Тёмный

Psychologist vs. MythBuster on God and Human Consciousness 

Apologetics Roadshow
Подписаться 251 тыс.
Просмотров 101 тыс.
50% 1

Jordan Peterson (psychologist) and Adam Savage (MythBuster) share their latest thoughts about the MIRACLE of human consciousness.
PATREON: / acts17apologetics
SUBSCRIBESTAR: www.subscribes...
PAYPAL: www.paypal.me/...
STORE: acts-17-merch....
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @apologeticsroadshow
VIDEOS CITED:
"There’s NO Good Argument for Atheism w/ Jordan Peterson": • There’s NO Good Argume...
"Adam Savage at the Reason Rally": • Adam Savage at The Rea...
"Is Adam Savage Still an Atheist?": • Is Adam Savage Still a...

Опубликовано:

 

26 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,7 тыс.   
@kingvinoda3896
@kingvinoda3896 3 месяца назад
I remember the atheist movement of the 2010s. I thought I was gonna see Star Trek become real whenever religion died, instead I have lived to see people growing more and more mentally ill and society becoming less morally sound. I regret doing my part to bring that. Jesus please forgive me.
@trentitybrehm5105
@trentitybrehm5105 3 месяца назад
God will not reject a broken and repentant heart.
@AtheismPoisonsEverything
@AtheismPoisonsEverything 3 месяца назад
Forget the atheist movement, it is dying, and from its ashes will rise strong anti atheists, which will be the total opposite of atheist religion. Not communists. Not feminists. Not muslims. Not atheists. Strongly against lgbtqwertyp (p stands for pdfilia) and indoctrination of kids with falsehood like men can give birth. And very very pro Christianity. Militant anti atheism.
@thegodofalldragons
@thegodofalldragons 3 месяца назад
Even the Federation of Star Trek was still religious, at least by Kirk's time ("We have no need for 'the gods.' We find the one sufficient." - Captain Kirk, "Who Mourns for Adonis"). Granted, probably only because of TV censors, but still, it ironically makes more sense than what the creators would have wanted. That's always been the thing that bothered me about Star Trek, as much as I like it otherwise. The creators thought you could get utopia without faith in anything other than humanity itself.
@commonman9782
@commonman9782 3 месяца назад
Kyrie Eleison
@danielhicks4826
@danielhicks4826 3 месяца назад
Yup and and most of them now reveals what cowardly demented anti truth anti biology and morality activists fanatics they truly are. There's a reason like 99 percent of the Adam Savages' and Neil Dagropey Tysons of the world now unconditionally side with objective nonsense and fanatical cultists like the LGBT cult for example.
@SoYouAreB
@SoYouAreB 3 месяца назад
Adam Savage has busted his own myth, savagely.
@MeanOldLady
@MeanOldLady 3 месяца назад
He's such a useless, man-child.
@Jesus_Student
@Jesus_Student 3 месяца назад
He's still a Mythbuster at heart. So he'll bust the myth of evolution eventually.
@SoYouAreB
@SoYouAreB 3 месяца назад
@@Jesus_Student I'm agree with you.
@remimwamba1482
@remimwamba1482 3 месяца назад
Wierd emoji
@SoYouAreB
@SoYouAreB 3 месяца назад
@@remimwamba1482 Lefties loosing it all.
@jamesshaver2376
@jamesshaver2376 3 месяца назад
For non religious people the “reason rally” sure looks a lot like a religion
@bozak2320
@bozak2320 3 месяца назад
More like a cult
@derekdavis3004
@derekdavis3004 3 месяца назад
@@bozak2320 Yes.
@rb98769
@rb98769 3 месяца назад
Like the Cult of Reason, that one didn't go so well.
@kladies3021
@kladies3021 3 месяца назад
And don't forget the Militant League of Atheists!!😬🤦🏽‍♀️
@kladies3021
@kladies3021 3 месяца назад
Ever heard of Sunday Assembly? Also there's a literal book of atheistic evangelism!!
@James_Bee
@James_Bee 3 месяца назад
"Everything that exists is because 'we' tested it and proved it" But, those things already existed; all we did was elevate our understanding of that which already was...
@thegreatid3595
@thegreatid3595 3 месяца назад
Yup people actually genuinely think that the big bang theory created the ability to make things like video games, cars etc. AI is another example, there's absolutely no way that anything other than a powerful mind could create something like this.
@Soliloquy-gy6zf
@Soliloquy-gy6zf 3 месяца назад
Humans live through lower mind, endlessly asking for "evidence"... never having understood how they happen to see what they're looking at.
@STho205
@STho205 3 месяца назад
Look at you being all Plato and Socrates!!!! A great statement of conscious enlightenment.
@Soliloquy-gy6zf
@Soliloquy-gy6zf 3 месяца назад
@@STho205 Plato and Socrates didn't understand how they happened to see what they were looking at. To this day science still doesn't know what "matter" is. Let alone "consciousness".
@browserboy1984
@browserboy1984 3 месяца назад
We have elevated our understanding in some cases and strayed far off path in other cases.
@collegepennsylvania837
@collegepennsylvania837 3 месяца назад
“If we find ourselves with a desire that nothing in this world can satisfy, the most probable explanation is that we were made for another world.” - CS Lewis
@hllyenaylleth9576
@hllyenaylleth9576 6 дней назад
Although the American Natives are often described has having been very satisfied with their lives
@fly_fast777
@fly_fast777 3 месяца назад
ex-muslim long time ago, deeper I study partical physic the closer it makes me to Jesus.
@miguelatkinson
@miguelatkinson 3 месяца назад
That's just stupid
@technicianbis5250-ig1zd
@technicianbis5250-ig1zd 3 месяца назад
​@@miguelatkinson Explain the complexity of a single cell?
