Redesigning the Light Monsters 

Quite interesting to see how divided everyone is on the idea of redesigned Light Monsters!

But, The whole reason the light island monsters were different shades of gray is because they’re supposed to represent each color of the rainbow

Creeptanium: "All of the Wublins would suck of they were all green" Also Creeptanium: *Makes all of the redesigns grey.*

I really liked your resesigns! But having them all be the EXACT same shades of gray is kinda off putting, what if they still had a really little bit of color but were a lot darker, so the light pops even more? or they look kinda like blacklights, still really cool tho!

Gob spewing out a red light makes it look like a spawner of nightmares...

I honestly don’t think that making everything grey is very “pleasing to the eye” the light monsters already look good, not all cold monsters have the exact same colour palette so doing this with the light monsters wouldn’t make the much better, yes this does make their theme a bit more obvious but draining them of all colour just takes away all their personality I’d say keep the colour they had and just making their light more prominent would be better. Also with fluoress they are a pure light elemental making them light up in all colours of the rainbow meaning they’re just using green for the sake of someone being green. This is not meant to be hateful I’m just trying to share my opinion so I’m sorry if I came off as a bit rude I’m fine if you do think these designs are better than the originals please don’t come for me

These are cool! I prefer the original designs more though, i just feel like they are more pleasing to look at, if light island was filled with grey monsters it would have probably caused the island to get hated even more, and it already gets so much hate

Yep, not good. My main issue is you changing the colours. Them having different shades of grey it defining and interesting, your version makes them boring. Light island is united by theme, and not colour palette. Plus Fluoress NEEDS to be rainbow coloured, that’s her defining trait. My primary qualms with light island are based around Tootoo being super ugly. I feel like a redesign for these monsters would be cool, but changing their colour schemes is not a redesign, nor does it improve the monsters Granted, Spytrap turning into a Discoball would be awesome

ct: if all wublins were the same color then it would suck also ct: *makes every single light monster grey exept for when they sing* edit: ok first of all, I'm not trying to be one of those "oMg tHX FOr ThE LikEs GuyS!!!!" people but thank you so much, this is the first time EVER one of my comments got onto top so THANKS edit 2: so apparently due to some STUPID youtube update, it now puts ALL of the comments made by said user at the top, THANKS ALOT, RU-vid(ಠ_ಠ)┌∩┐

I like it, but I don't like how they're restricted to one color. Maybe that one color can be enhanced instead of being their only color?

I would like to see how the evolution of the celestials when from adults to babies

I actually quite liked the different shades of grey on the monsters. It portrayed to me that they didn’t have to be active in order to stay consistent within the canon.

My complaints: The interior of gobs mouth needs to stay the same. So the “red” aspect of gob can really shine (get it cause light) instead of making it more dull than it needs to. Besides, you only see the mouth when it sings so it won’t ruin the theme of the light monsters. Having all of them the same shade of grey kind of makes the light monsters WAAYYY to dull and unappealing to the eyes. I’d prefer if the shade of grey each light monster had would slightly lean onto what colour they represent LIKE FLOURESS’S GREENISH SHADE OF GREY!! Fiddlement’s new shade of orange is too dark for me to like it. It’d be nice if it were more like a yellowy orange than the deep lava colour used. Pluckbill shouldn’t have a mouth, that’s really it. Blow’t is boring. I mean the *shade of grey* is. At least make it a bit better rather than making it all bright and boring. Also make the eyes glow when playing, IDK what colour but the face just needs working on when it comes to blow’t That’s really all I have to say. Please don’t take this as offence, I just like sharing my opinion and ranting about whatever is in my face at the moment, that’s all.

I love how you drew whajje he looks like me every Sunday

Ok, so personally, my opinion overall is that there are some good ideas and some bad ones. The light monsters being entirely desaturated seemed bad to me personally. -Fluoress not lighting up every color ruins her whole point. She is the PURE light monster, so she should be every shade of light. Also the 'Gob Grey' doesn't look right on her when she is lit up -Gob was made infinitely better, with the simple change of giving color and making his light actually light -Spytrap honestly should have been the green one. It has green eyes and looks like a plant pot. It should def light up more tho, but not so much you can't see the spider guy inside. -Pluckbill. I do not like Pluckbill. Not specifically this rendition, I just don't like it in general. It's a hideous purple with an ugly face. Beaks are supposed to include mouths, not a beak and ALSO a mouth. I hate it, it cant be redeemed. -Having TooToo ACTUALLY LIGHT UP YELLOW was a great idea. She is really standoffish compared to the group, as the others are all colors close to gray, but she is Black and White, so changing her skirt to a grey color may do well for her. -Bulbo looks nearly identical aside from lighting up more, so I like his changes -Fiddlement having his orange floof was what made him one of my favorites, so removing his orange made him lose what made him special to me, however, making it slightly more desaturated may look nice. It is also offputting having his face not lit while idle, as I can imagine that would make him look lifeless -I can't believe I didn't realize Blow't was represented by the ring on the element. Changing his color is a good thing because naked mole-rat pink doesn't suit him. Maybe not to grey, but def don't keep him pink. Lastly, I'd like to point out that the light monsters do have consistency. HOWEVER, their consistency isn't in their visual design. It is instead their audio design. They are all harmonious, soft, serene, instrumentalists. (Imo, the song sounds so much better with only them and Sooza, becuz I can't stand DUM DIDDLY DUM DUM DUM DUM)

