Red Dead Redemption 2 Comparison - Xbox One X vs. Xbox One S vs. Xbox One 

Looked surprisingly good on the S

As a proud OG Xbox one owner, I am very happy about this. Update: I’ve sunk in over 5 hours of this game so far and I’m blown away by the results coming from the OG Xbox one. Anybody else getting it on the same platform will not be disappointed.

S better than normal xbox one

Is it just me or the only difference I am seeing is the color temperature. Looks warmer to the S and cooler to the X. Or maybe its because of the dynamic weather feature? Anyway, both looks good to be honest.

This pleases me as somebody who owns an original xbox one and pre ordered

1 XBOX ONE X 2 XBOX ONE S 3 XBOX ONE

Xbox One X version is even better than ps4 pro...unsurprisingly

I play Red Dead 2 on the Xbox One S, and it looks great and performs good, just good. The FPS lock is at 30, and that 30 holds quite well anywhere where there isn't tons of scenery to be loaded in. The FPS suffers quite a bit when I'm in Saint Denis or Blackwater, otherwise, though, the Xbox One S is a great choice for Red Dead.

i have the one s . i wanted to see if the S looked better than the one . the one S chip is overclocked, making it a little better than the one .

He kept saying its decent on the regular one. It looks almost the exact same 😂😂😂

great video, as a xbox one owner I can say that Im happy that the graphics are not that bad

I own both Xbox one S and ps4 pro so I’m not one sided, don’t see much of a difference. Just a masterpiece of a game

You can get a One S brand new w/ a controller for $190 on ebay now (used for about $150-160). 4k BR/media player, and a solid gaming console. The value is off the charts. Are you going to get top notch graphics? Of course not, but for $190? It's a great deal, and games look great on pretty much any machine this generation imo.

I bought a XB1S cause I dont have a 4k TV :'v. But the game looks amazing in One S, I'm Glad :'D.

While it's obvious that XBOX ONE X looks the best I can't say that other 2 counterparts are bad... All 3 are really close except if you are "picky"

Bro I’m deadass in love with the bayou part of the map

This video could’ve been summed up and over in 3 minutes with: “the One X can render in background objects that are often blurred on older consoles, very clear at a much further distance.”

I'm so glad I can't really tell the difference

Absolutely incredible up-scaling on the One S. To the point where the average person may not know the difference between it and the X depending on where you are in the game. I mean, many of us have been saying this from the beginning, but let it be known: The One S's upscaling is better than even the built-in scaling on the highest quality TV's you can buy. That's no joke.

Can we run red dead redemption 2 on Xbox one (2013)

They all look really good and at times the S and X look identical. Since the one X dosent run a true native 4k but something close to it still looks super good!

I own all three units, and for the most part it’s cool to see that the older units hold up well

XB1X IS THE BEST 👏👏👍

Well done. This is the information I was looking for. Thank you.

They've done a really good job on optimising the game on the OG Xbox One & One S. Would not upgrade consoles for such a small graphics difference. (Especially if you had a One S with a HDR Enabled TV)

Bought the X specifically for this game! It's unbelievable how good it looks. The volumetric lighting is the best I've ever seen. Totally solid fps too.

Not only is it a solid 30 fps, but the One X version is running w/4K textures & at native 4k!

Only on Xbox one X in 4k.

Thank you,I have one s and you made me feel better about it :-)

Xb1x: brighter brights, darker darks and more lively environment Xb1s: darker overall, kinda feels like they took the game and added the colour spectrum of an iPhone 4 camera Xb1: same, but iPhone 6 camera

Brought this on PS4 on release and just upgraded my S too an Xbox one X - is worth buying again for the graphics/does look that good??

The game already looks so nice that you don’t need better graphics

I´ve got it on the One S. Objects at distance are a bit blurry. It doesn´t look bad, Witcher 3 level I would say. My biggest issue is that the framerate drops in the bigger cities. It´s a bit of a downer. Other than that, amazing game.

the hair on the mans head is not a selling point for the x. The problem you end up noticing on the x in general is that things like that look better and sharper, but it's still stiff. Pro is the same thing. Yeah they look better, but the static nature of most things is also more apparent because they are so sharp and in focus.

Looks amazing in all 3, why u be saying looks great in X and DECENT in the S and base?

Thanks for the Video guys. It is what I was looking for

I'm playing this on my 1X right now and it's fucking crazy how it looks, holy shit and I'm not even on a 4K TV yet.

