Reacting To Dave Meltzer's WWE Royal Rumble 2024 Star Ratings 

A year difference with World's End and now a month difference with the Rumble? Y'all took way less time than those OTHER guys!

Oh god that amazing woman's rumble so low, on par with that house show like 4 way??? Come on Dave

the women's rumble getting 1.25 stars less than the men's is insane, the woman tax might be worse than the inverse tokyo dome tax

THE WOMEN'S RUMBLE WAS MUCH MORE ENTERTAINING THAN THE MEN'S. THERE WERE BOTCHES YES. BUT IT WAS ENJOYABLE TO WATCH AND HAD SOME GREAT MOMENTS

Come on Dave. The women’s Rumble was the best match of the night

This batch of THE OTHER GUY'S star ratings have shown me that the Friendoclub star ratings are the DEFINITIVE star ratings.

wtf wrong with dave the womens was so much better

That rumble was rated 4.25 by him? FUCK NO!

These star ratings are cold, stale, and taste like a shoe. 3 stars for the women's RR?! Come on, Dave!

Womens rumble 4 * 4 way 3 and a quarter Kevin owens vs paul 3.5 * Men's rumble 3.5*

Need a NIA SUX shirt in RUN DMC font

The sad truth is with every women's match there will be people calling it sloppy

Dave is a joke with that 3 star rating!

let's see how well I do... matched perfect on the women's rumble! but also yeah, c'mon, Dave, give the women their stars. uh, not sure how many stars Larson said but it wasn't 3.5 so I missed on the Universal title fatal 4. didn't get the US title, went lower than that. and missed the men's rumble so I did bad overall.

Imagine waiting until the following month to review a show. Those... OTHER GUYS... need to speed things up man.

Am I tripping or did they not do the Logan v Kevin rating?

I think I liked the men's rumble more than most other people did, but in no world was it better than the women's rumble. I think I'd have them at 4 and 4.5 respectively

Bryans coo. But Ill never read the Wrestling Opinion Newsletter

The Womens Rumble was so much better than the men's. I know it's just one guy's opinion... But he couldn't be any more wrong.

So Jade, Jordynne, Naomi, Roxanne, Tiffany were less fun for Dave Doesnt Melther than Andrade, Bron and Pat. Checks out

Dave Meltzer is absolutely fried if he thinks the men's rumble was a full star and a quarter better than the woman's rumble...

I got two words for those... OTHERRRR GUYSSSS

Dave's not only showing his age he's showing his ridiculous sexism and it's just making him look sadder and sadder and sadder.

Bron Breaker should win Elimination Chamber and then beat Seth for Championship.

Sorry guys, recently followed this channel. Who are these ‘other guys’? Thanks.

Maybe we can get some retro friendo reviews ? 👀

"The 2024 Men's Royal Rumble was better than the Women's." Said no unbiased wrestling fan. Yes, it took a bit to get going, and there were some botches, but the women's had so many incredible moments. It also wrote the book on how to debut a new person by having Jade Cargil easily eliminate Jax after she had been built up as a beast over the past months and in the Rumble itself. IF Punk had not gotten injured and that last part between him and Cody went better, the men's might have come close. With the Punk injury, however, that entire end sequence was just brutal to watch. That plus not as many big surprises, the absolutely wasted entry of Pat McAfee, and even the fact you start with Jimmy and Jey and then they really do not face off against each other at almost any other point made the Men's Royal Rumble a slog to watch.

THOSE OTHER GUYSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

There were too many botches in the womens for me to put it at a 4 or above

That 4-way was my favorite match of the night. It was such a solid match, and a great showing for LA Knight. One of the more underrated matches in recent memory IMO.

Dave is never beating the hates women’s wrestling allegations

I’m just here to hear y’all say “Those other guys” 😂😂

"Those...Otherr Guysss"

Those rumble ratings should be switched

Dave giving the men’s rumble more than a full star more than the woman’s makes absolutely no sense

Dave has the ratings pretty accurate but his description why is off

OTHER GUYS HAVE GOT SERIOUS LIFE ISSUES

I usually think Meltzer's ratings are shit and he just gives those stars away to his friends and ppl that flip through garage. Especially if it takes place in the Tokyo Dome. But for once, I mostly agree with him. That women's rumble was not better than the men's, although some of the past ones have been, but the women's rumble wasn't bad. The 4way was predictable in a bad way. The men's rumble wws predictable in a good way. You knew Cody was gonna win, but I wouldn't have betted on it.

That Crowd wasn't quiet I was there it was rocking.

After getting their Wrestle Kingdom fresh out the oven, those *others guys* have gone back to their old ways. Taking a whole month for these Rumble ratings?!?! Disgraceful

Explain to me how could come with star ratings for Wrestle Kindom that had like 8 more matches than the Rumble in less than 48 hours but take a whole week for a ppv with 4 fucking matches

What fricking Rubble was he watching, GIR star rating were far more accurate

That dudes ratings dont even matter like what reward does he give people nothing literally nothing

There was no way Bailey was a predictable thing. Everyone said Beair or Beckey.

Why does it take Dsve to do a stsr rating for a PLE that has four matches. Then again. I've basically stopped paying attention to Dave anyway.To have all those inside sources. He still gets so much ish wrong. And has for decades now.

3 stars for the women's rumble is ridiculous. Pure technical proficiency is arguably the least important part of professional wrestling. The women's royal rumble had phenomenal storytelling

Dave "the Misogynist" Meltzer.

Swap the two royal rumble match's scores and i agree with the scores.

Although I enjoyed the women's rumble more overall, I'd rate the men's rumble higher just for how into the final four I was and how over the moon I was that Cody won. I do think it's wild to rate the women's rumble and the 4-way the same, though. For all the talent involved, that 4-way fell pretty flat imho.

I feel like you guys give woman extra points just for being woman lol like the opposite of what you guys accuse Meltzer of doing.

The Iron Sheik could have made it to the ring in a gimmick battle royal faster than it takes those other guys to get their star ratings!

After the great women’s Rumble and the couple weeks WWE has had, Dave’s obvious sexism seems more tone deaf and disgusting. I usually brush off as one dude’s opinion,but this comes off irresponsible considering his following and position in media.

The fact that the women’s Royal Rumble was the best match, speaks volumes for the rest of the card.

Meltzer is a clown

Dave is a kidding himself with that womens rating.. can we stop giving him so much press. He is past it

I liked the women’s match ,but it was sloppy. I liked the men’s match more. That being said I liked both matches.