i like how they all flowed as different colors with a VERY desaturated tone, giving them all personality and also each a unique way of glowing

I love how you made the lights coming from them actually light up and not just colors flashing

I LOVEEEEEEE THIS, Just one problem though. You said each Light monster corresponds to a color on the Light Symbol, right? Red - Gob Orange - Fiddlement Yellow - TooToo Green - Fluoress Blue - Bulbo Purple - Pluckbill Pink - Spytrap Aura/All of them - Blow't I think these monsters are meant to be DULLER versions of the colors they represent, not pure grey, that's why Pluckbill, Bulbo, Fluoress, and Spytrap are the colors they are. The only part I don't agree with is that they shouldn't be pure grey like Gob.

The way you designed them is quite boring and uninspired, the lack of consistency is apparent in all the islands and that’s what makes them feel diverse and having them look all the same is super boring

That whistle with Flouress tho

1:16 He hasn’t changed (Talking about the Dermit to the right)

Can you look at the design philosophy of the air elementals? Their whole design varies wildly so it’s had to pin it do just one word

This is a well made video, I'm in a like-dislike feeling with the idea. Though can't deny it's really well thought out and good.

0:20٫ that made me crack up

At first I wasn’t going with it seeing as he literally said that they shouldn’t all be exact cookie cutters of each other and then he made them all exactly the same color palette but once he started adding color he actually got me on board

This is so professional! Very impressed by the production of this video!

Although I do quite like the idea of the drab light monsters’ glow ups in song, I feel like inconsistent greys make a more dynamic island; whereas the same pale grey for all of them making them look broken? I don’t know how to describe it - changes of the grey between the monsters would seal the deal for me

I think their variations of gray is just foreshadowing of their glowing colour. No need to make them all grey. And even if so ya should've kept the value. Some must be darker some are lighter than usual gray. I do agree with everything else tho. Except tootoo's tutu glowing. It resembles fluoress too much. Better make the shoes light up. Aight great video anyways Keep it up

Hmm monsters with no color until when they sing is pretty genius

This guy adds math onto a game that’s just monsters making music. That’s what I call investment.

You don't have to but I think it would be cool if we actually saw them in action- y'know, *animated-*

0:06 gob bout to eat spytrap fr💀💀

I love all your ideas except the fact that they're all the same shade of gray but they're meant to be different shades of gray because they're all different and I love how fluoress has so much colours when played and I love how glob is just gray but I love how pluckbill's strings would be purple when played

I Hate That The Monster Redesign Made All The Monsters Have The Same Color As Each Other And It’s Really Bad, I Liked The Original Color Scheme Sense It Looks Colorful

My personal opinion I personally prefer the not same shade of grey designs, though that's personally my opinion I do like how much lighter all the light monsters are though Maybe change some colours though, eg: I thing tootoos brighter tutu looked better, and fluoress should probably still be rainbow. Bulbo was pretty good lightwise Spytrap is a bit too bright, and maybe the wrong colour Gob also looks a bit wrong But good redesigns anyways

Actually the symbol just means what shade of slightly colored gray is. Fluoress is gray green .too too represents the yellow .spytrap is gray pinkish red. Pluckbill is a shade of gray purple and ect. Their star color represents they gray colored skin or whatever .their light doesnt represent it tho.

I think the reason light the non light monsters are mostly singing at the beginning is because light monsters are canonically shy, so maybe the reason why Kayna sings though out the whole song is because she is trying to encourage the light monsters to join in (Bulbo and Gob are the first light monsters to start singing)

1:11 dermit did not change 😂

A small little consistency issue for Magical Sanctum in that G’day does not emit light in any way. Tell me if I missed something about them.

2:35 all of the monsters look dead inside and the light Bob boy who is directly to the right of glob (I keep forgetting that specific monsters name) it’s giving off the vibe that he knows there are people out there that can bring the color he was supposed to have back. He knows he was not meant to be that shade and he is deeply traumatized that his color got drained.

