Are people really hating on them for having "unstable" vocals while they're singing a fast-paced song live and doing heavy choreography. The reason you find it "unstable" is because you're all used to lip-syncing girl groups who never have their mics turned on. Give Red Velvet the credit they deserve.
i’d prefer to listen to someone lipsyncing during an award show, since they’re going to be constantly promoting the song, they’re gonna get tired and get unstable, but still good job rv for singing live
I rarely comment but I think that Joy is the hidden diamond in RV. Like seriously, she wasn't even in SM rookies, not that I know of, and Joy said that Yeri has been with SM longer than her, but I think SM had one of the best decisions to have her in. She could sing really well (watcher candy or something crazy live), rap, and has SUPPPERRBB CHARISMA . And she's also a bias at first sight!!!
Definitely giving credit where it's deserved. These girls are hitting every move with live vocals which is more than what a lot of other idols groups can do.
Jonathan Campos I have to agree that Mamamoo's choreography isn't as energy consuming as Red Velvet's, but this definitely doesn't mean that it's "easy for them to sound great." Mamamoo is a group of talented vocalists who (I personally think) are, as a group, better singers than Red Velvet. I love RV, but Mamamoo really takes singing to a whole different level. Give credit where it's deserved ^_^
Mister Wang Preme 2 years later and she's still not getting any recognition like she deserves and it's honestly shocking to me! I shudder at the thought of RV without Wendy!
JOY is LOVE. She's a triple treat and I can't wait for her to develop more. She's so energetic she always makes me smile. I usually like idols who are triple treats. Good job RV!
Automatic is my favorite song from Red Velvet. Everything about it is perfect! It made me fall in love with Seulgi's voice ^_~ I love the smooth.velvety side of RV more but I also like the red, bright side too. At first I thought.. what kind of name is Red Velvet?! lol.. But this is a genius concept.. I hope they keep doing both concepts because it works for them. Btw I never would've guessed that it was Irene who did that badass rap in Ice Cream Cake! It was surprising to hear that coming from such a cute girl lol! Irene is so pretty (^o^)
I agree! I was just as surprised by Irene. She is a gorgeous woman. Automatic and Candy are my favorite songs of RV. Ice cream cake and stupid cupid fall second but either way, they surprisingly had very very good music for their FIRST ep. I remember not liking GG's first album because it was too... sweet? I'm a sone for lofe, so I get to have freedom of my opinion. I have all their albums so no one jumps down a bitches throat lol. But I really like the concept RV has. The bright and bold of Red, the sultry and classy of Velvet, it's a great combination, I hope they continue this. It's BRILLIANT!
Yul Nguyen Next time you tell someone Inkigayo live performances aren't actually live and they call you a crazy conspiracy theorist, you can link them to this video.
Red Velvet is really an amazing group. Even if the notes are hit al the way and it doesn't sound completely right they still make sure to actually sing from beginning to end without lip-sinking. Got give them props. That's hard especially when you have to dance well too. Congrats Red Velvet!!!
In ice cream cake, Irene's sweat shirt goes from up to down in microseconds.. just pointing out how this is several takes spliced together and one of the reasons for the fast camera.
i think every kpop stan should be reminded of this era when they're talking abt "duality" i mean RV pulled these 2 different concept off so good and the fact that this is their first ep is truly amazing!!!
Seulgi's gaze in automatic! As well as WenSeul Vocals! And RV's visuals! I really love this song too bad that many people doesn't know how to appreciate beautiful things like Velvet side
The edge of this group among all the girlgroups today, is that they can sing live while dancing to a difficult choreography. Unlike others, their choreography is already easy but they still do lip synching😢 Fans cannot even recognize talent and skills over pretty face.
Red Velvet slay as usual~~~ Irene-Beautiful Seulgi-Gorgeous Wendy-Lovely Joy-Pretty Yeri-Cute And Irene chest is pretty much the Ice Cream Cake XD XD XD
am i the only one who thinks irene's rap is really awkward live? I still love her though, they always sing live even with such difficult choreo, proud of them!!
this choreography is much more difficult and exhausting compared to happiness, yet they still manage to sing live and actually sound good. that is very impressive, gotta give them some credits.
I'm pretty sure that Yeri was a popular girl back then, I can see it clearly in her moves. She is seriously confident. And she should be. When she first got into group I didn't think she is good but now she is my bias. She is the best dancer among them, and her voice is so cute that it relaxes me. Also her facial expressions is always on point, just like a professional but she is only 17 with Korean age. Yeri fighting!
They're really good! People need to realize that these girls haven't been doing this for a long time and judging them with a magnifying glass isn't going to help people's blood pressure either. Red Velvet isn't SHINee or Girls Generation, they can't dance and sing while be perfectly in-tune (yet), and since they only have five members, they definitely have less window room to breathe. These girls are doing well in their own regard and I'm so happy that they still look flawless after doing those difficult dance moves and high notes.
Ommmgg my Goddess Irene why must you kill me everytime.... srsly >< i cant handle ( love her hair style btw its so cute but i like the one in mv xD it was pretty ) and i was also waiting for them to wear these outfits these were my fave cause of the tops and skirts had a nice look to them Red velvet you are really doing a great job
They are sing live with the choreography like that? i must say they are not a rookie anymore, the dance move is really fast&energic,but they can dance perfectly with live singing, RV daebak
I want to see them perform the full song of Automatic so bad. I know for a fact there is a full dance for the song because I watched the Behind The Scenes. Why SM? .______.
Poor my girls... 2 comebacks days straightly, amd then SM Town in Taiwan, yet they came back within the night to prepare another stage at Inkigayo, yet they still all look gorgeous... Himnae Woori Red Velvet, SM's maknae... SM stans will be here to cheer u upppp
Some examples Joy •Good singer •Rapper •Great Dancer Jungkook •Good singer •Rapper •Dancer Some examples for Irene and Yongguk Irene •Leader •Gummy Smile •Like a mom to members •Rapper Yongguk •Leader •Gummy smile •Like a father to members •rapper
I know other girl groups do this too but with Red Velvet I'm mostly surprised: these girls can jump from the cute scene to the sexy scene and back to the cute scene! And all their songs are great like :O Red Velvet is amazing and I'm happy they have a new member ^^ Fighting!!
