etc are misused ...where is goverance ..
It gives me immense pleasure to watch the interview. Despite Barkha's best effort, PK remained stick to his ideas with absolute clarity. Enjoyed it. Hope PK will play some role to change the situation for a better India.
No strategist needed to win elections.. go and stratrgize the need of common people and ways to take away miseries of the poor... Rather than political strategist, we the people of India, need a public grievance strategist.. I wish PK and others get this fact.. Rather than winning elections, win hearts of people.
Every old party is like...we have to win the election..nobody is like ..we have this framework...this model...thats how we gonna develope ur state or country...everybody is like we have to win election
Educated?? Have you ever heard of K.Kamaraj? Uneducated but, did wonders not one Educated would ever thought about how politics and schemes to be introduced. Read about him and compare Educated politicians.
@@yudhvirsingh9909 Sundar Pichai is also educated... Can he run the country ? No right its a different ball game... So in same sense... Padha Likha IITian hai matlab desh acha chala sakta hai... Yeh logic baseless hai !! Padhe likhe toh aap bhi ho..
I was wondering why PK is giving so many interviews. The answer is, by doing these he is publicly inviting Congress back to the discussion table and by making clear statements about his intentions and would be role out in the public, he is trying to give them confidence.
As a proud Indian,Chhattisgarhi,I am blind fan of Bihar and proud Biharis for TRUTH.PK is one of that Bihar cum India's gem.Me and alike understood that in 1990-94 in Bihar where did I serve and learnt about LIFE and TRUTH.God says PK will be/is likely the best PM for India.Jai Hind.
what an outstanding interviewer Barkha Dutt is. Just have a look at all the other interviews PK gave recently and none could get as much info out of him like Barkha did. Kudos!
One word for Prashant Kishore... Simply fantastic. He is clear in his views, more grounded n realistic, knowledgeable with high risk taking stamina. He is daring.. taking on high n mighty bjp force, who still is front runner to 2024 n opposition is still fragmented... It requires courage to tk a challenge... N he has in him that wisdom to connect all loose ends n turn d table in favor of opposition. This man cn actually be d face that nation is searching. Intelligence, patience n hard work n a clearity of ideas.... He is going a long way ... This man
Every few months, when PK feels no one is talking about him and the world is still running fine without chanting his name, he goes to give interviews to the known sympathetic journalists. So more news cycles devoted to him. And he says exactly the same thing in every interview but still gets praises from commenters. There is nothing new in this interview that he hadn't already said in Shekhar Gupta or Navika Kumar's interviews back in Nov 2021.
Yes he is maybe saying the same thing because he is trying to build strong opposition, which will take years.. he has a vision and he will stick to it till end.
True sir.. India likes MASALA every week end -- We go to street corner and have that PANI POORI -- same here -- we tend to listen to same story multiole times without getting bored and PK knows about it .. He kowns hoe foolish voters in this country are .. And how our REPRESNATION OF PEOPLE ACT is full of flaws which he exploits
@@punitrcks What is the vision PK has ? break India vision ?. If PK really has vision let him use that to end VOTE BANK Politics through proper reforms in our election process - He is exploiting the situation and doing major disservice to nation . In 2014 INDIA needed a change from European rule and from 2010 to 2014 was governance filled with scams and hence PM MODI win was people's choice and not PK's magic . Hence if you say PK has vision perhaps he is like criminal lawyer who can argue in favor of actual murderer also. PK has no ethics -- He is power hungry person without values -- He has sensed flrsh in Congress and he is going there .. That is it .
@Mission Impossible : Your detailed explanation is really eye opener sir.. But as of now HINDUs are losing .. Even in 8th to 10th Std history text books we can see all the Hindu Kings were projected as losers which may not betrue BUT our children read that. Now right wing people gave verdict in May 2014 in favor of BJP - Now we are in 2022 January -- 8 Years gone -- What has happened ? Did the center changed any law on Vote bank politics ? No. Still we are holding on to that 1955 law REPRRSENTATION OF PEOPLE ACT which is having at least 200 flaws.. How come PK can make career out of exploitation of weakness of our law .. How come such a open discussion on caste and religion takes place in India . CM should be from JAT , Finance Minister OBC , Home Minister SC , etc.. Where is the room for MERIT in our country ? Zero . for a drop of a hat we quote Article 25 and " OUR RIGHT OF RELIGIOUS KILLING " becomes talk and there are many cases SC has upheld right of minorities ( 20 % people are minorities in India ) as GOSPEL Truth ..? Openly Christians are saying Conversion is Religious duty and Article 25 allows conversion it seems .. Recent case in TN where a girl LAVANYA 14 years young committed suicide for forcefully conversion which she mentioned in her death note with names. No case no media cover nothing.. Where are we heading ? All the time election and vote bank politics -- Can we not end this Vote bank politics ? It is totally possible .. I am sick of this politics which is another name for Corruption .. 2,46 lakhs crore is annual budget of my state out of which 40 % goes for corruption. When I fill a liter of petrol Rs 35 out of Rs 100 goes to CM fund (read state govt). 18 % GST of which 41% comes to state . This is huge attraction for unscrupulous people and we are allowing this through proper legal means called ....... . 30 lakhs cases pending in courts .. Courts taking 34 years for completion of case -- after 20 years the Bollywood movie star was acquitted in hit and run case .. Courts are deciding height of the Pole of DAHI HUNDI in Mumbai -- SC is considering 5 women activities right as supreme and passes judgement in Shabarimala case .. I think we are headed for doomed day -- People are still following rules in India because we are coward people and not having guts .. We are waiting for another Ibrahim Lodi to conquer Delhi like what happened some 1500 years back which appears to be eminent .. I will die before that as I am already 54 years .
