Reaction to Alamat's Dagundong MV & BGYO: Why Are Ppop Groups Not Becoming As Popular As SB19? 

Alamat is now my #2 now coz they have now consistently churned out songs with substance and they can also perform well live.

I love both SB19 and ALAMAT . They both are so talented, produce distinct and unique music and have very clear visions as a group. SB19’s vision of bringing lyrically deep and thought provoking PPOP music on a global scale, through their very own 1Z Entertainment. And likewise with ALAMAT’s desire to showcase diverse Filipino cultures, distinct regional languages/dialects and cultural attire are apparent in their music videos. Not denying the talent, music and visuals of BGYO, but perhaps they’re still developing a distinct identity and it is still not clear amongst the other 2 groups . And as Pablo as mentioned , the music industry is a competitive industry where one has to stand out . Healthy competition is what SB19 really promotes for growth and betterment for an industry as a whole. I do believe PPOP will rise on a global scale . Thank you for your analysis always 🙏

The best kagabi yung live ng ALAMAT Sa iloilo wala na akong boses kagabi kakasigaw at kakakanta ang galing din nila at ang posgi ni jao in person😍🔥

There are many reasons why SB19 has a loyal following in A’Tin. The other comments have enumerated enough of them. And I share your view that this Alamat song is just “enough” and nothing more. I too am an older listener. I appreciate Alamat on a casual basis and appreciate their goal of promoting Filipino culture and its diversities. But for some reason I remain just that, a casual. I’ve often described SB19’s rise as a miracle - no big networks, politicians or powerful families or even a management company to back them up. How then can this not be a miracle, especially in the Philippine setting? But for those who are not of a supernatural or spiritual bent, then let’s just say that our boys, especially Pablo, have poured heart and soul into their songs and craft. THAT to me is the miracle factor - to the exclusion of anything or anyone else, in spite of anyone or anything else, despite the lack of anything or anyone one else, their united will forged a powerful instrument that reverberates (dare i use this word? DUMADAGUNDONG) in many A’Tin. Our Inspirational and “Asperational” bits are triggered - for ourselves and for our country to be finally recognised worldwide.

I have to echo the sentiment that it's too soon for you to write off Alamat based on your evaluation of this one song/MV. While I do agree that Dagundong plateaus in terms of musicality, it's just one of many songs in their discography. You need to look into the objective behind the group's creation, the identity of the members, and the albums/singles before making an assessment. To say that they need a more modern and relevant take on their sound and styling is indicative of one's failure to delve deeper into their music. Dagundong and Kasmala are the only MVs that have a historical/nationalistic slant. Of the two, Dagundong was obviously composed for a local audience while Kasmala was produced by a Swedish team (with an MV unrelated to the lyrics of the track). The Filipino-centric branding is due to the incorporation of regional languages, folk dances, native instruments, local textiles,and cultural elements in their music and MVs but that does not mean that they're boxed into just singing about history and culture. If you watch their vlogs, you'll also know that they have recently been given creative input and that the boys have had a hand in composing and producing music, dance choreography and styling.

Even the SB19 songs made for brand deals is high quality. It really amazes me that even their solo songs are so good.

I love Maharani & Day & Night

SB19 SONGS are a story of life and they way the sing each lyrics penetrates your heart ❤️

SB19 has the genius in Pablo in writing hit after hit after hit. I can't really say anything more.

The difference of SB19 from the rest is their authenticity. When Pau described their group before as authentic, i didn't get it, but now i understand it already, what he meant by authentic is that everything they do or people see in them is real not put on and from the heart, the lyrics of their songs, the emotions when they perform, their answers in their interviews, their interactions to anyone, their attitudes, in their vlogs what you see is what you get, everything is authentic, that's why in return what authentic A'tin gives back to them is their devoted support..😊💙

Totally agree! I love ALAMAT and their music and wish they were more popular and well-known both in and out of PH. And while I love that they use a lot of Filipino cultural elements in their music, I feel like a "bridge" that translates the cultural aspect of their music into the modern world is missing. This makes it difficult for many to relate to. I think what sets SB19 apart is the storytelling aspect of their songs, while based on their own experiences, are so relatable. The manner by which the lyrics are written always hits you to the core even if they're not almost always not straightforward and literal (for instance, in Mapa - words like "I love you" or "thank you" cannot be found in the lyrics but these messages were clearly delivered in the entire song). Also, the melody plays an important role in creating that atmosphere. Sometimes, you don't even need to understand the lyrics but the melody and delivery of the lyrics are enough to understand the message.

