ok I just wanna clear up some things 1. I'm aware that soraru and mafumafu are real people 2. I didn't make the videos, I only added the text, the original videos are in the description. 3. sorry for getting merry kohakus pronouns wrong lol
Can you please please please react to Rin v1 growl? Hers was so realistic and addictive- idk why they changed it :( The little “voice crack” was literal heaven please- oh here is the link bestie ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-2KthXeCZ6dA.html
@@genxtq. It's just people thinking that the popular one is the original, which is not- I mean, I do get your preferences and opinions and all of that but it's a song about the person's constant contradicting lies and that they're growing remorseful over it but they think it's too late. You scream out because you're frustrated about yourself, I'm sure you don't growl when you're frustrated-
This part is supposed to be a screaming of frustration, it doesn’t have to be a growl. So Miku doesn’t need to be better, she’s the original and the standard. But yes, the growl is cool, Kagamines def my favs.
@@joe-qc3ff she doesn't scream though. I get that it doesn't need a growl but idk Miku doesn't sound human enough to get the cry though The ones that voice crack like Rin are the best
I think why everyone likes Fukase's version is for two reasons 1. It's a very popular cover, I actually heard it before the original and thought it was an original 2. There's no growl but there's still a dynamic change, also, his voice is very human like, this makes the yell hurt more. It's a very human song, so it hurts more.
i still prefer fukase's cover over the original or any other EXACTLY for that reason, he's tuned so well i don't even need my boy to growl to FEEL that scream in my VEINS. also he's just easier to sing along to with cause his tuning is so human.
Len put his probably horrible childhood, life, future, friends, identity, speech, mind, time, sight, taste, sense, rage, happiness, emotion, and everything, into that scream, my boi just told us that his trauma is extreme with a SCREAM. Holy shit guys I haven’t checked this comment in a while thx for like 6.k likes woah..
My favorite part of Len's cover wasn't the growl (although that was really good and I loved it) there's this one point at the climax of the song where he goes from his normal register to this piercing high note and it is so mind blowingly beautiful that it made Len's version my favorite~! But I've never heard of even half of these so I guess I"m falling down another vocaloid rabbit hole lol~
am i the only one who prefers the ones without growls? i think the ones without sound more realistic in a way. sure theres nothing overly special about fukases but the way it sounds even without the growl makes it special to me lmao. (also i thought it was weird you gave GUMI a 2 for yelling in lowercase when Luka did the exact same and she got an 8?) my absolute favorites are fukase, araki, kagamine lenka (i love the sound of nightcore), KAITO, VFlower, Gakupo, Soraru (especially since hes a real person and it just sounds heavenly lol), and mikuo
Well the song originally was indeed a scream not growl but the growl version became more popular than the scream. That’s why miku has no growl cause it’s a scream
remember everyone, don't bash the voicebanks, some of them were not suited to this and most of the quality is up to the producer/cover artist's tuning!!
Right, like the older voicebanks might not have as strong of voices or are able to growl because at that time they weren't designed to do that, or at least not yet
The Merry Kohaku cover always gets me the growl is so perfect and really packs in all that anger and frustration. LOVE AKEM AND ALL THEIR COVERS THEIR TUNING IS SPECTACULAR
fun fact from a producer: v3s can growl! it takes some effort and tweaking the voicebanks but they can growl. also everyone generally can but the people who did the covers didn't choose to lmao. i kinda am upset that most of the covers w cryptonloids suck (and gumi too) oof.
@@wevebi it's mostly cause people don't know how to do this and most of the covers are just rendered without any actual tuning, i see a lot of people using the same files and as a producer, i can hear the lack of actual tuning in there; it takes away the fun etc, and when people like me or others ACTUALLY tune something, they don't get any recognition. for example the luka cover sounds bad cause it hasn't been tuned at all, just rendered with her v4x voicebank. people should know that she's not good for "powerful" songs and if they use her like that, they should put effort in not making her sound muffled because it's actually very easy :)
i see! thanks for your time to explain it to me. it's a little sad to know how hard finding underrated producers can be sometimes, i have no idea of how to find new people without popular posts filling the screen :(
@@wevebi yeah that's true, unfortunately as well ahahah. I'm obviously not the best since i took various breaks but I'm certain that I'm improving each time i post something, can't wait to make an original :)
originals are so hard for me... i can come up with cool concepts but making actual lyrics and instrumentals for them is what gets me stuck. good luck for us, then! i feel like we can improve through time and that could bring people to hear the works.