@Mission Impossible who do people like you support? PK is a strategist/analyst, not a politicians involved in policy making. I said, I enjoy listening to his arguments and if you get offended by anything he said, it means you are not use to listening to sound arguments. Kids will suffer in our country due to environmental resource scarcity and that worries me more. You made a lot of points in your comment to give a good idea about how well informed and read you are. I hope you find peace!
Nice Conversation. It looks as if Mr P K is heart somewhere, It is his frustration that is showing. In that frustration sometimes he has spoken which is otherwise not in public domain. He genuinely wants to see India growing. Thanks Barkha for a wonderful discussion.
he is just dismissing this party. plus the shortcut is Congress and all other parties should merge with the AAP and let the AAP lead 2024 and the leader should be ARVIND KEJRIWAL.
PK has great answers to all Tough grilling questions. Indeed a very smart man. Sometimes I feel he wants to wash away his SINS of bringing BJP to power and Ruining the Country.
@@asadshetty moreover, what is coming out of him , that to defeat Modi ,a Modi plus version is required . That way he again endorsing that Modi is indispensable in current political scenario .
Insightful discussion, but what about voters like me in Mumbai who would want to vote for Congress say in upcoming BMC elections but are wary that they may end up allying with Shiv Sena just for power sharing? What's the message, as PK says, being sent here?
Great interview. I do hope that PK and Congress reach a deal and understanding very soon. That’s the only hope to get the country out of the current mess.
@Mission Impossible The coalition of all those pictures shown in the beginning of video are active to destroy the Sanatan Dharma from the soil of India in order to establish an Islamic State of India mainly. All the so called Hindu leaders shown have very big amount of scam money in different foreign countries. And they're determined to survive all generation after generations by encashment of the illegal deposits they possessed. Is this coalition leaders are patriot and at present developing the country??
PK is one person who can truly strengthen the opposition .. his approach is clinical, analytical and pragmatic. I do hope he is able to galvanise the opposition, which is the need of the hour for India. Strong and credible opposition only strengthens democracy, to the benefit of everyone, irrespective of who you vote for.
This man is politically so aware I mean he is dissecting each and every move. Very intelligent, to the point and not beating around the bush unlike most of the politically affiliated people who seem to have no clue what is being asked.
In my view he dilutes the truth just enough to suit his own agenda. For instance he seems to be a bit too keen on pushing the Hinduvta agenda against BJP that does not quite resonate with most of the Hindus I know. Its not a 1 V 1 for or against so-called Hinduvta but rather its an equation between Hindu and Hindu lite. His theory that a credible alternative can emerge around congress smacks of a bit opportunism by any objective electoral analysis of recent political trends.
What an exceptionally intelligent guy, prashant kishore ji truly is! I mean, the kind of answers he gives back to sometimes a little stupid or confusing kind of questions from barkha dutt, clearly shows that prashant kishore is very, very clear about his ideas and he actually knows what to do to turn the tables against the current ruling government! This man has a vision, really. And this time, at least ppl like me don't want just a party who's interested in defeating BJP in lok sabha elections, but we want a candidate who's truly willing to work for the nation, face the real issues of the nation and come out with workable solutions. That's it. We don't want that same old, religious or sentimental brainwashing to divert us from the real, nagging issues which have been so much ignored since decades that they have become a major, intolerable problem for the nation now. We want such a leader who can face such issues and even motivate the youth to co-operate with the government in bringing out the positive changes.
@@adeshmukhb rehearsed? eco chamber is where majority of Indian population drumming their chest thumping hindu nationalist beat. No nation in history with nazi style nationalism had a good ending and history will repeat in India with maybe millions dead. Its beginning of the end
The Goal of strong opposition is laudable and cent percent correct . If able to do, it will be a great contribution towards the company. The goal surely should not be to defeat someone or win, but only a formidable opposition so critical for the nation. PK is greatest at the moment.
Your voice is important n helpful to most of us who CARE ABOUT OUR FUTURE GENERATIONS GOANS FOR GOA PARADISE OF INDIA FREEDOM OF speech and GOD'S GRACE IS SUFFICIENT FOR US
We need a PK in Indian politics to make it more secular and rise above religious bias and separate religion from politics. Wish we had a leader like him with clarity of thought, word and action to move ahead. Couldn’t stop watching the interview.
