Raghuram Rajan Is Not An Economist: Subramanian Swamy 

For all those who Doubt Dr Swamy-- He is Harvard Phd in Economics at the age of 24. He is one of the five Phd students of Paul Samuelson (one of the greatest economist of modern history). He has written Samuelson-Swamy theory on index numbers. He was a proffesor at Harvard at the age of 27.

Why didn't he opposed Shatikanta Das with a degree of M.A. history getting post of RBI governor more strongly??

Only Swamy can get away by calling Raghu Rajan, 'Not an economist' without people calling him insane. *Gold and bold* .

I always adore Swamy, but this is stupidity

All those abusing Swamy do not know that he has PhD from Harvard University in economics.

Funny thing is Mr Swamy himself was never a pure Economics students. He did graduation in maths and then masters in stats in isi before doing a phd in economics. Raghuram rajan too studied different subjects in graduation and masters before gaining a phd in economics. So where's the difference? Manmohan Singh was a pure economics student.

And Michael Faraday was not a scientist as he hadn't possessed any formal degree on Physics 😂😂😂. WTF!

And now ask BJP something about unemployment...they have created a record in making unemployment highest in last 45 years....

This guy completed PhD from Harvard under a nobel laureate at age 26, and was soon after appointed as Asst. Prof at Harvard.

Swamy sir casually said that Rajan sir does not know economics.....Quint made it headline🤣🤣. I appreciate they are at least working!

Mr Swamy is a Hindu icon, who is Mathematician , Statistician , PHD in Economics (Market Economy ), and Lawyer without degree

Now I have doubt in Swami. How much he knows about economics.

People critising Swamy on his words in this video just cant counter him with any base, bcoz they are anti BJP they will downvote or absurd comment. COME WITH YOUR ECONOMICS

there's people with class and the rest Rajan was told the same statement and his response was," yes, Mr Swami is right, i am from Finance "

This guys is so arrogant. He thinks he is the only one knows everything and a complete intellectual man.

Modi government enjoyed low petrol prices for most of his period. But was not able to convert to economic growth. They fired Raghuram Rajan, ill-planned demobilization, cow politics resulted in lower GDP growth

I don't know why Mr.swami thinks if he is very smart or only smart person in the country.

Swammy is never wrong and never losses to anyone. Even Arnab loss in a debate with Swammy. I'm just waiting for Rajnikant's turn.

He is so obsessed with himself. Whatever he talks like he is the one and the only problem solve whom God has sent to earth like he speaks.

World admires Raghuram Rajan as a great economist, here this blague telling him he is not.

Raghuram Rajan was the chief economist of IMF before joining in as governor of RBI. If the former chief economist of IMF does not know economics then I don't think anyone does.

This is Swamy's trade Mark statement which media loves, he said same for PM and FM a while ago....

Raghuram Rajan is a Btech from IIT Delhi,Management from IIM ahmedabad , Phd from MIT. He was the professor of economics at University of Chicago after that he was the 7th Chief economist and head of research at IMF. In 2005 Rajan in a conference predicted the financial crisis on america and gave some solutions to prevent that the US Treasury secretary then insulted Rajan and denied his predictions but Rajan's predictions were proven right in 2008 financial crisis there was a documentary made on the crisis called Inside Job in 2010 and he was interview do see that. He was also the CEA to India and RBI governor

I understand why swamy didn't become anything . He talks too much

1$=1 rupee this swamy said in 2014 if modi came to power. he is a prime example of thotha channa baaje ghana

By the way, he really said nothing I had not read in first year economics

Elon Musk : Subramanian who ! 😂

Raghuramrajan has predicted 2008 market crash before and he is telling that he is not an economist. And in BJP government all the FINANCIAL institution are doing worse because there is no economist in BJP

And after removing Rajan, Indian economy is touching skies. This guy is a mad man and Indira Gandhi once described him so truly as "A Santa Claus with weird ideas" 😂

Correct yourself. He is a celebrated economist and known to be modernist

For all those taking stand of Mr. Swamy, he has strived to be a FM under more than 3 leaders for various governments but was never considered, coz politics do not work in economics. India has better people like Amartya Sen, Manmohan Singh and many more.. who donot talk about others' capabilities but woke best of their abilities.

So this man is saying A person who revived a dying economy,brought down the inflation, reimaged RBI is not an economist.

Before anyone calling him anything let me just inform you that he is a PHD in Economics from Havard University...

RR is not an economist, but Entire Economic Scientist 😂😂

Raghuram Rajan had an PhD from MIT in economics (something related). Was a chief economist at IMF and predicted 2008 crisis. How can he say he is not an economist.

Swamy is a legend🙏🏻

Everyone laughs at swamy's claims Then they are in court facing hard evidence .

Then why did indira gandhi called u mickey mouse of economics

He himself a big joker

Morarji Desai and even Atlaji have fired him many times for his oversmartness. He talks any rubbish. And some fools appreciate also.

