RDR 1(PS4) vs RDR 2 - Comparison of Physics and Actions! 

Rockstar was truly ahead of their time when they were making rdr1, truly amazing 😯

John lost his voice in rdr2 due to all that screaming lol

We Can all agree On that RDR2 Is the most realstic game ever. However RDR1 as a 2010 game is very impressive

Fun fact: In Rdr2, you can also tackle opponents and make them fall on the ground like in Rdr1, and then start punching them. You should've showed it.

Rdr1 is timeless idc how old it is it’s my favorite open world franchise

4:06 did you noticed that npc kept posture? Rdr1 is truly ahead of its time.

7:53 strange man🤫

In the game, the character interacts with the environment in a really cool way. They use a bunch of invisible lasers all over the place to figure out what they can climb, vault over, or bump into for special animations. There are hitboxes for every object, and they have to be just right to make sure the character does the right actions, like climbing instead vaulting. And when it comes to fighting, things get even more hairy. You can kick someone off a ledge or smash their head against a wall. The game even has AI that makes little tweaks to the animations on the fly. So if someone has a bigger or smaller neck, the choking animation adjusts accordingly. And when climbing, the AI takes into account how slanted an object is to make it little adjustments to the finger positions and the arm position, this is most likely done by using only one bone that has inverse kinematic to allow the AI to only need to worry about the hand position and everything else will follow naturally. This is a very simplified explanation its much more complex then this.

i found an rdr game at home, don’t even know how it got here, but now i wanna play it. luckily i have an old ps3 to play it on lol.

It's a 10 years difference I am impressed that rdr was like that

I like how when he drove off the cliff in rdr1 he got rejected like a beyblade lol

I think in GTA 6 they should bring back the freedom of choice we last saw in San Andreas,a good story like GTA 4 and details like RD2.Don’t you agree?🤔

I think the rag dolls are better in rdr 1 which is a big advantage since it's very common but everything else is a huge improvement in rdr 2.

I should probably add about the throwing knifes... That you can collect them if you used them on a person and animal. When you loot the kill you'll get it back at times. Noticed that detail when replaying RDR1 on the Switch... I'll probably remember it if I played on PS3 again but that version is pretty awful go back too.

Tbh I like rdr1 better just because of how John turns out to be and also of the ragdoll physics

Things better in RDR1: -Horse hair movement -Lasso visible on outside of body when stowed -John's brown undershirt as opposed to his white RDR2 one -Better gunbelt -Tighter gloves -Liar's Dice -Mexico. Mexico>Guarma -Better Abigail model/voice -Better Uncle model/voice -Drops/splashes of blood/rain on screen -Better story -Etc... Take away the graphics improvements of RDR2? Well, you've got a less fun RDR1 with a few small additions added and new characters. I love RDR2. But 1 is the best.

RDR 1 is incredible 😮

I honestly wish rdr2 had rdr1 s rag doll animations I love shooting someone in the throat and watch em walk for a short distance before collapsing

In rdr2 horses dodge objects like trees and such but other thing like going straight crashing into a house is a crasher

it is amazing on how much details they put in to these games rockstar games really put a lot of effort well…. sometimes

in rdr2 John slides off the slope, in rdr1 man straight up surfs on it

who think rdr2 is a masterpiece 👇

I love the fist fighting in rdr 2 there is alot of things you can do that you couldn't in the first game and alot of it they don't even explain in the tutorial. You can throw people and hold them hostage.

John is mewing in rdr 1 while he's falling

In rdr1 your character screams sometimes when you fall

even the camera man was shocked☠️ 7:56

Nice to see you again broo❤❤

The music that I hear in the video was used by ENXGMA, very good, bro. 👇

Can wait to a part 2 when rdr3 comes out

A muscles on the house are moving too in rdr1!

Just replayed RDR1 to 100% after not having played it since release 13 years ago, and as I remembered I definetly prefer it over RDR2. It just feels much better controls wise, strikes a fine balance between realism and smooth gameplay and I much prefer the environments and overall tone as well. RDR2 is really good and all, but feels too much like a tech demo and 'immersion simulator' which makes it tiresome to play at times.

Man what a step up from 1 to 2 though. :D

7:52 bro really say helicopter hellicopter helicopter hellicopter💀💀💀💀

Such beautiful games. I’m currently enjoying RDR2 for my first time

This intro is so good

I always hated the horse mechanics in rdr2...exclusivley the horse constantly crashing into everything she sees(my horse in game is female)...and before yall say some shit like "uhh...its not the horse, you just dont know how to play the game"...yea, even the best of the best in rdr2...eventually crash into a wagon or rock they didnt see at first

No horses were harmed in the making of this video.