@erlinghaaland5392
@erlinghaaland5392 3 месяца назад
​@@miguelatkinson bros Mad 😢😂
@catholicbeth2371
@catholicbeth2371 3 месяца назад
​@@miguelatkinsonMiguel, That shows a misunderstanding on your part of just how truly strange particle physics is...
@browserboy1984
@browserboy1984 3 месяца назад
@@miguelatkinson 1.0 GPA vibes right here.
@JaiAndDoC
@JaiAndDoC 3 месяца назад
Jesus is LORD 🙏
@SeekTheCross
@SeekTheCross 3 месяца назад
Yes He is ✝️🕊️
@torquemaddertorquemadder2080
@torquemaddertorquemadder2080 3 месяца назад
...and the iewish Moshiach is the Antichrist!
@Dude0000
@Dude0000 3 месяца назад
And Atheists detest Him because they think they are gods.
@mcfarvo
@mcfarvo 3 месяца назад
Amen!
@TJ-um8ce
@TJ-um8ce 3 месяца назад
Yes He is! 🙏🙏
@rothgang
@rothgang 3 месяца назад
The deeper you dig, the more you realize that in practice, atheists do not believe that there is no god, but that they are in fact God.
@greatmusic142
@greatmusic142 3 месяца назад
wot dat mean dawg?? u need to hit da books bro cuz dat makes no sense at all
@morganpauls1873
@morganpauls1873 3 месяца назад
yeah but its their role to play so it makes sense that they do
@Soliloquy-gy6zf
@Soliloquy-gy6zf 3 месяца назад
They are. God is everyone
@Nick-ij5nt
@Nick-ij5nt 3 месяца назад
@@Soliloquy-gy6zf If you're God then raise yourself from the dead and I'll believe it.
@Soliloquy-gy6zf
@Soliloquy-gy6zf 3 месяца назад
@@Nick-ij5nt from selfish... to self-less. Erase yourself... to raise yourSelf. To be or not to be. No one is born again without dying. There is no "me". There is only God
@GSpotter63
@GSpotter63 3 месяца назад
It never ceases to amaze me how so many people can believe that mankind will one day make self-aware AI but reject any thought that we ourselves could be the product of a higher intellect.
@tetelestai5522
@tetelestai5522 3 месяца назад
“‘Ask, and it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you.’” - Matthew 7:7 (ESV)
@henryschmit3340
@henryschmit3340 3 месяца назад
Everytime an atheist voices an immaterial abstract thought, he is demonstrating the existence of his own immaterial mind. Everytime he speaks he refutes atheism.
@almightyzentaco
@almightyzentaco 3 месяца назад
Just to clarify I'm not an atheist, but the belief in consciousness is not the same as the belief in God or a specific metaphysic.
@lizzard13666
@lizzard13666 3 месяца назад
@@almightyzentacoIt logically presupposes it though.
@almightyzentaco
@almightyzentaco 3 месяца назад
@lizzard13666 I don't agree. Many people believe in a world without the divine but with consciousness. I don't think the two concepts are necessarily linked. Consciousness shows that there is more to reality than we understand and it hints at the immaterial. It doesn't really show the existence of God or God's nature. We could easily conceive of a universe that itself is Consciousness. Panpsychism for example.
@henryschmit3340
@henryschmit3340 3 месяца назад
@@almightyzentaco I'm sure there are all kinds of beliefs regarding consciousness.
@PSNSMANIACALMIND1st
@PSNSMANIACALMIND1st 3 месяца назад
God is undeniable, "I tell you that, if these should hold their peace, the stones would immediately cry out."
@billbissenas2973
@billbissenas2973 3 месяца назад
When you begin to search for God seriously, you find Him.
@discobunny4eva759
@discobunny4eva759 3 месяца назад
Yes, he is more than happy to meet you, as the father of the prodigal son had demonstrated.
@sdud1801
@sdud1801 3 месяца назад
Amen. I was stubborn. It took many years and it was a painful process. But I learned that the truth can withstand the serious inquiry of a humble mind, much to my surprise.
@braedenmclean5304
@braedenmclean5304 3 месяца назад
Except for that time he made it so the pharaoh was literally incapable of finding him “hardening his heart” so god had an excuse to punish an entire culture
@joshuakarr-BibleMan
@joshuakarr-BibleMan 3 месяца назад
​@@braedenmclean5304 The pharaoh wasn't searching for God. He was trying to keep his slaves.
@braedenmclean5304
@braedenmclean5304 3 месяца назад
@@joshuakarr-BibleMan “hey Moses, go tell the pharaoh to free your people, but I’m going to harden his heart so he says no and I get to throw plagues and stuff at the Egyptian people (not just the pharaoh) so he *then* let’s your people go.”
@jwc713
@jwc713 3 месяца назад
They presuppose the validity of their reasoning while using their reasoning to prove that it is valid. This is a circular argument.
@GhostBearCommander
@GhostBearCommander 3 месяца назад
Underrated comment.
@JonathanVachon777
@JonathanVachon777 3 месяца назад
Exactly. Like evolution and fossils. -How do you know how old are the fossils? -because the layers of dirt -how do you know how old are the layers of dirt? -because of the fossils
@rwesenberg
@rwesenberg 3 месяца назад
Circularity is rife in metaphysics. The problem may be a limitation of language with respect to being.
@rubiks6
@rubiks6 3 месяца назад
Every argument, if carried to its ultimate end, is circular because we live in a closed universe. I stopped complaining about the circularity of arguments. Some of my own are often circular. The Bible is the Word of God because the Bible says it is the Word of God. You need to decide (I chose that word carefully) if some element of a circular argument is true which can validate the entire circle of reasoning. Of course, if some element is false, you can discard the entire circle of reasoning.
@Nick-ij5nt
@Nick-ij5nt 3 месяца назад
atheists like to talk about logic but there is not basis to believe in logic on their world view because logic is metaphysical concept and not made of matter
@deaconblooze1
@deaconblooze1 3 месяца назад
I've never understood why these people who supposedly 'love science' think that the default position, if you're not convinced by a religion, would be anti- that religion. The REASONable, scientific position would be 'I don't/can't know'. Glad to see so many finally at least coming down off their anti- God high horse.