Big difference with the Xbox one x unless your bong eyed

Who else has an OG xbox

Resolution on One S? 1920x1080? Or 900p?

Phew. Thanks for this video I was really salty that its not coming out on PC as I only have xbox one. Thought the graphics were going to be awful but they're not too bad. You have put me at ease.

1- xbox one s 2-xbox one x 3- xbox one

The One S looks real good too . Its a lot brighter than the One X , which I play on . Hmmm, anyway . Great job Rockstar !!

Monster Hunter World runs at 864p with worst graphics and unestable Framerate on Xbox one, so it's fine that this game runs at 864p and mostly stable performance on the base Xbox One, and I enjoy it, is the same thing that happens with the original Red Dead Redemption on PS3 wich have lower resolution than 720p and blurried AA and sells pretty well and was a 10/10 Game. Resolution doesn't matter to enjoy this beautiful game

Xbox One X 3840 x 2160 PS4 Pro. 1920 x 2160 PS4. 1920 x 1080 Xbox One S 1536 x 864 :''(

Xbox One S seems like the perfect one for me. It's sharp enough and detailed enough but still very cinematic while Series X is too clean.....

Honestly I can't really tell a difference

i got a xbox one fat +1 controller and 2 dvd games for $120usd. It still can run new gen lol

I mean really, o honestly can't see the difference, is that what you are supposed to pay two times more for?

The OG xbox one holds up well. Really not a huge difference between the s and the original. Maybe just some lighting changes. But when you compare to the x. Then that's a whole other story.

Xbox one X Xbox one Xbox one S S have like green and grey graphisc....

This game is still world class on Xbox One X. Just wish it would receive some kind of upgrade for Series X.

I have both the Xbox One and One S and I was considering selling both for either an Xbox One X or a PS4 Pro but after watching this video I decided not to.

The only thing I can really notice is the grass but that doesn't really matter as long as you're sitting far away from the TV

I can see x is beter than s, but with my 1080p tv its is not worth the 350 EUR upgrade

I have a 4K tv with the Xbox one s running 4K up scalling. The s is a big jump from the Xbox one in quality and for the half the price of the Xbox one x, you can’t go wrong cause the quality is so hard not to be disappointed.

I never usually notice framerates because I've been a console gamer all my life but on the og xbox it's so noticable because the graphics are so good, so its extremely jarring even you look around and it's so choppy. Not to mention everything is very washed out and low definition at far distances. Really makes me want to buy an xbox one x

I think I'm more upset about the fact that the Xbox One regular and S version only ouput 864p. How is it that the X version didn't need any downscaling but the S version was considered weak enough to require downscaling it a bit? I know there's a world of difference between Forza Horizon 3's 1080P and 30 FPS and RDR2, but it seems to me they could at least have given non-X owners 1080P resolution. It honestly should be standard these days. The Xbox One isn't an Xbox 360 that it still can't output at the MINIMUM 1080P. Although that probably explains why even the X is an improvement on 1080P TVs, since it allows the game to at least be ouput at 1080P as opposed to lower resolutions. I would assume. Did they say how how the resolution is on the X on a 1080P TV?

I got a normal Xbox one I bought 350€ with a game 3years ago. This way I can wait for rdr2 on PC to play in ultra 1080p 60fps 😂 Don't say consoles are better

I'm definitely buying a Xbox One X and a 4K TV... But just after my OG Xbox One breaks... 4 years and some months with me and it still runs games pretty well.

Thanks for doing the 1S too I haven't seen anybody else do a video on it. But it seems like It is better than the regular xbox one. Can anybody tell me how the 1s stacks in comparison? Like 1x is best, than what ps4 pro? then 1s? can anyone confirm?

It looks like they optimized it for the S but not the X, so the X is basically running it like the OG would. Honestly the difference is pretty negligible, as an OG owner this doesn’t make me feel like upgrading is worth it.

How is total disc on xbox one?

