Rabbis Get Coffee And Talk About Hell - with Rabbi Shais Taub 

Rabbi Friedman is SO wise that he’s humble, listening, even learning. Mamash my role model.

I love Judaism’s focus on improving the physical world, or making Heaven on Earth. There’s nothing impractical about it 😭

this conversation is so nicly blessed the laughfter ,,,,, the joy ,,,,, even about a big , all over the earth subject ,,,, OMG ,,, the Fear of Hell , it is still depressing most people , Manis Friedman ,,,,,, I asked God if you can stay longer with us , so much blessings in the Testimonies and teachings , Thank you .

What a beautiful conversation. I can learn so much from you both.

Thankyou for sharing this conversation with us,Gentlemen.

I'm a Christian and love listening to Rabbi Manis he's so humble and knowledgeable. God bless you sir and thank you for your honesty and wisdom

Regarding 12 months in Hell... The physical world is bound by time. And so, with our physical minds, we can only understand time but what we know it as. If afterlife / spirituality is not physical, it also isn’t bound by the type of time we know time as. I have no basis or sources for this, but this is my conjecture: 12 months in hell is not 12 months as in 12x30 days necessarily, but rather 12 months as in 12 timeframes of soul cleansing. Some souls need more than others. And the way I see it, hell isn’t either what we can understand physically, but rather an internal transformation until the person/soul truly faces that which they’ve done, in the strongest sense. Facing one’s wrongdoings in the most brutally honest way is hell. So the worse a person was in this world, the more brutal reckoning they have to do in the afterlife. And over time, the hell of facing one’s evil actions cleanses the soul. But I do admit my knowledge is limited, and I also don’t think anyone can truly comprehend that which is beyond the physical world.

The only reason that I've ever been able to justify living for,is to serve others. Without being in service to people, I can see no reason for life. Reward doesn't interest me,punishment doesn't scare me. But kindness received and given is surely the ultimate gift and the most beautiful thing in life.

Thank you for teaching me.

Wisdom is bliss. Thanks Rabbis. I have an addictive personality...I'm now seemingly addicted to failure. Don't know what to make of that 😕

Oh that thou wouldest hide me in Sheol, That thou wouldest keep me secret, until thy wrath be past, That thou wouldest appoint me a set time, and remember me! 14 If a man die, shall he live again? All the days of my warfare [f]would I wait, Till my [g]release should come. 15 Thou [h]wouldest call, and I would answer thee: Thou wouldest have a desire to the work of thy hands. 16 But now thou numberest my steps: Dost thou not watch over my sin? 17 My transgression is sealed up in a bag, And thou fastenest up mine iniquity. Job 14

I was an EMT and ambulance paramedic for over 6 years and I knew what people needed, even when they didn't. It's kind of funny because they didn't know what to thank me for and they usually didn't thank me for anything -- but I didn't expect it. It was a special was to help others and a good model for me to help others otherwise.

We want a closer connection to Hashem and building the temple. Baruch Hashem. Amen.

Fascinating...."all addictions are addiction to self"....

I can not Thank You enough for this coffee/chat, you have brought peace to my mind. I am sending a copy of the link to my family members. Again THANK YOU.

I enjoy listening to you. My pa (adoptive father) died when I was 12 years . A German anglican priest came to the funeral. Mom (adoptive) sat sheva at home . Relatives said the body had to face east. He was rapped in linen and buried soon . I did not see him in the casket . The priest said he is in a better place. I am ashamed I said a bad word and was dragged away. Do you think God will forgive me . My adoptive parents loved me. I am not a nice person but I am still ashamed then I was angry. Do advise our politicians. Prime minister Trudeau and premier Ford. I pray blessings on them and all leaders. You are special Rabbi Friedman.

Love these Rabbi I’m. Opens your mind but transitions are always painful. Change is hard.

Very good conversation, never heard such deep questions with this brilliant answers. I have learned so much from it! Thank you both!

Love this conversation, very opened up. The more selfless you are the more it's what God needs. The knowledge that this is exactly what God wanted, to create us selfish and to make us becoming selfless, it is the power of managing. I know from my own experience. When I'm in pain and I want something only reminding myself that it's NOT about me, that God is the one who needs me by his creation, only that what's getting me out of pain.