Now ask same question to Mr. Swami ..are you sure Mr. Rajan is not an economist 🤣🤣🤣

Excellent economist Mr. Swamy. He is guest faculty of Harvard University

FIRSTLY HE SAYS ECONOMICS IS TECHNICAL AND THEN HE SAYS RAGHURAM RAJAN WAS TECHNICAL MAN SO HE WAS NOT GOOD FOR ECONOMICS😆

The western model that raghu ram rajan follows itself is failing. He knows a lot of stuff but about the wrong subject.. India needs a more customized approach rather than pick and place approach

He is good but egoistic. Thats why he is not chance..

Who brought asset quality review which showed the real condition of nationalised banks in india due to non performing assets.

The Most Learned person on this planet earth is Subramanium Swamy...he has answers and knowledge of all Maa Masti Maanush

Raghuram Rajan - one of handful economist who predited financial crisis. The ex-Reseve Bank head who stopped rupee falling from the cliff. The guy who worth listening to.

Bevkuf swami ye padh Rajan was the Chief Economist and Director of Research at the International Monetary Fund. In 2015, during his tenure at the Indian Reserve Bank he also became Vice-Chairman of the Bank for International Settlements.

Is SSwamy ko Yeh samajh mein nahi aata ki house prices were running amock by less interest rates and they were leaping up for 16 years Straight. This was also one of the excuse given by BJP for de-monetisation. The high realestate price makes your products uncompetitive. India was exporting so less already, you could not have added any more to the exports. Besides, nobody with less money (Essential Workers) with high real estate prices be able to afford houses in cities. If SSwamy believes the theory of interest rates so much, why does India always keeps its interest rates high in comparison to West. Answer to that is because India does not have much capital in the banks and keeps looking for FDI inflow. SSwamy chickened out debating with Rajan about economy when Rajan came back to visit India and he was giving interviews in TVs and justifying the reason for high interest rates. SSwamy was not to be seen rebutting that anywhere. This man thinks he is good economist because he knows politics. Then should he not seek to become RBI governor himself using his politics. Country can only know how good economic knowledge one possess once they are in right post. But he will not do it because he wants to become finance minister. Also perhaps as RBI governor also reports to finance minister. Basically, position is more important to him than proving that he knows something. Frankly, this guy believes if your first degree is Engg then you can never do something else as complex as economy. So, by that yardstick, he himself was statistician, so how can he be economist. Irony is that Madam Curie won Nobel prizes in both Chemistry and Physics. She could not have done that as per SSwamy as app the first degree remains stuck to some one forever to be able to do something different. High class irrelevant talker he has become. Ask him to justify de-monetisation again? No body from BJP has raised their hands and sought apologies. They still pretend something good and only operational issues were the problem. Fact is country lost big time in that scam. It was no reform as all the black money became white and all fake currency became genuine, not to mention the 25 to 40 % commission earned by BJP itself for turning black money into white. SSwamy backed Modi for de-monetisation and he still thinks himself as economist. The irony of it beats me.

Actually, Mr. Rajan 1st did BTech in Delhi , MBA from IIM and Phd from MIT ( Massachusetts , USA ).

Ok so you think Raghuram Rajan is not economist, but Shashikanth Das (B.A & M.A. in History) is economist. Wow👏👏

Easy on the goumutra swamy..

mast joke mara hai re baba......world knows about rajan. except this man....

This genius recommended tax on expenditure instead of on the income. Imagine what tax would be applicable on the Ambanis and Adhanis who make money by thousands of crores and spend in hundreds of crores.

So urjit Patel is????

People should see whole interview of swamy ji before criticising him.

Mr Swamy the BJP leader a small advice to you, Don't critisize what you don't understand, you never walked in that man's shoes

Most probably the first lessons of economics Raghuram Rajan got was in IIT Delhi and were given by Subramaniam Swamy who used teach Economics in IIT Delhi during that time.

You cry do whatever still you can't be finance minister

And Sir Issac Newton was not a scientist, Albert Einstein was not a theoretical physicist by your logic Mr. Subramanian Swamy!

He says right.that time I criticize him but today it is true small and medium industry is collapse Demonetization ,gst and tight monetary policy by Rajan lad this happens .it started by Rajan and modi Make worse . Now we need manmohan Singh to take on this situation

RR is economist by trade and practice. And RR is also an economist by being a academician, if not by Education.

Rahgu Rajan has been requested by IMF to advise and lead during the covid crisis. Swami thinks too much of himself. Itni baat hai nahi jo swami khud ko samjhte hain

How is this guy still in politics? 😂

Now he sounds like BJP leader. Kaya kare aadat se hai majboor

Ramjethmalani on Swamy: "This diseased insect" "His has been a life of character assassination, malicious mendacity and sordid blackmail of any one who happens to cross his path. No body has been able to deflect him from his criminal course of conduct because few have the inclination to take on this vicious viper and expose him for what he really is."

