Well, it's like, you can't rate a new monster as a good thing because they'll tell you it's the new monster syndrome. So why even rate it in general? For that, wait a week or so to rate.
My ranking (With reasons and colors) 🟩14. X’rt (Not garbage, but barely gets any time to play) 🟩13. Piplash (At least plays more, makes the song funky) 🟩12. Nitebear (He only plays on the outro, but was able to make the outro more sad) 🟩11. Teeter-Tauter (It’s a good monster, but these guys BROKE my heart. I thought it was a xylophone but instead we got this) 🟩10. Meebkin (It’s a good support monster but gets drowned out) 🟦9. Blarret (Good sound, helps with the song) 🟦8. Whaill (GLORY!!! Whaill has been underused for a long time, but the second track is finally here! I feel like this track makes the outro more sad. And the fact that every workshop monster plays in that part…) 🟦7. Flasque (It’s a unique sound and a great contribution to the song. The song is not empty if you remove Flasque, but if Flasque is there it will sound amazing) 🟨6. Rhysmuth (The rest are already gold. I didn’t expect the design to be like this, but I didn’t expect even more for this to be a drum. Anyways it’s very good, adds beat drops to the song) 🟨5. Auglur (Good monster, good design, good sound, good contribution. Auglur carries the outro) 🟨4. Gaddzooks (It’s the backbone of this island, but more percussion getting added makes Gaddzooks less special) 🟨3. Yooreek (I don’t really care if anyone says Yooreek is annoying or repetitive. Yooreek is the catchiest monster on this island and carries the vocals) 🟨2. Pentumbra (Very creative idea for a monster. The shadow looks cute for some reason, and compliments other monsters very well. I like how Pentumbra also mimics a monster outside its terrain) 🟨1. Vhenshun (Y’all may have saw that Vhenshun was the best ever since wave 3, and he still is. The design resembles mech very well, and the sound is very good and creative. I don’t really care about anyone saying Vhenshun is overrated, because overrated doesn’t mean bad)
1: Gadzooks 🟨 2: Whaill 🟦 3: Pentumbra 🟦 4: Auglur 🟦 5: Rhysmuth 🟦 6: Teeter-Tauter 🟩 7: Vhenshun 🟩 8: Flasque 🟩 9: Blarret 🟩 10: Yooreek 🟩 11: Piplash 🟩 12: Meebkin 🟩 13: X'rt 🟥 14: Nitebear 🟥 might be a bit scuffed but going around and changing the ranks when i remembered about some monsters was a pain
Here is my tierlist 1:The god of angry birds 2:minecraft blocks 3:whale 4:kinito pet and pou 5:workshop 6:yeerook 7:Blue giraffe 3 bfdi mouth 8:patrick + drums 9:tater-tots 10:meebking 11:cool guy 12:moon green orange farting 13:green potions 14:freddy
My ranking: 👑1. Gaddzooks, best ethereal workshop monster no questions asked (10/10) 🟨2. Pentumbra, the main vocal and the design is genius (9.7/10) 🟨3. Venshun, we got a workshop in ethereal workshop (9.6/10) 🟨4. Yooreek, the sound is very catchy to be honest (9.4/10) 🟨5. Auglur, the synth is amazing (9.2/10) 🟦6. Rhysmuth, the sound is unique and the design looks like something from Minecraft (8.8/10) 🟦7. Whaill, the first track is great and I am really glad that the second track is now being used (8.6/10) 🟦8. Flasque, the sound is unique and makes some good transitions (8.4/10) 🟦9. Blarret, helps a lot in the song (8/10) 🟩10. Teeter tauter, cute monster nothing else to say (7.5/10) 🟩11. Nitebear, makes the ending more sad (7.2/10) 🟩12. Piplash, sorry piplash fans but he is not the best monster but his sound is good (7/10) 🟩13. Meebkin, my opinion changed on him, he is now quiet (6/10) 🟩14. X'rt, kinda grown on me but still doesn't add much (5/10)
