Reality of Citizenship Bill (CAA) | Opinion by Dhruv Rathee 

2:11 Minorities in Bangladesh, Pakistan 3:36 Logic of 50+ Islamic countries 4:29 Reality of Hindu Rashtra 6:16 Assam and North Eastern Rights 7:43 Threat to National Security 8:46 Real Reasons behind CAB

Who is here after govt imply CAA today?

जिसको इस्लामिक राष्ट्र चहिये वो पाकिस्तान जाय,जिसको हिन्दू राष्ट्र जाईये वो कैलाश जाय,,,जिसे साथ मिलकर रहना है वे ,,बे भारत में रहे,,जय हिंद🙏🙏

Who is here after watching news? Present?

Kon kon Elvis wala video dekh kar aaya hai like karo 👇

The real question is 'Kya humare boat main vakahi jagha hai, ya hum khud he doob rahe hain ?'

If India is not a secular nation, then India is not India at all. -Atal Bihari Vajpayee

Who is here after implementation of CAA?

Who came here after CAA bill pass .....👋👋

They are giving citizenship to those who came in india before 2014 . Not inviting them to come to India and take the citizenship.

So,according to liberals,CAA is bad as all religions should be treated equally but UCC is bad too which actually is about treating all religions equally.🤣😂

One question to respected dhruv, If humko desh se nikala jayega tho konsi boat khali hai humra liya ??

Koun koun bill Laagu hone ke bad aya hai 😂

When Taliban took over afganistan i came to know why caa is required

Hindu not safe in Pakistan and afganistan Is Muslim not safe in Pakistan????

The lvl of brainwashing in this video🥲

CAA news dekh ke kon kon aya hain idhar 💀

Why only Hindus be secular, why not muslim showcase their secularism.

DHRUV , in this video you have just showed your liberal aspect . If you were fair then you must have mention that those people who were fleeing from the Islamic states for economic aspects should not be granted citizenship , how can a Muslim be persecuted on religious basis in Islamic states , they must be coming for economic reasons while non Muslims are persecuted , of which there are enough proof .

Where a Hindu refugee can settle otherthan India, can a Hindu peacefully live in Pakistan /Bangladesh / Afghanistan.

How many people are see this video after caa act was implemented. 👍

Two question.. 1)why there is drastically decreased number in minorities in Pakistan..Bangladesh and afganistan 2)why we need to give minority state to muslims...even they are in large number than Christian,Buddhist,parsi,and jain. Why we have to gave them special scholarship for them.. 3)If you guys want to secular people's in india..why muslim not follow indian law.. 4)Why there is OIC at international level for muslims.. I m not opposing this secular term just want the answers of this question.. 🙏

5:28 Desh ke asle freedom fighters I loved that line...

Kon kon CAA Lagu hone ke baad video dekhne aya hai ?

Accepting muslims immigrants India's demographics will change in less period and later they will demand sharia and resulted angain partition You cleverly explained boat logic but it can't curtail the fact that why partition happened in 1947 Sweden is the best example they accepted muslim immigrants, but now swedish facing clashes

With this Bill, National Tadiaar was conferred "international Tadipaar"

"hell is empty and all devils are here" -william Shakespeare

Meri boat aadhi kaat kr ek insaan 1947 mein alag hua tha. Aaj wo doob rha Hai to mein kya Karu?

नाव और देश में बहुत अंतर है, बात समुद्र में डूबने वाले 2 लोगों की नहीं, पर 2 करोड़ अवैध लोगों की है, और क्या ग्यारंटी है, कि 2 करोड़ अवैध लोग वापसी भी करेंगे ?

Where's anna hazare? I haven't seen him from last 6-7 years.

"If you have guts please have a debate on this topic with dr anand ranganathan...🔥🔥🔥🔥"

Nahi ban na bhai secular country, hindu rashtra ban na hai

अम्बेडकर जी ने भी कहा था जब तक हर हिंदू भारत और हर मूसलिम पाकिस्तान ने जाए ये ये विभाजन अपूर्ण है

Media sold out😚

1.Bjp is just distracting people's from the main issue. 👍 2. Just for creating their secure future of vote bank. 3. It leads to lack of resources for citizens of India. 4. This bill will break the main organ of the Indian constitution - secularity. It may creates a lot of imbalance in nation. Thanks @dhruvrathee for spreading awareness. And suggesting right direction in which this should be done.

We went CAA

CAA lagu ho gaya 11 march 2024 se

Wheather it will become the hindu rastra I dont know.......but looking at the price of onion india is certainly becoming a "Jain Rastra"

Dr bheem Rao Ambedkar never said that hindu and muslim can live together..

Are gadge . Agar muslims ko CAA mai jagah milegi toh Pakistani Islamic log bhi aajayenge .

“Sab milke yahan pakode talte hai…” bhaisaab gajab 👏 People don’t understand the heavy consequences of this act, “free ki citizenship”, there’s already unemployment at its peak and now you’re inviting others too, Indians should think neutrally about this, this will ruin the country further, think practically people!!! Only bcoz a particular community is protesting against this doesn’t make this act flawless or applicable, All of the Indians who love their country should protest against this, this is COMMON SENSE🙄

Watched this video after a week because of the Internet ban in Assam.