This was exactly what I was looking for, a side by side of all three because I own all three and wanted to know which one i should use for what.

why xbox one s looks better than xbox one

honestly as long as the frame-rate doesn't dip too much below 30 on my standard xbox one I'll still enjoy this loads

O xbox one x tem mais detalhes na textura, mas em ambientes claros, o xbox one s tem mais vantagem, pois da tem mais brilho de sua roupa e da textura por causa do sol, pra quem gosta de apreciar a textura e detalhes bem feitos, o xbox one x é mais doque perfeito, mas se vc gosta de ver a ambientação e um grafico mais alegre e claro, o xbox one s seria uma otima escolha Minha opinião

I love how it looks in game on the x but for some reason I like how its alittle blurry in the cutscenes on the og xbox. For some reason it seems more realistic. You guys probably think I'm dumb af lmao

Running regular xb1 here! And for me not buy 864p to play masterpiece of game until upgrade!! EDIT:make the dessition and buy it already playing right now and just can say this game of the year 10/10 masterpiece😍

The xbox one 2013 was still kicki'n bruh, to play this new generation video game xbox one 2013 can still handle it perfectly.

WTF... 30 FPS... next gen... it's soooo 2018. 30 FPS is far from smooth.

OK I'm not even gonna be worry about Xbox One X anymore.. you're basically getting better resolution. And to really see the difference you need 4K which I don't... have to stick with my 70inch 1080p

Yo tengo xbox One s

Why is everyone arguing on which is better? Everyone keeps saying how bad it is on xbx1/s but is no one gonna talk about gta the defenitive eddition or cyberpunk 2077? The graphics in rdr2 are slightly changed on each console but everyone still argues about it.

but the S only does 864p..... all playstation run it at 1080p..... lol

Phew, I thought the one might have had Just Cause 3 framerate all over again

All xbox nice

The X version is a little better than the S version...But is it $200 dollars better as thats about what the X cost more than the S

honestly xbox 1 looks better than s LMAOO

Got the One X today... and RDR2 I gotta say, this game is astonishingly beautiful. Extremely impressive and after trading in my OneS and getting the special deal Gamestop is running, I saved 200$ on this OneX. That’s right. Worth it.

Will the game have launch for xbox360? I have xbox 360 elite.

Interesting. Are they all capped at the same FPS and resolution? X looks better overall, but in some scenes there's hardly any difference. HDR seems to make a nice difference in some pics; way more colors presented in the S and X compared to the One.

People who dont buy a console because there is one second it drops on 29fps is just dumb..😂 And it looks good on all systems

i can only imagine running this on my PC :3

Buying an Xbox for Dolby Vision and Atmos support in Netflix... Question is, is it worth the steep price hike for the X over the S ? I mean, games look better but... that is a huge price difference for graphics that may only be noticed when compared side-by-side.

X box A, X box B, X box C, x box D, X box E, x box F, x box G, x box H, x box I, x box J,x box k etc...

What are the resolutions on each? I hope RDR2 can be played in 1080p on the Xbox One (first gen.)!

I don't even have 20/20 eye vision and I'm so happy w/ life it must be why I'm so lucky for choosing only one console PS4. Games and graphics are fuxn cool and plus fixing your tv settings it's all greatness

Whats the resolution of the one s? What resolution does it upscale? Or is the one s just at 1080p?

I like how misty and smooth it looks on the regular Xbox one. Performance might be lower but I like the way it looks most

no big difererences @ 1080p, 6 GFLOPS and i dont see a really big diference

Playing fallout 4 on Xbox One and Xbox One s is pretty different too

Here's the bottom line, if you don't have a 4k tv then there's no need for an Xbox one x. All versions look spectacular honestly and you can't go wrong either way. Just enjoy the game on whatever system you have.

Little help please, I've never owned any Xbox system I've always been and will be a PlayStation fan but there are some Xbox exclusives that I want to play so I'm going to break down and get a Xbox just don't know if I should get the One S or One X. As of Right now I Do Not have a 4K HDR TV and won't be getting one for at least a year, by that time it will be a lot closer to the Xbox 2 release date, that being said should I get the Xbox One S which I can get Brand New for $200.00 and it's a 1TB console or spend the extra $250 Plus for the One X??

This game is native 4k on the x? That's crazy. The next consoles should hit 4k natively if this is the case.

When the online comes out will people that own the original one can still play with people on the one S and one X???

Don’t know why you include the s it’s just a smaller normal Xbox one

I do not understand how that difference was so great in Monster Hunter. I have the Xbox One OG I do not understand

To reduce blurriness on base Xbox one or one s turn the sharpness all the way up in the settings menu of the game

I have an xbox one x and I can tell you its beautiful but this test is bs you can see the difference but the video is not in 4k, so you can't see how much of a difference it is between