My ranking here my rules (🟩=good+better) (🟨=neutrals dont changing song at all) (🟥bad+worst) 🟩1st.Pentumbra 🟩2nd.Yooreek 🟩3rd.X'rt 🟨4th.Vhenshun 🟨5th.Flasque ill do update later will be reasons and more monster Were missing: (Meebkin Blarret Auglur Gaddzooks Nitebear Whaill Piplash Tooter Minecraft Oddigity and bemeebeth)
My opinion: 14. X'rt 🟩 - being at the bottom of the list, still adds to the song and doesn't ruin it, but other monsters are way better, plus it doesn't play that much 13. Nitebear 🟩- same as X'rt, but at least it helps better at the final verse 12. Piplash 🟩- barely audible in the final verse, though does good in the Auglur verse 11. Teeter-Tauter 🟦- adds a bit to the song, but it's easy to hear and plays through (i think) all verses 10. Meebkin 🟨- already yellow.., i am sorry but all workshop monsters are so good, song feels incomplete without even one of them.. I think it's very underrated, but i believe it's the backbone of transitions, especially from the first verse to Whaill's verse.. the pause with meebkin soloing for a bit just feels so good 9. Blarret 🟨- Blarret is a great substitute for Yoreek, and I think the second track is unique 8. Whaill 🟨- Great, carries their verse and feels empty without them in their parts 7. Flasque 🟨- very hard to describe how good Flasque is, but he helps change the song in some way 6. Rhysmuth 🟨- who knew a minecraft quartz beacon with gold blocks could carry the entire song? i swear, from now, without these monsters the song feels empty. complements Meebkin, carries the Whaill verse, makes the song feel "mechanical" but not as mechanical as Vhenshun, just complements it 5. Auglur 🟨- carries its ENTIRE verse, and the song feels sad in a good way at the final verse with Auglur 4. Yooreek 🟨- been here from the start, still one of the best vocalists in the island. i get it can be repetitive, but is the intro of the song alive without Yooreek? the synth effect for some reason is very satisfying and track 2 in the climax of the song is something i can't forget.. track 3 helps with the beat drop too. 3. Gaddzooks 🥉- Originally supposed to be number 1, but with the addition of Rhysmuth, it's hard to hear Gaddzooks in the final verse. still carries the intro, but it's getting drowned out more. still the 2nd best percussionist in the island in my opinion 2. Pentumbra 🥈- the most mysterious monster in the island is still one of the best. first of all, i know many hate the Mimic because Mimic chose Gobbleygourd out of all the monsters to mimic in the fire island, but the monsters Pentumbra mimics are very good. First, it mimics Yooreek, which already carries the island, THEN IT MIMICS MONSTER FROM OTHER ISLANDS. Geoode themself already carries water and ethereal island, and Pentumbra mimicking them is just an unfair advantage. easily the best vocalist. 1. Vhenshun 👑- spotlight of the song. best percussionist in the workshop in my opinion. many parts don't feel as good as it is without Vhenshun alone. i have a good taste on mechanical or industrial stuff, and that makes Vhenshun even better for me. it makes the song feel crowded at times.. what i like so much is that Vhenshun isn't making music, rather it's just working.. hear me, if you aren't an MSM player and didn't see the monster, you'd think it's just factory sounds.. that's what i like so much. i'm sure you don't understand me, but i just like it so much.
