Revolutionising power transmission.

Подписаться 568 тыс.

Просмотров 260 тыс.

50% 1

The energy transition solutions of the 21st Century will take many forms, with a complex mix of different power producers. Moving energy across ever greater distances will overcome much of the intermittency of renewables like wind and solar. The way we will achieve that is via truly mind boggling high voltage direct current transmission systems. The question is, can we manufacture them quickly enough?
Help support this channels independence at
/ justhaveathink
Or with a donation via Paypal by clicking here
www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr...
You can also help keep my brain ticking over during the long hours of research and editing via the nice folks at BuyMeACoffee.com
www.buymeacoffee.com/justhave...
Video Transcripts available at our website
www.justhaveathink.com
Center for Behavior and Climate.
climatechange.behaviordevelop...
Previous Just Have a Think videos about HVDC
• Renewable Baseload Pow...
• China's MILLION VOLT E...
Research links
X-LINKS and XLCC
xlinks.co/
xlcc.co.uk/
www.offshore-energy.biz/world...
www.energylivenews.com/2023/0...
US Energy Information Administration - Coal chart
www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/det...
VERITASIUM - How Electricity Actually Works
• How Electricity Actual...
ELECTROBOOM - Why HIGH VOLTAGE DC power Transmission
• Why HIGH VOLTAGE DC po...
CLEANTECHNICA - HVDC is the new pipeline
cleantechnica-com.cdn.ampproj...
Interactive map of all current HVDC locations
osm4wiki.toolforge.org/cgi-bi...
US - CANADA shared wind power
www.rechargenews.com/wind/us-...
SOO GREEN HVDC LINK
soogreen.com/
CHAMPLAIN HOUSE
chpexpress.com/
NORTH SEA WIND
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotlan...
EUROPE HVDC
www.nsenergybusiness.com/feat...
www.mordorintelligence.com/in...
CHINA HVDC
www.hitachienergy.com/news/fe...
INTERNATIONAL SOLAR ALLIANCE
isolaralliance.org/work/osowog/
Check out other RU-vid Climate Communicators
zentouro: / zentouro
Climate Adam: / climateadam
Kurtis Baute: / scopeofscience
Levi Hildebrand: / the100lh
Simon Clark: / simonoxfphys
Sarah Karvner: / @sarahkarver
Rollie Williams / ClimateTown: / @climatetown
Jack Harries: / jacksgap
Beckisphere: / @beckisphere
Our Changing Climate : / @ourchangingclimate
Engineering With Rosie / engineeringwithrosie
Ella Gilbert / drgilbz
Planet Proof / @planetproofofficial

Опубликовано:

27 май 2023

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 1,4 тыс.

@Stuartrusty Год назад

Olympic levels of sarcasm at the beginning! As a fellow Brit and electrical/electronics tech, I appreciate not only the research and production values in your videos, but also the great British art of sarcasm being alive and well.

@davefoc Год назад

As a retired electrical engineer I was up for the challenge to find something to be snarky about. Alas, I didn't find anything. Very disappointing.

@mm-qd1ho Год назад

As an EE from across the pond, I appreciate the overseas delivery of dry British wit as much as I appreciate the delivery of electrical power

@dermotdonnelly5495 Год назад

Great video as usual.

@alexgrandino8777 Год назад

As a French men , I don’t usually have to deal with Brits sarcasm , and I barely understand their jokes but if this is one them , it’s not funny ! You are telling me that almost everything I learned about transmitting DC and AC is wrong ? And Tesla was wrong for using ac electricity for long transmission lines. I am surprised that only few comments were sent. Can a smart person give me some infos !

@campbellthomas6209 Год назад

Possibly the most English name for a RU-vid account

@DSAK55 Год назад

'It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.' Upton Sinclair 1935

@alanhat5252 Год назад

Taylor also met resistance while he was inventing "time & motion studies" for Ford. The outcome gave us mass-produced cars & an excellent Charlie Chaplin film.

@brucefrykman8295 Год назад

Bingo - especially true for our climate hucksters - agreed ?

@Snugggg Год назад

@@brucefrykman8295 what's a "climate huckster"?