This was amazing. Interesting. Thought promoting. I think that the idea of making the world a better place is subjective. It creates the arrogance that some think they know what's best which they then try to inflict on others. It doesn't work. People need to make their own existence better, then move outwards. Living is of course thinking of others, which makes our existence better.

dust you are and unto dust YOU shall return. dust has no feelings. dust can't see or speak, my brothers of other mothers Peace - Shalom

Best title for a video I’ve read in a long time

Welcome brother father in heaven family

To not feel selfish or selfcenteredness or greed; give all credit to God; for, he is a jealous God and thou shalt not have no other God before him. For as Emanuel said; the greatest in Heaven is the one who comes to earth to serve; not, the one who came to be served.

There's a selfishness that takes and a selfishness that gives. Let there be light and let the light rule the darkness.

I have experienced the out of body objective perspective at an early age.. just like you say, it's true. Of course it's my experience, I cannot prove it, but as The Lord lives it's true. Just for the sake of confirmation of belief... Totally objective. Even though I saw trauma happening to my body, I had no feelings or shock or complex thoughts at all. Just objective observation. And, my sight was clear and perfect as if I had eyes out of the body. Also I was much taller. Shalom!

...They will live as long as trees and have time to enjoy the works of their hands. They will not labor in vain, and their children will not be doomed to misfortune. For they are people blessed by the Lord, and their children, too, will be blessed.. Isaiah 65.

Charity is the reward! As Im ending the video im feeling comfortable! Everything is

Thank you 🙏🏻

Just observing the reward and Punishment in this life is enough to motivate anybody

Gehinnom is not 12 months. It could be eternity! If it were just 12 months, I should just sin all the time here and only suffer a year after! Then I get an eternity of good! Stop denying Gehinnom's severity!

You two are awesome to hear as you sound off of each other. B' HaShem

The truth is mind blowing!

At the end is about making someone life a little bit better said mckenna. Love is universal, what is Love is the true question remaining and thats unanswerable, can only live it, its objective

Yes sir Rabbi i believe

You guys need to do this again, who is a better sound system.

It says in the word of God : " That the leaving know they will die / but the dead no nothing," Please explain this for me. Ecclesiastes 9:5 For the living know that they shall die; but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.

Very profound discussions! Thank you....

Hell is the world of Peoples with ETERNAL pains in every form.

8:00 The soul is life itself.

Please pray for all levels of governments and doctors and essential workers also for the best for our enemies. Pray corona goes please. Israeli cried out to God and they are redeemed. There is hope

This is cool

Reality as we perceive it is an appearance. It is built on this infinite sea we exist in and bound by consciousness. The soul and Hashem are real, nothing else is.

In management their were definitely times we would rather hire someone who had no prior experience some develop bad habits and sometimes it is easier to start from scratch.\ than to break a learned bad habit. Or the attitude of we did it this way at previous employer.

It is very difficult to explain what I am thinking. I will try. I think that we can be selfless by dying to ourselves (our egos). That is a hard thing to explain. I will try. About 5 years ago I suddenly realised that other people are just as valuable as I am. I mean that they really are just as valuable as I am. Sometimes I listen to them deeply. I lose myself in them. I find it to be a lovely and enjoyable experience. People love it when I tell them that it was good to see them or good to talk to them. When I do say this I really do mean it. I don't say it to people that it was not good to talk to. I think that as you give money or whatever to someone else that it opens you up in some way to receive even more money or whatever than you gave. It is unblocking a pipe in your life. I have found that when I give myself psychologically to someone else that there is a joy. It unblocks the bad feelings in my life. Also, when I am by myself I am even more joyful. Maybe it is because there are no agendas at all. I can just forget about my own ego and agendas when I am by myself. In my old way of thinking these bad feelings were there because I wanted people to serve me in some way. I was self absorbed. I was angry and upset because nobody wanted to give me anything without getting something in return. So when I waited for other people to give to me first then nothing flowed through me to anyone else. Also when people did give to me then I wanted to give them back less than they gave me. I wanted to win on the transaction. When I do give to other people then good feelings of joy come because I am not blocking things up with having things serve my agenda in some way. I am creating something by giving something without an agenda and I am expecting nothing in return before I give it away. I do these things now (I don't always do them of course) because that is who I am now. There is no other reason. When I do them it is fun. So I keep doing them because it is fun. My motivation is not particularly because it is more moral and I will get a reward in heaven (even though I probably will get these things). I don't have to grit my teeth and do it while hating it because it really is fun to do. I appreciate that this is something that is not easy to communicate. I have found this very rarely in other people. I have met only one or two others who see things this way. Most people are self absorbed. A lot of people's faces are miserable on the streets. It is such a joy not to be always wrapped up in myself. A weight is lifted off me when my pipe is unblocked.

