Тёмный

Quick Martin D41 vs D35 comparison - flatpicking 

Tom White
Подписаться 448
Просмотров 34 тыс.
50% 1

Practising another Carl Miner TNAG demo tune, and recorded a slower version on the D41 and the D35. The first run through is on the 41 -- a 2018 reimagined, and the second time round is the 35 -- a 2014 retro one. They both play really nicely, but it's always refreshing to swap between them. I didn't apply any audio 'stuff' -- this is straight from a spaced pair of SDCs panned hard left/right.
Carl's original (and wonderful) tune is here:
• Bob Thompson D Curly K...

Опубликовано:

 

7 июл 2022

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 124   
@USNAVDC
@USNAVDC Год назад
I"ve listened over and over and while both guitars sound good, THAT D41 is off the charts! Those high notes on the D41 just resonate forever!
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
it's amazing to play too!
@darrengysbertsen2169
@darrengysbertsen2169 Год назад
What a difference the 41 is ! Sings at a whole different level bright and rich sound...Holy shit
@-Atmos1
@-Atmos1 4 месяца назад
D41 has a fuller spectrum of sounds , nice playing
@jspendleton3898
@jspendleton3898 Год назад
Both are superb specimens, exemplified by the wonderful playing. Great job! I hear the presence of the D41 sitting a little further back, with alot of bell like ringing and overtones. Very spacious and rich sounding. The D35 is a bit more in your face and fundamental in tone. It's less rich, but stronger in sound. Horses for courses.
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
Thanks! The D41's overtones really stand out when I switch between them - it really does ring!
@staleyexplores
@staleyexplores Год назад
I agree with the bell like tones on the 41 which I do love along, kind of reminds me of my d18
@USNAVDC
@USNAVDC Год назад
Both of those guitars sound really great and your touch really makes them sing. Thanks for posting. Beautiful tune to show those guitars off, and the tempo was perfect! I had to listen several times.
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
Thanks - it's really nice to be able switch between them. I was mainly strumming today, and the D35 is a GREAT strummer!
@rgbart01
@rgbart01 3 месяца назад
I played a D42 30 years ago that I’ve always regretted not buying, incredible guitar, the one that got away. I have a 69 D35 that’s the best one I’ve ever heard. I added bone saddle, nut and pins, to compensate for the bass from the 3 piece back, it’s an amazing guitar. I’ve got a few others that I love but Martins are still the king of the flattop to me.
@danielhehir1
@danielhehir1 Год назад
I play a somewhat older worn-out Martin D35, but when I put new strings on, it really comes alive. 012's are swell, but let me tell, they sure make that guitar ring. 010's my friend, are easier to bend yet the prettier they sing. I play it in the daytime, I play it in the night, I play it when I'm feelin' blue, it makes me feel alright. I play it when the Sun shines, I play it when it rains. I play when my heart aches and it takes away the pain. I play it in the early morn and in the afternoon, it just does something to me, it really makes me swoon. I play a somewhat older worn-out Martin D35 and I still have no regrets, I play that thing so much these days, I've worn out all the frets. So I went and bought another one, the younger of the two, so now I have two sweethearts and I don't know what to do. The younger is the pretty one, the older is the wise, the older breaks my heart and the younger feeds my eyes.... So tell me Tom, please tell me, what's a soul to do? How dare I play the one and to the other still be true?
@G_Demolished
@G_Demolished Год назад
Tens though? I have elevens on my Telecaster. 😂
@USNAVDC
@USNAVDC Год назад
I have a 1963 Martin D-28 that my father bought new (In the picture). He's been gone for 42 years, but I can put my ear to that guitar, and still hear him playing.
@monsterzero1965
@monsterzero1965 3 месяца назад
.10s on a Martin is an ABOMINATION
@kotla671
@kotla671 Месяц назад
Please play, record, and share how the 10’s sound!🙏
@billieg826
@billieg826 10 месяцев назад
Both guitars are just excellent !
@thinkertoo2995
@thinkertoo2995 Год назад
Beautiful Melody. Superb guitar work. Thanks ! ! A+
@rjreddenbaker4351
@rjreddenbaker4351 Год назад
There is a shine to the 41 the 35 just can't touch. Both are beautiful and great sounding instruments though. That 40 series of Martin guitars is special.
@ShawnBrockMusic
@ShawnBrockMusic 29 дней назад
Lord man, I can’t come close to making up my mind of which I like best lol. Great job!
@bradh.689
@bradh.689 Год назад
I have a 2018 Ambertone D41 and it has, what I call, a "shimmer" to the tone that I hear in this D41, as well! It's the special quality that made me purchase that guitar over every other Martin I tried out. Great playing!!