I do kind of wonder if Red Dead 1 could've happened on the Wii

I wish the lasso was still there in rdr2

It doesnt matter how much time passes, john will always have his goofy run lol

Rdr1 feels like toned down version of gta 4 physics ( which is probably the case) rdr 2 is a genuine improvement over all games especially gta 5

Guys, I discovered a way to paint your guns with two colors🤯🤯🤯

Gun safety was invented in 1911 rdr2 takes place 1899/1907 and rdr1 takes place in 1911/1914

here for you i subscribed your channel now you are my favorite gta game teacher channel ❤🎉

2:08 this could be canon since he's older

By the way, you can shoot off the knives you've thrown with your gun in RDR2.

Ragdoll is tons of times better in RDR1, and enemy reactions on gunshots too.

Ngl, that intro was cold 🥶

RDR2 is still the best game ever made. If GTA 6 is announced on the 17th, we'll hopefully finally have a game that lives up to it.

Fun fact:If you grapple a npc and knock them out near a window (does not work on all windows you can go to Smithfields bar to try this)You will throw him out

in RDR1 I think he just accept his fate when jumping from a mountain and stays calm😂😂

The gravity looks like it's low in rdr 1 when falling

Fist fights in rdr are endless

Intro was clean

John in RDR2 looks pathetic, the way they made his gloves and pants gigantic while saturating the colors is just...

Rdr was made ps3 for its time it was best game made. Even today it’s better than 99 percent of games. Red dead 2 has better graphics, but enjoy ability was way better in red dead!

Fall physics in rdr 1 look like John could take it whilst in rdr 2 he falls like A dead bird

the best thing in rdr 1 is the game is like GTA it's not too realistic like rdr2 and it's not arcade like GTA games (3D era games).

Hope that GTA VI gets details just like RDRII.

John Marston, in red dead redemption, one screams he just doesn’t scream sometimes

I hope i can play RDR 1 on pc..i hope soon

Rdr2 was very nice but the first one is better imo. I have played it more than the second

Red dead redemption 2 and Red dead redemption 1 and red dead redemption undead nightmare and Red dead redemption 2 online where is Red dead redemption 3?

Do RDR2 vs real life

Made in 2018 but a long time ago it was 1899

In red dead redemption 1 jhon screams too

7:55 MY NAME IS BIRD MARSTON

Bro ran out of gta ideas 😂

I feel like rdr1 has gta 4 anims while rdr2 has gta 5s animation

None of them could fight gravity

at 0:13 the gravity is turned down in rdr1 for some reason

4:31 you can loot them off someone when thrown at them

If u crouch in front of someone then hit them it’s a 1 shot knockout

It is so good that there is a RIGHT scenery in RDR1, RIGHT atmosphere, and no tuberculosis simulator like in rdr2. I love RDR1

RDR 2 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ RDR1 I haven't played it yet

RDR 2 with path tracing and will be legendary. Where is the next gen update ? For PS5 Pro ?

0:26 Old GTA 5

Still no 60fps on ps5 with rdr2 is insane to me

Rdr1 dead eye better than rdr2 much

RDR1 lighting hurts my eyes

Yk my cousin got the brand new PS5 and yk what they're playing on it? Fornite 😂 I asked them why ain't you get rdr then they said "dad told it was old that's why" and that really hurt me

What I hate about rdr2 is that they made john the same shape as arthur and made john look ridiculous

There is no point comparing RDR1 PS4 and RDR2 because its not like RDR1s got an actual remaster its just a simple port lol

Stop comparing the 2 they are both masterpieces

Npcs in rdr2 are really smart unlike other games which make the game feel more realistic

Sliding ❎ Sliding✅

wait till you see VI

Rdr1 got the same ragdoll engine like gta4

Why did it take them so long to add the rd revolver movements into gta games like the flips to dodge the special ability the ability to get behind cover, it took them so long

I would like to see a video comparing AC Mirage and Red Dead Redemption 2.

RDR1 wins. RDR2 has 0 cowboy gunplay.

rdr 2 is goat

I hope RDR3 Main character is Red harlow, he's the red dead legend himself and even mentioned in both redemption series

Rdr1 was very great

How can you change the Dead Eye effect?

I have never played Red dead redemption before .. I just downloaded RD 2 on my ps4 but im wondering do i have to play the first one ?? Please help

If you shoot a gun in rdr1 it does infact fire just not always. The ragdoll in rdr2 are horrible. He magically turns upside down. Both great games but rdr1 ragdolls all the way.

1 it’s still beter

I’ve never played rdr1 because one of my friends said to play rdr2 first so I’m wondering should I buy rdr1 14 years later?

I feel bad for the horses