If I can add in terms of the slow rise of PPOP and how hard it is for other groups to gain popularity, the Filipino culture itself is to blame. Generally speaking, we are not fashion forward as I’m tying this with music. We see how SB19 got mocked when they were still starting because of how they dress, coloring their hair, their music (though I think their ballads suit Pinoy taste) etc. Filipinos always play it safe. We are not risk takers. I’m glad that SB19 kept going despite the adversity they faced. But if we want to be recognized globally (not just in music) Filipino mindset has to shift as well.

SB19's authenticity, humility and integrity traits are infused in their character as individuals and as a group. I believe it is not a marketing strategy to create "an emotional story" to the masses, but SB19 transcends their difficulties and journey of success to give INSPIRATION not only to artists/musicians but to ordinary persons who can relate to the message in their songs. MATA SA LANGIT, PAA SA LUPA! Truthfulness and humility, exceptional talents, creative and genius minds, very strong brotherhood, imperfect and God-fearing, and always grateful to everyone who believed in them since the beginning - they have the formulas equated in utmost sincerity. This is the SB19 I know!

SB19 mostly writes their own songs and they write about their experiences which most of the time resonates with listeners. A lot of people also like the story of their journey and their down-to-earth personalities. They can relate to their struggles. They’re also not afraid to show their true selves in every light - from their glamorous side to their embarrassing actions. BGYO and Alamat had big companies backing them from the start so they did not have the “struggle” story that SB19 has. I think that these are some of the major reason why they’re not as popular. Another reason, of course, is that the talents of SB19 is just on a different level. Three of the members are recognized songwriters, two members have their own companies not related to music and a third is launching his own soon. The members’, especially Stell and Pablo, musical talents are just phenomenal and just command respect. Plus, they genuinely love the people in their fandom and are always grateful to them (and God) for their success.

Sb19 song will move you.. the sound itself even if you don't understand will penetrate your soul..

About the MV, it felt lacking for me for Alamat's Dagundong. The song is fire and lots of potential to be a breakthrough song but an indoor production of the MV just didnt work. MYX old school video. They represented different groups here, i wanted their backdrop to be outdoors on this one but maybe thats just me. Outside this MV, Alamat also has been really doing well, focusing on their craft and I love their relationship with each other too. These boys can be the next SB19 if you ask me. For BGYO, their talent is overshadowed by controversies. Because of a huge company backing them up, they must have expected that fans will come in automatically. And when it didn't happen, they didn't know how to handle it. And instead of focusing on their crafts and respecting the process of hard work, they start blaming people around them. Their last interview didnt even show an ounce of self reflection and accountability. They deflected again and blamed the fans and industry. When SB19 started, they faced ridicule and disappointments but pushed through with it. They appreciated even the small audience. I think the game changer was when they decided to stand on their own because they are no longer restricted to "what's generally accepted". They made themselves their own competition. And that's why every single year, they've made themselves 10x better. They literally created the PPOP industry now (yes I do think that), and all the other group have to do is utilize the road paved for them. SB19 don;t even care if other groups go beyond what they achieved. Heck they're not even just planning on their own success, they are working hard now to fund future artists under 1Z.

I think sb19 and Alamat are so good, i think this generation really don't like to listen or knowp about our own culture

I appreciate MV with a story. A song is actually a story.

SB19's music, talent, passion, dedication & humility is truly admirable & inspiring. Worth supporting & to be proud of. 💙 PS. I'm into bands & rap/hiphop genre since the '90s neither into Kpop too but after hearing their music's messages got me hooked & calmed me. Just last year on my 40th birthday despite prohibited going on crowded events like concert because of my anxiety/panic disorder but i insist & hearing them live made me somehow healed. 😊

A'tin here but also a casual listener of Alamat. They have good songs actually. Some can be at par with SB19. Kulang lang sa marketing and extra content which was Viva's fault. As for the or Ppop, that's a whole other issue kung bakit hindi sila makaadvance the way SB19 do. Kung meron mang group who has the potential to follow SB19's footsteps eh sorry to say pero Alamat palang ang nakikita ko to have what it takes.

