Q&A: Anti-Zionism & Anti-Semitism, One State Solution, Ismael's Prayers, Israel in Halacha

Просмотров 7 тыс.

% 135

Q&A- Machlokes, Anti-Zionism, and Humility (Rabbi Yitzchak Breitowitz)
Ask the Rabbi with Rabbi Dr. Yitzchak Breitowitz, a world renown lecturer and the Rav of Yeshivas Ohr Somayach, Jerusalem.
Comment of this video - Q&A: Anti-Zionism & Anti-Semitism, One State Solution, Ismael's Prayers, Israel in Halacha
Q&A: Anti-Zionism & Anti-Semitism One State Solution Ismael's Prayers Israel in Halacha
00:00 How do name changes work?
04:33 What are the differences between "mituvecha" and mituvah" and between "sim shalom" and "shalom rav"?
16:43 Why are there so many machlokos in the Oral Torah if Moshe was told only one version by God?
24:15 Why is there so much anti-Israel sentiment?
28:56 If God could have made ultimate pleasure, why bother making us?
34:54 Is there any truth to the claim that the Pashto are of the Lost Tribes?
41:08 Is a one-state solution morally wrong?
47:00 What is the definition of Jewish music, and can that include rap?
51:13 Why should Ishmael be rewarded for prayer if those prayers are directed to an incorrect conception of God?
54:02 What is the meaning of the blessings to Ishmael?
57:23 Did the Generation of the Dispersion really think the Tower of Babel would work?
1:00:27 Is there a reason a trustworthy, disciplined man should get an Internet filter?
1:02:57 What is the importance of humility and how might one be humble?
1:07:55 What exactly is Neturei Karta?
1:19:05 How has this war changed the Haredi opinion on the state?
1:26:43 How much caution should one take to turn the faucet to the cold side on Shabbos?
1:28:51 Why would Avraham marry Hagar if he had prophetic visions of other offspring?
1:32:49 How can one tell who is a Yaakov Jew and who is an Avraham Jew?

Опубликовано:

12 ноя 2023

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 80

@gr4707 6 месяцев назад

He’s right. Ishmael is impossible to defeat. It’s matter of time. Thanks!

@rameezrazzak 11 месяцев назад

I’m a Muslim, have all my sympathies with the plight of the Palestinians for moral reasons. Listening to the Rabbi about the two state solution makes me respect his sincerity and honesty. I loved how he brought the “moral” aspect. The way Muslims are raised, we are to respect the elders of all religions, if I was around him I would be standing up until he takes a seat. What group of Judaism does he represent? Is it different or the same as the - excuse my ignorance - “settler type” group?

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 11 месяцев назад

the rabbi in the video represents Jewish people that follow the Torah, Today we call it religious Jews. thanks for sharing your thoughts. I (not the rabbi in video) am also a religious Jew, I grew up secular, so I think I am openminded to a degree. I understand that all people deserve to live a good and satisfying life. But I want to suggest that you do research on the conflict to be more aware of the facts, not just how one side presents it. here are some things to consider but please research it for yourself. 1) in 1948 and before both Jews and Arabs even Christians lives in Israel. None of the above people controlled the state - it was controlled by Britain. The Jews were given a small portion and the Arabs a gigger one - it was rejected by the Arabs and Israel was attacked by 5 countries who's goal was to take all of land. 2) Over 800,000 Jewish refugees were forced to leave Arab countries because of the war in 1948, and also Palestinians Arabs were displaced because of the war - their total numbers were less than Jews kicked out or that fleeded for their lives. You can research the rest - all the best

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 11 месяцев назад

my friend here is a video link from Muslim woman that I think is both balanced and informative - I'm interested in your thoughts on this. all the best

@rameezrazzak 11 месяцев назад

@@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 thank you for the response! Yes, I have been researching. When emotions are high, it is harder to find neutral information. I am aware of the Arab resistance against the 1948 resolution, which in retrospect appears to be a mistake. I am interested in the theological spectrum regarding establishing sovereignty over Eretz Yisrael. Why does it appear there is a division between religious Jews about this? I have seen extreme views from Rabbis calling for complete forceful takeover of the whole land and violence towards all non combatants completely justified, and then I have seen Rabbis calling sovereignty over the land before the Messiah is 100% against the religion. Did this division arise after the Zionist movement?