@matityaloran9157
@matityaloran9157 3 месяца назад
The only purely evidence based stance would be agnosticism
@savioblanc
@savioblanc 3 месяца назад
The more you listen to them, the more you realise that they are adult children trying to be rebellious against the religion of their parents, which in this case was primarily Christianity and the older they got, the more pathetic they sound. It didn't come from reason. It came from rebellion. And anything that comes from rebellion, comes from Pride. And Pride always cometh before the Fall. That is where we are now.
@sampreece
@sampreece 3 месяца назад
The brain is like a radio. To think consciousness is within the brain is as ridiculous as thinking a song/ singer is within the radio.
@miszker8724
@miszker8724 3 месяца назад
Perfect analogy
@markmcflounder15
@markmcflounder15 3 месяца назад
Wow! This is a beautiful statement. I wish I would have listened to that.....now I have a broken radio that I have to replace 😊
@paullavoie5542
@paullavoie5542 3 месяца назад
Bad analogy because it seems like your saying conscientious doesn't happen in our body but is sent to our body like a radio.
@PSNSMANIACALMIND1st
@PSNSMANIACALMIND1st 3 месяца назад
​@paullavoie5542 That is at least partially the case, hence intrusive thoughts, or logismoi in the Greek.
@emmanuel8310
@emmanuel8310 3 месяца назад
​@@paullavoie5542 That's exactly the point, we know almost nothing about consciousness. That's a good analogy. Else...tell us, where's your consciousness from?
@petrkarv
@petrkarv 3 месяца назад
The issue is pride.
@Soliloquy-gy6zf
@Soliloquy-gy6zf 3 месяца назад
... and nothing else. 👍
@oussamaettaieb21
@oussamaettaieb21 3 месяца назад
Fact 💯
@mharpold128
@mharpold128 12 дней назад
"And in professing to be wise, they became fools". Roman's 1:22-24 KJV
@rubiks6
@rubiks6 3 месяца назад
Atheists often tell me there is no evidence for God or ask me to show them evidence for God. I usually respond, "You are the evidence."
@GThomas-qq6mp
@GThomas-qq6mp 3 месяца назад
I avoid that. Just like saying oh my god in front of an atheist. It's a pride thing running, they inflate themself as being the one instead of being like a child of God.
@SNinjaQK
@SNinjaQK 3 месяца назад
That's not evidence
@bradyd.6332
@bradyd.6332 3 месяца назад
Every explanation atheist use is this”God can’t exist because he doesn’t act the way I would if I were God”!
@AmbiguousMan724
@AmbiguousMan724 3 месяца назад
​@@SNinjaQK Of course it is.
@SNinjaQK
@SNinjaQK 3 месяца назад
@@AmbiguousMan724 Can you explain how?
@MOR54DA7H30S
@MOR54DA7H30S 3 месяца назад
These videos have brought me back to the church... I was baptized as a baby but never did anything faithful I'd say. Just got confirmed not a week ago!
@nikkismith7154
@nikkismith7154 3 месяца назад
Baby baptism is not biblical..... And beware of the church. Enter into a personal relationship with Christ.
@smidlee7747
@smidlee7747 3 месяца назад
As nikkismith pointed out the church doesn't save it's Jesus Christ who saves. They can baptize you a million times and it wouldn't save anyone. Jesus Christ is the only one who saves. Watch out for those in the church who glorify the church more than Jesus Christ. The church is the bride of Christ , the WEAKER vessel who role is submission to the authority of Christ.
@thepierianspring2353
@thepierianspring2353 3 месяца назад
Welcome home! Ignore all the Biblical illiterates trying to pass themselves off as Biblical scholars!
@JonathanVachon777
@JonathanVachon777 3 месяца назад
Welcome on board!
@GideonNine
@GideonNine 3 месяца назад
Welcome back brother.
@smidlee7747
@smidlee7747 3 месяца назад
There is no reason to believe reason is a byproduct of that which has no reason.
@Bilfford
@Bilfford 3 месяца назад
There is much reason to believe that reason is a byproduct not of that which has no reason but rather that it is a gift from the one of who's reason is flawless.
@tsuich00i
@tsuich00i 3 месяца назад
It's a mira-I mean cosmic accident!
@AtheismPoisonsEverything
@AtheismPoisonsEverything 3 месяца назад
@@tsuich00i A miracle in atheist religion is defined as "the claim that men can menstruate and give birth, despite there has been zero cases through history of this being true"
@jamiesimms7084
@jamiesimms7084 3 месяца назад
That's very reasonable
@aaronharlow2137
@aaronharlow2137 3 месяца назад
I find it amazing how Atheists claim that just because you can explain HOW something operates, that somehow disproves the existence of an operator. Like saying, "the lightbulb is lighting the room because of electricity, and since we know how electricity works independently, this disproves the idea that someone turned on the lightswitch."
@GThomas-qq6mp
@GThomas-qq6mp 3 месяца назад
That's a good analogy. The other day I came across a meme about the endless discussion whether there was a 6 or 9 laying on the ground, it's about the perspective. The 3rd denominator, the christian man in the meme saying: Someone laid that number down as a 6 or 9, so he will know the truth.