Haha! Go to chabad! Nice comeback @34.. That's exactly right! How can we help

Your hats remind me of my biological and adoptive fathers' hats. Precious memories. Thank you. These dark days of lockdown is hell coffee helps .we grew coffee and spices. If in Grenada see the discontinued mikvah in Richmond estate. Who are my relatives? what am I? Bodie and Rika what are these names?

In between the giggles and the sarcasm that imply knowledge, they teach things that CAUSE people to NOT DO TESHUVA because according to them everyone goes to a better place regardless of whether they go against God or not, which is completely against the entire Torah. They're actively destroy the desire to do better and be better for the sake of eternity, and have created a new religion.

Its all about love it comes down to really loving hasem!!

Heaven eventually is here on Earth

Thank you for explaining.

The Rabbai’s talked about an amazing subject - I think they need a new camera LIGHT crew......

“In my fathers house there are many mansions each one got a fire proof floor.” Bob Dylan

יהוה YHVH is the name every heart beat says with every beat. Listen to your own heart beat with a stethoscope, or lay your ear over the breast of your loved ones heart and listen for yourself.

This type of intellectual discussion is extremely valuable and stimulating. More please!

Very good conversation. Very inderstandable. But who is the soundengineer. It sounds like they were sittin on the beach!

"I'm here to help bring about an objective reality in this physical world that would give immense pleasure to my maker" 4:48 - 4:59 So, what is that? What does that look like? I think you might say what you've already referred to Earlier in the discussion, basically the messianic age. I kinda wish you had elaborated on that a little more before moving on to the next question though. I do think this was a good discussion though . In part because you both were honest about how, even children have the thoughts and feelings of not having asked to be born and in that vein, the tedium and futility of living "a good life", what ever that might mean. I appreciate that.

This is complete heresy. The truth about gehinom is "gehinom by rabbi yaron reuven".

"i didn't ask to be born" is the nefesh habahamas stating that it can't win it's goal of personal pleasure.

Now that was cool. Deeper.Probing and suggesting a Resolve rather than wasting time being perplexed.

G-d’s “selfishness” is different from human selfishness, because - perhaps only one of several reasons - our selfishness is at the cost of other people’s needs. Our selfishness is manifest in “greed,” wanting more than we need, as in “i want it all.” G-d’s selfishness is basically expressed by what is required to show our love and appreciation for G-d. We know what it takes to primarily show our love to our spouse, for example: we are loyal to our marriage. Is expecting our spouse to be monogamous being selfish? No, it is an understanding of what is required to prove or show our love for our marriage - our relationship to our spouse, our coven with a person we love. Hence, our relationship to, our coven with, G-d has its requirements. These have been outlined as to how G-d wants us to show we love our Creator....or.

Here’s a quote from Orthodox Christian theologian, Metropolitan Hierotheos of Nafpaktos who summarized: “Paradise and Hell do not exist from God's point of view, but from man's. It is true that Paradise and Hell exist as two ways of life, but it is not God who created them. In the patristic tradition it is clear that there are not two ways, but God Himself is Paradise for the saints and God Himself is Hell for the sinners."

I belive we are all in a hell realm its a horrable place that could be way better if mankind could only grow the smeg up

Is not a the river of fire a test of your faith and works - purging what is corruptible from the incorruptible. Why did God give us the 10 commandments, if there is no reward or punishment

Hi Dear Rabbi I would like to explain me this verse. Thanks. May God Bless You. Exodus 32:33And the Lord said to Moses: "Whoever has sinned against Me, him I will erase from My book!"

Colossians 3: 23, is my motivation❤️🔥💯

Thank you so much for allowing us to witness this exploration! If I may be so bold, I disagree with the idea that acts need to be objective as the goal. Rather, once the physical body has, in essence, surrendered to the life and beingness of the soul, after lifetimes of the soul passing through the River of Fire, and becoming its most highest, most pure essence, most pure self, then our actions will be objective and our physical world will be transformed. In other words, once we’re all like the Rebbe, we’re there. In my very humble opinion.