@rameezrazzak 11 месяцев назад

@@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 I don’t see a link

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 11 месяцев назад

@@rameezrazzak I have never heard any Jewish person religious or not, say that killing non-combatants is allowed - it is absolutely forbidding. Can you please give me a link to where you saw that? There is a lot to talk about, and perhaps on a different platform we can discuss more. For now, aside from religion 1) Israel was attacked 2 times by many neighboring nations - this should give them the right to establish borders they need to protect themselves. 2) the Arabs that were displaced is a problem, but there were more jews displaced so this isn't a reason to attack and kill jews. 3) I pray and so should everyone that God help us all find peace. But the Muslim extremists is to me the main problem - and they ignore the truth and make up lies this needs to stop. all the best my friend

@amnonisagoglu5158 11 дней назад

this rabbi is very nice

@ihababbas5731 4 месяца назад

“Do you order righteousness of the people and forget yourselves while you recite the Scripture? Can’t you reason? (44)”

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 4 месяца назад

Funny the religion that stole its truths from the Jews - give back what you took and all you’ll have left is honor killings theft rape and lies

@justsomeguywhoispartofjust1965 3 месяца назад

@@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511you mean your idf plenty of reports suggest they are expert at it but go ahead try to pull antisemitic card in front of God on the day of judgment 😊

@salampakistan3691 2 месяца назад

@@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 Islam never stole nothing, its the original religion of Adam AS, Nuh AS, Ibrahim AS, Musa AS and All the Prophets. What dis Ibrahim AS and Musa AS call the religion they were following, definitely no mention of judasim or jews in the Torah. All the Prophets prostrated like Muslims in prayer, they dressed like how muslim dressed, they order modesty like how muslims ordered modesty. We follow in their footsteps...we do not follow the jews. Your religion very different from ours. Only similarity is the worship Allah swt.

@AbirDawah 11 месяцев назад

One state live Muslim and jews together would be perfect

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 11 месяцев назад

Even better One World where we ALL live in peace even better

@channelone3773G 11 месяцев назад

only, if House of Yishmael Prevails...!

@melray5001 10 месяцев назад

And everwhere around the world not just Israel ...peace...

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 10 месяцев назад

@@channelone3773G so nice the religion of one more piece - that's what you are about - to dominate and rule over world - that will never bring peace

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 10 месяцев назад

@@melray5001 absolutely - that it the point of creation

@Maimonides119 7 месяцев назад

Okay so according to him, Avraham made a mistake praying for his son...which is ludicrous enough... but did G-d make a mistake with all the particularized promises that He gave Yishmael?

@Maimonides119 7 месяцев назад

How could anyone compare their reason to that of Avraham avinu by saying " in retrospect he may have made a mistake" - that is incredibly arrogant and disrespectful and G-d is not swayed randomly the way it seems to be described here...theres wisdom and justice in all that G-d does

@nothingbutthetruth613 11 месяцев назад

I heard the reason why Reb Moshe didn't change his name is because your name is what people call you and since nobody is going to call him anything but Reb Moshe since that is how the whole world knows him, changing his name wouldn't make any difference. This is why giving someone 2 names and only calling him his whole life by only one of them is not necessarily correct

@hisStory-y2g 10 месяцев назад

17:15 Oral Torah

@jakobw135 8 месяцев назад

Why are you suggesting that because a sage assumed something that it is necessarily correct? After all, cannot a wise and righteous individual also make a MISTAKE?

@kdog543 10 месяцев назад

Thank you Rabbi. Zion and Zoar or the land of Judah like the land of Zoar or stuff like David days but I got to much head damages to remember exactly. God knows ones or like sons and daughters or calls them by another name God calls them like phophet name like my name is Mose si iff by my God.🦁👑🦅

@SuperKripke 3 месяца назад

What an obscene view to think that antisemitism is a blessing that draws more people to Judaism.

@amnonisagoglu5158 11 дней назад

interesting critique😅

@Mohahamd_arabian95 4 месяца назад

God chose Ishmael after sending the messiah to Bani Israel. Unfortunately, they killed him by crucifying. God promised Ishmael to make him a great nation - 2 billion Muslims. We have conquered half of the world and GCC countries, which are the richest countries due to oil. You should confess that Bani Ishmael are promised as bani israel .