I love Alamat next to SB19. They are craft focus and very dedicated to their goal. Unlike ng iba dyan na instead on improving there craft, they keep on whining like a damsel in distress hahahah

Eh, I think Alamat is in their own league, and just their music videos and songs are enough to get them a local and worldwide fanbase. The problem we need to tackle is marketing. I don't think judging ALAMAT for one of their songs is enough either. If you listen to ILY ILY, Gayuma (which is my favorite), Maharani, Aswang, Kasmala, Day and Night,. The list goes on. To me, they rarely miss. All the songs they've sent out are worthy of gaining worldwide attention, and they do have international fans too, by the way. And you don't need to be like SB19 at all. You don't need to be writing your own music or whatever else; to be honest, if that's our argument, then the artists with ghost writers in western media shouldn't have been as successful as they are. If something is marketed well, (ex., there are K-pop songs that are on advertisements) it will click despite how little effort the music production or music video has. If your argument is that these groups should all tick and check everything SB19 has been doing, then that will also be one of the reasons why said groups won't ascend. We all know how much Filipinos hate copycats. ALAMAT has the individuality for that, and so does G22, Bini, and BGYO. If you factor in the lack of marketing and the Filipino taste in music (Filipinos mostly listen to K-pop and indie-ish OPM songs), then those are the main reasons why other P-pop groups aren't clicking. People still have misconceptions about P-pop and again, lack of marketing will further these misconceptions. I've been to a mini concert of YML and G22 in my area and I heard fellow students of mine make fun of them before they even performed, that's because they still think P-pop sucks. After YML and G22's performance though, a lot of people were cheering them and even fangirling/boying. WE NEED PEOPLE TO SEE WHAT P-POP IS CAPABLE OF. A lot of people argue that P-pop copies K-pop without seeing that the famous indie OPM songs right now are exact formulas of their western descendants. I can literally find a song similar to Raining in Manila, and people wouldn't bother saying it's a copycat. Not that I'm saying Lola Amour copied or anything; I'm just saying it sounds the same because it's duh. A GENRE. If only people would realize this. Marketing and altering people's perception of P-pop should be the first step.

I personally love Dagundong, the rap part and the chorus is an LSS for me, but i can see what you mean about the highlight part, i think its because the intensity? or whatever you call it, is the same allthroughout the chorus and also almost the same to some of the verse and its short that's probably why there is no room for a highlight. and yes its also good to put a lyrics that connects the history into the modern time like perhaps a lesson that is applicable for an ordinary human, but still big respect to them because this song still has a vision, if telling the history is what they're going for then so be it. Truthfully tho, we cannot force others to like it if it is not their forte. That's the beauty of music, different music for different people. When it comes to discussion in general about why other PPop group's music is not clicking to many Filipino audiences is that we really cannot come up to only one. There are so many factors to consider that come into play not just musically. for instance lack of promotion or strategy by their agency, some although obviously talented but lacks genuiness in their music because its highly manufactured which is probably the fault of agency too, some group also lack a clear and specific vision and mission hence the group is disorganized and it will show in their works, or maybe PPop in general is still not accepted by majority, and so many more.

SB19 compose, create, sing and dance their songs, the most amazing is Original Pilipino Music, so much talent👍🎶🎶🌈🌻❤️

I grasped the situation about BGYO through X (Twitter) because I can’t understand what’s being said in the video. I’m not quite sure how a fan base can prevent a group from succeeding but I think that if the group doesn’t have beliefs people can stand behind then they won’t be considered marketable. From what I am understanding of what is being said about them, they don’t seem to be nice people in general. I saw comments from people who are fans of them, people who are not, people who liked their music and people who have been turned off by the group and the groups fan base. I think a huge difference between Esbi and the other groups I’ve seen is length of training. I feel like Esbi has the longest training of any of the other groups. Minus the exception of some members of other groups who trained with members of Esbi. Also, pandemic helped Esbi become heavily involved with their music. It helped them become self sufficient in their music. Some of the groups don’t have involvement in their songs. Esbi are very close because they had to rely on each other a lot during their trainee days and during the pandemic. They have a very large socmed presence especially during the pandemic and they made an uplifting song for people during that time. They continuously think of others as well. Back on training. Because they had such strong demands on training and they put these large demands on themselves, it presents through their performances. They were trained to be performers first so that if anything went wrong the show doesn’t stop and the audience leaves satisfied no matter what. Performing in venues such as banquet halls (while serving food), nursing homes, orphanages, malls, etc built tenacity and resiliency within them. The respect they have for each other is big too. Pablo is also a huge factor I think as well. The passion he has for music is palpable. Even though he says that him being the leader is just a title, the amount of respect he has for his members and the huge amount of respect Josh, Justin, Ken and Stell have for Pablo is visible. It’s endearing and makes you want to support them. Their motto of caring about others makes you want to do the same. Their songs together are uplifting and encouraging. They have individual personalities that you can see yourself getting along with. They are very respectful of others and it shows. Another thing, their tight bond is because of their training and trust of each other which shows in their performances. There have been mishaps when performing but because they are performers you hardly notice. I feel that all I have said is what sets them apart from other groups. I’m not saying other groups don’t work hard l. They do. But, they haven’t had to face as many challenges in public while performing which training prepares you for and they also weren’t forced to be self sufficient with their music which happened to be a great thing that occured for Esbi.

