Remaking a Cake FAIL (Hyperrealistic Orange Cake) 

I love that she is so open to criticism… Role model!

Can you make a half a coconut cake next? With coconut water inside? I think that would be interesting, and the hairs on the shell would look really cool. And the cake inside could be coconut flavoured.

The peeled orange looks absolutely real. But the other one looks too perfect. I think it needs some imperfections to look like the real thing.

Just the gelatin itself looks like an orange! You matched it perfectly!

The half orange cake came out amazing! The slice looks like a painted orange, but it was hard to tell if it was special because it cut so similarly to how a real orange would.

She always makes decorating a cake so easy though. I have had times where I’ve tried replicating her work and halfway through I think “ what have I done.” 😂

Sideserf is the type to not just to make a wedding cake but to make a cake of the whole wedding.

I’m glad she remade it bc she wasn’t very cheerful in the original either, it makes me so happy that you’ve improved so much, and it gets better every day😊❤

“I don’t know I’m just making it up as I go!” Literally described my whole life- 💀

Her husband deserves appreciation too. His work helps to make her video more entertaining.

If I didn’t just watch the whole process I would have NEVER known it was a cake! This is really good Natalie wayyyy better than your first one!

I watched you make it but my eyes still couldn’t believe that was cake. Well done Natalie!!

you think you could possibly make a life size tv cake and a tv remote?? put a scene from your favourite tv program on the screen. you’re so talented! ❤️❤️❤️

The gelatin side literally looked just like an orange peeled open..I would totally grab that expecting an orange lol

This woman can make anything a cake Edit: 355 in one day 💀 Edit 2: 440 in a week💀

I love how Natalie is all ways finding ways to improve her already amazing cakes and i think the way she advertises her merch is very unique and funny 🥰🤣

Not only is she making hyper realistic cakes, she's making hyper realistic gummies.

In my opinion, it's one of your best cakes. And for sure the best remake.

it definitely is an upgrade from the last one. Though I do feel that the half with its peel on looks a bit fake but I also feel the same with some real oranges. Like they just seem fake even though I know they are real.

Out of all of the ones that you’ve made I think my favourite is the peeled one. The broken bit being shinier definitely makes it look more realistic 😊

It looks so real that I can feel the taste of orange, don't ask how

Love that it looks so much like an orange this time. Awesome job using that gelatin technique. But was a bit disappointed in the lack of cake this time so that can be something to add on to this cake next time! Awesome job tho, love your work

I just love to see a channel without drama where you can just sit and watch there content without hearing beef with another channel

Omg you are so talented,Natalie, and don’t let ANYONE tell u that your cake isn’t good cause, let’s be honest, they probably can’t even do 1% of what you can 😊❤

Natalie never fails to make our day!!! Let’s get you to 5MILLION! 🎉

Natalie, you are so talented! You amaze us every single week! I would have not known that was a cake if I didn't see the process. Thank you for sharing your talent with us week after week!

That looks like a real orange. If this was my first time I probably wouldn’t believe it was cake until the cut. Good job!

I love ur videos so much! U are a huge inspiration to me. Ur humor, the fact u don’t get mad at all if someone criticizes u, I’m a huge fan !

This one is so much more realistic! It's amazing!

You should totally make a Harry Potter bust cake!! I just ❤ ur cakes!!!

Wow! Nice job… I am enjoying the remakes. Keep ‘em coming!

I love how you take constructive criticism. I liked that cake, but I knew it wasn't your best work. You never disappoint! I love ALL your cakes and videos!

This is the remake I’ve been waiting for!! So much more hyper realistic!!

I like how she remakes cakes and doesn't ignore that it doesn't look realistic. I gotta say.. Both tricked me Natalie!

She's so cheerful and friendly, I love her videos so much

I love your videos keep up the good work ❤

I love how she accepts and embraces failure and criticism! She bounces right back with joyful enthusiasm, ready for a challenge!

I'm really enjoying your remakes :3

You improved so much omgg! And i love your nailss 💅🏼

Did anyone else notice the mini orange inside the big oranges when she peeled them? 😅🍊 Anyways, your orange cake looks so realistic! The old one still looked amazing but this one is so good!!!

love the realistic cakes!❤

I just LOVE this channel!!!

I'm love the orange transition 😍 It's so fun to watch and makes the video even more amazing

This is AWESOME 🥰 You did a Really Good Job with this one. The first one was Nice, but these today are a Good Step Up 🥰 Keep up the Fantastic work, its so Fun to see how you Solve the Challenges 🥰

It's incredible, love it

Finally a new cake!!! I've been waiting for two weeks 😍💃💃 why did you post for two weeks ☺️

Omg never doubt yourself! This is incredible. I don’t have any words 😮 I feel so relaxed when I watch your videos ❤❤❤great job ❤

I still cant believe how talented this woman is..

Can ya make a Rubix cube cake please?