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 3 месяца назад

Wait till the end my foolish friend. God doesn’t change His mind, he doesn’t stop loving those that He loved. False Prophets jealousy hate this is what the religion of one more piece has brought to the world. I don’t k ie where you’ll be at the end but I know the Jew will be here - if he is still here it is because he is immortal - and that’s another reason why the world hates the Jew A waist of energy - Join him and you too will live forever- fight him and you will sadly Die like all those that tried before.

@Mohahamd_arabian95 3 месяца назад

@@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 Who said I hate Jews? Stop playing the victim. Like a pathetic person, I am only informing you that promises were made for Ishmael as well as Isaac. God has a plan for both of them. If God didn't want Ishmael, why did God send an angel to save him from death? And why did God send the Messiah, Jesus, who was rejected by the Jews? For this reason, God expelled you from the holy land and punished you for the past 2000 years and kept his promises to Ishmael's descendants. So, if God still favors you, why didn't he help you 2000 years ago? 🤣🤣

@mohammedmia3654 2 месяца назад

@@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511you hold on to 1 city and you think you chosen hahahahaha. Hashem has left you and moved on to Ishmael. We Muslim have 57 country and a thousand city. Unlimited wealth, 2 billion in number and 3 holy sites. You days are numbered as per the prophecy of our books. You have broken all hashem oaths so taste the darkness and exile

@shanewoody4232 13 дней назад

Didn't God give the Jews victory over like 5 Arab Armies at once? I don't think any of the muslims are meant to conquer Israel in the modern world because they would have decades ago

@rameezrazzak 11 месяцев назад

Also, regarding “hate of Israel”, I can tell you someone who was raised religiously in Pakistan: hating “Jews” for the sole reason of the religion or ethnicity is sinful, and a path to hellfire. Also, Jews are considered to be the closest to Islam, and their similarities are often discussed with happiness. Hitler is considered the most evil man in modern history for the murder of innocent people. Hate of the country of Israel, however, is abundant. Israel is seen as a secular, colonial, oppressive country, a wing of the West to oppress innocent people. The country’s links to judaism are not a factor in this. When a Pakistani sees a practicing, humble jew, for example, it evokes the same emotions as looking at religious Muslim elders.

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 10 месяцев назад

Being that there was always a Jewish presence innIsrael, why is it ak to hate Israel. There are so many Muslim states why is 1 Jewish state such a problem. It seems to me it is simple Jew hatred. There is a big lie in Islam, they want to steal Israel from the Jew, the holy Temple Mount from the Jew, the chosen was from the Jew. You know Islam believes they are the true religion, anyone that believes God threw the Jew His children away for them is a liar and a fool. But you seem nice, choose the path of peace and goodness, don’t fall for these lies.

@the_famous_reply_guy 10 месяцев назад

That is a lie, Pakistani on the whole don't even know about Jews only the Nakba, 1948 1967 and now the genocide

@shakil000 8 месяцев назад

@@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 "You have so much money why don't you give me some. Actually I can take it forcefully with my buddy who has all the weapons." - Thank you for being candid.

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 8 месяцев назад

@@shakil000 Actually I am collecting donations, you want to make a donation?

@Hnif.76 Месяц назад

@@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 Because The State of Israel until today ethniclly cleansed the Palestinian People

@salampakistan3691 6 месяцев назад

All muslim circumcise at birth. Both my brothers were circumcised at birth at usually within 4weeks of births,mostly the first week Muslim fast on Yum Kapoor for 2 days, we do it on 9, 10 etc of Ashura. Before Ramadan verse was revealed, it was compulsory to fast two days same time as jews but when Ramadan verse was revealed, the two days of fasting became voluntary fast, highly recommended rather then compulsory and Ramadan became compulsory 30 day fast.

@salampakistan3691 2 месяца назад

Muslim saved jews and jewish jewry, its all written in history books even by non muslims, you cannot erase it with heresay

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 2 месяца назад

A sane person knows not to reply to Insanity Peace

@salampakistan3691 2 месяца назад

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 Why are you replying then???? You know I am saying facts. I am sane then. Muslims treated jews far far better then Isrealis are treating muslims.... You cannot wipe out 1400yrs of good relations between jews and muslims, western historians all testify to this. You rely to much on heresay and chinese whispers, evidence that would thrown out of court...

