Тёмный

Prof. Francis Sempa: How to Think Strategically about China and Russia 

WestminsterInstitute
Подписаться 12 тыс.
Просмотров 8 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

21 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 42   
@alaskavaper2490
@alaskavaper2490 Год назад
Excellent discussion.
@rakadus
@rakadus Год назад
Logic and sanity.
@Westminsterinstitute
@Westminsterinstitute Год назад
Glad you enjoyed his talk! You may also enjoy our latest interview with Doug Bandow from the Cato Institute.
@ekesandras1481
@ekesandras1481 Год назад
The truth is, that most of the central part of the so called Eurasian landmass is a wasteland, a desert, a barren land almost empty of people. Yes, China and Russia share a border, but the Chinese heartland and the Russian heartland are thousands of kilometers away from each other, inbetween is ice and snow, swamps and mosquitos, deserts and forests and almost no people. The country of Kazakhstan, that looks huge on the world map, only has 18 million inhabitants, Mongolia has only 3 million inhabitants, Turkmenistan has only 6 million inhabitants, etc. Asia is only really populated along the coast, from China, Souteast Asia, Bangladesh, India, Pakistan, Iran, Turkey. Everything North of that line is only interesting for extracting resources or hiding rockets.
@kalvin1123
@kalvin1123 Год назад
About Japan and the war: Syngman Rhee, the eventual first president of the Republic of Korea spent the first half of the 20th Century in the US. And during that time, he wrote a book titled "Japan Inside Out". He explained that Japan couldn't be trusted and warned that the US would go to war against Japan. The book was published in early 1941 and became a bestseller before the Pearl Harbor attack. So, the war against Japan was more than because of economic reasons.
@lynnelee4390
@lynnelee4390 4 месяца назад
Finally someone with some sense
@alaskavaper2490
@alaskavaper2490 Год назад
How about some serious diplomatic efforts by America with the Chinese, instead of the current militaristic the approach of our government. I believe that bipolar diplomacy or some sort of cooperative hegemony should be the topic on the agenda! This is far preferable to a likely major war and possible nuclear armageddon. 😢 I was born in 1936 and have experienced much of America's war-like nature. It is now most urgent that the earth needs major change if humans are to survive. Will “AI” be that change, or will everything accelerate and only get worse? Soon my small light will go out so I wish you all a successful transition.🎉❤
@stanleymax4388
@stanleymax4388 Год назад
The US trying to defend Taiwan is like China trying to defend Puerto Rico. It's not logistically possible.
@dddz961
@dddz961 Год назад
Then how have they done it up until now?
@willengel2458
@willengel2458 Год назад
nothing is impossible for uncle sam, verbally.
@ekesandras1481
@ekesandras1481 Год назад
Have you heard of the first island chain? From the Philippines to the North of Japan (and South Korea). They all don't like the People's Republic of China. Taiwan wouldn't be alone in a case of conflict.
@willengel2458
@willengel2458 Год назад
@@ekesandras1481 Uncle is retreating, its assets and personnel are in the second island chain and beyond.
@willengel2458
@willengel2458 Год назад
let's not forget, China when it was at its weakest, along with North Korea took on Uncle Sam and its lackeys, in spite of superior weaponry, unchallenged airpower, better logistics, earned its first non-win in the Korean war. it's second non-win in Viet-Nam. you think North Viet-Nam could've imposed a DMZ on US?
@dddz961
@dddz961 Год назад
Is earning a non-win something to be proud of? How many soldiers did China lose in three weeks of fighting in Vietnam?
@willengel2458
@willengel2458 Год назад
@@dddz961 India is holding a grudge, and so is Viet-Nam. are you aware what happened at SCS in 2016?
@dddz961
@dddz961 Год назад
@@willengel2458 India, whose northern borders China encroaches upon? Vietnam, whose boats and islands China claims? Making every neighbor an enemy is not a foreign policy.
@ekesandras1481
@ekesandras1481 Год назад
North-Vietnam was supported by the Soviet Union and not by Red China.
@chrischicago6928
@chrischicago6928 Год назад
Misinformed. It is we have very DIFFERENT definition of what "victory" is. If one reads more history, here are the facts: 1/ China casulties close to 5 MM; 2/ US casulties close to 50K. US Media was in Uproar when 50K casulties occured. If one defines a war with 5MM deaths/ injuries (while the enemy losts 50K) A WIN, I will take A LOSS on any day.
@christophervaughan2637
@christophervaughan2637 Год назад
God this is a horrible philosophy: “looking after our own” as if humanity is not “our own”. It’s insane to talk of “our own” on a nationalistic basis. This is surely merely a dressed up kind of racism. This is not to say there is no logic in some of the strategic thinking, such as China being a greater threat than Russia. But if you remove human sympathy then who will be your ally? This is also part of strategy. To show human feeling for the suffering. What I would argue is that the philosophy of this lecturer: to make strategy a matter of self interest and power is exactly the thinking which has alienated the US from so much of the world and which has made many parts of the global south unable to feel safe with Western power: thus making them silently side with China and Russia.
@dddz961
@dddz961 Год назад
What the heck are you talking about? You even edited this rant and it makes no sense.
@christophervaughan2637
@christophervaughan2637 Год назад
@@dddz961 what’s wrong with editing in order to correct typos? And it’s certainly not my fault if you are unable to make any substantive criticism of my comment and you can only resort to ad hominem. That is entirely your failure and you need to take responsibility for your own failure.
@dddz961
@dddz961 Год назад
@@christophervaughan2637 are you deranged? Is that your problem? You think he is "racist" against Ukraine for prioritizing Taiwan more? What is his race, child? Does he look Asian to you?
@tbearus
@tbearus Год назад
They are all right, NATO has US for both creating and fighting the wars. They only need to enjoy life.😂
@mityabor
@mityabor Год назад
India nowadays has two times bigger economy than Russia, the biggest population, and is formidable military power, which has a border dispute with China. Perhaps world has changed over the last 50 years, and now "triangle" is USA, India, China.
@newhailman
@newhailman Год назад
India relies on Russia for almost all of it's defensive arms purchases while we arm Pakistan in the meantime. The India you reference doesn't exist.
@pjeng1
@pjeng1 Год назад
India is not a key player in this world power game. India has none of the key strength qualities needed to become a super power like the US, Russia, and China.
@rdf098311
@rdf098311 Год назад
@@pjeng1 Russia is not a superpower
@rdf098311
@rdf098311 Год назад
@Tyt Xlx what are these fundamentals?
@alaskavaper2490
@alaskavaper2490 Год назад
I await an answer...lol
Далее
Stephen Kotkin: Sphere of Influence II
1:31:05
Просмотров 307 тыс.
Немного заблудился 😂
00:16
Просмотров 251 тыс.
Steven W. Mosher: China's Demographic Challenge
1:05:00
Full Video | Episode 139 | Col. Douglas Macgregor (ret.)
1:27:00
The Future of U.S.-China Relations - Joseph Nye
1:31:26
The Deserter: Parts 1-3
2:17:55
Просмотров 13 тыс.
Немного заблудился 😂
00:16
Просмотров 251 тыс.