@brucefrykman8295 Год назад

@@Snugggg *RE: " what's a "climate huckster"* Generally speaking, it's those con artists who cash in on the brain washed scientifically illiterate who now cling to the idea that CO2 releases caused by humans are anything other than beneficial to all life on Earth. There are innumerable corollaries to the nutty idea that such human CO2 releases somehow damage "the" climate, make the oceans go "acid," cause the seas to rise, cause forest fires and the like. Essentially they support political interference supporting unworkable electrical power generation fatuously referred to as "clean energy," or alternatively, ridiculous battery driven vehicles which are essentially more than multi-ton golf carts. People are not naturally this stupid, rendering them so requires endless hours subjected to sheer nonsense in government indoctrination camps called "public education" Corporate media plays its role as in mass producing ignorance as well. They are currently testing the heights of nonsense that such brain atrophied idiots mass produced in "public schools" will accept as "settled science." The current project: "Men are often impregnated by women" What next: eating bugs and maggots in high priced restaurants as a sign of enlightenment? .

@charetjc Год назад

@@Snugggg the doom-sayers that constantly remind us that global warming will end civilization/displace coastal populations/whatever in 2012, 2018, 2028, etc.

@briangarrow448 Год назад

I have friends who work in the electrical transmission construction industry and they have been talking about this for years.

@weedfreer Год назад

Me too...of a statistical analysis nature.

@thomasherrin6798 11 месяцев назад

I have friends everywhere who talk about unfunded schemes for the redevelopment of the whole world, however most will not be implemented because they are unfeasible and maybe not just for monetary reasons, it might be because the World is not "joined up" at the minute it's going the other way!?!

@richardwilson5709 5 месяцев назад

Yes, the key phrase is, "known for years"! Having a background in utility operations, I can express my dislike for the REGULATORY processes that are being administered by fearmongering politicos and other incompetents, both of whom are kept in control of the processes by the largest battalion of media and talking heads that exist on earth. If this were NOT the reality of this issue, the problems that are being discussed would already have been solved. Industry will continue to advance at a very slow pace relative to the underlying solutions that are already KNOWN!! FINAL comment there are NO UNKNOWNS in this matter of utility operations. EVERYTHING is KNOWN! Pay attention to the competency of the regulatory people and political interest and resolutions will occur at the speed of commerce.

@BlackThorne Год назад

From Romania, we're putting up solar panels on residential roofs at breakneck pace. Just got our residence wired up last month, and injected 500kW into the grid since. Cool to know that we'll be able to leverage timezone differences to share the benefits.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

...especially once India connects Asia to Europe

@heyhoe168 Год назад

@@alanhat5252 that scale of power grid is impossible yet. Also in order to build such grids we have to solve wars problem.

@sambal777 Год назад

@@alanhat5252 power loss increases exponentionaly over distance hence why power generators are often as close as possible to where the power is needed. This is also the reason why ideas like lets just build the entire worlds supply of energy as solar pannels in a remote desert somewhere dont work.

@edomeindertsma6669 Год назад

I think you mean 500kWh? 0.5 MW seems like too much to me.

@BlackThorne Год назад

@@edomeindertsma6669 Mea culpa, you're right. I forgot mega is kilo x 1000, i was thinking it was only 10x

@kenbaird7067 Год назад

NZ has a 800km UHVDC 1.0 million volt line from Benmore power station in the South Is to the Haywards Converter station in Lower Hutt, North Is. It was chosen as the transmission losses for DC were significantly less than for the traditional 220KV AC lines normally used. The route involved the undersea crossing of the dangerous Cook Strait. Generously, NZ Electricity provided a HV generation facility for the new Engineerig School in Christchuch - 2.5 MV makes a very loud bang when discharged (Also used for testing the insulators for the DC line). Ken Baird BE(Elect) CHCH School of Engineering.

@user-bw4jm1bv1i Год назад

How do I get a job in this industry 😆

@derrelllipscomb693 Год назад

There was a similar G.E. insulator facility in the US that had a huge Tesla in a very old building, which was recently demolished. Surprisingly, they didn’t destroy the Tesla Tech, which they sold to a bloke in Florida that wants to house it in his museum. He is currently trying to fund setting that up. Saw this on another channel where these very tech savvy guys snuck into this secure and security guarded building and filmed the Old Tech from all angles and described what they saw and how they thought it functioned. Super Cool!