Natalie I absolutely love your videos! I have a suggestion, could you make a dollhouse cake? Like the victorian wooden hobby lobby ones! With an inside and furniture! It is a bit of a challenge but you love challenges and I know you can do it! Please, maybe next week? 😊

Love you videos! Been waiting for this vid all week 🎂, this cake turned out amazing

It looks amazing love all your cakes

Natalie that looks so good!! I almost wish it were a real juicy orange😂🍊

This is so crazy!! You are so talented!

I think these are amazing!😍💖. I feel like the shiny-ness and all different orange-tones would been soo hard but you made it fantastical. I would love this cake

The peeled orange was a little bit obvious not being a real peeled orange. But that half in the left was really awesome!

Why’s nobody talking about how she called the first cake an orange cake when it was of a mandarin?

Love ur channel!

This was awesome, I loved how the orange looked juicy❤ You should make a cake of a dogs foot next. Not a whole dog, but the bottom of a dogs foot/pawpad complete with hairy textures and claws. Theres so many weird textures to work with on a dogs paw pad, and it would just be such a weird cake. Disembodied dog leg/foot cake for no reason other than you can xD (for the record I love dogs, but I also love the weirdness of these cakes)

Natalie, you should make a cake of napkins!!!!!!!

She’s making these beautiful cakes and i can’t even decorate a cup cake

Wow, just wow! As someone who doesn't typically watch cake-making videos, I have to say I am utterly blown away by your talent and artistry, Sideserf Cake Studio! This orange cake is beyond incredible; I had to do a double take to make sure it wasn't a real fruit. Your attention to detail is simply mesmerizing, and the way you bring a cake to life is nothing short of magical. You've not only made a cake that looks like an orange but also made it an unforgettable piece of art. Your work is an inspiration, and I can't help but feel in awe of your talent. Keep doing what you do because you have gained a new admirer here. Thank you for sharing your incredible gift with the world. You've earned every bit of a 5-star rating and more!

I've been waiting so long for you to do this!💯✨

Awesome cake, as ALWAYS! 🙂

What I think would be cool is if she made a beehive cake with little cake bees 🐝

Your cake was just... I'm just speechless! If you offered me that orange I would think it was a real orange. That is crazy how you got it so realistic! I just love your videos! My mom is so picky about RU-vidrs, but when I showed her one of your videos she's just like, Wow!

You are amazing! I’m loving these remakes. Can you add a part at the videos comparing them side by side? I’d love to see the difference next to each other!

"An apple a day keeps the doctor away" LOL here apples are hyperrealistic cakes!

Hey there natalie i would love to tell you that i took some inspiration from your video's and i decided to make a funny fiels like you mentioned in your video. so ill share with you my favorite one: a funny story in my funny files is that when i was a kid my siblings and i used to think that my mother wouldn't brush her teeth because we never saw her do that, so i was wondering if you could make a cake of a toothbrush, a tube of toothpaste and for an extra challenge - floss. i would love to see you make it!!! thank you so much!❤❤❤

That peeled orange is insane, it looks so real!!! The sliced orange is pretty but a little too perfect, it looks like a painting or an advertisement for an orange, but it’s wayyyyy better than the first attempt!

My fav remake so far!!!! Side note~ your nails 💅🏻 look so pretty

“Do you wear clothes or know someone who does?” 💀💀💀

omg Natalie, you're cakes are so realistic that my cake expert friend failed to tell is it cake or not

So much talent!!! You are so amazing and inspiring!

Fantastic as always!

Genius how you layered white onto the gelatin to make some areas less juicy looking. You, milady, are a cake pioneer

Wow, you can really see the improvement!

First I’ve followed your vids for a while now and they are AMAZING!!! You put so much effort in and it’s oddly so entertaining Thank You So Much!!!

Your old orange cake is one of my favorites, so I am excited and intrigued to see what you change for the new one!🩵

I love your work✨

it looks AMAZING! they both look so realistic!! ill be honest, if you put it next to real oranges, I wouldn't be able to tell XD edit: would you be able to do a cake of splintered wood? i know it is weird but i wanna see if it can be done 😅

You should make a cake of one of your subscribers

Im never gonna beilieve anything Natalie does is a fail cuz that cake is AMAZING !!!❤❤❤ i love it

Oh and also your cakes are so lovely keep it up

I think that they are still the same amount of "hiper-realistic-ness"

You should make a chessboard cake

YOUR TELLING ME THATS CAKE? best one yet can’t wait to see what’s next

This was such a good remake ur rlly talented😊

Love ur cakes but why don't u make a cake of the tools and thr products u use to make a cake?!?!

FIRST

Your work always amaze me😍

Amazing!!! Well done!!!

Why is the style of the video so nostalgic?? Like it's giving early 2000s science crafting shows

It’s like even though I knew it was cake, I was still shocked when you cut it! Your amazing! ❤

Been waiting for this remake for a little, looks so much better and now i couldn’t tell if It was cake or the real thing😂love the way it turned out, and thanks for all you do!

Absolutely 💯 I would never have been able to tell if I'd just seen the end. Brava!

Another Amazing Sideserf Cake!!!

i love these transitions!!! they remind me of watching chowder as a kid

I love all your hyperealistic cakes!😊

I love when something intense is going to happen, she brings in the clothes