Sorry but Giselle is a much better rapper who actually writes her own rap, lisa is not a rapper and will not be considered a rapper ever, talking fast with one single rythem in your whole career will not make you a rapper
@@eulalia3468 I know you dislike Lisa. But please check whether your information is right. Because Because Lisa WROTE her RAP PARTS IN bp songs. Some of which are Sure thing, So Hot, Love to Hate Me, etc. If you want proof, Google is free, search it by yourself. So stop exaggerating that you know everything. In terms of Technique and Speed Lisa is definitely better than Giselle. And even Lisa can write her rap parts
@@kavitha.r9260 omg you do realise that rap isn't about speed and fast talking, it's about rythem and delivery and agility, you do realise that by professional Giselle is classified as one of the best rappers this generation and her rank is above lisa, because lisa is not a rapper, please check your information before typing because techniques are very important in everything and Giselle has much better techniques
@@eulalia3468 Omg 😱 Neither I nor you are rappers here. So stop praising yourself that you know everything. Even some Professional rappers considered Lisa Rap as the best for her delivery. You mentioned "DELIVERY, RHYTHM" right. Then listen Lisa is known for her best Delivery and Rhythm, not for so called speed. Ok
@@Unforgettxble__ not only foot tier decides who is good dancer . All body control must be imp If we see Jennie , ningning, Giselle they have great tier. But body control , flexibility , flawless movements , hips control and dancing on point and along the beats . This all qualities are in rosé more than those three . I'm also dancer . So only tier can't decide who is better . All body movements must be imp and on point and rosé Know how to do it.
@@eulalia3468 I know you dislike Lisa. But please check whether your information is right. Because Because Lisa WROTE her RAP PARTS IN bp songs. Some of which are Sure thing, So Hot, Love to Hate Me, etc. If you want proof, Google is free, search it by yourself. So stop exaggerating that you know everything. In terms of Technique and Speed Lisa is definitely better than Giselle. And even Lisa can write her rap parts
@@everyxtime There is no such thing as C-. Karina and Giselle are closer to average tier by gap. Even if we ignore tiers, they're less nasal and throaty when they're singing in comparison to Rosé. They're also more relaxed in their mix and they support it better, their lows have better quality.
Yes Rosé rapping speed is 6.33 with 8/10 flow so she is probably a 5th or 6th in rap and she has a high tone too Jisoo is better in vocals than Lisa but in this vifeo everything is based on speed and open style and all But Jisoo and Lisa interchargeables in vocals Jisoo and Rosé interchangeable in dance
@@kalpananehete1985Rap is Correct bcuz Jennie is the best rapper among them who has the best flow, delivery etc Giselle writes her own rap and also has amazing flow,clarity etc Lisa lacks clarity in her pronunciation and uses a blaccent and also has a great delivery,flow etc Karina has an amazing tone,flow etc but she still lacks something I don't know everyone lacks something I don't know Winter has an Amazing Flow and Rhythm and Ningning has a flawless delivery Jisoo lacks clarity and Rosé is a below Average rapper so the ranking will be 1) Jennie (Tier 4 rapper) = Strong 2) Giselle ( Tier 4 rapper) = Strong 3) Lisa (Tier 4 rapper)= Strong 4) Karina ( Tier 6 rapper)= Above Average 5) Winter ( Tier 7 rapper)= Average 6) Ningning ( Tier 7 rapper)= Average 7) Jisoo ( Tier 7 rapper)= Average 8) Rosé ( Below Average Rapper)= Weak Dance is based on Open Style Open Style Ranking = Overall Dancing Idol Dancing = No Valve Open Style Ranking 1) Lisa 2) Karina 3) Winter 4) Jennie 5) Ningning 6) Giselle 7) Rosé 8) Jisoo
@@ДэлгэрбуянЭнхтуяа for what ??? For telling the truth??? It's an open style dance ranking so it's obvious winter is better than rosé. If I say beyoncé is better singer than rosé does that make me a "fake blink"??
I respect your opinion but in my opinion, jennie is a better dancer as she was the second best dancer followed by lisa in her debut days but again I respect your opinion.
if you don't know before Jennie is choos to be lead dancer but she have healt isusse and just for that stupid thing rose is now lead dancer but if you look for real Jennie is better dancer why someone call her lazy she just was sick and if you same don't know jennie theach rose dance skills and i think that rose don't be that good now if Jennie don't teach her how someone can say jennie is rude she help rose with dance, lisa with korean and jisoo with english
I think Jisoo should be above Lisa in terms of vocals. She sounds much better live and Lisa has no range to speak of and a very poor sense of pitch. Just watch her "Say so" performance, it was absolutely horrible in terms of vocals.