@loopyroberts Год назад

It's only a +-350kV bipole, not 1MV. But HVDC is undergoing a massive boom at the moment.

@martincotterill823 Год назад

Great news, Dave, and goes to show, that the transition doesn't just cost jobs, but creates many too

@lestermarshall6501 Год назад

Somebody is gonna have to employ those laid off oil workers. Great job as usual Dave.

@martincotterill823 Год назад

@@lestermarshall6501 sure, oil and gas drilling crews are already drilling geothermal wells. Engineers and experienced technicians are needed everywhere, they don't need to search long for their next job

@IanPritchard Год назад

Lol. yeah, right. How many times have we heard that before?

@martincotterill823 Год назад

@@IanPritchard through the cutting of subsidies to the PV industry, the CDU/CSU government were responsible for the loss of approx. 100,000 jobs here in Germany. So, the jobs were here and could be created again. Tesla isn't the only company deciding to build batteries in Europe. The transition requires multiple solutions therefore multiple opportunities for new jobs.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

@@lestermarshall6501 no they don't, coal miners were just abandoned

@stevedunlop9623 Год назад

New Zealand has had an HVDC cable running from the lower South Island, over the Cook Straight to the bottom of the North Island since 1965. It moves hydro generated electricity north most of the time.

@kenoliver8913 10 месяцев назад

The converter stations - the most difficult and expensive part of a very short HVDC link like this - have been completely replaced twice since then to keep up with the improving technology, with the second involving a complete redesign and new cable.

@Hochspitz Год назад

I lived off DC/AC assisted for 13 years starting 1990 in Australia. My system was solar, later wind which enabled AC. The system was very primitive, a fair amount of maintenance but it worked and I was one of the few who still had power when devastating bush fires hit.

@Vigilante-cu9th Год назад

I'd like to weigh in with industry insight. I work for a company that builds high voltage AC transmission in Iowa. The HVDC line that SOO Green proposed is 100% dead in the water. The AC system on either side of the line was deemed insufficient by the Independent System Operators (MISO and PJM). Neither system can handle such a large injection of megawatts onto the AC system. When presented with this information, SOO Green was unwilling to fund the necessary system upgrades. On top of that, SOO Green was marketing and paying for the line using a "Merchant Line" system. In this system, individual loads and generators directly pay for their transmission usage along that line. For context, there are currently 0 Merchant Lines in PJM or MISO. Here are two examples of many where that system falls apart. 1. "I want to pay to bring Iowa wind energy to Illinois" "No, the local energy companies want that investment. Build wind farms in Illinois instead." 2. "Illinois has extra generation right now, and we've paid SOO Green for a percentage of their line. Export to Iowa!" But at the same time, "Iowa wind is over producing, and we've paid SOO Green for a percentage of their line. Export to Illinois!" When it is economical for both paying customers to supply or pull from at the same time, the system breaks down. Feel free to reach out to me with more questions about how electricity markets work in Midwest USA. If you want a great video idea on the topic, search "MISO Long Range Transmission Planning" (LRTP).

@rickrys2729 Год назад

Here in New England and eastern Canada we can imagine connecting 34 GW of Quebec hydro power to act as a huge battery with the planned 70GW of offshore wind with bi-directional HVDC.

@mike160543 Год назад

An excellent idea. the combination of wind, solar and hydro is the only sensible solution.

@patrickcorcoran4828 Год назад

I'm in Vermont and the governor and the utilities (the largest of which is owned by Hydro Quebec) have been arguing for years that we don't need any more in-state renewable energy because we'll just get power from Hydro Quebec. The renewable energy community, like you said, keeps pointing out that we should have as much in-state renewable energy as possible and Hydro Quebec can be used as a battery either by slowing hydro generation and raising water levels while other renewables are online or by pumping the water back upstream.

@mikeskutches1018 Год назад

Thank you so much for this and your many, many great videos. You are doing important work, and it is much appreciated.

@TheTonycima Год назад

Hear hear. Er, having written this, I think that probably only the English will understand it! Well done Dave. Great work.