@braedenmclean5304
@braedenmclean5304 3 месяца назад
That is a pretty good example….for a child and if you don’t think about it for more then a couple seconds. I mean it’s easy to mock something when your straw man stops at the explanation of how a lightbulb works at “electricity” and doesn’t go on to “needs someone to flip a switch for it to turn on” Just because you end all ideas and problems with “and god did it” doesn’t mean everyone else does the same with other things
@aaronharlow2137
@aaronharlow2137 3 месяца назад
@braedenmclean5304 that's exactly what Atheism does though. It stops at "everything works this way" and "this is how" and is based on the assumption that no one turned the light switch. Basing the conclusion on the assertion that your presupposition is correct is circular reasoning
@braedenmclean5304
@braedenmclean5304 3 месяца назад
@@aaronharlow2137 it’s literally not even remotely how science works. There is very rarely a moment where any scientist will say “yes this is 100% exactly how it happened and there is no room for improvement” because we are always learning new things about how the world works. Science is like one long passive aggressive argument taking place over decades. There hasn’t been a theory that has been put forth that hasn’t had at least a dozen other scientists say “that’s what you think? I’m going to spend years of my life trying to prove you wrong idiot” In Christianity if your reasoning doesn’t end with “and god is the best and made everything” you are dismissed entirely and told you are going to suffer for eternity because of it. But it bring it fully home here is a question. How was the sun formed? God made it How do we know god made the sun? Because he said so But how do we know he is right Because god
@aaronharlow2137
@aaronharlow2137 3 месяца назад
@braedenmclean5304 I'm talking about Atheism. Not science. Atheism. What is the meaning of life? I don't know, but it definitely wasn't God. Why are we here? I don't know, but it has nothing to do with God. How did the natural order come about, since nature has a beginning? How could nature have been created from nature? I don't know, but definitely not God
@psynergy007
@psynergy007 3 месяца назад
Quote by theist polymath Leibniz "If you could blow the brain up to the size of a mill and walk about inside, you would not find thought or consciousness". Even in the 1700s this guy knew.
@braedenmclean5304
@braedenmclean5304 3 месяца назад
“Ya, I can dip my hands in mercury and nothing bad will happen” - also people from the 1700s
@jwc713
@jwc713 3 месяца назад
@@braedenmclean5304 Truth hurts.
@braedenmclean5304
@braedenmclean5304 3 месяца назад
@@jwc713 is that why so many people go to religion, to help hide away form what hurts
@psynergy007
@psynergy007 3 месяца назад
@@braedenmclean5304 atheism is a fairy story for men afraid of the light.
@Nemija
@Nemija 11 дней назад
@@braedenmclean5304 Let's assume someone actually DID say this about mercury. I am not rooting for any side here, just thinking. Do we discard everything from the past? Because of mercury? How about James Webb? Do we discard everything up to THIS DAY that came from atheists, because the telescope challenged a few important astronomical concepts? That new atheist stuff might have worked well back in the 90s. Now you've got to try harder. Dawkins and Hawking....well, they just don't impress that many people anymore. Peace. ✌️
@nezele
@nezele 3 месяца назад
"And I have concluded after careful consideration that this person keeping score...is ME." oh my god lmao
@dansands6363
@dansands6363 3 месяца назад
The pride and arrogance on full display
@James_Bee
@James_Bee 3 месяца назад
That's satanism.
@michelepaige8080
@michelepaige8080 3 месяца назад
"You can be God" sounded much better when the serpent said it first back in the Garden.
@i7Qp4rQ
@i7Qp4rQ 3 месяца назад
@@michelepaige8080 "Ye shall be as gods." = "transhumanism"
@PSNSMANIACALMIND1st
@PSNSMANIACALMIND1st 3 месяца назад
​@i7Qp4rQ nothing good ever starts with "trans"
@TheMarredVessel
@TheMarredVessel 3 месяца назад
You have a great approach at pointing out the nonsense of the minds that are blinded. May God open their eyes and give them new hearts.
@uumlau
@uumlau 3 месяца назад
Tyson didn't say "Facts are true whether or not you believe in them," as MythBuster claims, he said, "Science is true whether or not you believe in it." And that second version is absolutely false. The essence of science is being skeptical of claims of truth, not an act of faith in the practitioners of "The Science".
@tirididjdjwieidiw1138
@tirididjdjwieidiw1138 3 месяца назад
even if there is a way to perfectly reconstruct your brain with every single chemical interaction, all your neurons being exactly wired right, it is not you, it’s someone else. Even atheists have to concede that consciousness cannot be purely material.
@KevinGeneFeldman
@KevinGeneFeldman 3 месяца назад
@@mithunbalaji8199 This is nonsense. In fact the difference between you and me would have to be the same difference between your brain now and our brain a nano second in the past, because the tiniest change in your brain equals an entirely new brain and therefore should equate to an entirely new person as different as I am to you. The memory does not phase shift over to you because it isn't about the memory, its about the one who observes the memory. I observe the memory no matter what it is or how it changes and I will observe any memory I receive, I would observe any body I receive, I have never been replaced with a new observer.
@mithunbalaji8199
@mithunbalaji8199 3 месяца назад
@@KevinGeneFeldman if you lose the ability to make any thoughts or emotions and even lose all other form of senses but except visual, it's gonna be like a deep state of meditation . Awareness or consciousness exists but objects like self does not. There is no sense of self. Think of it in this way all your thoughts, emotions, sensory experiences etc.. are all analogous to matter. Then what is conciousness or awareness? Matter has the property to occupy volume no matter whether it is strange matter from neurtron stars or some ice cubes. Consciousness as such is something similar to the property of volume when thoughts, emotions are matter themselves (analogy) It's ridiculous and far fetched to claim that consciousness itself is metaphysically distinct which is akin to claiming volume as a property itself is metaphysically distinct from one object to another. Try looking into open individualism, Advaita Vedanta and non self in Buddhism, if you are a Christian it's time to atleast temporarily remove your metaphysical dogmas and stuff like souls
@Dialogos1989
@Dialogos1989 3 месяца назад
There is no “you” that persists moment to moment. There is a flow of consciousness.
@KevinGeneFeldman
@KevinGeneFeldman 3 месяца назад
@@Dialogos1989 That doesn't mean anything, thats just words.