I can say the music itself really does make a difference. All these groups are no doubt talented. SB19 stands out because throughout the years, they have actually morphed into their own sound. They went through a journey searching for their sound until it just became defacto that SB19 cannot just be boxed into one genre, and yet you can figure out that these songs are SB19's despite how different they are. That is SB19's appeal. They're now even taking advantage of that versatility, using it as a vehicle to align with the trends when they need to (as in when they cater to their endorsements and other brand commitments). Along with that is their freedom to experiment with different techniques, sounds and methods. On the other hand, other groups don't really have that kind of freedom. While there are few who do write and create their own songs (like KAIA who recently released a banger, btw), few have the platform that established groups have to further propagate their music. In a way, SB19 might have a really rough start (so rough they bled for it), but looking back, it was a blessing in disguise because they learned to create their foundation themselves. Because of that, now SB19 really doesn't have to prove anything, not to their fans nor their haters. They probably will always be thankful for the fans, but they don't have to prove anything to ANYONE anymore. They carved their own bedrock and no matter what happens, whether a flood or a storm comes, they will always have that bedrock to support them. They can always build anything on top of that bedrock and it will remain steadfast. Hence, PAGTATAG.

SB19's edge is that their songwriter/musical director is a part of the group, which makes it easier for them to create a sound that the composer wants to deliver. Best part is that this person is not ordinary, so as the other four. I hope Alamat will be able to compose & produce their songs one day with full reign on their craft. They have the potential, but is somehow constrained. Also, i feel like it's hard to stick to their concept bcoz music is evolving. SB19's sound is modern but u know it's still pinoy.

Perhaps because BGYO still didnt find their identity.. i can see their talent but compare to Alamat and SB19 where you can can see their identity the moment you laid your eyes on them.

I think after SB19 ... Alamat is it.

All over the world and through out the length of its history, "boybands" are like the visual artists in the art of MUSIC, and in any time period, the type of Music and the poetry in their music is almost exclusively for, and most preferred listen to type of Music for GIRLS in and around their teenage years. Now, in this "boyband" sub-genre emerged the "K-Pop boyband", which has differences with the original "boyband", but not very far off, especially its FAN demographics. That is that. SB19 may be a group of all boys BUT, people know and should know, that they have a much wider and more diverse fan demographics, also one that would disqualify them as a "boyband". 2nd things is that, their music sure is popular BUT it really doesn't necessarily fall under the POP Music genre, i.e. "MAPA", "MANA", "CRIMZONE", and others is NOT AT ALL the typical POP type of music. These are facts. OR you can simply trust the opinion of a 40+ year old MALE listens and would appreciate all types of music, EXCEPT for the typical "boyband" music or very girly or girlband music, with a rare exception of a few songs though. But men, in general, just don't like "boyband" music because it's somewhat insincere, and it's the type that lacks most the musical artistry from the artists themselves, especially vocal diversity. But the simple and all honest truth is. . . people listen to a song or music that they prefer or like, so if they are not listening to your music then that simply means that they don not like it.

MAHARANI IS THE SONG OF ALAMAT MANY CASUALS ALAM ANG SONG NATO DAHIL SA TIKTOK

Kulang sa puso ang BGYO … unlike sb19 talagang maluluha ka sa mga lyrics especially Mapa❤❤❤

One key factor going for SB19 is Pablo's lyrics, for me music is a personal expression so I like artists, bands ,and groups that really make music based on their own experiences. I like them to express themselves as much as possible through their music. Although a good, catchy beat also attract me but lyrics is first. SB19 works for me because I don't really like commercial pop songs.

SB19 songs are all very good that most people can appreciate and relate to no matter what nationality. It is all well written. Pablo is a genius.

SB19 the PPOP KINGS, ALAMAT the PPOP prince.

that all said, promotions and exposures are the key for them to be known. Mag viral or trending. That's it!! Im BTS army, and I like Alamat and Hori7on. Thanks.

AL🫶🏼MAT 🇵🇭☝🏽

Its their music, personality, talent, skills and outstanding stage performance that made SB19 standout from the rest they have the complete package to be famous in the world.