Here's an unpopular opinion, (I guess). The non-plasma triples on EW all kinda suck when compared to the others, here's my arguments: Nitebear: Nitebear's sound is all sad but he gives more impact to the Last verse, we all got used to it by now, but when compared to the plasma triples, he's kinda mid Piplash: Piplash (in my opinion) is really bad, all that carries him is his charisma and design, I have a kind of beef with him, once I first saw him on the trailer I thought we was gonna be a Jaw Harp, (since that's an instrument that I really wanted on the game), but then he's just...weird guitar noises? Not even all that good? Just to fill up some space? Honestly...I'd even rate X'rt higher then him, and speaking of which X'rt: He's uhh...odd...his sound doesn't really helps or ruins the song, it's just noise, he adds a nice little baseline, and he's good for transitions, but also he ugly, VERY ugly, which honestly fits the theme of the island, good job X'rt for at least trying to do something Teeter-Tauter: Back when they were just leaks, I tried to avoid 'em, but once I gave up and looked at them, I got all hoped up since they were clearly going to be instrumental, I mean...look at the purple guy's legs! He be stomping! And now look at the Yellow guy's one and also the purple one's head, that's clearly a Quibble/Tiawa sounding individual...or at least that's what I thought, because now they just bark and do YIPEE noises...meh :l Now that the new verse's here, they all got a bit more of time to shine, Piplash actually does something now, Nitebear makes the ending much better, Tooty-Fruity exists and X'rt is X'rt, no commentary, but still, when compared to the og 5 (+ Flasque), they're still...kinda meh, and I'm a little worried that the Poison Quad will go the same path, but I bet that they'll do something with 'em So in conclusion: Have the Plasma element if you wanna sound good (on Ethereal Workshop, Ethereal Island is diferent, also Piplash sucks, ACCEPT X'RT SUPREMACY), Thank you for reading, and have a Nice day and remember, this is only my opinion, not facts, I am not a god (yet),
1.MeebKING👑 2.Vhenshun🟨 3.Yooreek🟦 3.Pentumbra🟦 5.Rhysmuth🟦 6.Teeter-Tauter🟦 7.Flasque🟦 8.Whaill🟦 9.Gaddzooks🟦 10.Auglur🟦 11.Blarret🟦 12.X'rt🟦 13.Nitebear🟦 14.Piplash🟩 Ik they are mostly blue but all the workshop monsters are really solid.
My ranking list: 1.gadzooks.(tbh this really carries.) 2.petumbra(is really good to listen to.) 3.vhenshun(kinda overrated but is still pretty good.) 4.Teeter-Tauter(I know everyone hates the sound, but I personally love it, it’s kinda cute in my eyes,also having two monsters in one is still a neat thing.) 5.nitebear(does anyone hear that weird SpongeBob sound effect?) 6.Auglur(it’s kinda the one who is making it cool.) 7.Whail (dude the secret track is out!) 8.yooreek (kinda repetitive.) 9.flasque(metal pipe sound effect.) 10.Rhysmuth(a new percussionist.) 11.blarret(kinda cute but still worse yooreek.) 12.meebkin(probably won’t be heard in the next wave.) 13.X’rt(let’s go, pears.) 14.piplash(kinda bad but atleast gets more parts to play.)
Mine: Red Tier 🟥 14th: Teeter-Tauter 🦾💎☣️: Honestly, who taught it was a good idea put THESE things in the island, they DO NOT WORK OR FIT WITH THE THEME OF THE SONG, they have a annoying sound, a design that doesn't even fit the instability or what it is, and let me remind you that THIS IS THE LAST AND MOST UNSTABLE TRIPLE, and THAT'S WHAT YOU GET AS A REWARD!? EVEN X'RT IS A BETTER CANDIDATE AS THE FINAL TRIPLE, that's how bad of an addition this monster is. Green Tier 🟩: 13th: Meebkin ⭐️👥💎: Yeah... this was definitely a barebones monster, especially for one released at the beginning of the song's release, the first track is fine though the second track is nearly useless expect for that first Whaill verse or something, yeah... it definitely cannot keep up with the other monsters, and if not Teeter-Tauter being an absolute disappointment to conclude the triples for Ethereal Workshop, it would have remained last, but just mid and not bad. 12th: X'rt 👥💎☣️: Yeah... the monster is... questionable, at first glance it sounded odd and felt out of place, but the more i listened to the song, the more i got used to it and the more it fits, it is a interesting concept and works way better than i thought in the song, the others are considerably better compared to X'rt, but hey, better something to play with Yooreek than nothing else, I guess. 