Ranking RED VELVET, TWICE, BLACKPINK, ITZY, AESPA & NMIXX at VOCALS 

Even without that, she'd be on top

@You See itzy isn't a vocal group

Ningning should be B-

Itzy: Lia: E- Yeji: F+ Chaeryeong: F Yuna: F Ryujin: F-

@Rania Raninou lia is d-

@@keriahannah1250 Lia isn't D-..

Kinda weird that you put Rosé, as if she was one of the strong vocalists.... and then said "even Winter" when Ning Ning is a stronger vocalist that her. It would have made more sense to say "wow she surpassed Seulgi and Jihyo, even Ning Ning" (seriously no hate, I stan every one of them, your comment just didn't make sense to me)

​@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 I think you misunderstood what I meant, I put Winter because she is a very strong lead vocalist, so strong that she can be Main Vocal of any other group As Winter was being considered a leading vocalist I put her on because I thought that Lily is a very strong vocalist to surpass her and Ning Ning who are considered one of the best of the generation.

​@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 I didn't find anything strange in my comment, just interpret it well, that's up to each one

@@Lily-maze oh I don't disagree that Winter is a strong vocalist, but when you put "even ____" it's used for someone who is considered the strongest, which would be NingNing. So yeah you could say "she surpassed Winter, Seulgi, and even NingNing" it's much clearer and gets the point across that Lily is quite a strong vocalist. Anyways, sorry for coming for you, wasn't trying to attack you🙁

​@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 No, I'm sorry you, it was my fault, since my mistake was the grammar it's my fault yes, English is not my mother tongue, so I'm sorry

а я не агри с этим ранкин почему? потому что автор dolbaeb , он nihuya v vokale ne sharit джису лучше дженни это странно ставить дженни ниже

They are so good

Is that Black Pink? I'm not exactly a fan but it's a reality that BP don't need vocals to be famous, so maybe that's why YG don't care about vocals and care more about promotion

@@melekbasri1575 YG focus on Rap , Stage Presence and Have English Speaker.

@@kisarukurosaki1736 Oh yeah, but they also focus soo much on promotion. BP are so good but they wouldn't be that famous without promotion and marketing stuff, it's obvious

@@melekbasri1575 but I hope Baemon have D+ or C- Vocalist 🤞🤞

@@kisarukurosaki1736 Don't really know what Baemon is, but ok I hope it too

I think so too she sings with a very nasal sound so I think she does that on purpose

not just her but everyone in nmixx except the “main vocal line”, jiwoo, kyujin, and jinni sounds like they’re all holding back and can do more if given the opportunity

jiwoo actually trying to sing with that raspy type tone that's why I guess

Omce she has resonance, she pretty much got the title (Wendy herself is inconsistent with it. Taeyeon on the hand is a beast). She has a C#5 that was pretty close, but she needs to be more open and work on her vowel shaping. She is currently focusing on improving her lower register and getting a better support quality in her mid belts, so it will take her a while to get resonance, but I am sure she will end up there. The question is if she will be able to surpass Taeyeon. She has D5/Eb5 down as well, has a better lower register, consistent resonance, good dynamics, etc.

With nmixx

@@jeannedemba6120 And Red Velvet!

yess with Nmixx based on Average Nmixx : 2.83 (7/7) aespa : 2.75 (4/4) both queen vocals and in Gen4 only nmixx and Aespa already has 2.0+ point heheh

sullyoon and haewon also have beautiful vocal colour and agree rose litreally give me butterflies

@@pinksavage9470 yes ❤❤❤❤

Like literally, Rosé is really something. The girl can sing in her real and forced tone at a same song ( Rfl). I don't think so, even powerful vocals ( SM VOCALISTS, nmixx, Monday) can do this

I'm also sad because few people talk about Wendy's vocals

Wendy's vocal is just too strong and she have a good technique

i mean Lily is B and Wendy B+, so they are not that far from each other, and she's a rookie just debuting and she's improving fast, she's better than Wendy rookie already

@@luisssfer Exactly Lily can improve and same for Wendy too she can still improve too cause rv didn't disbanded yet she's still in music industry and she can do more