@Dialogos1989
@Dialogos1989 3 месяца назад
@@KevinGeneFeldman read some eastern philosophy, Hume, or Schopenhauer. The idea that the “self” is an illusion isn’t new
@JackL-hd1cj
@JackL-hd1cj 3 месяца назад
Let's pray that Adam experiences the love of Christ! 🙏
@Jax-xn5bd
@Jax-xn5bd 3 месяца назад
Awesome. True David Wood style. ❤
@paulleannefischer1148
@paulleannefischer1148 3 месяца назад
I agree! 👍👍👍
@mkplusultra4171
@mkplusultra4171 3 месяца назад
Ninja Art: Wood Style!
@F0r3v3rT0m0rr0w
@F0r3v3rT0m0rr0w 3 месяца назад
I give it 10 years jordan and adam will both be christians.
@wills9392
@wills9392 3 месяца назад
Jordan confessed Christ (in his way) in an interview with the popular atheist Alex O'Connor
@F0r3v3rT0m0rr0w
@F0r3v3rT0m0rr0w 3 месяца назад
@wills9392 I didn't know this. This is great news.
@James_Bee
@James_Bee 3 месяца назад
"in his way" well, there's only one way to the Father so...
@FuddlyDud
@FuddlyDud 3 месяца назад
@@F0r3v3rT0m0rr0w He didn’t truly confess Christ, but rather said Jesus “probably” walked out of the tomb. Granted, I’d say he is wrestling with himself and his faith so much, that’s he’s more Christian than someone like me. XD
@rubiks6
@rubiks6 3 месяца назад
@@wills9392 - Many will say, "Lord, Lord ..."
@JonathanVachon777
@JonathanVachon777 3 месяца назад
G.k. Chesterton was right about them; "The crazy are not the one that lost reason, they are the ones that lost everything but reason" "The asylum are full of prople that believes in themself"
@Rocky-ur9mn
@Rocky-ur9mn 3 месяца назад
It's impossible to find a bad Chesterton quote
@Dross-s5n
@Dross-s5n Месяц назад
Did Chesterton use reason to say that?
@JonathanVachon777
@JonathanVachon777 Месяц назад
@@Dross-s5n can ask you a question too.. did he loose everything?
@Rocky-ur9mn
@Rocky-ur9mn Месяц назад
@user-pl7si5pn5k the quote is against pure reason not reason. Chesterton grounds reason on God while a rationalist materialist who cannot prove empirically the corelation between when he perceive as reality and actual reality leads them to madness
@Dross-s5n
@Dross-s5n 27 дней назад
@@Rocky-ur9mn Your sentence is grammatically wrong. I can't follow what you are trying to say.
@amberwishon
@amberwishon 3 месяца назад
It is a good day when you release a video! 🔥 on point as always!
@MetalByzantine
@MetalByzantine 3 месяца назад
That athiest rally clip made me physically cringe
@AntiAtheismIsUnstoppable
@AntiAtheismIsUnstoppable 3 месяца назад
It's a pdf file meet up
@duderama6750
@duderama6750 3 месяца назад
How is it different than any other meeting of the faithful?
@MetalByzantine
@MetalByzantine 3 месяца назад
@@duderama6750 because ours is not about self pride. Easy
@duderama6750
@duderama6750 3 месяца назад
@@MetalByzantine Sure it is. You're just fooling yourself. Easy.
@Endwankery
@Endwankery 3 месяца назад
​@@duderama6750 The fact you say that proves you have no idea what the point of church or bible study is
@Joanne-t6j
@Joanne-t6j 3 месяца назад
I really enjoy the entertaining way you tease out the arguments. It makes your videos very watchable.
@directorchuks8156
@directorchuks8156 3 месяца назад
God is the better explanation than all this atheist mumbo jumbo
@brianvell
@brianvell 3 месяца назад
Oh yeah? like lightning was believed to be god's wrath and illness god's punishment?
@northernforever818
@northernforever818 3 месяца назад
Yeah, Illness was placed on the Israelites for disobeying and blaspheming against God. Seems to correlate.
@michaelhutchings8599
@michaelhutchings8599 3 месяца назад
​@@brianvell You cannot even comprehend God. You can try and understand how He work's, His rule's, but you're human. You are going to come up short. We barely understand some of his law's! Gravity, magnetism, velocity and beyond... Simple.
@oldcountryboy
@oldcountryboy 3 месяца назад
The atheist mambo Jimbo Do you actually mean scientists You don't believe what scientists say I wonder do you wash your hands
@brianvell
@brianvell 3 месяца назад
@@michaelhutchings8599 Natural laws stand alone and any claim of a god is baseless. Science is about observing, measuring and building simplified models to understand the natural laws. They take no position on a god that is outside of natural laws. Having said that, if a god intervenes in nature, the effects would be measurable thus science would be able to measure the intervention. As such, if a god exists, it is not the capricious, antropomorphic, interventionist god described in the bible / quran / torah.
@andys3035
@andys3035 3 месяца назад
As John Lennox has said, consciousness comes from mind, not matter. That mind is the eternal Logos, Jesus.
@miguelatkinson
@miguelatkinson 3 месяца назад
Wow now verify that for us
@Soliloquy-gy6zf
@Soliloquy-gy6zf 3 месяца назад
Consciousness and the mind are different things
@SirKenchalot
@SirKenchalot 3 месяца назад
When Jordan Peterson (of all people) has to put on a funny voice to mock you and your ideas, you know you're in trouble.
@savioblanc
@savioblanc 3 месяца назад
It's basically Kermit mocking the sh*t out of you 😂
@midimusicforever
@midimusicforever 3 месяца назад
Materialism doesn't work.
@Earthad23
@Earthad23 3 месяца назад
Consciousness is a quality not a quantity.
@Dude0000
@Dude0000 3 месяца назад
11:40 oh my word, that had me rolling. My stomach hurts, I can barely see what I’m typing, but man, I feels good to laugh at something that was unintentionally one of the funniest things I’ve ever heard… …atheist converts to “New Testament Agnostic”.