11th: Piplash 👥🦾☣️: Alright, at first release, Piplash felt really off, especially at the verse it played in, though i got more used it as i listen to the song more, and the extension of the song made Piplash better, but not enough to get anywhere the top 10. Blue Tier 🟦 10th: Blarret ⭐️👥☣️: Kinda sad how much Blarret dropped, i once considered it to be one of my favourites from Ethereal Workshop at day 1, but now it is at the bottom of the top 10, Blarret rarely plays much in the song and is just overshadowed compared to other monsters, it at least is still great though. 9th: Flasque ⭐️💎☣️: Yeah... i was harsh to Flasque when it first released, where i compared it to Gadzooks for both being percussionists (Meebkin was out of the question), but i later realised that as time went on they were used for different purposes, and that Flasque actually adds a lot to the song, especially where it actually makes the first Whaill verse catchier at the second half of it. 8th: Yooreek ⭐️👥🦾: Once the staple of the song... your right with how it gets repetitive and such, but it's verses wouldn't be anything without it and i respect it for being the main beat at it's verses. 7th: Nitebear 👥🦾💎: A severely underrated monster, it was a great monster from the day it was released, it actually improved the original ending verse than worsening it by what others say. The extension of the song also makes Nitebear higher as it helps in these verses too. 6th: Whaill ⭐️👥🦾💎: If not for the extension and the secret track, it would have been way lower than it is due to how little it played in the song, but with the extension now real along with the secret track, it CARRIES that end like a champ! But it isn't in the top 5 because of how little it plays, it plays only twice, IN THE ENTIRE SONG EVEN WITH THE EXTENSION! But at least they didn't waste the opportunity so i respect that. Yellow Tier 🟨: 5th: Pentumbra ⭐️👥💎☣️: It indeed helps ALOT whenever it plays, it is basically an Ethereal Mimic of some sorts that can also mimic instrumentals, and it's design is clever that the shadow is alive for Pentumbra, it is really creative and makes it's title of Shadow Quad really cool too. 4th: Vhenshun ⭐️👥🦾☣️: This Mech Quad is literally a workshop inside THE Workshop, it adds some nice secondary percussion and it's use of construction tools as instruments is really cool and creative, though it only plays when Gadzooks is playing, i kinda wish it has some time to shine as the the only percussionist than to be a layer for Gadzooks, it still is fire either way. 3rd: Rhysmuth ⭐️🦾💎☣️: I think that having an absolutely awful triple might be compensated for an AMAZING QUAD! It really livens up the verses it plays in and makes for some SICK TRANSITIONS! Easily the best quad in the island so far, even moreso than the other three. 2nd: Auglur ⭐️🦾☣️: Auglur was definitely declining throughout the waves, if not for the extension, it would have been just Blue Tier and not Yellow Tier, that extension really gave Auglur time to shine, which is food as it was once my favourite monster in the island, though it isn't anymore due to being more stale compared to the number 1 pick, but still awesome sounding. Crown Tier 👑: 1st: Gadzooks ⭐️🦾💎: To be completely honest, if not for the second track (the one from the sneak peaks, not the Auglur's verse one), it might not have even reached number 1, but now it makes the first Whaill verse a BOP! It also adds alot to the extension too! From being one of the worse monsters in Ethereal Workshop, then to one of the best and THEN the best, Gadzooks takes the title of best Ethereal Workshop monster as of now. In conclusion: Ethereal Workshop is a great island, sure, there are just a few below average monsters (and Teeter-Tauter being an absolute disappointment of a addition), it still holds up with AMAZING additions during the song's time in being updated, this gives me high hopes for how the Poison Quad and a potential Ethereal Quint impact the song...