Kejriwal needs to build up his image fast as a pm candidate fast before 2024 elections. There's a difference between regional leadership image and national leadership image who can deal international situations like immigration global warming pakistan US china etc
Kejriwal is very shrewd politician and the quality that I admire from him is as a politician is that He learns his mistakes and tries to correct it.. unlike other leaders..
@@shubhamsinghal1727 Right .. if you keep on saying modi is worse bad.. Nothing will happen. At the end of the day if not modi. YOU have to answer what is the alternative agenda that you have got.. ? What is your model of development
@@ragnar6592 what AK did was negative advertisement that actually helped modi Now he has redefined his strategy straight ahead only of development issues Handling media is also a big thing
PK is certainly a great strategist and thinker. His point about need of a strong opposition is absolutely correct. Democracy needs strong opposition. The question is how the fractured opposition can achieve 4 M's: Message, Messenger, Machinery and Mechanics and stay together if and when they succeed in defeating BJP. By nature of politics leads to chaos. Not withstanding PK's great success at state levels since 2015, I believe, the National level will require order of magnitude higher efforts. In the end, the Messenger will have to be the PM candidate. If the Messenger emerges before 2024, the opposition can succeed. If the Messenger is "Collective Leadership", it will not stay together even after successfully defeating BJP. Janata Party defeated formidable Indira Gandhi only to crumble shortly thereafter. In my humble opinion, only Congress has presence in entire India, how so far weakened. Congress will have to be the opposition party that implements the 4 M's. Maha-Gathbandhan at national level is unlikely to succeed in providing the strong opposition. I see BJP Vs Congress and rest parties in so called Third front. BJP and Congress can fight it out at national level. Many third parties can and will continue to dominate at State level. In the end, the national level governance needs to with an united strong party whether BJP or Congress. At state level the politics may remain fractured...
With that smile on her face , it is obvious that Prashant Kishore joining politics warms the cockles of Barka's heart. Here is someone who can defeat Modi in 2024!!
Congratulations PK. Democracy definitely needs strong opposition. Nation will remember you for safeguarding Democracy. Crystallization of thoughts towards better India and pursue your approach.May God bless you
Prashant Kishore - a rare, analytical and yet practical brain. I wish the leaders of Congress Party reflect over his arguments about the possibilities of mounting a credible and feasible challenge to BJP
Prashanth Ji so called democratic election in India, always fought on religion and race not on the performance of government and ability of leaders, which is the main purpose of a government. Indian practice of election is not more than fooling public in the name of religion and caste. You being a smart election strategist, can you turn this practice by educating public that name of government is performance, not turning it as a priest dom .
Had you been in Europe or the US you would be complaining that election is always fought on race and not performance. Elections are always fought on identity. That is human nature. It just so happens that at this moment in India, people's primary identity is their religious identity.
Can there be a new party (say Federalist Party) who fights only parliamentary elections and doesn't compete in assembly elections? If yes would such a party more likely to be supported by local parties, other things being equal?
Good point. The parties active in the southern part of our Country are desperate to take part in the formation of central government and are very much popular in their areas.
@@SAFFRONINFERNO where ?? Only karnatka n a few in Telangana... where bjp will get routed this time... who is delusional now? n stop being shallow andha bhakt !
I am 18 years old from bihar. I too much interested in politics. hmm movie bhi dekhte hai to Prakash jha ka hi, abhi tak hmm vote nhi diye hai but probably 2024 me first vote karenge.ye sab to thik hai but mrs. barkha u miss a question : that question is in bihar or india what pk thinks Robinhood in politics. Aap samajh rhe hai hmm kya kehna chah rhe hai. Agar aap kichad ko kichad se saaf kijiagaa to kaise kichad saaf hoga. Thanks for these types of contents 🙏🙏♥️
PK is blessed with amazing clarity...such level of clarity that as we listen to him, we are able to imagine the functioning of a strong opposition front
Mr PK you are going as opposition party candidate in historical 2024 general election.BEST WISHES.Your answer to last Q of Barkhaji thrilled every Indian.Amen,तथास्तु,सो ईट बी।ईश्वर करे आप ,आप जैसे ईस पवित्र देश का मार्गदर्शन करें।जय हिंद।
Much more to be decided based on 2022 assembly elections. If AAP performs well then AAP will be the only Strong party to lead opposition. PK and AK may join hands then!
Happy Republic Day. Glad Modiji, BJP and all of us changed the foundational narrative in India. Netaji and INA were instrumental in Indian Independence Fight. Foreign hand and their Indian Stooges were intent on keeping us uniformed and ashamed of Indians and India. Thank God for the TRUTH. Vande Mataram
What about UP specifically. If PK could throw some light on his understanding of possible narratives for the opposition. Barkha, could it be possible to ask him this? Thx n Salute to you, your memory n spirit. In Solidarity. J
Barkha is a master interviewer, night and day from Vasu's interview. Side point - Pandits trying to find hidden meanings in what PK is saying and getting frustrated that there's nothing controversial. His track record shows he's a thorough professional, and one of the most consistent and transparent political figures. Looking forward to 2024 (and beyond) to see how he applies his experience, ability to make data-informed decisions and belief in Gandhian principles to the Indian political arena