And an economist and politician became the finance minister... Now everything is excellent 😂😂

Swami is missing the context of the decision taken. Economics is partly science and rest is theory. Swami forgot that Rajan is just a professional

Ok. You know very well about Economy, you're Economist. Then What about your Bjp government now? You just said about Unemployment and Economy. You should advise to FM Nirmala Sitharam.

People talking about his qualifications but forgetting that honesty is a thing. You can talk a lot of technical jargon, introduce a fallacy and no one would notice it and will accept it as a good argument. He didn't say if he increased the interest rates beyond a point that would affect SMEs fatally. In his own words, it's all about general equilibrium. That's intellectual dishonesty. Conveniently ignoring numbers. He normally makes good observations on the economy but here he's not being honest.

He contradicts himself so poorly. Rajan was a true genius who found himself among bunch of people who didn’t belong to his league. He was far too superior for them. But nobody understood him. I recommend watching a famous documentary “Inside Job” ; where Rajan’s detailed interview is included. Politicians like S Swamy can never understand him. They think from political perspective rather than economic perspective.

he is high on goumutra this time

Very foolish of him telling that Raghuram Rajan couldn't understand the economics a layman like me could understand. Clearly, Swamy hasn't seen the depth of the analysis that the former RBI governor posessed!

Swami is Forrest Gump of Indian Politics. It appears that every event in last 30-40 years revolved around him. He should better start gardening and Lawn care compnay.

By this logic Nirmala Sitharaman should be removed

Think about it, what a waste of true talent. Mr. Swamy, sidelined, and Ms Nirmala Sitaraman given Finance. All because he won't say, "Jee sahab ji"!!!

Dude he is from Harvard...😂😂😂

quint is dividing whole interview such that people will have only negative view about swami .I request all of you to watch full episode before making your mind,

Swamy is one brilliant Economist to Never get the post of Finance Minister

The title for this video should have been, "Great mind proves that the Earth is flat".

Plot twist : meanwhile bsc economic failed useless brains are commenting on swami...below

Raghuram Rajan is engineer basically and it's unfortunate that he left science field and went in to this man made stupidity call economics

Although I am against swamy on many matters, but on this matter, I agree fully that Rajan does not know any Economics. Recently he wrote a book, suggesting India should not put much emphasis on manufacturing instead concentrate on service sector.

There can be no bigger fool or lier than the one who says "Raghuraman Rajan isnt an economist"

Yeah theses guys so knowledgeable about economics such you can judge them by the state of economics now!!

Piss off Raghu Ram Rajan predict the Recession and he was called a luddite for that , then look what happened ........if Recession is not predicted by an economist then who???

True swami ji is , mathematics major , done stats major , and is PhD in economics , that pretty much says he is very qualified to make these statements , raghuram rajan is just mad that he was put aside and that's whay he is all opposite

Look who's talking of UNEMPLOYMENT 😅 Sir aap UNEMPLOYMENT k bare main baat naa hi kare toh acha hai, today's all time high unemployment rate is very much enought to prove whose policies were worth following & about Raghuram Rajan Sir toh his presence in the race for the post of Governor of Bank of England proved his mettle & about Manmohan Singh, stop defaming a person who believed in dids rather than throwing some insane talks... You're staining a person whose actions during the recession are admired by the world today.

Raghuram is not an economist that's why IMF was planning to appoint him as chief.

He is a modern day Chanakya, there is no doubt. Once in a 1000 years people like him get birth on this earth.

Raghu rajan is teaching economics in Chicago university n this gobar minded bhakt is saying he is not an economist hahaha 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

2:20 everything happened the same, SME Businesses died, Unemployment is still rising @ 6 percent, But the economy is growing as per our govt.... I'm confused... either all the above things are wrong or the stats provided by govt is wrong..

He was an engineering student. His IQ is high . Now mixed up with economics. But India required professional economist like Manmohan Singh. Lots of engineering student joining bank as they couldn't get engineering jobs. Total wastage of human resources.🙄 You can't learn things in depth only by learning quizzes. Half knowledge is most dangerous

he is very right... he should have been the finance minister long time back

Rajan was the worst RBI governor we ever had......

I am not sure, why his own party would not make him a finance minister or even a deputy Fm?

Epic Samples of Dr. Swamy : 22 June 2018: "Manmohan Singh took my credits, I made the roadmap" 22 June 2018: "Raghuram Rajan was not an Economist" 16 September 2018: "Arun Jaitely ko Economics nahi aati" November 2018: "Shaktikanta Das did corruption during demonetization" 5 August 2019: "Swamy lost to Mr. Jethmalani"................... Whom are you trying to teach sir? every among these 4 has shown iconic performances and thus been rewarded with achievements. Well, he always proves his incompetency with his statements.

He was the brains behind 91 reforms, biggest claimed achievement, and now quint discrediting him, the day he becomes FM india will shoot towards 10%+ growth

BJP think that they are world class intelligent in economy 😁