Here's my ranking 1. (Best) Gadzooks- the song would be nothing without him 2. (G.O.A.T.) Auglur- auglur sounds angelic and carries each verse they are in 3. (Great) Yooreek- repetitive but he is the main singer and is pretty much needed for ethereal workshop (although he doesn't fit in the final verse but that is a problem for the other monsters as well) 4. (Great) Petumbra- I love his design and sound 5. (Great) blarret- duets well with yooreek and sound great in the last verse (well at least his second track) 6. (Great) Whail- introduced a great verse with a heavenly track 2 7.(not bad) Rhysmuth- it's a cool percussion but kinda too loud 8. (Not bad) Meebkin- it's kinda suddle but adds still adds to the song 9. (Not bad) flasque- extremely overrated, he creat a nice beat but he is so sudden 10. (Not bad) Vhenshun- also extremely overrated, he just sounds like a background filler noise than anything else 11.(Not bad) Fred- I meant Nitebear- adds a little bit to the auglur verses but overall nothing special here folks 12.(Bad) Teeter-tauter- OVERRATED AS HECK, he just sounds like someone just excercising in the song rather trying to add something in the song AND HE GETS PLACED ABOVE BLARRET JUST BECAUSE HE IS CUTE?! when I like monster it's because of how it plays in the song, not its looks. 13. (Bad) Piplash- he exists 14. (Cardinal sin) X'rt- WHAT THE HECK IS THIS THING, AND ACK ITS SOUND!! EASIELY ONE OF THE WORST MONSTERS IN THE GAME!!
So I'm not gonna make a whole list because I am already really indecisive and can't choose favorites, but I wanna rant about a couple of monsters here for no reason. First, I think Vhenshun is way overrated in terms of the actual song. I think it is a really good monster that is incredibly creative, and it certainly does add something to the workshop that no other monster could, but I simply don't get why so many people put them so high. I would say that both Vhenshun and Flasque are quite similar in the feel they add to the song, but I never notice Vhenshun when I listen to it compared to how Flasque easily is a highlight in some of its parts. I can't see the song without Vhenshun in it, but I don't think it deserves to be as high in rankings as most put it. Second, Meebkin never gets the love it truly deserves. While I can definitely see how Meebkin gets a little pushed out of the song due to the layering of so many monsters, its part is literally integral to song. For instance, in its first track, those sections require its contribution in the background to help the song flow through its parts. Its second track is even more important though, and mainly to Whaills first verse. Without meebkin, the song is literally silent for the first period, which can be a little jarring to say the least. The last monster I wanna say something about it Piplash. I think Piplash is a really nice monster and its inclusion feels really interesting in the song, but its like impossible to hear them. I can have piplash in the middle of my island and zoomed in, but it is still a bit hard to hear them. Anyways, sorry for ranting in this comment section. If you disagree with any of my points I'd love hear why because other people's viewpoints are always really interesting to me.
While rhysmuth was being ranked*to stick to the topic I said that*I realized he has no dark element, and dark is cold and water island*the island with crystal*doesn’t have cold and kf you translate dark to to natural you get cold! So this is the first quad that matched up with its islands quad alement!
