Works really nicely I think. Push the Button has always been one of the toughest to recreate live and it's clearest in the chorus harmonies that this line-up's voices just blend beautifully.
why are people having a problem with this? when keisha was in the band and they all sang overload, no one had a problem, its the exact same situation, heidi was the only original in push the button, as keisha was with overload, so its the same.
I'm loving 4.0 though I must admit, Ive had "awkward" moments seeing them perform some of the older hits ("It sounds good but, strange when you expect to hear another person's voice"). That said, I truly feel that THIS SONG IN PARTICULAR, actually sounds better than ever live with this line-up. Not only is Amelle finally sounding comfortable doing Mutya's verse, but the chorus, which has ALWAYS sounded off live even with 3.0 AND 2.0 (!), FINALLY sounds "right".
These "the originals are the best" comments get boring very fast, people make out the are a god send to the music industry, they've failed twice. Don't get me wrong love 6 members but why spread so much hate? Love these 3 and the originals 3.
@Kiki, As I understand it, James was the winner of the Windows 7 promo contest (the campaign starring the Sugababes) - the prize was a personal concert, which ended up being for his birthday party.
Amelle does sound like Mutya, which shows how the producers wanted to maintain the originality of Sugababes. She has a husky voice like Mutya and Jade has powerful vocals just like Keisha. BUT I just wish Amelle would do something about getting out of breath(she can't say all the words) every time she sings Mutya's part. I first thought it was because Keisha was around and it makes her nervous and I thought that was gonna change since Jade replaced Keisha but I was wrong. I hope she improves...
Dennis Vladimir Villaflor In this particular performance and song itself, harmonies are exactly the same when Keisha was in the band, Heidi and Amelle sang the melody and Keisha sang the high harmony in the chours and thats what Jade is doing.
Amelle annoys me singing this, she doesn’t have the breath control at 1.29 that sentence should be sang as one, not broken at “ new dimension” she does it in most performances
hhmm really liked it but srry i just love Keisha on the ad lips more on the chorus she do them much better and she makes it less poppy Keisha always made the music r&bish with a twist of pop etc
Every member deserves to be recognised but this is piss poor. I feel like they should have called themselves something else and they could have been more successful. The managements treatment of Keisha was shameful and Heidi should have realised what a shit-show this would turn into. If you watch them in another video describing how Mutya got the rights to the name on paper and cardboard, you'll see how ego got the better of this line up.
![Push The Button [Live @ James' birthday party]](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