@@luisssfer Maybe in gen 5 lily will be B+ and wendy is in A already

@@luisssfer Im not gonna say that she is better than rookie wendy cause bruh wendy's shine on me in happiness is hard too and i saw some video where trainee Wendy is singing she's good too Lily literally reminds me of rookie Wendy

she is a e tier I thought

Actually they don't have any official positions. They were introduced as 7 vocalists-7 dancers-7 visuals. From how they're promoted and shown, I'd say Lily and Haewon are both the main vocals, Sullyoon, Kyujin, or Bae might be lead vocals, and the others are sub-vocalists even though they all can support. For dancers, there are 4 main dancer material, Kyujin is definitely a main dancer since she excels in both open style and idol dancing, Jiwoo does better or probs the best in open style so she is probably one. Jinni is also very good and from how she is promoted in mvs and performance, she is probably also one. Lastly, Haewon, she's definitely a whole package who is a main vocal and might be the best idol dancer in the group but with how much she's promoted as a vocalist, she's probably not in the dance line (she deserves to be). For the rappers, Jiwoo is definitely the/a main rapper based off her performance in their Thunderous cover. Jinni and Kyujin are probably lead rappers based off their lines in O.O. The oldest is Lily. The maknae is Kyujin. The leader is Haewon. The visual is obvs Sullyoon.

​@@coje1012 ok thanks :3

@@coje1012 when you put it that way, haewon is kinda like Jihyo, both could've been a main dancer but since they were leaders and marketed as "Vocalist" JYP refused to give them a dance position

yes I will do it someday

U can't do rank list because some of them are lack of materials.

@@kisarukurosaki1736 but at least they all can rap except i dont know haewon sullyoon jeongyeon

Gugsu, I think I was falling in love with you because I thought you were so unbiased but then you dissappointed me. And all my love is gone(in roses voice) not completely gone tho😊. I hope when you are doing the rap you put your opinion aside and do it based on facts.

@@genius_on_the_way8702 Sullyoon had rap in "Stay" cover and Haewon had in "My universe" cover. Also 7/7 nmixx had rap in their vlive karaoke,especially Lily is soooo good not being in rap line

She did not regressed. She was actually overestimated. She has tendency to get shallow in her support that's why she's a high w-a vocalist not a low average vocalist. Because to become a average vocalist (even low average) , one should be able to support consistently with consistency

@@vampiregaming9820 I agree. Some vocal ranking pages overestimated..

@@555loona2 even in loona, haseul is overestimated. Just because of her opera style head voice, she's the best vocalist....... While she barely supported her mix. hyejin, chuu and Yves are all better than her

@@vampiregaming9820 yes I agree. I think some members are overestimated in vocal ranking like haseul

@Rania Raninou nayeon too she improved in POP

Her mix is good but sometimes she becomes very light and this and her vowels stops her resonance. Haewon has the most consistent mix in Nmixx and Lily has the best head voice of 4th gen along with haseul and yunjin

@@dumbdumb1853 lilys mix is better, her C5-E5 range is just very good, but haewons G4-B4 is better

@@days3164 No Lily sometimes gets a bit light above C#5

Yeay

@@dumbdumb1853 umm no lilys mix is better than haewons don’t underestimate lily at all

I honestly thought they could be interchangeable since Wendy (in terms of range) has a better mix, but lily has a more supported head voice.

The #1 just because it's your favorite XD

Yes especially after that high note Sullyoon had in Dice

giselle is a viola and she was in a heart for more than 8 years so i think she has a better technique than karina and SM does not give her opportunities since she is already a main rapper.

They're interchangeable anyway Karina has stronger moments but has a more messier approach Meanwhile Giselle is more cleaner in her approach

They tied, Giselle and karina are in the same spot

Yes but is is true giselle is such a good vocalist back vocal in bridge of black mamba belongs to her and you can see her vocal ability in bsides

@@choiminyoung3282 This take is nearly incomprehensible to me but I guess your opinion is your opinion. Don’t get me wrong I actually think Giselle is a great singer but I’m shocked to find out anyone would put her on the same level as, let alone above someone like Nayeon,rose, karina, kyujin etc. I get liking a persons tone but skill wise they’re pretty much objectively better singers. I feel like just being massively biased toward a certain group and possibly also a certain member is the only thing that could produce this ranking. And yes I’ve heard all their bsides, I’m a fan. there’s only aespa song I don’t like actually.

@Rania Raninou she has significantly worse highs and runs and the difference is way bigger than lows and mix which is already debatable. It’s also not just Nayeon. as much as I like aespa I’m not going to kid myself, Giselle being above some of the people she’s above here is delusional. She’s noticeably the weakest vocalist in aespa, She shouldn’t even be above karina. She’s at minimum 4-6 positions too high OP is an aespa Stan account and wanted to force them all into the top 10.

I love Giselle but I agree that she shouldn't be above Nayeon at the very least and certainly not above Karina. Maybe in a few years but not now.