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
Thanks!
@capohd28
@capohd28 Год назад
I have the same guitar, a 2018 reimagined. It has that shimmer too. I have four Martins, two of which are vintage, but the D-41 is the best sounding by far. It is so resonant.
@hutchklutch2594
@hutchklutch2594 Год назад
They are both incredible! I played both last night and It's too hard to decide which I like more
@son0fsocal
@son0fsocal Год назад
Im glad i saw you video brother..the 35 just has that extra RING to it..im getting one tomorrow from a local mom pop shop in Texas tomorrow , I can’t wait! And who says that the big stores can give good prices, they took 12% the list price! I can’t wait! They are a Martin repair center too so im covered..your video helped me decide between a 28 and 35.thank you bro!
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
yay! The D35 is such an awesome guitar, I love mine - and hope that yours is equally awesome!
@PhilTaylorGuitar
@PhilTaylorGuitar Год назад
Lovely playing Tom. The D35 just shades it for me.
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
Thanks Phil! Over the weekend, I was 100% preferring the D35 for this piece. But when I came to record it, the 41 felt/played so great, it changed my mind.
@zororosario
@zororosario Год назад
Both Beautiful sounding instruments, at this level I honestly can't hear the difference. The devil is in the details of which one is better or nicer, both are keepers that's for certain.👍 Thanks for the review, Cheers
@kevincullen2742
@kevincullen2742 Год назад
Great playing! For the money D35 takes it for me. If I’m spending over 5k on a Martin it’s going to be from the 60s or earlier …….or have the word “Authentic” after the model designation. 😁
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
I've been playing the D35 a lot over the last few weeks, and can confirm that it is awesome.
@user-tm7me1ef9l
@user-tm7me1ef9l 5 месяцев назад
I watched a video a few days ago. I think the guy was a Martin employee, but I can't say for sure. I also think that he said that anything above the D-35 had expensive appointments, but was no better constructed for sound. I have owned a D-15, a D-28, and a D-35, and I loved all of them. I loved the D-35 the most. It was easy to play, and the sound was the best of any guitar I have ever owned. The D-28 may have projected better, but I had the guitars almost forty years apart, so I couldn't say for sure.
@tdlw
@tdlw 5 месяцев назад
I've heard the same thing about the higher-numbered models. I've also heard that there might be less 'variability' among the higher ones (i.e. perhaps tighter QA controls?). Either way, I bought the D-41 after playing it in a shop, and regardless of the bling -- it was the nicest sounding, easiest to play acoustic that I've ever touched!
@tfrost33elkhunter
@tfrost33elkhunter Год назад
Wow! That 41 is the real deal!
@sooparticular
@sooparticular Год назад
i owned both d 41 was satisfying for alot more styles...so rich and those chimy overtones! great playing and video!
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
Thanks! The overtones on the D41 are sweet!
@jmorenomar1
@jmorenomar1 Год назад
D35: 3.800 €, D41: 5.400 € This is also important
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
True!
@jeffhildreth9244
@jeffhildreth9244 2 месяца назад
There are Martins without the pricey ,unnecessary, bling that sound as good as the D41, though that particular D41 was exceptional.
@mikegraham4513
@mikegraham4513 Месяц назад
@@jeffhildreth9244 More than just bling separating D41's from other Martins. Quality of woods and build for example.
@Yorkie285
@Yorkie285 Год назад
Music to my soul.
@michaelhayes9773
@michaelhayes9773 10 месяцев назад
I don't think I have ever heard a D41 before this, wow. I have a D35 and it's nice, but something about that D41
@agailframe6590
@agailframe6590 Год назад
Nothing on earth c compares with a Martin. Their tone is matchless.
@doleary703
@doleary703 9 дней назад
I always thought that the D35 sounds a bit muddy, my D41 sings with outstanding clarity and balanced output.
@wrightwrjr
@wrightwrjr 2 месяца назад
Once I pick up and play an American made Martin they all sound good to me. I recently bought a 000-18 and while shopping I played a D41 and a D45. The store didn't have a D-35, so I've never played one of those, but the 000-18 I purchased sounded just as good to me as the D41 and it has a shorter scale length which I really like. They just make great guitars. Now, once you drop down to the Road Series and others that are made in Mexico there is definitely a big difference in sound. There are a few that I can't believe Martin puts their name on, but when it comes to the American made ones they are just unbeatable in my opinion. I've owned Taylor, Blueridge, Epiphone, and Takamine, and they don't stack up to a Martin. I do have an Alvarez that has a wonderful sound, but it's a different sound than my 000-18.
