@@chyuck8915 원래는 프로는 프로다워야 한다고 비하인드에서 일어나는 일은 보여줄 의무가 없다고 생각했던 것 같은데 음악의 소비 기간은 줄어들고 그만큼 음미하고 분석하는 소비자도 줄어들고 어필하는 시대가 되다보니 슴도 걍 공개하기로 한 것 같네요.. 공개 안 하던 시절 가수들이 덜 잘하던 것고 아니고 그 때 작업물들이 대충이었던 것도 아니고 걍 대중들이 떠먹여주지 않으면 알려고 하지 않는 시대임
@@user-wq7rz6nk9z 멤버 모두 다 잘하지만 마지막 후렴구 다들 힘들게 부르는데 웬디 혼자 웃으면서 여유롭게 부르는데 어나더클래스는 맞다고 생각함 그리고 고음 이나 코러스 등등 분량 제일 많은거랑 라이브 기복도 거의 없는거 보면 못한다는 소리는 절대 안나올 실력은 맞음
A lot of SM groups do, SHINee and Red Velvet are the most overall vocally competent groups from SM that generally do their own backing vocals & sing the chorus together.
Yeah, all SM groups harmonizes for their chorus. Sometimes someone will take the lead or their voice is placed more forward in the recording, but SM has always done group harmonies for chorus
@@zoria4520 I don't think this person is talking about real resonance here . Probably talkinh about their harmony and hoe they blend so well with each other .
There are other groups that also have great vocalists but oh my Gosh, when we talk about harmonization none compare to Red Velvet, it's five voices that sound like a complete choir, even just two voices already sound like a choir, there are in several songs, including Irene and Yeri harmonizing while team Rocket do their parts and it's amazing, who says they're subvocalists and rappers? If there was an award in the vocals category they would win every year.
What surprises me most about RV is that their vocalists are on very different levels, yet they blend together. Even with Irene and Yeri not being very strong vocalists, they have very recognizeable and pleasant vocals.
I swear adding Yeri in the group really add colourful harmony that RV have compared to when they debuted as 4 back in 2014 if u listen to Happiness backtrack vocal.
3:02 부터 미쳤다 .. 내 개인적인 생각이지만 레드벨벳 목소리 합이 제일 좋은 것 같음 .. 연차가 쌓이면 쌓일수록 노래도 너무 좋고 성적도 좋고 무엇보다도 레드벨벳이 활동할때 너무 행복해보이고 좀 더 단단해지는 느낌이여서 3세대 걸그룹 중 오래 활동할 것 같은 그룹 중 하나임
Producers heaven. Each singer can make her own layers with ease, and you have also a complete harmony of power and tones for the group vocals at your disposal. You don't have to touch anything. Now I understand why the vocal arrangements are always so deep and complex in Red Velvet songs. They do it because they can. It's common a producer asking a singer "do you think we can do...", and the answer from these five members is always "yes". They can do it all, and then you have Wendy's absolute prodigy and all becomes just unfair in the industry.
Dame Diddy from The Report Card Reactions put it perfectly... "Wendy is the only Kpop Idol that you can actually *hear* her smiling throught the microphone while she's singing."
레코딩 비하인드 보면서 느낀 건 노래도 이 정도 수준인데 춤부터 비주얼까지 종합 예술의 끝판왕이란 생각이 들었음... 아직도 아이돌 산업을 폄하하는 시선들이 있고 어떤 측면에서 그러는 건지 잘 알고 있지만 그럼에도 불구하고 매번 실력과 예술성을 놓치지 않는 레드벨벳과 같은 그룹들이 있기에 수준 높은 작품이 될 수 있지 않나 싶음
SM Entertainment man. They are admittedly trash in treating their artists but finding each individual and forming them together in groups is chef's kiss.
actually hybe is worst at treating artist. They just disbanded gfriend, debuting bullies and threatening victims by sueing, don't say anything about p3do.