Thank you so much for reacting to Alamat 🤎😊🙏

I think there's several reasons other ppop groups haven't clicked the way SB19 has, but the no. 1) factor is time. It's taken SB19 a LONG time to get to where they are now. The other groups have only been around for a comparatively short time, and they also didn't train for as long before debuting, so their baseline skills aren't as advanced as SB19's were when they first debuted. 2) Filipino crab/colonial mentality. Most people won't even give ppop a chance & dismiss it as a copycat even before they try it. As though OPM and all other Filipino music doesn't have international influences either. We love to talk about how welcoming we are but when a fellow Pinoy tries something new they get ridiculed for it - until some foreign celebrity says they like it, and then suddenly it's okay to like it too. 3) The incredible luck/fate of SB19 having the perfect mix of voices/talents. High range, low range, rap, songwriting, producing, lyricists, harmonizing. Especially having Ken, since his voice type is so rare in pop music and is something none of the other groups have. 4) Pablo. Other groups just don't have anyone writing songs for them that resonate the way Pablo's songs do. Not necessarily a group member, but any songwriters. I like Thyro Alfaro's stuff for Alamat a lot, but it still feels like he's not really writing specifically for Alamat, if that makes sense. It feels like he wrote the songs and then fit Alamat into them, rather than the other way around, which makes them feel a bit impersonal. 5) Management. So many ppop groups have huge amounts of talent and potential but they're given mediocre songs and choreo, or else get shelved and barely release any content.

Alamat has stepped up their game in producing content and music. Props to them!

As an A'TIN, I quickly stanned SB19 because of their struggle stories and genuine, unpolished interviews before they went big. Their realness made it easy to connect with them. New groups are launched too polished, with few interviews showing their true personalities, making it hard to connect. Talent and looks alone aren't enough; emotional connection is key. While new groups can capture attention with songs and looks, there needs to be something deeper for viewers to connect with. SB19 is unique because their initial look didn’t fit typical Pinoy standards, but their talent was undeniable. The more you got to know them through vlogs and interviews, the more you focused on their personalities and charm rather than their looks. Now, they are considered gorgeous, but it was their authenticity that stood out. New P-pop groups need more content showing their real, unpolished personalities. Trying to be perfect all the time makes it hard for viewers to connect. They should have more vlogs and interviews where people can relate to their stories and personalities. Many A'TIN don’t support SB19 just because of their songs; we support them individually no matter what they release. For example, Ken/Felip sold tickets for his "7sins" album concert before releasing the songs, and fans still bought them. This shows that SB19 and its members are strong brands, with loyal fans willing to support anything they do. That’s a deep level of trust and connection that new Ppop groups still need to work on.

Bat kase hindi puwde pag usapan ang ibang group na hindi nasasali ang boys nagagalit ang A’tin dati pag na kukumpara ang achievements ng boys sa BTS dati nakahit sa totolang kahit 1/4 ay diman lang naabot ng boys tas ngayun ginagawa ng A’tin sa ibang groups sa totoo lang nakakahiya na kapwa Pinoy pa tsk

The other PPop groups have the potential and next to SB19 I really want Alamat to follow in their footsteps. Its just that SB19 have 5 talented guys with a leader that is a genius composer & selfless pushes each member to bring out the best in them & all are supportive of each other no ego they compliment each other added to that the 5 distinct voice timbre which makes their songs uniquely their own sound.

SB19's songs, sound, choreography, creativity, passion and the boys themselves with their charisma make their band a cut above the rest.

I love SB19 and Alamat, oh and I’m a big BGyO fan as well so I don’t understand why can’t bgyo and alamat be as giant as SB19

Yung DAGUNDONG maganda. even mga foreign Yt reactors madaming nagandahan.

❤❤❤❤❤

dapat ba talaga i compare ang SB19 and Alamat ??? PPOP cla both sb19 is Waaayy more popular to Alamat bat dapat icompare PLUS ang content talaga Not becoming as popular.. and ofcors hahanapan talaga nang negative vibes yung Alamat (dagundong) just to justify y bakit di cla Sikat as SB19.. dba ! the vlogger is just focusing in just 1 song or video.

Mybe they need rebranding of style, though they are good performers, the SB boy’s advantage is their versatility, passion for their craft, and they create their own songs, not to mention their solo acts with wide range of genre.

I am a magiliw and A'tin.. I love the songs of both groups as well as BINI the sibling group of BGYO.. napansin ko May kulang sa BGYO.. puso? Charisma sa audience and casuals.

Spot on reaction. I actually like this song and video, but not enough for me to listen to it again (and there's nothing in it that hasn't been said/presented before by others). I'd just like to add that it lacks what we musicians refer to as a "hook" that leads to recall. Pablo and his producers are so good at this, every song he wrote for SB19 has it (even several sometimes).