@lotsofhairbutnomoney3705
@lotsofhairbutnomoney3705 Год назад
Great video. Nice demo of the tonality. I gave this a like and I'm not in a habit of doing that. The d41 sounds better in every way but in certain rare instances, I feel like I would choose the 35 due to the slightly less "perfect" tone. The high end is no match and that just underscores the amount of definition on the 41 vs the 35. The 41 is also tighter and more elegant. But I can put down money that some people would pay to NOT have elegant tone. Lol. I'm certainly not one of those players but I can understand it. Anyways great video as I've mentioned already.
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
Thank you! Something that isn't easy to get across in the videos is how *great* both these guitars are to play -- even though they differ in sound, they both feel amazing in the hands.
@demolitionwilliams7419
@demolitionwilliams7419 11 месяцев назад
D35 for the win
@pedrovelez323
@pedrovelez323 Год назад
D35
@iemgr2002
@iemgr2002 10 месяцев назад
to borrow the ol golf saying, 41 for show, 35 for dough.
@hughnguyen1772
@hughnguyen1772 Месяц назад
The D35 sounds brighter while the D41 sounds warmer. The D41 sounds like a well aged guitar.
@lordemed1
@lordemed1 7 месяцев назад
D41 allday, everyday
@ggrahman9371
@ggrahman9371 Год назад
I like D41...👍
@thejafernando2677
@thejafernando2677 Месяц назад
Does martin worth such a huge money 😮
@demolitionwilliams7419
@demolitionwilliams7419 Год назад
I love that tune you're playing. What is it? I've been learning it by watching you play it and it's a perfect one for testing a guitar's tone and playability out
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
It's a tune made up by a guitarist called Carl Miner - he demos a lot of guitars, and makes up his own tunes. I think I link to his original in the description. Best thing is, he knows how to make a guitar sound great!
@demolitionwilliams7419
@demolitionwilliams7419 Год назад
@@tdlw Carl Miner is incredible I've seen him before on a cross picking video. Thanks for the info! You make those guitars sound great as well
@batman48195
@batman48195 Год назад
Nice playing! Do they both have the same nut width and neck profile? You seemed to hit the notes cleaner on the D41. I think that one has a 1 3/4 nut width. I know I do better on a 1 3/4 vs a 1 11/16. But, nice demo. I really enjoyed it.
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
Yes - both 1 and 3/4 nuts, and very similar neck profiles; great to play!
@ydocmit
@ydocmit 2 месяца назад
Such an interesting video. I have a 2001 D45, which sounds very much like the D41 here: perhaps even more shimmery. I also have a 1967 Brazilian Rosewood D28. If I A-B that with my D45, the D45 sounds weak... Weird stuff
@slbolfing56
@slbolfing56 Год назад
Both sound great, and if I had not just heard them side by side, I would have bet there'd be no difference. But the D-35 sounded more compressed or almost muted compared to the D-41. Now I'm really GASing for a 41...
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
I didn't think I wanted one until I played it...
@jan_phd
@jan_phd Год назад
D-35.
@alexcorll90
@alexcorll90 4 месяца назад
Both sound great. I suspect the D41 sounds better in the room. The D35 has a more mid forward sound and seems to record better imo. I would take the 41 just for the bling.
@simon-oy6um
@simon-oy6um 3 месяца назад
The d 35 has a more mellow and deeper tone ,both nice 😂😂😊
@raluvelayo782
@raluvelayo782 Год назад
both are amazing.but for me d35 for the budget🤠😜🤗
@williamrehl6520
@williamrehl6520 3 месяца назад
Both phenomenal but I give slight edge to D35 so damn clear .
@tikigodsrule2317
@tikigodsrule2317 4 месяца назад
Felt like the D35 performance seemed less aggrresive but both are wonderful and the audience would not notice any difference at anyway. Even guitarists don't all agree. Either one is a win
@WysteriaGuitar
@WysteriaGuitar Год назад
I have both and they are both excellent. My D-35 has a bit more bass and my D-41 a bit more treble...
@jamiemorgan4146
@jamiemorgan4146 Год назад
That’s just the wood talking, not the model #
@WysteriaGuitar
@WysteriaGuitar Год назад
@@jamiemorgan4146 Yes, precisely...and the design, three piece back, braces, etc.
@Yorkie285
@Yorkie285 8 месяцев назад
D-35, 100% the winner.
@hulihulichicken
@hulihulichicken 4 месяца назад
I like the sound of the D-41 better, it sounder fuller and richer to me.
@jcarry5214
@jcarry5214 3 месяца назад
That's a very good 35, but I suspect that's an exceptional 41. I've played a bunch of acoustics and not seen any as across the board solid as that one.