और जो खुले आम बंगलादेशी घुसपैठ कर चुके हैं वो पकौड़ा बेचेंगे या आपकी वीडियो को लाइक करेंगे.......🤔

Toh theory to rejected hai Partition toh ho gaya hai Pakistan muslim na Banya then why should we make India a secular What the rubbish logic is this

hamare desh ki boat mei extra jagah nhi h

India really needs uniform civil code in our country...when we need constitution to run smoothly there should be no discrimination regarding any caste creed or religion...this is for sure

Start Watching from 9:30 - nothing made better sense that those points ! First financial mess , economic mess, now migration mess , country is heading for a chaotic mess !

Saari underdeveloped muslim countries hi hain ...zyadatar

2024 me dekne wale like karein😅

7:10 pakoda talne ke liye bhi pyaz chahiye jiska value high hai Jo afford nehi Kar sakta hoon😂😔

Really. Is that the perfect analogy you gave in the beginning. One of the two has been thrown in water while the other jumped on his own. Being secular or unbiased doesn't mean you have to criticise everything government does. As for rest of the people seeking citizenship of India usual channel is still open. Please be impartial in your analysis. That's what diffrentiates you and I think that's why you started this whole thing.

Who is watching in 2024 March . Amit shat confirmed

Nowadays it's too difficult to understand the actual meaning nd information about any matter from news channels that's why I'm here to know what's CAA after the announcement.

Please go and watch the parliament arguement of j.sai Deepak an advocate of supreme court. where he clearly stated what exactly CAA interprets

Let me clear it, "Shia" are muslims. In Pakistan, we "sunni" and "shia" get education together, sit together, eat together. I have many "shia" friends. They are not discriminated. Yes, there are some people full of hate and illiteracy ( which are found in every country) who (for their political or anti pakistan agenda) try to create "shia" "sunni" discrimination but on the whole there is nothing such thing that " shia muslims are in danger in Pakistan". We all are muslims and we are brothers.

Itna dard ho raha hai to bacchon ki kar raha hai kya to khud hi neta ban 🤣🤣🤣

You don't misguide us mr. Druv rathi😤

*I'm a Muslim & a biker and I've given lifts to many people but never asked them about thier religion not even name!*

Ideally no one should be allowed to enter in the country.

Hindu dominant country name : India Muslim dominant countries : 49 Total 2014 ke pehle jitne bhi religions India migrate hue h expect Muslims majorly Hinduism followers hain or Hindu dominant ek hi country hai clear hai ? Iska matlb kya hota hai ? agar bhaar desh mein Hinduism believers ko problem ho rhi hai toh unke liye last option kya bachta hai ? Bharat ham asliyat mein bhartiya Hindun hain !!! Or bharat hame bachayega Yaha Tak clear hoga ab Rahi baat Muslims ki !!! Muslims ke pass multiple countries hain vo Kyun hain vo clear karta hun bharat mein cast factor hai agar bharat mein minorities ko exploit kra jayega toh kya ?? USA JAPAN RUSSIA UNKO Easy citizenship denge ya pakistan hi dega ? Unko Hindu minorities cast se kya mtlb ? ye ex tb hai agar bharat mein lower caste minority ho tb Abhi majority mein hai vese hi Bangla desh pakistan jese desho mein siyah Muslim minorities mein hain Or sunni Muslims majority mein. Hai. ab agar bharat in desho ke un Muslims ko bharat mein sharan dega Jo ki casteism ki wajah se pareshan hokar India mein gair kanooni roop se India aaye hain isse bharat par kya fark padega farak ye padega ki law religions ke basis par citizenship dera hai agar apko Muslim casteism ki wajah se ek desh mein pareshani hori hai toh ya toh aap wapas apne desh jaakr protest karo ya Ese desh mein jaao jaha casteism siyah sunni ki wajah se minorities Muslims ko dekha jara ho !!! Samudra Muslims logo se bhara hua hai bhyiii !!! Ek naav mein Muslim already bhar rakhe hain or Hindu bhi bhar rakhe hain par jb pura samudra Muslims ka hi hai toh fir ham Hindus ko kyun exploit hone dein jb le deke unka ek hi sahara hai Rahi baat humanity ki or religion ki religion mein or cast mein Bohot jyada farak hai!!! Ham Muslim majorities ko jo ki all over world mein hai unko bharat mein jagah de hi nhi skte!! vo casteism ki wajah se pareshan hain or Hindu religion ki wajah se !!! to nav wala example mt hi do Dhruv rathee better hoga

Great work bro. May Almighty guide you.

5:06 bro i have lived in Usa and japan, they r not as secular as they show,there is not even one national holiday for people of any other religion other than christianity and buddhism that is there majority religion,even us currency got printed in god we trust as a symbol

Peolple who came after partion of India are not refugess they are indian so please change the line.....