@camillewilliams3185
@camillewilliams3185 3 месяца назад
​@@mysotiras21 In reality they aren't Christians at all.
@Realauntmeme
@Realauntmeme 3 месяца назад
David smashes it again. His brain may be sociopathic but his mind beautiful.
@jwc713
@jwc713 3 месяца назад
Psychopathic.
@James_Bee
@James_Bee 3 месяца назад
*psychopathic. Clinically.
@malcomlittle251
@malcomlittle251 3 месяца назад
Superb. Superb explanation. Especially at the end summary.
@medoz7331
@medoz7331 3 месяца назад
It took me a while to warm up to you David, but by now I really like your video, streams, and style altogether. Praise the Lord, he brought me closer to you.
@basedchadnerd
@basedchadnerd 3 месяца назад
These videos are really well put together. Always happy to watch these vids.
@Jax-xn5bd
@Jax-xn5bd 3 месяца назад
Not sure the word ATHEIST and the word REASON should be used in the same sentence 😂😂😂 in defense of either 😂😂
@apologeticsroadshow
@apologeticsroadshow 3 месяца назад
Yeah, but when I use "donkey-brained," I get complaints!
@Jax-xn5bd
@Jax-xn5bd 3 месяца назад
@@apologeticsroadshow 😂😂😂😂 Well, we can't gave hurt feelings now, can we? That just won't do😂
@sanchopanza6535
@sanchopanza6535 3 месяца назад
@@apologeticsroadshowAs you should…no donkey deserves to be compared to an atheist! 😆
@Apocryphile1970-check_it
@Apocryphile1970-check_it 3 месяца назад
​@@apologeticsroadshow when it comes to God created the universe or nothing created the universe. Well that is a easy one for me but some atheists are that angry with God they don't think straight. Angry reduces your iq so its even harder for them
@XYisnotXX
@XYisnotXX 3 месяца назад
Donkey brain Dillahunty thinks you know who is indeed a woman. What happened to his brain activity?
@skihas1
@skihas1 3 месяца назад
Your videos get better and better with time. Don’t ever stop ❤
@EnglishPalette
@EnglishPalette 3 месяца назад
Attending a 'reason rally' seems like a harmful experience for one's IQ.
@droverholt
@droverholt 3 месяца назад
Excellent stuff David! Love it!
@arthurw8054
@arthurw8054 3 месяца назад
Pretty sure Adam meant Ram Dass AKA Richard Alpert, LSD guru and spiritual philosopher... Outstanding presentation. Thanks and God bless.
@monthc
@monthc 3 месяца назад
"His knowledge remained woefully incomplete, Harry! That which Voldemort does not value, he takes no trouble to comprehend. Of house-elves and children's tales, of love, loyalty and innocence, Voldemort knows and understands nothing. Nothing. That they all have a power beyond his own, a power beyond the reach of any magic, is a truth that he has never grasped." Reason is not the greatest power available to humanity.
@ImStuckInStockton
@ImStuckInStockton 3 месяца назад
The same commitment to "it must be proved" reason that Savage used to support atheism is what caused me to abandon it. I don't think we have the capacity to fully comprehend what caused existence. Maybe they will prove me wrong one day. Ha. "There was nothing and then it exploded" is not nearly as satisfactory of an answer as "something that transcends human understanding caused nothing to explode".
@miguelatkinson
@miguelatkinson 3 месяца назад
Umm who was claiming that "something blew up and created everything" if your referring to the big bang theory then you severely misunderstood it
@wrongthinker843
@wrongthinker843 3 месяца назад
Someone needs to remind scientists that what they have are *models of reality* , not reality itself.
@wrongthinker843
@wrongthinker843 3 месяца назад
@@miguelatkinson No, it sounds dumb because it is dumb.
@Orm-zn6fl
@Orm-zn6fl 3 месяца назад
Consciousness is not in a brain, a brain is in consciousness.
@Soliloquy-gy6zf
@Soliloquy-gy6zf 3 месяца назад
Finally someone gets it
@JosephSevirene
@JosephSevirene 3 месяца назад
Animals are conscious and they sleep. Human consciousness has mathematical ability, animals don’t know 2+2= 4. That fact points to the existence of the Devine.
@yossariandunbar2829
@yossariandunbar2829 3 месяца назад
I'm a Christian, but it does seem that animals can count. For example, corvids seem to be able to count out loud, and honey bees seem to count salient landmarks to help them navigate.
@JosephSevirene
@JosephSevirene 3 месяца назад
@@yossariandunbar2829 Bees navigate by the magnetic fields. I think. Just because there could be a species outside of humans that can do counting, is not enough to exclude God. I’m Christian also. Usually when I post, I’m referring to the God that deism proclaims.
@yossariandunbar2829
@yossariandunbar2829 3 месяца назад
@@JosephSevirene I know, I just want to make sure those clever little beasts are getting their dues in this comment section.
@almightyzentaco
@almightyzentaco 3 месяца назад
Could you elaborate a little on how humans having mathematical ability points to the divine?
@JosephSevirene
@JosephSevirene 3 месяца назад
@@yossariandunbar2829 I hear you. The Lord is the one who converts us , not words or arguments. If you just are able to get an unbeliever one step away from no belief to correct belief, that is good enough.
@pankaja7974
@pankaja7974 3 месяца назад
Super lovely stuff from brother David as always.
@mathewrichards2713
@mathewrichards2713 3 месяца назад
I think it’s interesting that Christians who have Alzheimer’s can’t remember their family members but can still talk about Jesus and preach, like my grandfather did.
@artangel23
@artangel23 3 месяца назад
“Heaven and earth may pass away, but My words will never pass away” - Jesus
@lowreztv
@lowreztv 3 месяца назад
If we have to "wait" for answers to be testable and provable, then we'll never get anywhere as a species...