@JustHaveaThink Год назад

Thanks Mike. Much appreciated :-)

@bearcubdaycare Год назад

It's good to see this progressing. There was a study decades ago showing that commercial wind power in a 1000 radius connected by a grid, would be as reliable as a coal power plant. Trying to achieve reliability by storage alone is making the task much harder than necessary. DC is the way to make long distance feasible with modest losses.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

miles or KM radius? I'm pleased I've not been the only one saying this since wind power became a thing.

@TaiViinikka Год назад

It's true, what you said. In some places (as in the big Morroccan project Dave mentioned) you can place significant solar generation somewhere within that 1000 mi radius as well, and gain considerable diversity over wind alone. Now consider that both weather and (heh) nighttime darkness are predictable hours in advance. Here in Ontario we have a program where large consumers can receive payment for shutting down large power draws temporarily. It also helps to have hydroelectric power that can be ramped up and down. Overall (assuming some co-operation across borders) it's not clear why a person looking at the whole picture would think we need to burn fossil fuels beyond 2050.

@Nphen Год назад

Transmission going between states & countries faces right-of-way hurdles and takes years. Good that it's finally starting in earnest, 30 years late like everything else that could have started in earnest in the 1990's; EV, clean energy, reduced car dependency with bike lanes, e-bikes, microcars, and small modular reactor nuclear power. Grid batteries/storage aren't here to "make the task much harder" they're being used for load balancing, Virtual Power Plants, and home energy storage & blackout protection. Look at how Hornsdale battery stabilized part of Australia's grid. More UHV and HVDC are part of long-term grid stabilization that includes batteries.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

@@Nphen IFA, the first UK-France interconnect has been operating since 1986. It's rated at 2GW.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

@@Nphen you say 1990s, it *_did_* start before the _1890s!_ The first self-propelled motor vehicles (long before steam) were electric (2, 3 & 4 wheeled) & are still used industrially, the first house fully electrified was powered by water, microcars (then called cyclecars) were very popular from the beginning of the internal combustion engine (1897?) but were essentially killed off (in the UK) by the Austin 7 of 1923 though by modern standards it was a microcar at 1m wide & 2m long & it didn't stop there, hydro-power was common with Niagara Falls in the 1880s being nowhere near the first (though it did have the first long-distance transmission line in 1896). Even "small modular reactors" have been in service since 1955 as ship & submarine power initially but also land-based later.

@alberthartl8885 Год назад

Transmission cable made from Carbon fiber with an aluminum jacket is available from a company called TS Conductor. It's ampacity is 30% greater than traditional steel core aluminum jacket transmission cable. That means an existing transmission line could be upgraded to carry more energy without and changes to the support structures.

@incognitotorpedo42 Год назад

That's cool, but the cost of the cable must be huge.

@timtravelnomad Год назад

My understanding is copper has many times greater ampacity than steel wire... so the carbon fiber option doesn't sound very impressive...

@junkerzn7312 Год назад

@@timtravelnomad AC transmission lines run the electricity over aluminum. The steel core is there just for strength to support the wire and does not actually carry much current due to the skin effect caused by AC. HVDC works differently... because it is DC, the current runs through the whole core so cable strength has to be engineered differently. Copper is way, way too expensive to use for transmission lines.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

@@timtravelnomad there are too many modes of failure & they happen too frequently for copper to be used in transmission lines, it's also hugely expensive.

@Bill53AD Год назад

Ther is an HVDC line from Canda to Massachusetts, USA. Done around early 1990's.

@JustHaveaThink Год назад

Glad to hear it :-)

@doug.horne2378 Год назад

I liked your casual reference to the technical engineers and other professionals just quietly getting on with the job. They are effectively dragging the rest of us, many kicking and screaming, into the 21st century. Thanks Dave. As usual I feel more knowledgeable for having watched this video.

@davidjd123 7 месяцев назад

Yah misinformation and money has nothing to do with what engineers are made to create. Wind and solar can’t compete with coal atm. And why do they have to lie about the oceans rising and we all will die if it’s such a great path?