4:46 hum ye nhi kehte ki india ko hindu rashtra bnao hum ye khte hai ki india ko non muslim rashtra bnao

Very wrong! Pakistan Bangladesh and Afghanistan majorly Muslim population hai. Aur minority mein Hindu jews Christ Buddhists etc. This bill is totally about to give indian citizen to these minority which was prosecuted in these countries.

U missed the point 5 : West Bengal elections ...

I don't think we are inviting people. The peope who were in India before 31st Dec 2014 and will be in India till 31st Dec 2019 will be given the citizenship.

Aur phir woh boat mei 2 ko bachaya aur phir woh muslim dono hindu ko maar kar samandar mei phek dia aur chala gya

Subhas chandra bose ne toh ye bhi kaha tha ki kuch time Tak democracy nhi hogi

We never have to fight we have to became a happy family

Bhaar ke desho me itni jaldi Visa nhi milta or Ye log citizen bill de rahe hai sidha Wah !

*Just wondering…why did BJP/ Hindus agree to taking on the burden of accommodating Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, Parsi-Zoroastrians & Christians too?*

CAA and NRC are much needed in todays time 🔥

The video misses out on several points. Some of the points that it has missed are listed below; 1.) The Act just provides citizenship to individuals from 3 countries belonging to 6 religion who were prosecuted on the basis of religion. 2.) It doesn't bar anyone from any other country practising any religion from getting citizenship in India, such people can still apply and get citizenship through old citizenship laws (This is the point which has been missed by everyone who assumes that the bill is against secularism). So if you say that Shias and Ahmadis from Pakistan will not be provided citizenship if they apply is not true 3.) The bill has set a cut off date of 31st December 2014. So anyone else (even the people from the 6 religious group mentioned in the act) have entered after or on 1st January 2015 will not be considered under the 2019 act.

Not only hindus, there are Sikh, Jain, parsi, christian, how come Hindu Rashtra?

I am seen today 12/03/24 😮 really this law our nation very dangerous

I hate Dhruv . 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰 SHARIA 🇦🇫🇦🇫🇦🇫 Sharia No rights to minority Because they are muslim . Karma tum logo ko Madad na karo toh tumhari bhi koi madad na jare

finally i have started believing that Arvind kejriwal is the only good guy left in politics

Government creating new issues to hide/ignore the current issues.

Aap bahut accha bolte ho hakh ki bat karte ho... youtube me ek aap hi ho jisper mujhe yakeen hai aur jise mai follow karti hun ur great i will support you

Bhai itne Rohingyas hai India me unke liye ye nahi bol payega 😅😅😅

Real India can only be understood through experience not through books ..and judgements 😐

Two nation was proposed by savarkar and then implimented by Jinnah...they both are equally responsible for what ever happened from 1948 till date...my openion

Bro didnt he just gave a point a helping everyone, nd then just went back on point that we can't help everyone and problem of that it can also lead to security issues😅

Don't foolish the people read the CAA properly

Common man: Supreme Court has given it’s verdict in Ayodhya issue. No more Hindu Muslim politics. BJP: hold my CAB

Bhai apki soch mujse milti ha poori i also dont want any discrimination in my india related to any relagion Acc. To me relgion ruins humanity💔

Sanathan Dharma is above everything.....😊

you are spreading propaganda. in the bill is mentioned that those people who came here before 2014 shirf unhi logo ko citizenship milega. lekin aapne end main kaha ki "iss bill ki madat se koi bhi aake citizenship le lega, free main citizenship bata ja raha hai". lekin ye to nhi hai na

I just want to say what I have understood after watching channels like these. It's not good to have one sided opinions. We should research ourselves before believing anyone. Remember people who have the power to influence can use it in a wrong way. Whether it's about CAA, Modi or anything else, it's better to hear facts from multiple sources. There are people who just work for money. So, it's imperative that we ourselves go through the primary source and form our opinion.

5:27 Desh ke sare "asli" freedom fighters 😀 very good choice of words 👍✌

Who is after watching the news?

Biggest problems of India : -Overproudness -Poverty -Low GDP per capita -Surrounded by enemy countries Developments of India : -Development in Technology -Manpower -Slow implementation of UCC (It's being implemented in a few states one by one) -Good relations with almost every country -Secular Thanks, Dhruv for letting us know the truth about everything.

Modi:" blocks and shuts down the net" Still modi: tweets for all the north people Logic level 9999999

Contradicting your own point in the same video..... u said that there is enough space in boat for 5 people .....then u said that there is already so poverty in india that where are we going to accomodate these minority people ..... but i agree with ur nrc + cab fact.....that would be disastrous..

भारत को एक जर्मन नागरिक से नही सीखना है कि भारत क्या करे

watching this again on 12 march 2024

0:35 What??? You said kaafi jagah hai Our country is already densely populated (over populated) Hamare desh me jameen ke hisab se jarurat se jyada log hai Ye CAB ki jagah 1child policy aani chahiye thi 1child policy>>>CAB

Did you just talked about Singapore as secular.. You arr not allowed to prey in singapore..😒😒.. You can't preach another religion in singapore. Only some manasteries are allowed but only inside their area.. Outside you are not given freedom to even pray 😕😕

Toh kya bhai sabka theka India ne liya hai???😂