It's hard for Filipinos to support local because of the colonial mentality embedded into our psyche. The old works and branding of SB19 was very kpop, that's why they got flack for being copy-cats. But then their Go Up video went viral. I personally didn't like their sounds because I grew up listening to r&b and soul, even rock and ballads. I wondered what was so special about it. Honestly, it was nothing special. I first came across SB19 when I watched them on Fox Channel via YT. I didn't think a pop group from the Philippines would go that far. I'm trying to get to my point, but my mind is going haywire. But I only began to be a fan when I watched videos from Cashual Chuck. I was hit emotionally. I guess that's the formula, you gotta have that emotional attachment. So I became an A'tin. Going back to the colonial mentality. We are trained to like everything that's started by western pop. It's only now that more Filipinos have begun to support indigenous sounds, embracing our roots, going local. Why? Coz the rest of the world started doing that. We, Filipinos, want to be in the trend. But it turned out great. Many passionate Filipinos began the movement. We began appreciating our local products, growing and making our own food, wines, cheeses, preserves, coffee, chocolates. The list goes on. And yes, OPM is back! The Japanese and Korean are very patriotic, and it's only been in recent years that we've come to appreciate our own. So we can't be like them. I still think Filipinos are one of the main reasons K pop culture reached its peak. We freakin' love everything korean. Our standards in beauty, music and pop culture are based ON THEM. I don't understand why. We can't, because we are Filipinos. We are built differently. We have our own strengths, and I think instead of comparing us to them, why can't we begin to appreciate them? When a young child begins to walk, you don't tell them, "Walk like your older brother tout de suite! Come on, do it!" Instead, you tell the toddler, "Great job, you're doing so well! You can do it! We'll be here at the end of the hallway, waiting for you." Right? I mean, did you think KPop started great? NOPE. The fans made them great, even when they were just mediocre. Filipino talent is insane, but we chose to support foreigners. Hence, the death of OPM. What I notice based on my personal experience as an A'tin, some are very selfish and refuse to see other groups as good enough. In my A'tin community, most are close-minded and would never lift a finger in supporting the newer ones. For them, nobody comes close to SB19 and everyone should be like them. I mean, I get it. They are the standard. But the attitude isn't very motivating. It's very arrogant and close-minded. It's really hard to explain, but that's how I feel in the A'tin community I'm in. Other groups will never be better than SB19, and it's hard for them to grasp that. I consider myself an A'tin, but I'm not really out there. I never watched them coz I live in Europe. I'm not a die-hard fan of any group, but I really admire the concept of Alamat and their songs. I honestly listen to their songs almost every day. Their songs resonate to me and it's because I'm very patriotic. The musicality and artistic concept is very Filipino, and that's what I crave. You're right. That's their brand. To infuse different languages and indigenous beats to the modern is a feat one cannot pull off that easily. And they did it so well. It's experimental and avant garde imo. And I am excited to see more works from them. ILY ILY, Kasmala and Dagundong still relate to this day. We still face the same dilemma with the dispute about the seas. I expect PPop to pave their own path, not follow what Kpop and Jpop is doing. I'm all over the place, sorry. I guess what I'm trying to get at is that Filipinos will only begin to appreciate PPop once we get validation from other nationalities, especially the West. Hence, the bliss of validation from foreign reactors. Don't get me wrong, SB19 worked blood, sweat and tears to get where they are now, but they hit the jackpot with their fanbase. The boys know it and admit to how fortunate and blessed they are to have such a strong fanbase like A'tin. The support they have is undisputable. There are many OPM songs I feel should have made it big but didn't. Fans make the stars, and A'tin is the best example. It's all about who you know and how you market yourself to gain a passionate fandom, and that's what SB19 did. Alamat, VXON, BGYO, Bini, G22 and 4th Impact and all other groups have to do the same. They all have hit songs, plus they are a total package. It's the MARKETING. Hit the masses with an emotional story or some genius strategy This is just my personal opinion, but hey, I could be wrong.

Next to SB19 my top 2 is Alamat.. Walang yabang kc ang personalities nila..

Wala akong ibang masabi ,mas magaling ang SB19 sa lahat Ng napanuod ko na artist,mapasinger ,mapabanda o MAPA ano paman na grupo..kakaiba talaga ang SB19.