@brymstoner Год назад

Brilliantly communicated as always, Dave. Thank you for not being as shouty as everyone else seems to think they need to be!

@tims9434 Год назад

Excellent news.....looks like an actual solution is taking shape. Thanks for giving us something to reduce our anxiety about this current problem.... better than all the negative conspiracy theory!

@HermanVonPetri Год назад

Intelligent and practical scientists and engineers keep charging ahead to generate impressive output, while the insular fossil fuel interests remain static and resist change.

@tsaicio Год назад

@@TheHorseshoePartyUKIncomparable with dam catastrophy in China in 1975. Nuclear is the safest energy source. In Poland aprox. 10.000 die yearly due to carbon and fuel burning (pm 2.5 and pm 10, beznoapiren, NOx --> lung cancer, stroke, heart failure)

@elephantintheroom5678 Год назад

@@TheHorseshoePartyUK Did you even LOOK at the cost overruns for nuclear and nuclear storage? Compare it to solar, wind and subsea cable projects, and you'll see what a stupid investment in money, time and mental resources nuclear projects are. It's just a hobbyhorse for people who don't like (for mostly emotional reasons) the resources (wind and solar) that make the most sense.

@elephantintheroom5678 Год назад

@@tsaicio None die from solar and wind.

@jeffbooker Год назад

Sharing appears to be key to the workability of these ideas, and unless we are convinced that sharing is good, we may not see or understand the well being of us all as being connected.

@rpower1401 Год назад

I had a Friday night cards friend who works with HVDC. He was in town for a few months setting up one of the red pins on your screen. Neat tech with great potential. It was almost 10 years ago now since we parted ways but I recall him recanting (in general terms) the many challenges of getting the system running at the time. Since then it's slowly been ramped up in capacity with major teething pains but looks like it will work out.

@InYourDreams-Andia Год назад

Huge power to these HVDC companies! Good new info on power distro needed and upgrades, very informative, and great investment opps!

@tbix1963 Год назад

Thanks for sharing your thoughts, ideas and videos. Nice to see an update on new transmission projects coming up. Like everything, moderation is the key to implementation. Big projects can cause big problems. As long as they are well thought out the problems can be dealt with. Having worked in the power transmission industry for more than 32 years I’ve coordinated all types of technologies. No one is better than any other. The problems come from situations when exceptions are made in operating policies because this or that just can’t happen, which of course is usually proven wrong eventually. The DC import from HQ into NY was limited by the ability to recover from the loss provided from a single contingency. The primary contingency was the loss of the HQ power system and we trained to recognize it if it happened. After many years they decided that’s just not going to happen again. And people retired and new people were not trained to recognize it. Then the rule was dropped. Come one morning I’m doing my job and earlier I read about forest fires in the HQ system that were so big nasa had spotted them from space. I noticed it was in a major HQ transmission corridor. And pondered that can’t be good. A little while later the impossible happened and we lost all of our DC imports at the same time. Thankfully the imports were relatively low. I recognized it as the loss of the HQ system probably due to the forest fires. Sent my theory up the chain and surprisingly that was exactly what had happened even though all the experts said it couldn’t happen. Thanks again for your videos, wishing you and your family the best.

@bader2886 Год назад

you have a great experience, I’d like to hear more from you

@jeanlouisfrenette534 Год назад

One must not forget the world wide electricity distribution between several electrical transportation suppliers. These AC-to-DC-to-AC transfer points are being used for far more than a century. Then there is that comment from a US Congressman who was frustrated because the US cannot transport an electron from New York to San Francisco; many state boundaries do not have synchronisation capacities to allow AC synchronisation between states. Thank you for your presentation.

@vernonbrechin4207 Год назад

Thank you for this overview of the HVDC transmission system. I've been amazed at how rapidly the system has expanded. What used to be technically impossible a half-Century ago has become routine due to the creation of the high voltage, high current switching semiconductors utilized in the converter stations that convert the AC to DC and back again at the respective end stations.