@Rania Raninou ah OK, thanks for explaining

How? Dahyun is way more inconsistent with her head voice, and she has a unsupported low voice. Chaeyoung isn't much better than Dahyun but she has a better supported head voice and falsetto

Yes, aespa sub vocalists is much better that some main vocalists.

@@kkinojo not

@@ab-els2522 Just because blackpink is like the most popular GG, doesn't mean they are good in vocals. Rosie is like D or D+ while Karina and Giselle are D+ to C-.

You understand that she is a main vocalist in her group only right?

She's only main in blackpink, there are many idols in kpop except rose, lisa, jisoo and jennie.

Lol embarrassed blink

rosè is a D

@@Oliver-uz1fs Isn't Jeongyeon a C

She is D+ not C-

Naur rosé is D-/D

no jisoo is better than lisa for sure

Jisoo is obv better than Lisa

guys bruh, I used to think that but it's not debatable, not only according to me, but to a lot of others.

@@ValentinaFlowers Giselle is now better than Karina. Giselle is consistent to her Bb4. While Karina sometimes inconsistent. And Giselle has a better mix

@@lol-yz2kd Giselle is not better than Karina, Karina hit B4 and G3 with support constantly, she has a better development in agility and versatility, and breath support(that's why she holds the long notes) Giselle tends to has a flat vocal! When Giselle tries to be fuller she sounds so pitchy, she doesn't sound fuller or with the same tone! She changes, meanwhile Karina keeps the same dark tone, she even sounds bolder and wider!

They could use it lol

@Amy Lebe what part of my opinion do noy understand

Me too 💀☺️

LMFAO 😭

No jisoo has not improved infact she has damaged her voice and the damage is still going on unless she gets a better vocal coach her voice will be ruined

Yes of course 👍

Well is your opinion but I don't think so, I respect your opinion, but it is something that is always said that Jisoo can break her voice and that she is going to hurt himself, well in two years he could improve, don't you think? Maybe the change has not made her grow like Rosé but she has grown and let's just wait for her comeback in September and we can decide if she improved or not. (I for one will have )

@@Feli_pampam Well it's obvious her voice is damaged she has a deep voice but she has to use unhealthy technique to sing in their songs. I hope she gets a better vocal coach and improves like she did during debut

Dahyun and Ryujin should be swapped, but other than that. Lisa vs Dahyun is debatable.

@@kokichioumasimp8508 I agree. Dahyun should definitely be higher than Ryujin. I think Lisa's mix is quite solid, it might even be better than Jisoo's

ok i changed the positions (actually dahyun has a good voice in ttt) but it don't change lisa position, now she is interchangeable with jisoo, sana or maybe yeri (isn't biased)

Lol i have to laugh how to be come too bias 😅

They provided the support ranges and all and obv this video is correct. NN and Winter are good but not better then Wendy lily haewon. Winter turns nasal and airy a lot of times and Ningning upper register is not developed like them , Ningning lower register is good but haewon’s lower register is also very great. Lily hits a A5 in nmixx debut song o.o, and Lily’s upper register is obviously much more better than Ningning. You’re being toxic and rude while you don’t even have any knowledge about Wendy lily and heawon’s skill. You’re saying the creator doesn’t know Kpop while it seems that you don’t know anyone except aespa. This channel has enough knowledge about vocals but you don’t. I also love aespa and their vocal line is great but that doesn’t mean that they’re the only best singers. You’re drunk when you’re writing it. Stop being rude when you don’t know anything.

Wendy alone is better than all the ÆSPA members💀

@@kokichioumasimp8508 I thought Blinks was delusional ...but I guest reveluv is even more ...not all dreams come true darling 😴😴😴😴 keep dreaming maybe u wake from that dream 😁

he's maybe drunk but you are dumb

@@aespathrone3845 It’s a solid fact that Wendy and Lily rank higher than Ningning, Haewon is either higher than her or on the same level but these four are definitely better than Winter

For me my own opinion vocal ranking by group 1 aespa 💜 2nmixx ❤ 3 red velvet ♥️ 4 twice ♥️ 5 black pink ♥️ 6 itzy ❤

@@cassandraadea5536 okay but for me Nmixx Lily and Haewon has a better technique than Ningning and Winter, also Sulyoon and Kyujin is better technique but Karina and Giselle are closer then last is the rest of nmixx but i not really fan of aespa esp Nmixx

Wendy is way better than IU even NingNing is better

No offense but IU is not a great vocalist tho 😅 If there's someone replacing Wendy, it's deffo not her.