I wonder based on what I’ve heard so far, what happens to the soul of evil people, people who are irredeemable (like Hitler evil). 12 months is ridiculous

Thanks. I now realize I matter.

I want to give my view to the question about selflessness. Now be aware I am a christian so my answer doesn't neccesarily reflect the jewish faith. I believe we ought to behave selfless because god himself acts selfless and loving. He made us a certain way in that he has given us freedom of will. He created us and gave us the choice to decide for or against him. Now that is an act of true selflessness and love. A god who created us not to serve him as slaves but to live in love with him and among us. Now you say he is needy, he needs us to do things. I'd answer he shows us our natural way of living. We were created to be with him warmed by his love. Now we created money, entertainment even drugs to make us feel that warmth but we cannot feel it. We feel empty because we are not with God. Only through God's love will we be fullfilled. Now if he created us to be with him and in his love doesn't it make sense that we have the ability to be selfless? Doesn't it make sense that we have the abilty for great and pure love? Now as a christian I live by the word of Christ. As the word became flesh it manifested in a fairly poor man, leaving everything behind and living a selfless live doing many act of great love exactly as God intended. He is the way and as such reflects God's will because he is God. He so often says he is not here to rule but to serve and so shall we not rule but serve. God doesn't sit on a cloud ruling. He came down to earth. He shows that he misses us more even than we miss him, that he suffers with us and wants us to be fullfilled wants us not to suffer, to return to him so that he may come into this world once again and greet us with open arms, for where a man of true faith in spirit is, there is the Spirit and God is the Spirit so the kindom of God touches the earth.

11 months seems awfully short for the worst of us.

You guys sounds like deep involved apprentices in the topic, so I would have a QUESTION: What are these messages directly answering my thoughts, independent from the outer timeframe of the question & the answer? 😂

To build rewards in Heaven; no greed do you have, you give without getting repaid, you keep it to yourself unless it's a one on one teaching moment. The soul doesn't die and we are told this in God's word where he says they (Call) it the second death, it doesn't mean you die. Remember the story of Lazarus and the rich man. Each man will suffer if he dies in his sins. The lake of fire or the river of fire is not about consuming; but, torcher for sins not forgiven. " for the pain of their suffering will last night and day, for eternity. What good does it do a man to gain the whole world and lose his soul"?. I believe there are 7 churches 7 levels of hell, and 7 levels of Heaven then the Temple of God that is set aside for his chosen people Israel. The outer courts are for people like me, gentiles. May the Father bless you both.

Ooooh baby...do you know what that's worth? We'll make heaven a place on earth.

It looks like you have some problem with the sound system , we hear constant noises .

thanks Rabbi Manis Friedman ..please can you put translation in arabic . because not all my friends and family know good english.. very appreciate.. please pray for me and my family .

Two heavy thinkers champions!

the soul that sins, it shall die.

Yes Rabbi HELL is where ideals speak, where they live, and where they preach! When human beings decide to copy God from their understanding of GOD, all they manage to create is HELL!! People blame the devil for their bad impulses, and their bad choices! They wear a black dress all week and hang the white dress in the closet for worship time! Having said all that, both sides of the coin have know each other, accept each other, learn to cope with each other! Miracles happen at which point and hell goes away just like that!!

May I ask the name of the other Rabbi please?

Rabbi, you said there was a Heaven on earth for a short time, the Garden of Eden. Do we know how long the garden lasted until sin came?

You don't have to study much to see that all of recorded history tells the tale of the world in one mess after the other. How much more evidence do we need that war, tyrany, bigotry, violence, etc have never solved anything, and yet they continue, unabated. And then, probably the most frequent cause of these messes are religions fighting one another. I know I'm a mere mortal and incapable of truly understanding the infinity of God, yet my humble question is...why does His plan have to look like no plan?

Before the world was created, God was there and after he destroys the world he will be there, sometime I wonder why it was created for so much misery, disease for mankind

Hell fire is a true place and paradise is a true place

🌹

Non duality, just be careful how you are thinking! Observe your thinking and acting

🌹Thank you 🙏🏻

You think you are thinking, senseless act of kindness comes from something, we think we exist, we are not doing nothing, we are characters in a movie and God is ENJOYING, ITS SXRIPTED its not that nothings matter if this is the case, everything matters.