@johncassidy3071
@johncassidy3071 3 месяца назад
And when was this principle tested and proved? About the best answer is we continue to test and prove this. Thus we don't wait for a completed state, but just or successes here and there. Where would we be if Lavoisier had waited ~200 years for Karl Popper to describe Science in terms of falsifiability? And would Popper have anything to describe and illustrate 200 years later, if Lavoisier did?
@Pseudoornitologist
@Pseudoornitologist 3 месяца назад
What a surprise! Wasn’t expecting a Dizzle video just now. Thank ya!😊
@paulschlachter4313
@paulschlachter4313 3 месяца назад
I like David's snark. Life programmed his brain in a really entertaining way.
@elsantoschalbi4459
@elsantoschalbi4459 3 месяца назад
the applause from the atheist comic con audience for the mythbuster guy with his "human reason" speech is literally the simpsons in real life. embarrassing
@Absynthexx1
@Absynthexx1 3 месяца назад
Those are just lost sheep. Jesus will find them all. I should know, I was in the audience that day cheering. I recall Dawkins that day remarking that this was a "target rich environment" for people to be smited. We all had a laugh when no one was harmed.
@miguelatkinson
@miguelatkinson 3 месяца назад
​@@Absynthexx1so you fell for the fallacious nonesense
@happyexmussie7085
@happyexmussie7085 3 месяца назад
That was brilliantly put together David. Thanks heaps. 😅
@hextoken
@hextoken 3 месяца назад
A Dizzle Classic.
@MasonsMotions
@MasonsMotions 3 месяца назад
You have quickly turned into my favorite apologist, & not because you make the sinner in me feel good, but because you’re the most clear cut person out there, I think even above whaddoyoumean? or even Michael Jones. You make the clearest distinction between belief and unbelief.
@KnightDogNamedBuns
@KnightDogNamedBuns 3 месяца назад
I hope Mr Peterson has a good conversation with David or any other mature man/servant of God and straighten Peterson believe once and for all.
@hariman7727
@hariman7727 3 месяца назад
Oh WOW, you can hear the bitterness and anger at the skeptic community in Adam's voice when he talks about what happened with them.
@mike1967sam
@mike1967sam 3 месяца назад
7:43 - The only thing missing is to start hearing Queen's "We Are the Champions my friend...".
@j3m638
@j3m638 3 месяца назад
Excellent work David. I think the most honest thing any scientist could ever say about this is - "here's what we think we know so far". Loving the hair btw :)
@discobunny4eva759
@discobunny4eva759 3 месяца назад
You’re killing me with the clown emoji analogy 😂
@tylerfisher2371
@tylerfisher2371 3 месяца назад
Great video. I’m guessing the recent video from Savage brought this on? The algorithm gave me his video to watch recently, and wondered if any of y’all had discussed Savage. Got my wish this morning. Keep doing what y’all are doing, I really appreciate the hard work putting these videos together. God bless
@FuddlyDud
@FuddlyDud 3 месяца назад
What I find fascinating is exactly those points on how the mind can’t be measured by the brain. While MRIs can actually provide signs of activity for certain emotions and skills, those things don’t tell us who we are. For, while we may be able to determine someone is a creative, low-stressed, violinist, such qualities don’t define the person. To discover that, the minds must meet in relationship and there appears no equivalent substitute. And, amazingly, God calls us similarly to relationship and He has provided us the Way, the Truth, and the Life. It’s not through the brain, but through the mind which feels more real than anything merely measured of the brain. :)
@jesseadebayo4746
@jesseadebayo4746 3 месяца назад
Brilliant explanation and illumination of a difficult topic. Well done!
@paulschlachter4313
@paulschlachter4313 3 месяца назад
"Why does Adam talk about physicists when mentioning the miracle of the mind?" Neuroscience is multidisciplinary - physics is one of those disciplines among others. Neurophysics is the branch of biophysics dealing with the development and use of physical methods to gain information about the nervous system. Adam seems to be interested in this specific field - it's fascinating, puzzling and fun to think about.
@michelepaige8080
@michelepaige8080 3 месяца назад
Thanks, but so what? David's point still holds because it's physicists doing the work, as he claimed.
@mogx2586
@mogx2586 3 месяца назад
Love this content David. I dip into your streams but feel your strength is putting these videos out there for those of us that need some stuff SPELLING OUT. I'm not a good student when it comes to philosophy and appreciate the breakdown mate. Lav frum da UKay innit? 😆
@FriendOfChrist
@FriendOfChrist 3 месяца назад
Your comments about attempts to create consciousness in AI reminded me of something I wrote, "Why do mathematical formulas, natural laws, and chemical-based processes require some of the most brilliant minds in the world to discover and employ if it was just dumb luck or nothing that created them?"
@samiam9202
@samiam9202 3 месяца назад
Man, you sound like my dad. Specifically in his last days. I love this channel.
@GranMaese
@GranMaese 3 месяца назад
I love this channel so much.
@bsan7070
@bsan7070 3 месяца назад
7:54 David you might be one of the funniest creators I see on yt😂, keep up the good work you are so anointed
@chrisearl2217
@chrisearl2217 3 месяца назад
AI just proved that intelligent and consciousness are two separate things.
@Augustus087
@Augustus087 3 месяца назад
Absolutely brilliant. I love this- thank you, David
@robertthomas2673
@robertthomas2673 3 месяца назад
Well constructed David!!! The upanishads which long predate Buddhism (and Abraham come to that) describe exactly your conclusion. THE Truth is fundamental. And will set you free. I have that on good authority.
@jfr45er
@jfr45er 3 месяца назад
Another example of the standard narrative having Holes.
@michelepaige8080
@michelepaige8080 3 месяца назад
Good one!
@fergusonhr
@fergusonhr 3 месяца назад
You are a spirit, your soul is who you are, your conscience. Your body is where your soul resides...Your brain is where your soul stores information and what controls your body...Your soul gives the brain commands and it in turn sends the proper signals to the body to respond...