*Best Vocalist In Blackpink

Yeah she good but just in blackpink

Omg what a biased opinion

Hilarious

Help

Mess up sis Wendy Lilly Ningning their vocal tier is Wendy B+ Lilly is B Ningning C+

Karina is D+ too

Karina isn't C-

I also think that way

I love Twice but straight up she got the bottom three right for vocal.

@@Oliver-uz1fs exactly

@@Oliver-uz1fs Nope Ryujin atleast has good tone Momo is last here

@@Oliver-uz1fs momo was supposed to be a rapper but jyp changed that and made her a vocalist instead so i don´t think she would have chosen to be that if she could choose for herself.

@@layh6842 momo was a better vocalist on debut anyway and then they barely even make momo rap when she’s decent.

The supported rangs is already mentioned, You're literally proving u have 0 knowledge about vocals

Rosè is not close to Giselle, Giselle is far better than Rosè, in lots of registers.

2 words:vocal technique Giselle doesn't suffer from nasality nor has she built a behavior to be as nasal unlike the people below her, she's cleaner in her mix compared to Rosé (YG's fault for giving Rosé bad training tbh)

@Loona the world Says The One Who Never Uses Her Brain👌🏻

@Loona the world Yes I'm Talking About U

From the 1st generation JYP is always above YG and only this time in the 4th generation JYP is equivalent to SM 😂 In My Opinion in Vocal : 1st GENERATIONS: 1. SM (HOT, S.E.S, BoA, Shinwa) 2.JYP (G.O.D, RAIN, Park Jinyoung) 3.YG (Big Mama) 2nd GENERATIONS: 1. SM (SNSD, Super Junior, TVXQ, Shinee, F(x)) 2.JYP (2PM, 2AM, Wonder Girls, Miss A) 3.YG (Bigbang, 2ne1) 3rd GENERATIONS: 1. SM (EXO, Red Velvet, NCT ) 2.JYP (Got7, TWICE, Day6, 15&) 3.YG (Winner, iKon, Blackpink, AKMU) 4th GENERATIONS: 1. SM & JYP equal, SM(Aespa, WayV), JYP (Stray Kids, ITZY, NiziU, NMIXX) 2. YG (Somi & Treasure)

@@muhammaddandi7242 you forgetting big mama from yg all members are around (B+ - A) they're the best vocal group ever in kpop sadly they all left yg

@@hirano5725 oh Big Mama I've heard the name but don't know from which agency

@@muhammaddandi7242 same heard of them last year and omg the vocals i think they're from 1 gen that's why they're not that well known

@@hirano5725 i wouldn't consider Big mama comparable to idol groups. All of the Big Mama members were already trained chorus singers before they were joined into the group, so there isn't much that YG did in terms of raising them vocally.

Jisoo can't

Rosé has too many shallow momments to be considered C-, jisoo just doesnt support and jennie is E-

Jisoo's supported range?

@@chewieqtpie Jennie is now E

Jennie is inconsistent, jisoo does not support at all. And rosé is D-/D stop the cap🧢

I think you should learn more about vocal ranges and support, coz your comment made absolutely no sense lmao

Seulgi is high Average, she can't be A-AA. Giselle and Karina are high w-a.

who the hell said that, the delulu blinks???

Lol naur

•gxm• nah she's too nasal and airy to do that and prob knows nothing about anything other than indinstictive singing despite supposedly having vocal training when she was younger

Jihyo regressed since Alcool free era and Seulgi is getting less nasal and supporting better

Jihyo doesn't have good support sadly. She's missed out on a lot of vital technical training and now her vocal technique is all over the place, whereas Seulgi's from SM and has had the proper training and has vastly improved over the past few years.

Yeah Seulgi better then Jihyo

Seulgi has always been better or atleast they're on par but Seulgi is less nasal now ans jihyo regressed

Nope, actually she’s a great vocalist but not better than lily haewon and Wendy . Lily has more developed higher register than Ningning and haewon’s lower register is also better than Ningning. And Wendy ? Gosh She is one of a kind at vocals. But I know Ningning is also very great and my bias in aespa but the truth is truth. They provide support ranges and all and It’s true.

beCause your fav is lower? lol y’all are sore losers

Sad bc your faves couldn’t rank high.

@@blueflame3155 you too

@@delgerbuyndelgerbuyn8171 I’m not sad bc I’m not a biased person even though Itzy ranked low in here I don’t say that this is a true rankings and agree with it. Btw my faves are Aespa and Itzy

Yeah, Same she is lower C . People haven't seen her real POTENTIAL yet cause she uses a nasal technique. Her real vocals were really something, also she is IMPROVING she'll get even better .