The difference between you and God, Sir is we are mortals and Almighty God is immortal, no one is born from him, and he and is not born from anyone

Yidden in golus...? Didn't many yidden live in " hell" in goyish Europe or Russia? Todah raba. Shalom

The natural world at least what our natural eye sees looks endless, so heaven must be the same, so there is plenty of room for billions and billions of people, but planet earth as it is now is not big enough for billions upon billions of resurrected people?

WARNING IN BIBLE: 7 So thou, O son of man, I have set thee a watchman unto the house of Israel; therefore thou shalt hear the word at my mouth, and warn them from me. 8 When I say unto the wicked, O wicked man, thou shalt surely die; if thou dost not speak to warn the wicked from his way, that wicked man shall die in his iniquity; but his blood will I require at thine hand. 9 Nevertheless, if thou warn the wicked of his way to turn from it; if he do not turn from his way, he shall die in his iniquity; but thou hast delivered thy soul. 10 Therefore, O thou son of man, speak unto the house of Israel; Thus ye speak, saying, If our transgressions and our sins be upon us, and we pine away in them, how should we then live? 11 Say unto them, As I live, saith the Lord God, I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked; but that the wicked turn from his way and live: turn ye, turn ye from your evil ways; for why will ye die, O house of Israel? 12 Therefore, thou son of man, say unto the children of thy people, The righteousness of the righteous shall not deliver him in the day of his transgression: as for the wickedness of the wicked, he shall not fall thereby in the day that he turneth from his wickedness; neither shall the righteous be able to live for his righteousness in the day that he sinneth. 13 When I shall say to the righteous, that he shall surely live; if he trust to his own righteousness, and commit iniquity, all his righteousnesses shall not be remembered; but for his iniquity that he hath committed, he shall die for it. 14 Again, when I say unto the wicked, Thou shalt surely die; if he turn from his sin, and do that which is lawful and right; 15 If the wicked restore the pledge, give again that he had robbed, walk in the statutes of life, without committing iniquity; he shall surely live, he shall not die. 16 None of his sins that he hath committed shall be mentioned unto him: he hath done that which is lawful and right; he shall surely live. 17 Yet the children of thy people say, The way of the Lord is not equal: but as for them, their way is not equal. 18 When the righteous turneth from his righteousness, and committeth iniquity, he shall even die thereby. 19 But if the wicked turn from his wickedness, and do that which is lawful and right, he shall live thereby. 20 Yet ye say, The way of the Lord is not equal. O ye house of Israel, I will judge you every one after his ways. (Ezkiel 33:7-20). Heaven&Hell Exists,Dont be Deceived.

Can I be Jewish? I used to be Baptist but as ive grow and studied other beliefs I didnt want to be any religion until i have started learning the Jewish beliefs I would like any response on this matter thank you

God reduced himself in the size and we became

Do all souls keep going up n up?

Rabbi ASMR at the beginning

Can you add references to scripture that supports your statements on haven and hell?

First the Tora isn't the beginning and ending of truth, revelations are endless. There is so much truth you can't contain it all, if you could we might have to call you God. There are revelations for a moment in time, than revelations that are eternal. Hell is the grave? Hell is a place of Torment? Hell is a place for you to be burned for eternity? Hell is punishment which is death? Speculation not revelation?

The "wolf & the lamb" I perceived purely in methaforic terms. It's basically a state of the soul which already transitioned trough the boundaries of EGO. It's a state where the positive & negative reached agreement in one's mind & heart. Basically an unification of seemingly ununifiable forces. On the topic of my favourite druid rabbi, concerning the question of change in resonance of human experience, I think it's a good thing. What I am thinking it's a spiritual stage which been described as outpoor of holy spirit. People, no matter of age are striped of blocking influences, like fear for example in order to function as independent units & to be able to receive the ”holy”. The blood of Christ & tears of Marry shall fall on all of us in this process. God bless 💜

Questions I hope someone can answer as this is very important to me 1. Rabbi mentions that the max sentence is 12 months for Gehinnom. So, after these 12 months does everyone make it to the world to come? Not to some cliche but does that mean that Hitler would make it?....eventually after the max sentence 2. Do all the ideas mentioned in the video apply to Noahides or is it only for jews? if only for Jews, then what is the experience like for Noahides? Thanks!!