@13thdivision70 3 месяца назад

By Ishmael? Does he mean only the Arabs since technically Ismael AS is the father of the Arabs or all Muslims regardless if they are English, Russian, Indian or even Jewish by race? And is it true that Edom(Europeans) and the followers of Ishmael will have a Great War before the messianic era?

@marklevy9314 7 месяцев назад

Also can Jews rule Jews any better than say Muslims can rule Jews especially since the ancient Greeks? Eg Alexander Janneus and his successors, Zealot control of Jerusalem during war with Rome and now we have the Netenyahu regime and its conduct in Gaza with resulting affects in the West?

@awamy91 Месяц назад

Say (O Muslims), "We believe in Allah and that which has been sent down to us and that which has been sent down to Ibrahim (Abraham), Isma'il (Ishmael), Ishaque (Isaac), Ya'qub (Jacob), and to Al-Asbat [the twelve sons of Ya'qub (Jacob)], and that which has been given to Musa (Moses) and 'Iesa (Jesus), and that which has been given to the Prophets from their Lord. We make no distinction between any of them, and to Him we have submitted (in Islam)." English translation from Quran

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 Месяц назад

that's great - it proves you don't know the difference between a mad man a rebel and a prophet of God. But you and everyone else will soon learn the difference.

@marklevy9314 7 месяцев назад

But wasn't Esav a Jew with two Jewish parents. Therefore couldn't one say that some amongst today's Jews act like Esav?

@Subuzgreatest 11 месяцев назад

G-d regrets NOTHING. If anyone says that, he speaks against G-d's nature - All knowing. That puts a question mark on their intelligence/knowledge of HaShem.

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 11 месяцев назад

sorry to inform you - But there is a verse in the Bible that says God regrets - and in other places it says he doesn't - MEANING THESE MATTERS NEED A DEEP UNDERSTANDING - good luck on your journey and learning and keep in mind who is the student and who s the teacher

@xpressvisa4720 10 месяцев назад

One state solution is the best solution as it will help integrating the new state in the Middle East and establishing people to people in the region relationships. Iran tension will dissipate as well. Including Palestinians in the west bank and Gaza and give them equal rights and respect will help eliminate the reasons to make them hate the occupation and oppression and will moderate them and will become beneficial economically and add manpower to the new state. It is like uniting east and west Germany. Those who oppose this solution could be the right wing in government now, they are expansionist, have colonialist mentality. The USA evangelist community will not support this as they want war and blood everywhere, so their Mesiah comes back as they say. The USA government as well as the present situation creates tension in the region and flaming the conflict.

@hisStory-y2g 10 месяцев назад

1:08.00 neturi kartah anti-zionism

@ihababbas5731 4 месяца назад

God regrets? How dare you!

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 4 месяца назад

I understand your question look up Mesechet Succah it say there that God regrets - I’m sure the Sages knew what they were talking about, and so does this modern Sage. But you are correct to ask a question but telling the rabbi off is not the way to do it. All the best Channel manager

@salampakistan3691 2 месяца назад

@@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 Allah swt can see past, present and future, He has no begining and no End so its impossible for Him to regret. Allah swt knew we will sin and there wisdom behind Him allowing us to sin, giving us free will to test us how we will do. Also Allah swt loves it when we seek forgiveness as we are truly humble at that time relying on His mercy rather then our deeds, He loves the tears of the repenter.... Abu Huraira reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “By the One in whose hand is my soul, if you did not sin, Allah would replace you with people who would sin, and they would seek forgiveness from Allah and He would forgive them.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2749 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Muslim

@ouahibasaoudi3345 11 месяцев назад

Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸💀

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 11 месяцев назад

We are working on it

@ihababbas5731 4 месяца назад

I wonder if this is ignorance or lies. Dare you to educate yourself and just read even a few pages of the Quran and you will know how deceived you are.

@divinewisdomliveabetterlif3511 4 месяца назад

Anything in the Quran that’s true come from the. Jewish prophets and everything else is lies from your false prophet that was actually insane - according to history. You know that your religion lies so don’t make believe you are stupid. Goodbye