Hi, i'm older than you i guess.😊 But i like both SB19 & Alamat. I like Alamat's songs, music videos and choreos. They have a lot of international fans from reactors. So i've been hoping that they can work more on their live performances for them to be successful in any concerts outside the country. I was a bit sad when i saw their PPopCon performance where the backtrack is so much louder than their own vocals so it gave an impression that they were doing lipsync. It would really help PPop rise.

Sharing my two cents worth on why other PPop groups aren't clicking the way SB19 does. 1. Songwriters and producers often focus more on being artistic and forget about the "pop" side of the music. They are niche songs and often don't click with the majority. Take for example Pablo's "La Luna" and "Determinado", they are great but I believe they belong to niche songs. 2. Filipinos are still addicted to ballads especially with belts or "birits". Songs need to be relatable, both lyrics-wise and music-wise for non-ballads to click with listeners. Producers are afraid to gamble on new sound that stray away from the traditional. Eraserheads, Parokya ni Edgar among others broke the monotony of Filipino ballads. Moira did a fresh take on love songs with her 'fresh style' of singing. Hopefully producers will take a chance on new sounds. 3. Finally, its the artist themselves. Its a matter of having the x-factor or not. Sometimes even having a ton of talent or great looks isn't a guarantee for stardom. Filipino talent scouts should have a feel for potential stars with true talents and x-factor and not just focus on looks.

I only stan SB19 coz they are the only authentic boygroup out there (considering all aspects) in my opinion. Also for people who do not have the luxury of time to stan a lot of groups/artist, picking just 1 will definitely go to the most deserving to stan in my personal opinion and preference.

Besides SB19's talent and their discography, what made me a fan is how they conduct themselves during interviews. They are on another level compared to other groups. You can see how comfortable they are with each other, they sound natural and not scripted, their authenticity is very endearing and lastly, they are articulate. They had mentioned that part of their training was personality development so kudos to their trainers for prepping them well. I've tried to listen to Alamat but unfortunately none of their songs have resonated with me so far. I guess their brand is just not my cup of tea. I have heard about their advocacy and how they want to represent different indigenous groups from the Philippines. While it's an admirable goal and mission, I'm not quite sold. For some reason, it feels just more performative rather than a real passion. There's something missing. That's just my take.

I enjoyed the breakdown of the history although that was not the purpose of your reaction.

For me these songs lacks universal appeal which are always the focus of most SB19 songs which are intended to be heard by everyone, not just specific group of people or nationality. If they really want to penetrate the world stage they must think of songs that can be enjoyed by all. Just my opinion. 😊😊

Hi Ma’am, hope you can react on the latest cover song of SB 19 justin, Sunday Morning. Thank you and more power!

Sb19 completos recados

Pablo of SB19 who composes their songs is a genius, they are able to connect with audience given the quality of songs they have. kita nyo lahat ng songs nila walang tapon! every and all their songs are great! that is one of the things that BGYO doesn't have.

I love the fact that ALAMAT is promoting the Filipino culture in their looks. But here is what I notice specifically in this MV ➡️ The musicality (arrangement) sounds a lot like K-pop regardless of the language used. This RV made me realized (cause I never really compared Ppop groups, I would compare Kpop songs with that of Sb19 since thats the usual issue), that SB19 is indeed authentic even in their musical arrangements. Maririning mo parin ang pinoy ballad sound sa mga kanta nila, then they make sure na yung sa mga songs nila, mixes are very minimal, kasi mas prefer nila nga vocals nila ang ma-eemphasize, na kapag kinanta live, it would sound evenly or much better.. Emphasis on vocals talaga which is their signature. SB19 resonates to listeners because they market talaga their vocals and the message of their songs. We cannot explain pero maririnig mo talaga yung papaging Filipino ng arrangements ng mga popular songs nila..Even Gento. Agree rin ako didto na SB19 truly retains the Filipino sound talaga. Kahit music plang nila, you will already feel the difference from Kpop. ☕️☕️☕️

SB19 does not simply sing their song, they do and see it as an art. They sing their song like telling a story, and very relatable

Another factor bgyo is bashed bcoz they came from a big network and can also be connected with politics…

Bgyo be blaming fans while my Alamat and Sb19 were focusing on their crafts and trusting the process that’s my boys!!!

If you want to know the truth try to watch the full video not the spliced version. There is a context behind there and if you are one of the OG & Mature PPOP fan you will know the reason behind their statement and FYI they didn't mention any particular group or fandom. That's what they feel and you guys doesnt have the rights to invalidate their feelings just because you dont like them. Its their right to hear their side of the stories against all the accusations thrown to them. You guys ask for respect for the artist you support but you disrespect other artist. You hate the bullies but what you are doing is bullying. Calling them pa victim,while invalidating their feelings.