There's another version for Rin's growl where she goes "aaaAaAaAa" (basically her voice breaks when she screams and it makes it sound a little more powerful and realistic than the other version's) and i really really recommend you give it a go
I can't believe how little love there is for Merry in these comments, she literally has one of my absolute favorite cover and her unique voice is so satisfying in this song
@@sssbstads idk if you already know about this but utaite isn't a software as far as i know, they're people who cover vocaloid songs (example : soraru , mafumafu) (feel free to correct me if i'm wrong)
Why isn't anyone talking abt V Flower's growl? It's litterary amazing. Also Lenka's growl is *chef kiss* (In my opinion. Also other growls are amazing but these are my fave.)
I am a metalhead and when this title said "growl" is fully expected something else. Not to say that they are not growling but they are more... purring? I guess lmao. Still, cool vid. I mostly agreed Teto (and a few others) had some roughness within, i liked that a lot
2:47 Soraru and mafumafu aren’t vocaloid but got fame from singing vocaloid songs but yes, they’re really good at singing! I recommend checking out their work!
I was so happy to see IA. I haven’t listened to her songs and covers as much, so I didn’t know about this one. But she sounded so awesome! (My favourite vocaloid)
Me when I saw Soraru and Mafumafu: YESSS (and yes they're human but especially mafu, he can just do those crazy high notes from vocaloid songs in original key like wHAT
UTAUloids have this roughness to them that helps make their growls distinct. As for VOCALOIDs, they’re professionally recorded, often with softer tones, because who in their right mind would add gruff screaming to the voicebank (except Len, he slayed it.)
@@ameilioracryptos5298 It's 100% the case tho, UTAU is really superior on a lot of points (like for thier realism, it can handle extreme power voicebank, it was the first to do "on note" pitchbands tuning, and the plug-ins) and inferior on some (like the outdated ui and no tension/air parameters, and no multi-track or inst-track)
Alright, let's give some of the main vocaloids some credit. Miku: Her voice is soft, not exactly a growl, but it's cute. Gakupo: His voice was extremely smooth. Kaito: His voice was actually quite nice. If there was a bit more rage behind the growl, he'd be a close second to Len. Len: Do I really have to say anything? Rin: Her voice is absolutely adorable, and emotional as well. Loved her's. Meiko: Surprisingly amazing. It was high pitched, but great. Teto: Her's was realistic, and a growl indeed.
@@neptuneex_ plus, do I really give a shit if she an "utau" and whatnot? If she's included in vocaloid and in the vocaloid fandom why not make everyone's life easier ? No one here needs to be a smartass ☠️
Teto is easily the best growl for this song, ESPECIALLY when tuned by Tanjiro Taidana. He's an absolute LEGEND when it comes to tuning Teto. Love his work
0:09 omg wow i have never heard kaito sound so amazing I was also a kaito fan but his robotic choppiness was like :/ this makes it sound really good Also 2:59 kaai yuuki is definitely one of the better vocaloids available. Her Voice bank is incredible. There isnt a bad song of hers out there
Miku is a 10/10 now, before you scream at me,I just wanna say this song wasn’t meant to have a growl. You can see in the romaji and English shes saying “Aaaaaaaaah!” not a growl. So that makes it fit the song perfectly to show she’s in pain or whatever(opinion btw)
I was pretty confused when I saw this video as “rating ‘growls’”, as I’ve only heard the original song xd. But yeah miku’s voice is very clear and gud.
Just to put this out there, Mellun, who made the Defoko cover, doesn’t want their cover or video to be reposted in any format, either in full, or as part of a compilation. I don’t think they’ll appreciate this video using their work. They’ve asked people to stop disrespecting their wishes and to take videos like these down.
@@bappo218 No, it's definitely the same. It's not the remake version though, the one it's from is ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-dkt1bxKH4eg.html
Me trying to growl just like Ruko: *GARAAAAAAA-* cough cough f it I lost my voice help Attempt 2 *HOAAAAAAAAAAAAAaaa...???* Wait how did they growl? Attempt 3 Haaaa. I lost my motivation.
@Flame7000 like i said if its ur opinion keep it to yourself if u dont like them then,dont say "no" "they are overrated" you know theres alot of ppl love them right? So keep it
@Flame7000 im not a fan of vocailad anymore but they are good Miku fukase both of them are good. Can u tell pe where ppl say that but i dont have social medias just tell me im not hating you just telling