I think making the entire monsters just purely grey doesnt work, like gobs inside mouth has no color and the others also have parts that should be colored.

im sorry for this but im not trying to be mean ,but i dont like the desing you made..but well.everybody likes diffrent things right?

You didn’t even mention my favourite light elemental. Show some support for Fiddlement

Personally, I think that the grey should have a *light* colour to them, for example, floress (correct my spelling if im wrong) should have a bit of green in the grey and light up as she does now, so should the others. Blowt should keep your redesign but when singing have a stronger (and I mean *blindingly* strong) glow

To be honest, I wasn’t expecting Pluckbill to be the Light and Fire, I thought Light and Fire would be a lantern monster or something

Each monster was colored in the way to match the colors on the light symbol, and the color of a rainbow, they all don't match yes, but they still represent the island with the variety.

No offense but this is worse than the original light island because of the colors and the shade of grey that everyone has

Well there's no point of them having diff elements then cuz they all look the same :/

Could you please release the pngs of these images

I think the designs should stay how they are now but I do agree tootoo should light up whenever she dances.

I personally don’t like really these redesigns. I can’t really put my finger on what’s bothering me about them, though. Making them only have the color they represent is cool. But for an idea for the next one, maybe cover the Psychic element next? Some monsters like Bonkers and Tapricorn really don’t strike me of having Psychic capabilities.

96% of the comment: msm 4% of the comment: pepole

The light monsters colors is actually clever, the grey in spytrap is kind of red, it makes a red light, gobs grey is part green, makes green light, bulbos grey is part blue, makes blue like etc etc

I’m on the fence…maybe if someone edited these designs into the song so I could see them in action…I could get a better idea how it would work

1:16 All the other wublins: *turning green* Dermit: *just being dermit*

Everything being gray isn’t very.. nice looking… it’s original design is unique and their light is different as it’s like harmony.

Feel like the original look of Flores looked better than just having green

That grey hurts my soul why did you have to do that

My take on design for each one: 💡 Fluoress: For me, Fluoress's color could be a gray + green, and when lighting up, each one of the... Dress...Thing... She plays, could light in a different shade of Green. 🍃💡 Gob: Gob's design is good. But maybe if it was a little bit more Red..? You know, a very small shade of red-gray and when lighting up a very distinctive Red Glow! ❄💡 Bulbo: I think i like Creeptanium's design on it, it looks cool and fits the island. 🔥💡 Pluckbill: Firstly we remove the mouth, secondly the strings should glow when played, but only one. Like, if it played the 3rd string to the right, then only it should glow. And at some point in the song (specially at the end when all Light Monsters sing together) Pluckbill should play all strings at the same time with both hands so all of them could light up! 🍃❄💡 Spytrap: I think it's eyes could alredy glow Pink, and the stem of the plant could be a shade of pink-gray. When playing it should be the same, only the places where it hits the plant should glow. 🍃🔥💡 TooToo: The idea of the Tutu lighting up Yellow when playing is actually genius. It makes lots of sense. About the color, maybe Black fits it but some parts like Fingers, Shoes and Lips could be yellow, but a very gray-like yellow. ❄🔥💡 Fiddlement: For me Fiddlement is fine, it looks cool and maybe the color could be a gray-like orange. Just that. 🍃❄🔥💡 Blow't: I like Creeptanium's design on it. Looks cool, but maybe the Monster could be a black-like color? Meh... Just my thoughts. At the End, each Monster resembles a color: 💖 Spytrap ❤ Gob 🧡 Fiddlement 💛 TooToo 💚 Fluoress 💙 Bulbo 💜 Pluckbill 🌈 Blow't

I like your idea. I really do. But the fact that every single one of them is Gob's color is kinda... what's the word... Boring. Like you said before, Wublin island wouldn't look good if they were all the same color and that goes with everything else in the universe of msm. One of the many points is uniqueness. In sound, in display, and even in identity. That's what makes not only Light Island special, but the entirety of the msm universe special. I like the idea of making them more luminous, but I have to disagree with literally almost everything else. Especially the single color thing that's supposed to match the light element logo. That's not fun.

Glowbes would be perfect for light island

My predictiona for cloverspell 2024: Rare maulch Rare squot or rare pladdie Rare larvaluss Epic phangler or epic flowah (Most likely will be in amber island epic collection) Epic sooza (too) Epic ffydil (i cant spell it right ) At the end there will be a teaser for wubbox in fire oasis

Inconsistentsy: I don't like the change Emission: I kinda agree except that spytrap is getting burnt from light radiation Canonicity: I don't like it at all This is just my opinion

ngl it looks kinda bland and just plain and bad when they are all gray like that for plant island most of the monsters are green/brown to resemble plant life but share a different color palette and there is some big differences like Bowgart, T-rox, ect. and same goes for cold but with like a blue/white for cold, orangish for air, blue for water, and red/black for earth but yet all the monsters there still all idenify as a unique color palette or design and Floress lights up in a way that makes her unique and not all of them need to light up for the real light island to show and Floress and Gob still look good but they wouldn't be very unique when every monster exept for the non light elementals look almost the same and if this includes the rares it wouldn't be very worth the troubles to get it and wouldn't be very sight seeing.

