@@historiasdeinternet569 Umm, it is real. Was played during two shows in 2009 but then dropped from the set. You can hear crowd singing the last line of the bridge.
Rosenrot was the song wich introduced me to Rammstein around 2006 (born in 2001), since that moment, R+ was my favourite band. I really hope that we can experience this masterpiece in the 2024 tour!❤️🔥
@@historiasdeinternet569 inicio de la gira 2009, hay poca información, puedes saber de esto en el video, "el LIFAD TOUR" de inder dunker heilt, también tocaron Main Leid en los conciertos de prueba, o también buscando en el mismo canal 25 curiosidades del álbum Rosenrot
In my opinion this is real for two facts, first there is a bass riff repetition after the chorus, no vocals (in the studio version it starts with voice), second that's the snare (i think) live sound. In conclusion i think that's legit and it is awesome. (hope my english wasn't bad)
this is most definitely real audio, where would there be audio of an audience chanting the prechorus cut in without a clear disturbance of audio quality? the only other live performances are done by tribute bands with obviously lower quality sound. Also the tone coming from till sounds raw and performed, not like the studio vocals being reverbed
you can literally hear people scream “was sie will bekommt sie auch” before the chorus. doing about 30 minutes of research i found that they did perform it ONCE live in Berlin.
You can clearly hear this is the studio version with added effects and crowd noice. It's for a project titled "The impossible concert". Sadly not real.
@@bllainerr927 hahahaha nope, the people are fake. This is easy to do in audacity, but there are many more complex softwares out there to get fun. Isn't too hard
@@aschezu_asche пытаюсь скинуть ссылку но она удаляется, но про 2009 можно узнать но одном сайте где есть все сетлисты, а про 2016 есть одно фото с сетлистом репетиции и там была Rosenrot
Oh, what a cheap hoax that is. Firstly, Till's singing is taken from the studio version. It just sounds so identical. Secondly, anyone could record a live full band cover of this song and then mix the recording with Till's vocals. And the crowd's cheering is also fake. Rosenrot was never on a live show setlist. Rammstein did perform the song a couple of times at exclusive rehearsal \ pilot pretour shows for LIFAD community members. So, no big crowd whatsoever. Just a bunch of lucky fans who'd won the invitations. With this being said, the crowd we hear roars full blast. It must be several thousands of people to say the least. A small crowd would never generate such a massive noise. Period. So, folks, don't let yourselves get pulled a fast one.