@mygreenbaguk
@mygreenbaguk 2 месяца назад
What is the name of this tune, please?
@staleyexplores
@staleyexplores Год назад
i personally like the d35 better as far as my ear goes. a retro 2014 version, that's interesting. the d41 is really aesthetic but too flashy for me I think. I might have to try to learn this demo/piece.
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
I'm with you on the looks - but when I'm playing, I can't see any of the D41's bling anyway! I definitely encourage learning Carl's tunes - they just sound awesome (even at slow speed with added mistakes)
@capohd28
@capohd28 Год назад
When I bought my D-41 reimagined, I was all set to hate it due to the bling, but the tone blew me away and I bought it instantly. Now that I have had it for awhile the bling has grown on me. I still have the fear of marking it up compared to my other Martins have much more character.
@staleyexplores
@staleyexplores Год назад
@@capohd28 super lucky you found a great one! yeah I'd rock it too if I had the opportunity and the sound resonated with me.
@reflexionesjm706
@reflexionesjm706 Месяц назад
Im ready to order the D35 tomorrow but when I heard this video makes me want the D41, you think the $2k price difference worth it for the D41? I was trying to find the difference and the only difference I can see is just cosmetic, that abalone and neck, is another better difference on construction, that makes this guitar sounds better? Thanks
@tdlw
@tdlw Месяц назад
Been playing D41 and D35 a lot this week - and I love them both! My two feel very similar in the hand, which is one of the reasons I bought the 35, because it plays almost as well as the 41 - in fact the 35's neck is slightly easier for me to get my left thumb round. The sonic differences come from the 35's 3-piece back. If I wanted a strummer, I'd reach for the 35. For single-note melody stuff, the 41's got more sweetness too it. I'm not a huge fan of the 41's 'bling' - but I don't mind it either; if I coulda bought the same guitar plain, without the abalone, I probly woulda.
@reflexionesjm706
@reflexionesjm706 Месяц назад
@@tdlw thanks!! 👍
@zen234
@zen234 Месяц назад
The first guitar is more balanced to my ear
@SimoneOrtisi
@SimoneOrtisi Год назад
D41 wins 😁
@HollaJo3
@HollaJo3 3 месяца назад
D41 and D28 would've been a better direct comparison, right ?
@jeffhildreth9244
@jeffhildreth9244 2 месяца назад
No, as the D35 has the narrow 1/4 inch top bracing, and that is the main difference in the tone. .. not the whing ding bling.
@Michael-Ray
@Michael-Ray 8 месяцев назад
Where did you get the tabs for this wonderful piece?
@tdlw
@tdlw 8 месяцев назад
No tabs I'm afraid, I learned it from Carl Miner's TNAG video, which I linked in the description.
@TutorWindow
@TutorWindow 2 месяца назад
D-35
@laurentmiller387
@laurentmiller387 Год назад
Do you have the tab of this song ? thanks
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
No tab, sorry - I learned it from the video I link to in the description^
@jean-jacqueslarribal3337
@jean-jacqueslarribal3337 Год назад
Merci pour la comparaison, mais franchement mis à part la finition de la décoration, au niveau sonore ça me semble vraiment similaire 🙏
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
Convenu! La différence est la plus grande après avoir passé du temps à jouer d'une guitare, puis je passe à l'autre.
@bigtorrisi
@bigtorrisi Год назад
I play a poor man's Martin, a Guild...its a USA mind.
@lawrencerasmus
@lawrencerasmus 10 месяцев назад
D55 is a Martin killer
@bobsyeruncle4841
@bobsyeruncle4841 Год назад
reserved and tasty playing, i don't like the bling bling on the D41
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
Thanks! Good thing about the bling is: I can't see it when I'm playing!
@TomTom-kv5nf
@TomTom-kv5nf Месяц назад
Hi! What strings are you using?
@tdlw
@tdlw Месяц назад
Elixir PB 12s
@thegrandpencil4374
@thegrandpencil4374 3 месяца назад
Between these two models, I choose... eh, screw it. Get a D-18 instead! haha
@jeffhildreth9244
@jeffhildreth9244 2 месяца назад
BINGO ! You win the prize. There is nothing like a good D-18. No bound fingerboards or 1/4 inch bracing or jewelry. just tone and playability.
@Ledzepfan88
@Ledzepfan88 Год назад
Is it just me or was the d35 louder
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
Yeah - the D35 plays a little louder than the 41. Although it's totally possible that when I recorded I played louder, I notice a slight difference in volume when I switch between 'em when practicing
@Ledzepfan88
@Ledzepfan88 Год назад
@@tdlw thanks for the feedback! If you could start with one and not be wanting for another for awhile which would you recommend? I've played them all just not in the same vicinity. 18-28-35 hd variants. I'm a sucker for mahogany but I don't have a rosewood guitar yet lol the one in my picture is a custom super jumbo I had made on Etsy.