Tbh I kinda don't like the idea that much

The redesigns are very interesting but them having the exact shade of grey seem a bit off putting, Maybe if they all had different base colors and still make a brighter light and color would be the same. But I dont really know this is just my opinion

I'd like what you were going for but making them all the same Shade of Grey seems kind of boring same with symbol canonicity if almost all of them only have one color it kind of ruins the magic of light Island I feel like it would be better if tutu spytrap and pluckbill didn't have any color until they started playing and instead of them having one color like red yellow and purple each time they play their color with change which one the colors of the rainbow

Wonder why light monsters are grey? Because the color of the rainbow combined always turns out grey or black!

I’m not trying to be mean or anythin but this kinda sucks. The color gave them a bit more life, but makin them all gray just kinda ruins it.

And you also made flouress look more like garvendoir from Pokémon. Yeah both of those names were spelled wrong

14 year old girls be like 1:05

I liked the originals better but I wish they had more light emission

I like your designs but flouress being only one color is kinda boring. The fun thing about flouress is that she breaks up into multiple colors having only one color takes the fun out of it

I think florecst should stay rainbow cause I think she’s supposed to be like a xylophone

i think fluoress should stay rainbow like blow't, i mean fluoress is just only light element so i thought that would make sense

I don't like the plainess of it and the chosen colours for each monster, but I want to see them light up like the video with the ingame colour

To be honest, I didn't like the change that much, but bulbo change was amazing in my opinion

Terrible. The worst part is that there are some really awesome ways to redesign the light monsters, but you instead decided to do the stupidest possible option.

it would have been better if they kept their colors og colors but the already lit ones like pluckbill and bulbo turned into the same color and they lit up like the rest

1:17 dermit be like: what

this is a great idea but i think that they shouldn't all me the Exact same gray color they should have a little more color to em or at least different shades of gray

I didnt like The first ideal of put then with The same type of gray, i think that idea depends of People opinions tbh, i like them to have diferents type of gray

I Love Redesigned Flouress And Redesigned Spytrap The Best

I wouldn’t change the color sense it gives them a little bit more character with the different shade of gray

these are bad but dude you are so talented

I would of done a grey version of they’re color except bloat who’s just plain grey

Creeptanium, I'm sorry to say this, you have fangirls. I am not one of them.

I feel like limiting floress to one color kinda destroys there entire design philosophy and pink dosent fit spytrap

Light island is my favourite island as it was the island that I got my first rare (rare gob day of release

I think making them the same shade of grey makes them more lifeless and unappealing to see, but the rest of the redesigns i think are cool tho i prefer much more the originals

They looked ok but making them the exact same shade of grey makes it worse

im fine with the light changes But makeing them at frist looks so Bad for some reson

I think that they should keep their redesigned colours (other than Fluoress’ that should stay rainbow) but keep the different shades of grey. Making them the same just makes them look even more boring than they already were. And also, the lights should be a little less, saturated. Because Tootoo looks like when you go to a colour picker and go all the way to the top right.

Light Island took 50 shdes of Gray personally

They looked fine before

Your wrong it's magical island (that is Nick name)

I only like the bulbo and too too redesign I don’t like the all being the same gray though

I like when fluoress was the first a whistle sound just came.

I think some of the monsters, especially Blow’t and Pluckbill, should be more colorful when they are playing. The monsters should also have some variation in color. Fluoress would look very plain if its dress was completely green, and Gob would look kind of strange only emitting red light. They should also vary in color when they aren’t playing, even if it’s only a little bit of variation. Especially since some of that gray color carries over into when the monsters are playing. These new monsters aren’t as illuminated as the originals, they should be more varied and colorful. Maybe Spytrap could flash multiple colors, but it could flash pink more than the others and always have the pink aura where it hits. Blow’t’s face could gain color when it puffs up, and it could change color as it plays different notes. Pluckbill’s strings could be different shades of purple, and it gains its original color when it plays. Fluoress could have a dress with different shades of gray, and when the different parts of the dress are plucked, they could change to a vibrant color, then become green, and then go back to gray. I’m not trying to be rude, these Light monsters look wonderful. I just think variation is the key to a good monster. You don’t see a blatant copy of Furcorn on every island.

I just gave tootoo a glowing skirt in one of my videos