@andrewpaterson5192 Год назад

The New Zealand HVDC ( 350 kV ) cable , called "The Cook Strait Cable" , runs from Benmore Hydro Dam to Wellington is 610 km long and runs for 40km under the Cook Strait been the South and North Islands started construction in 1961 and commissioned in 1965. That is rather more than 50 years ago. This technology is not new even though some RU-vid channels may have only just learned about it. The Cook Strait Cable system has been significantly modernized over the years but the principle remains unchanged. It is now a bipolar thyristor based 1200 MW system.

@c.augustin 11 месяцев назад

@@andrewpaterson5192 Interesting. Which technology was used for the Cook Strait Cable system in the 1960s? Good old vacuum tubes (well suited for high voltages)?

@Mucklehorn Год назад

People must have felt the same at the start of the industrial revolution, the speed and scale of innovation is incredible. That 'oh, hang on' bit genuinly made me laugh as well. Keep up the good work JHAT team!

@JustHaveaThink Год назад

Cheers! Glad you enjoyed it.

@marcm. Год назад

Here in the US during the 2008 financial meltdown, one of the things I argued was that we should create a big infrastructure build of just such an interstate line. Precisely to help out with load sharing and the fact that we create so much energy in the southwest at exactly the same time that it is necessary in the Northeast... Instead we got nothing... 14 years we could have been ahead of everything... Having said that, I am extremely happy to see this going on now

@brucefrykman8295 Год назад

The elite (royalty and their politicians) had nothing whatsoever to do with the industrial revolution; a revolution that freed great populations of slaves upon which the elite previously used for their energy needs.

@metatechhd Год назад

👏👍 "Absolutely Olympic levels of sarcasm right from the start! As a fellow Brit and tech enthusiast, I can't help but appreciate the thorough research, high production values, and the fact that the great British art of sarcasm is alive and well in your videos. It adds that extra touch of wit and entertainment. Keep revolutionizing power transmission! ⚡🔌🇬🇧"

@nickkacures2304 Год назад

That is amazing that we can move that much power through underwater transmission lines .I am excited about the new technology in battery storage systems like Iron flow and vanadium flow batteries that last twenty five years or longer and are environmentally sustainable that could help get the intermittent supply issues resolved to store energy from these new lines

@alanhat5252 Год назад

flow batteries are now old enough tech that you can buy one

@nickkacures2304 Год назад

⁠@@alanhat5252 yes I bought a few shares a couple of years ago from ESS they make iron flow batteries and a German company prolux is making a flow battery for home use they are going to be less expensive than lithium batteries for home storage

@AlsanPine Год назад

and how wonderful it will be when we no longer have ugly overhead power lines going through our forests. right now there are huge areas of our forest being cut down to make a path for the long distance power lines. i just hope people are smart enough to lay a large conduit so the lines can be serviced, updated, repaired, etc. i know it would make for a more expensive startup but it would also make resilient flexible connections where we could also run fiber or any other new tech that will come up. just think how awesome it would be to have true distributed network of power and information that is cheaply update-able with zero impact on aesthetics or the environment. it could me a huge machine that we can dump all our plastic waste in and have a heavy conduit spit out the other end which buries in in the soil it dug just before. i saw an awesome asphalt road replacer system that dug the old asphalt, crushed it, heated it, added new tar, laid it down with a squadron of rollers flattening the new road. it was only moving at a mile an hour or so but it was taking a poor road and leaving a perfectly new road in one move... it was awesome.

@incognitotorpedo42 Год назад

That road technology sounds cool. I don't think that we could do plastic recycling the same way. HVDC cables are very sophisticated and need to be made under exacting conditions, so a factory is needed. Recycled consumer waste doesn't have the properties needed for underground HVDC cables. It would use a sophisticated engineering resin or composite.

@AlsanPine Год назад

@@incognitotorpedo42 true but i was not suggesting the wires be made on the spot. i was suggesting the tunnel (conduit) they run through be made on the spot... out of waste materials.

@davidbatchelor6393 5 месяцев назад

As a retired elec engineer it's great to Great to watch your informative and intelligent videos Dave. Keep them coming. Cheers another Dave

@extraincomesuz Год назад

Thank you for this brilliant update! I saw the initial one in 2021. Great news for us all and it puts a rosier pic on the fact that climate temps are rising faster than projected. We will undoubtedly have some generations that suffer and some species lost, but the future with clean energy will allow us and the Earth to recover. I'm old but I hope I'm around to see this cleaner future.😊

@simongibbs3601 Год назад

Thank you for your brilliance and insight. It’s lovely to have such a good example of how to combat the ignorance of this world.