@Soliloquy-gy6zf
@Soliloquy-gy6zf 3 месяца назад
No. The soul is not in the body. It's the opposite
@johnv5275
@johnv5275 3 месяца назад
I'm disappointed....... I thought I'd hear skydaddy atleast once 😂.
@anthonypalo8191
@anthonypalo8191 3 месяца назад
Skydaddy.. skydaddy.. Flying Spaghetti Monster! 😅
@johnv5275
@johnv5275 3 месяца назад
@@anthonypalo8191 🤣 thanks. Don't forget to add the spider-man "fallacy" next time though.😂
@i7Qp4rQ
@i7Qp4rQ 3 месяца назад
Dont forget the great flying spaghetti monster.
@braedenmclean5304
@braedenmclean5304 3 месяца назад
“See I mocked you in a silly voice, that means I’m smart and handsome and right and all of you are stupid and wrong”
@i7Qp4rQ
@i7Qp4rQ 3 месяца назад
@@braedenmclean5304 a tu quoque attempt? I dont think ive ever heard of an atheist that havent been using silly voices.
@richardokeefe7410
@richardokeefe7410 3 месяца назад
About 11:20ish, Adam Savage says "As a scientist ..." I greatly enjoyed MythBusters, and I frequently watch his RU-vid channel. My respect for his design and fabrication skills reaches the levels of awe. I would be honoured to shake his hand. BUT. A scientist he is not. The testing process in MythBusters was showmanship, engineering, and explosions a-plenty, but it was entertainment, not serious science. Dr Savage's doctorate is an honorary one, very well deserved, but for *promoting* science, not for *doing* it.
@nalbano85
@nalbano85 3 месяца назад
Great video. We are conscious because of God. We are souls with bodies.
@nicholasalbano1937
@nicholasalbano1937 3 месяца назад
Great video. We are conscious because of God. We are souls with bodies.
@Steph-sk3xb
@Steph-sk3xb Месяц назад
This topic has blown my mind. I didn’t know that we can’t explain conciseness and how complex it actually is.
@jfr45er
@jfr45er 3 месяца назад
Thank you to the individual who gifted me this membership so I could watch this dizzle video a day earlier!!
@semi-mojo
@semi-mojo 3 месяца назад
I second this
@seif9923
@seif9923 3 месяца назад
Hey david I have videos of Arabic famous Muslims scholars saying that a man marrying his daughter from fornication is allowed in islam with sources and other things about how if a man found out his wife is cheating he should just be the father of the baby even if he doesn't think its his baby how can I contact you to send you those? I have A TON of those, like kids saying how stupid the tawaf is when they are at the kabba and other stupid videos like that that portray them in a really bad way
@yohannbiimu
@yohannbiimu 3 месяца назад
I commend Adam Savage for his honesty and leaning toward objectivity. I pray he keeps examining this miracle of consciousness.
@seanjazzguitar
@seanjazzguitar 3 месяца назад
A closed system cannot explain itself inside itself. There has to be an outside reference. Consciousness is more than a material process in the mind. That argument alone might not get us all the way to Christ but it at least shows that atheism is illogical.
@Vibarb
@Vibarb Месяц назад
Respect to you brother from Australia
@jimberezow721
@jimberezow721 3 месяца назад
Excellent. Thanks for this post.
@fromjulian
@fromjulian 3 месяца назад
Of all creation, only human beings were made 'in the image of God'. Our minds, like him, are immaterial, invisible, rational, creative, personal, relational, self-aware and moral.
@jankusthegreat9233
@jankusthegreat9233 3 месяца назад
Good morning
@gloriousginger
@gloriousginger 3 месяца назад
Russell Brand is now Christian and accepts Jesus as Christ. Adam is on the right track. Two years ago, I got tired of trying to "sum it up" and just forced myself to accept Jesus as Christ without questioning "why". Through Christ I am healthy, wealthy, and wise.
@miguelatkinson
@miguelatkinson 3 месяца назад
Question why specifically Christianity why not any other religion or God also how can you "force" yourself to believe in a god and religion that tells me you did not have any genuine belief and in no way does this provided any proof or veracity of Christianity
@Soliloquy-gy6zf
@Soliloquy-gy6zf 3 месяца назад
​@@miguelatkinsonChristianity and God are very different things. Religions are confusion, and separation of people. The opposite of what God stands for. Divide and conquer 👹
@maltardraco9555
@maltardraco9555 3 месяца назад
The new atheist movement was entirely without consciousness.
@chadhauskin1461
@chadhauskin1461 3 месяца назад
Thank you for this, David.
@youtubeaccount5153
@youtubeaccount5153 3 месяца назад
Live streams late last night. Drops a video at 6 am. 😴
@Gerhard2770
@Gerhard2770 3 месяца назад
Another excellent video!
@nezele
@nezele 3 месяца назад
10:15 the audacity lmao
@jmad71
@jmad71 3 месяца назад
Adam is engaging in what I call ABC spirituality. Anything But Christ.
@bornagainstefan
@bornagainstefan 3 месяца назад
Gute Arbeit, danke Dr Holz 🧠 Gott segne dich und deine Familie
@Dudeswagmaster
@Dudeswagmaster 3 месяца назад
I remember being taught that consciousness is something that appeared in our brain. I suffered with severe depression after that.
Далее
The Future of Atheism
26:06
Просмотров 123 тыс.
We finally APPROVED @ZachChoi
00:31
Просмотров 3,2 млн
Свожу все свои тату (abricoss_a_tyt)
00:35
He LAUGHED at the TRINITY, Until I Said . . .
25:52
Просмотров 285 тыс.
10 Questions with Mike Winger (Episode 16)
1:30:40
Просмотров 93 тыс.
The Quran DOESN'T Say What Muslims Think It Says!
37:42
Atheists Trusted Sam Harris, Until . . .
21:32
Просмотров 360 тыс.
Ten Ways Jesus Is GREATER Than Muhammad in the Quran
20:45