My ranking: 🟥= Garbage 🟩= Their okay🟦= pretty good🟧=Awesome 👑= The Goat. Also I included the castle bass 1: Castle Bass 👑 I’m sorry I just had to include it, without the castle, NOTHING IN WORKSHOP IS GOOD. THE ENTIRE CASTLE BASS ALWAYS PLAYS AND ALWAYS WILL STAY SUPREME. 1: Gaddzooks 👑 He absolutely carries this island, without him the song is basically “empty” and there is no more of that kick toward the song 2: Rhysmuth 🟦 On top of there with the percussionists, Flasque and Vhenshun, I especially love their design and like how their egg and name are inspired by bismuth crystals. 3: Pentumbra 🟦 Pentumbra is just a lil’ guy :D their inclusion in the ending was really nice, especially the 3rd track 4: Vhenshun 🟦 This was where it was at, Vhenshun was always not only the mech boss but THE top boss 5: Auglur 🟦 Auglur is extremely good, their ability to provide a completely different mood toward workshop still baffles me 6: Flasque 🟩 Used to absolutely carry the island along with Gaddzooks and Vhenshun, however he just got more quite the more monsters added 7: Whaill 🟩Whaill made me so happy the unreleased track came after 6 months, only to play in a single section. If it could have a bit more build up toward that mashup of everybody then would be good, also give us more monsters to fade out instead of all of them, please BBB. 8: Yooreek🟩 The craziness in the final verse is amazing! Duetted nicely with Blarret but there are others that come before it 9: Blarret 🟩 Blarrets pretty good not the best but he is a nice ending to the song 10: Piplash 🟩 The best of the four without plasma, but is pretty far down the list. At least it got a bit more time to shine 11: Meebkin 🟩 Used to be the top but got drowned out by all the monsters on the island. If the islands song was longer and had longer verses that could expand the song he would be ranked higher 12: Nitebear 🟥 It’s just an overall small comparison to the other monsters since so many have these loud contrasting different from the song and then there’s just depression 13: Teeter-Tauter 🟥 I don’t care what you say. I do not like this monster at all. I hate its sound, somewhat like its design and that the only reason it’s in 13th 14: X’rt 🟥 This is just a wasted monster
@@EMMR0228I agree man, this ranking is tbh kinda bad. I mean teeter-tauter is a good monster, it even makes the yippee sound.Its too cute for me.Who ever made this ranking should go burn.
@@Your_Average_Bulbasaur_PlushMy ranking: 🟥= Garbage 🟩= Their okay🟦= pretty good 👑= The Goat. Also I included the castle bass 1: Castle Bass 👑 I’m sorry I just had to include it, without the castle, NOTHING IN WORKSHOP IS GOOD. THE ENTIRE CASTLE BASS ALWAYS PLAYS AND ALWAYS WILL STAY SUPREME. 1: Gaddzooks 👑 He absolutely carries this island, without him the song is basically “empty” and there is no more of that kick toward the song 2: Rhysmuth 🟦 On top of there with the percussionists, Flasque and Vhenshun, I especially love their design and like how their egg and name are inspired by bismuth crystals. 3: Pentumbra 🟦 Pentumbra is just a lil’ guy :D their inclusion in the ending was really nice, especially the 3rd track 4: Vhenshun 🟦 This was where it was at, Vhenshun was always not only the mech boss but THE top boss 5: Auglur 🟦 Auglur is extremely good, their ability to provide a completely different mood toward workshop still baffles me 6: Flasque 🟩 Used to absolutely carry the island along with Gaddzooks and Vhenshun, however he just got more quite the more monsters added 7: Whaill 🟩Whaill made me so happy the unreleased track came after 6 months, only to play in a single section. If it could have a bit more build up toward that mashup of everybody then would be good, also give us more monsters to fade out instead of all of them, please BBB. 8: Yooreek🟩 The craziness in the final verse is amazing! Duetted nicely with Blarret but there are others that come before it 9: Blarret 🟩 Blarrets pretty good not the best but he is a nice ending to the song 10: Teeter-Tauter 🟩: Listening to it after the wave has changed my mind, it’s a really goofy and fun monster so it gets bumped up a bit 11: Piplash🟩The second best of the four without plasma, but is pretty far down the list. At least it got a bit more time to shine 12: Meebkin🟥 Used to be the top but got drowned out by all the monsters on the island. If the islands song was longer and had longer verses that could expand the song he would be ranked higher 13: Nitebear🟥 It’s just an overall small comparison to the other monsters since so many have these loud contrasting different from the song and then there’s just depression 14: X’rt 🟥 This is just a wasted monster
Ranking: 1:auglur 2:gadzooks 3yoreek 4:flauque 5:rhysmuth 6:blarret 7:meebkin 8:whail 9:pentumdra 10:vhenshun (overrated but still kinda mid) 11:piplash 12:nitebear 13: teeter-tauter (i flipin hate these guys, i dont get why people love these guys its just a bunch of grunting) 14:x'rt