Personally, I think Alamat has potential. I listen to Sb19 because they have more grit and passion and it shows in their songs. The videos and lyrics are relatable, and the hooks are sticking. The cinematography for Alamat and BGYO are a bit meh. Alamat at least has personality but they lack the level that SB has (perhaps because they're still young). You can tell the difference in vocal quality and tone in SB's members. BINI has the same thing and that's why they're clicking with audiences. Charisma is big factor and BGYO doesn't really have that (at least from what I've seen from them so far).

My problem with Alamat is they are stuck with banking on PH history and culture to sell music. Many of my friends do not like the idea of them pulling the nationalistic card all the time since it makes them feel less of a Filipino if they don't support their releases. Anyway, they are also too young for this concept. A more modern styling, music and fashion wise, would actually do them good.

Alamat & BGYO, kelangan makuha ninyo ang kiliti ng tao at dagdagan ang inyong marketing at promotion strategy, although mahirap pantayan ang SB19 kahit kayo pa ang nauna sa kanila. Iba sila, halos nasa kanila na lahat.

I watched some ppop MV's and performances. Yes, they are also good and I don't discredit them, but SB19 has something that others don't have. Ang music nila ay parang masarap na candy na swak sa panlasa na babalik-balikan mo sa tindahan para bilhin. But I support PPop bec i am a pinoy.

Can you pls talk tagalog nalang po… or taglish

Rather than 'pay their dues' it's more of Filipinos saying "No, we will not pay and work for you to oppress us anymore". Nah, he's not a reactor, he's a historian who acquiesce to the viewers' requests to react to the PPop MVs. All PPop group need all of their videos to have correct English CC, and not just their MVs so that viewers can connect w/them. History and culture helps to set apart from other groups, but yes the concepts needs to translate/connect with modernity too (as they DO and DID have fashion that combines history and culture to modern outfits) w/o going too PC (politically correct/UBER woke) nor political (SB19 were NEUTRAL during election i.e. they didn't voice out who they were voting for no did they ask the people to vote for a specific group/person). Another thing is, SB19 is an all-members ALL-ROUNDERS. All members CAN sing, dance, and rap. Sure NOT ALL OF THEM ARE GREAT in those individually, but they are PROFICIENT ENOUGH that they can do each others parts (whether song line, or dance parts) w/o much problem. They're authentic in their craft and with their interactions towards each other and with their staff and fans, and brands.

BGYO is a cookie cutter boy group with superficial pretty face + common/sub-par singing/dancing/performance skills.. They have nothing to offer that can match even a factor of what SB19 is capable of: from writing, to producing, to directing, to performing solidly live on stage! Plus SB19’s backstory of struggles, of coming from nothing and coming out victorious over it earned the respect of many vs. BGYO and newer groups that came after them with big networks backing them up complete with red carpet. I am an A’Tin and I truly hope there will be other groups who can be at the same level with SB19 to help them promote Filipino music globally. The “flag” SB19 waving now will be a lot lighter if joined by other groups who deserve to wave it too!

Basta wala silang mapa Crimzone Gento At PA high notes ni stell

bakit lahat nalang inaaway ng mga fans ng SB? BGYO, BINI, MNL48, HORI7ON, CALISTA, 1st.One, VXON, PLUUS, YGIG and KAIA. Kala ko ba Ppop rise bakit ayaw natun umangat ang ibang grupo?

As an A'TIN, I quickly stanned SB19 because of their struggle stories and genuine, unpolished interviews before they went big. Their realness made it easy to connect with them. New groups are launched too polished, with few interviews showing their true personalities, making it hard to connect. Talent and looks alone aren't enough; emotional connection is key. While new groups can capture attention with songs and looks, there needs to be something deeper for viewers to connect with. SB19 is unique because their initial look didn’t fit typical Pinoy standards, but their talent was undeniable. The more you got to know them through vlogs and interviews, the more you focused on their personalities and charm rather than their looks. Now, they are considered gorgeous, but it was their authenticity that stood out. New P-pop groups need more content showing their real, unpolished personalities. Trying to be perfect all the time makes it hard for viewers to connect. They should have more vlogs and interviews where people can relate to their stories and personalities. Many A'TIN don’t support SB19 just because of their songs; we support them individually no matter what they release. For example, Ken/Felip sold tickets for his "7sins" album concert before releasing the songs, and fans still bought them. This shows that SB19 and its members are strong brands, with loyal fans willing to support anything they do. That’s a deep level of trust and connection that new Ppop groups still need to work on.