well no one can deny wendy's vocal ability but she's just saying it as her preference.everyone has their own preference. I really like wendy's voice because it's powerful but i prefer joy's vocal color more.
Although Wendy's vocal technique is admirable that's why she stood out but the voices of the other two lovely girls is magical I must say. Seulgi's voice is very soulful, magical and distinctive as well as Joy's voice, it is full of emotions and her technique is not just suited for trot singing it fits beautifully in this song. Kudos to this sub-unit SeulWenJoy!
Same for Wendy. Full of soul and emotion on top of an amazing technique. NO ONE in Kpop sounds like Wendy. She also can sound different on every song. She's very agile and versatile. Seulgi and Joy sound great as well. They also sound similar to each other and like other vocalists in Kpop.
@@joythinker739 Wendy and Irene have a similar tone, but you know damn well Irene can't do what Wendy does as a vocalist. A three second line does not equate to what Wendy can do as a vocalist from track to track. I've always said Wendy and Irene have a similar tone, but my comment was about how Wendy sings overall. NO ONE can sing like her in Kpop and I stand by that.
Wooow.. Some salty solo stans are so mad that many comments praising Joy's vocals. The girl just gets what she really deserves after all. Joy's voice is so soulful. It can make you feel happy or make you cry
@@eyebrowstj I'm not but Joy is my bias. But at least I'm not like you who always come for comments praising Joy's vocals or stage presence to spread negativity. I never throw shade on a member to praise my bias like you. You're the one who got so mad that most comments here are about Joy
@@abyrea1453 Joy is one of my fav idols and vocalists in Kpop. I'm actually listening to her right now 😂😂 😂 My issue is always with Red Velvet fans under RU-vid videos. I am just joining in on the insanity of this fandom! I'm pretty used to it now 😂😂😂
@@eyebrowstj people have their preferences and they're free to praise whoever they want. It's not insanity and please stop saying wendy is underrated while she has almost 1m monthly listeners on spotify. The fans know so well how powerful vocalist is wendy so when the talk more about other members' vocals it's because they are the underrated ones when it comes to singing abilities
Love it when Red Velvet do ballads. Still wish Yeri and irene sang even a few lines with them here even though they're not the main vocalists but that would've been lit
RV's songs from 2016 were something else, especially ballad songs Miss their old songs so much, I've barely follow them since Power Up era wish JoWenSeul could be an official sub-unit
소중했던 사람이랑 연락의 기약도 없이 헤어져본 경험이 있어서 그런지 이 노래 가사 하나하나가 제 마음을 찌르는 부분이 있네요.."그대의 멀어지는 모습 그대로 더이상 잡을 수 없네" 장미라고 하면 기쁜 날 사랑하는 사람에게 주는 꽃다발에 사용되는 화려한 꽃이라고만 생각했는데 장미꽃 향기가 이렇게 쓸쓸한 분위기를 낼 수가 있다니..ㅠㅠ 앞으로 이 노래를 들을 때마다 보고 싶은 사람이 생각날 거 같아요. 레드벨벳 분들 리메이크 버전 너무 좋아요
@mr_godman it really shouldn't seeing as I AM a Muslim. I just don't see the relevancy of what people said here. Honestly, the way they said it makes MY religion look bad
Opposite for me! Wendy on a whole other level with her singing than the others, but I do love Seulgi and Joy's voices as well. How anyone can not choose Wendy as their vocal bias is beyond me. LOL!
As someone who lost my significant other this year, this song always makes me cry and remember her. I’ve been listening to red velvet since 2015 and I will never, never stop listening to their music. It moves me so deeply
Navillera Buddy when some members ( usually 2-3 ) form a smaller group with their own songs albums and performances. Popular examples would be Exo- CBX ( chen baekhyun and xiumin ) or snsd- TTS ( taeyeon tiffany and seohyun )
An autumn sunday afternoon listening to rise scent breeze laying in my bed with no lights on only my phone screen's... I feel so light in my heart right now. Only red velvet makes me feel like this, only their music warms my heart. I love you my angels. Thank you for your art.
if red velvet were to go on immortal song they should definitely sing this song and their other songs. it would really show the public that rv deos not only sing upbeat songs and that they are capable of doing any song especially ballads. it will also show their vocals more and why they r the most musically interesting group in kpop.
okay. this song is so shooting. I’m so proud of them , they have beautiful and soft voices. My heart is pounding and I feeling like i’m in heaven. Let me please :))
Saying they appreciate Wendy's vocal isn't complaining. Please do accept that other ppl might like Wendy's or Joy's more. I think people think Wendy's vocal are slept on because kpop usually stan visuals more than talents. It's shallow but it's reality for the kpop industry.
@@amusedtofu why would you comment without understanding? People are commenting about how wendy should be appreciated but also complaining that joy gets more appreciation. Joy is talented too. I know wendy is underrated so you could just compliment her and say she should be appreciated but people are trying to put her up by pulling joy down. So that's not nice. And your reply is invalid.
@@amusedtofu also sorry for being rude😅 a year ago when I commented this people were being mean to joy stans and saying wendy should be rated higher than joy which is not true cause both of them are talented and should be loved equally. A year later there are much nicer comments which is good for the fandom. Reveluvs have really evolved.