@@WONYDIARYOFFICIALTV there's a difference btw stage presence n dance skills Sometimes winter dances even better than karina She's the perfect example of idol dancers( she has everything an idol dancer requires - angles, isolation, extension, rhythm, musicality but what she lacks is dynamics n if she improve it then she'll be even better than karina)
@@blink_____jenniequeen6670 Rosé is a really nice lead dancer. She can actually easily become a main dancer in non-dance based groups like aespa. To me she is even better than Karina (the main dancer in aespa). Her dynamics are really good and she is a carefree dancers which dances with emotions, which is a big plus point
@@WONYDIARYOFFICIALTV it's true rosé dynamics are better than winter but she lacks in all other techniques. She's not even better than winter so passing karina is a big no. Rosé has weak musicality, her body lines are not perfect, sometimes she overextend her mover sometimes she under dances and also she's very inconsistent with her techniques maybe becuz big hiatus btw cb. Karina has better isolation, footwork, consistency, better extension, better angles n better dynamics n core strength but she's sometimes stiff near torso region( so rosé wins in this category) but overall considering all techniques it's karina > winter > rosé See it's not my opinion but objective ranking. I prefer rosé dancing but it doesn't make her better than karina or winter
100% Correct but let me change Stage Presence (IMO) Jennie Lisa Rose Ningning Giselle Jisoo/Karina Winter Updated :- Jennie Lisa Rose Ningning/Karina Giselle Winter/Jisoo
Lawak lo, bikin konten tapi gak sesuai fakta Opini sih opini tapi ini udah keterlaluan Rosé udah naik vocal nya btw Dance rosé itu harusnya no 3 atau 2 Rapper rosé lebih bagus dari ningning Dan rapper jisoo lebih bagus dari winter STAN ya? Gak heran sih Vocal rosé (D+/C-)
TRUE ONE IS 👇👇 vocal 1NING2 2WINTER ROSÉ C- 3KARINA 4GIS 5JENNIE 6JISOO 7LISA DANCE 1LISA 2KARINA 3ROSÉ 4WINTER 5JENNIE NING2 6GESOO no hate i just say the truth and not biassed and i just talking about dance and vocal bc she is i think just MY
@STAY WATERMELLON 🍉 I'd say Lisa 1st, she does slightly better in BP in non written verses and her written verse(Say so) is much better than Jennie's written ones. Also this comment was made 2 days before gugsu said that Lisa>Giselle
So biased, so now jisoo whom can't even support is better than karina and Giselle who both are D+ vocalists same as rosé ??? Who also have better techniques than rosé? Lol Lol wtf? Ningning and winter are much better dancers than jisoo and rosé, you ok? Giselle is better than jisoo, what, you dare to put Ningning below jisoo??? Hhhhhhh what a joke Pffffff again Ningning and winter are much better rappers than jisoo, are you ok?
@@eulalia3468 nah be for real, we know that ningning & winter is better vocalist than jisoo, but jisoo can easily outrapped both of them LMAO so how ningning & winter is better rapper than jisoo?