Rosè isn't C, not even Nayeon is C. She can't be C.

@@kokichioumasimp8508 I think they mean low C.

@@kokichioumasimp8508 Rosé is definitely better than Nayeon. Though

@@lol-yz2kd no she ain’t. Nayeon is above rose. But blinks never accept that for years

Why are you lying?😂 jisoo is F she does not have any sense of support at all. Stop reaching

And Jennie definitely does support she’s in the E tier. Educate yourself on vocal pedagogy before you try to argue bc your embarrassing yourself and setting jisoo up

@@vvenuskook4170 she definitely has

@@vvenuskook4170 Jennie does not support, you are tho one who is making a set up here

@@Someone-ow8ts if Jisoo does supports, why Jisoo sounds airy and breathy when she sings than Jennie?

Thats how far she can go, problem?

Nope

D+

Her voice is weak

Hell no, she cant be better than Chaeyoung and Jennie who SUPPORT. Tzuyu is shallow, Yeri and Irene have better technique.

You are still stuck in 2019

@@Kpopobsessed952 i am new to kpop so i have no idea

@@karamjitgogga3306 lmao, Jisoo strains and her vocal technique is bad, her vocal placement is also extremely unhealthy. She’s very close to actually damaging her voice. She also doesn’t support any of her notes, she’s relaxed most of the time. Although she has the best lower register in BLACKPINK, she still has lots of serious problems.

Nayeon is way better than Rosè, what are you talking about?

Nayeon is still better than rose. Wdym 💀

@@kokichioumasimp8508 both are D+ so there are not so far from each other

Nayeon’s technique is better so she is stronger than Rose

Like I said, Highnote ≠ Good vocalist

Free ningning

No one is saying Jisoo is bad vocalist, she is AMAZING. But that doesn't mean she is the best

@@melekbasri1575 and when did I say she is the best

@@Oliver-uz1fs it always doesn't matter cause you know yourself what you can do not other's yg don't let blackpink show their real power

Hơn là hơn thế nào bạn có thể ghi ra chi tiết chứ không phải mỗi kênh này bảo Tzuyu vocal tốt hơn đâu.

@@myhoppy3199 trong ba nàng visual thì tzuyu yếu nhất là đúng rồi

@@hentranvan3240 thì mình mới hỏi yếu là yếu thế nào đó bạn. Rất nhiều kênh bảo rằng Tzuyu vocal hơn, cả phân tích chi tiết. Còn bạn vô nói 1 câu như vậy thì chứng minh được gì?

@@myhoppy3199 tzuyu hát bản năng, còn irene và jisoo là F+

@@hentranvan3240 rồi nhiêu đó đủ để phản biện lại video trên kia chưa? trên đó bảo Tzuyu có shallow sp nhưng ko nhất quán đó. Và theo mình xem tất cả các page bên vn phân tích thì jisoo ko có cả breathsp thì sao là f+ được.

Rosé is D-/D

I thought Rose was D+

@@blueflame3155 No she's somewhat inconsistent on Bb4

this is not about opinions

Yes, because Blinks would never agree

it's a fact that V is better than Jungkook tho

Ok

Please don't get me wrong. I like V he caught my eye before I even got to know bts. And I find him very handsome. But I am asking you this even tho I don't value high notes. Do you think Tae can hit the high note Jk did in on kinetic song or Jin in Run bts or Jimin in no more dream . He was even labelled as the autotune guy by an American singer and song writer because anytime it got to his turn a slight authotune had to be added to make it more pleasing. Well I dont know how true that is if it was his true voice in dynamite or auto tune but from what you people keep saying about vocals you always talk about high note. Can he hit them tho? I love Tae my good boy but I am just being sincere and want to know the truth.

The lest stylistic is messing up my medulla😁what does that mean? So good vocalist is not about high note. But why is it that a lot people keep stressing on high note to say a vocalist is good or not.

Please creator can you do male version of this video? Including bts all of a sudden I am interested.

nah

Then did you mean to put "don't agree"?

@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 and then? Should I agree? The girl is clearly a mid AA vocalist She didn't even producing one resonance to put her in the AA_P tier

@@soujoudlouhichi9695 You put "I do agree"

@@Lss125 🤣😂yeah that's what I was trying to point out, but I guess they didn't get it. I wasn't arguing or anything..

@@chrissyalapo-calg9748 They went so defensive like... wtf XD

they literally provide facts and back up to support their ranking . no she isn’t

no she is not

True

Delulu

@@chiraaz0 reasoning?