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
@@Ledzepfan88 both are great. The clarity of the D41 edges it for me, but I would be totally happy with just the D35. Note that from a playability point of view, they are very similar and both feel amazing
@Ledzepfan88
@Ledzepfan88 Год назад
@@tdlw sweet! Thank you. The more I played the d35 back and forth with a j45 in the store the more I felt like the d35 felt and sounded nicer to play. Both being melancholic in nature. I can't afford either and I definitely don't plan on selling my custom in my profile pic, way too sentimental. it'll be a lifer lol
@jhnfalls
@jhnfalls Год назад
I think that once you move into the 3 and 4 series martins, theirs not a lot of difference in the sound. They all sound great. Looks are what your paying for.
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
Also note both of these are beautiful to play, but the 41 is a *little* better, partly in terms of the high E string on the D35 being a little easy to slip off the neck (which could be fixed by cutting a new nut, but it's fine as long as I remember when I fret it!)
@Michael-Ray
@Michael-Ray Год назад
@@tdlw The D35 you played in this video must have been pre-2018, because the Reimagined series from 2018 onwards all have a 1.75” nut.
@jamiemorgan4146
@jamiemorgan4146 Год назад
It’s all bullshit. The people that say that a 35 or 41 is for this or that knows “Nothing” ! For me Martin tone is what I’m looking for. You can’t go by the model. Each and every guitar, no matter the number on it sounds different. Find the guitar that has your sound and that’s the best.
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
I tried both of these in shops and loved them. I split my playing time between them and enjoy it equally - but I dunno which is more martin than the other!
@capohd28
@capohd28 Год назад
I agree for the most part, but I think these reimagined D-41’s came from the same wood stock and builders. They all sound very similar with that shimmer. I can’t say the same for other models like D-18, D-28, D-35, everyone sounds different.
@jamesvela3680
@jamesvela3680 Год назад
Amen!👍
@jeffhildreth9244
@jeffhildreth9244 2 месяца назад
This is where your bullshit hits the fan, there is a major difference between the 35 and the 41 (and 28, and 42, and 45) the 35 has 1/4 inch top bracing. And that is THE difference. I do agree that guitars are case by case. I have played many Martin dogs.
@fretkillrlives
@fretkillrlives Год назад
The D-41 sounds about $1,800 more. ;-)
@tdlw
@tdlw Год назад
Cha-ching!
@tschaffner4970
@tschaffner4970 7 месяцев назад
They sound identical to me.
@user-hd2te4by3i
@user-hd2te4by3i 5 месяцев назад
Yes, but one of the two sounds more 'identical' than the other. Don't you agree?
@jeffhildreth9244
@jeffhildreth9244 2 месяца назад
@@user-hd2te4by3i Funny !
@clementnade972
@clementnade972 Год назад
D41 is way warmer. D35 sounds bright.
@jeffhildreth9244
@jeffhildreth9244 2 месяца назад
We have different definitions of bright and warm. Most would consider the opposite.
@revisionist3824
@revisionist3824 3 месяца назад
both sounds chinese made.....
@jeffhildreth9244
@jeffhildreth9244 2 месяца назад
You are deaf or deluded Mr "Old School."
@jamestaylor5231
@jamestaylor5231 3 месяца назад
A D2r is as good if not better than any Martin made,same specs as the best Martin makes.Why did Martin Discontinue the D2r is because they were buying it over their high priced Martins,D2r Was $950.
@jeffhildreth9244
@jeffhildreth9244 2 месяца назад
You are very fortunate to believe that.
Далее
Tanghulu Cotton Candy
00:31
Просмотров 17 млн
Что за бренд? Supertype
01:00
Просмотров 221 тыс.
Vintage D-28 vs New D-41 Martin
7:56
Просмотров 666 тыс.
1972 Martin D-35 | Guitar of the Day - Angela Petrilli
12:23
Martin D18 vs Martin HD28 vs Martin D35
10:38
Просмотров 9 тыс.
Everything Wrong with my 1970 Martin D-41
14:01
Просмотров 23 тыс.
Talking Guitar, Martin HD-28 vs D-35
8:40
Просмотров 18 тыс.
Martin D-28 vs HD-28 vs D-35
10:26
Просмотров 28 тыс.
Martin HD-28 vs Martin D-41
9:30
Просмотров 25 тыс.
Tanghulu Cotton Candy
00:31
Просмотров 17 млн