#Vocal Ningning Winter Giselle Rose Karina Jennie Jisoo Lisa #Rap JENNIE Lisa Giselle Karina Jisoo Winter Rose Ningning #Dance Lisa Karina Rose Winter Ningning Jennie Jisoo Giselle #Sp Lisa Jennie Rose Jisoo Ningning Karina Winter Giselle
Ningning might be better than Rose in Vocals but putting the whole group before BLACKPINK is just nonsense, Rose should ranked 2nd (the golden voice of Korea) in my opinion (don’t hate pls)
No hate but i only liked your stage presence ❤ In vocal it will be +Reason NingNing's tier is C+, Winter's is C Karina and Giselle's are D. Rosé tiers C like C+Or C- Now do you think you put them in fair it would be - 1.Ningning ❤ 2.Winter/Rosé ❤ 3.Karina ❤ 4.Giselle❤ 5.Jennie as she is E+/E-❤ 6.Jisoo F+/F-❤ 7.Lisa F-❤ Rap - 1.Jennie as she is main rapper her rap is D4,Pre -debut and Bombayah,Solo and much more. is epic ❤ 2.Lisa her rap in lalisa and pretty savage ❤ 3.Giselle main rapper for reason ❤ 4 Karina .Lead rapper for reason ❤ 5.Jisoo as she is outstanding sub-rapper she shocked whole kpop her good rap in HWLT,Shut down and Pretty savage ❤ 6.Winter a devloped well rapper❤ 7.Rosé as she is improving a lot and did much better than past we can see she can rap lead rapper parts too very well❤ 8.Ning ning last but not the least she is also practicing very well and soon will be good too ❤ Dance -Maybe correct ❤ Sp-Perfect ❤ Pls reply me if u agree with this or not and give reason so i can have knowledge if i am wrong if you ignore it will show that you did it in biased Though amazing editing videos❤
Sorry but what Giselle and ningning dance? Over rosé? Technically Giselle also has stiff in her torso and poor coordination but her isolation getting improved her musically in dance is not so good her locks may be inconsistent while ningning her isolation is nice but her ability is need to be develop armlock is kinda stiff While rosé her musicality is much better her torso is consistent, isolation, but her locks is kinda over powering and may lead to getting stiff her Technically rosé is Better in dance than the two not being biased based on what I saw on their dance recently
The fact that it's an updated version n Giselle has improved a lot n u can see it in her cover danc vid. She has better extension, rhythm n isolation than rosé.
@@blink_____jenniequeen6670 isolation?what she's even stiff in torso how come on isolation Well Gisele improve but also she can't even executive some details Rosé has good coordination and control...and even in fluidity rosé is way better than Giselle especially in musicality it is just that sometimes her footwork may getting unbalanced Extension maybe both of them has nice extension I agree with that And the mobility they are both weak in that
1) Ningning C+ does not present resonance, possibly down to C due to its light mix 2) Winter C 3) Giselle D+ his support is more consistent, it is not as messy with Karina's, she has a connected head voice 4) Karina D+ 5) Rosé D his support is shallow, larynx rises from A4, his Bb4s aren't consistent all the time, B4s were only in their prime years ago, he doesn't have a low register of a C- 6) Jennie E- rarely shows support, too throaty, pushes a lot 7) Jisoo F+ she is stylistic, she sings pure with her throat which blocks her support and push a lot 8) Lisa
@@reinaldolemus169lol Rosé,Jennie improved. Rosé consistent A4/Bb4/B4 tier High' D+/C- Jennie consistent G#4/A4s E+/D- And Jisoo maybe E- and Lisa HighF+ and don't forget Lisa support F5 with upper register.
Vocal Ning Ning Rose Winter Jisoo Karina Jennie Giselle Lisa Rep Jennie Giselle Lisa Karina Winter Ning Ning Jisoo Rose Dance Lisa Karina Winter Rose Ning Ning Giselle Jennie Jisoo
@@anniebananie8095 It’s not about tiers, or vocal range. It’s about tone and speciality in ur voice. Rosé has emotion in her voice. Those girls have average, copy and pasted tones with no emotion in their voice. Just because rosé doesn’t have a higher tier DOESNT mean she’s main vocalist for no reason.
@@anniebananie8095 What? That's cap, Giselle, Karina and Rosé are all "D+", but some people even consider Rosé's a "C-" due to her supporting B4's, but still she's a "D+" due to her B4's being shallow.
Almost everything is wrong how Giselle can be better in rap than Lisa ? Rosè should be 2 in dance and 2 in vocal now people can be mad at me cause I gave Rosè 2 in vocals but Rosè has angelic vocals trust me Rosè and Ningning has a bit different in vocals and Jisoo should be 5 in sp and Karina is better in sp than Ningning and Jennie has better sp than Rosie but I am sorry because I am comparing idols a true kpop stan shouldn't compare their idols and btw my biases are Rosè and Ningning ❤ I love all idols but I have compared them it's not good to compare them they are perfect in their ways ❤
Someone just ranking idol based on bias,maybe ad likes aespa more than BP so ad didnt give us the right ranking,some part of this video were wrong and it made lots of pp get BP or Aespa wrong
Honestly I dislike Jisoo's sp cause I didn't see it much😭 it's just rosé Lisa and Jennie beside her that's why u gonna think she's so good at sp too.... Sorry...