@jasonwidegren3211 Год назад

Fascinating! I had no idea that these hvdc were already so prevalent. Good to hear!

@MervynPartin Год назад

Britain has been linked to France by dc cables from Sellindge in Kent since the 1960s. Cost is not the only consideration, but system stability and fault levels have to be contained. Joining 2 large ac grids by a single ac interconnector can quickly become unstable, hence the use of dc. For long lines, the Ferranti effect can lead to excessively high voltages at the receiving end with light loading, so again for that dc wins. The small size of Britain means that the overhead 400kV ac lines are quite sufficient for secure operation. If that was to be wholly replaced by underground cables (You think your bills are expensive , now?), then the situation may change. As for the viability of the Morocco link, the vast profits being made by the wind and solar power suppliers are due to the cock-eyed way that the electricity industry was privatised, whereby cheap generation can be remunerated at the same rate as the highest cost generation on the grid. That situation, currently costing everyone in the country, may not last. Like every other major infrastructure project, I predict that it will be years late, way over budget and the constructors will be begging the government to bail them out.

@bjarnesegaard5701 Год назад

You have one of the best most professional youtube channels I have seen. Great well researched explanations with good graphics and presentation. Thanks.

@ecospider5 Год назад

High voltage DC is so cool. I’m glad we have switching power supplies that make this possible.

@nicka99 Год назад

Wow amazing video, I’m very lucky to be somewhat involved in the ‘energy transition’ but this just take it to another level understanding the worldwide impacts

@geordiew2162 Год назад

WOW! Thanks for taking a dive into that info that has been skewed for so many years, great presentation, way to slap the pinchy twirps so elequintly.😎

@peterdollins3610 Год назад

Great possibilities & realties well expressed. It is uplifting to get some good news now & again.

@JustHaveaThink Год назад

Cheers Peter

@gordonriley4297 Год назад

Thank you, enlightened and educated on a subject close to my heart. 👌🏻

@JustHaveaThink Год назад

Cheers Gordon

@paulsmallwood8779 Год назад

Sun Cable in Australia appears to be set for HVDC transmission from Western Australia to Singapore, Cannon Brookes has won control of the venture from Twiggy Forrest. The scope for electricity sales to Asia of green energy from the vast outback seems to be a real game changer.

@adrianthoroughgood1191 Год назад

Let's hope they can also connect the east and west coast to smooth out supply variability and reduce the amount of backup power needed.

@marccracchiolo4935 11 месяцев назад

As usual a great video very informative and it’s nice to know that it really is coming together behind the scenes despite what you might hear otherwise.

@balasubr2252 Год назад

Interesting approaches solutions and developments. Let us hope humanity survives to enjoy these anticipated outcomes.

@pattuwale7629 Год назад

Your channel is one of the best resources available to me (and doubtless many others) to keep off the cynicism.

@electricAB Год назад

Couldn’t have said it better myself.

@hokitika4888 11 месяцев назад

Nonsense it's a Green/Marxist propaganda channel

@istvantoppler5999 Год назад

Good to hear common sence, facts, logical arguments with full verification that is "well thought out and presented"

@nowthenad3286 8 месяцев назад

This is a great channel. I find videos like this so exciting.

@utubota5522 Год назад

Thank you. I did not know that underground and undersea cables were so much more favorable for DC.

@brianmckeever5280 Год назад

Fascinating! I wonder how DC handles solar flares vs AC? Have no idea, just something that came to my mind as I was imaging all the conductors wrapping around the globe.

@lengould9262 Год назад

Underwater and underground cables are not vulnerable to solar excursions.

@brianmckeever5280 Год назад

@@lengould9262 Then another great reason for them. Thank you!

@stevencowles8419 Год назад

This is interesting and encouraging but it is key that we don’t forget lesson from recent world events. Inter-country arrangements have a lot to offer but we need to factor in energy security too. I hope to see less reliance on hoge distance power transmission with a grid comprosing more ‘local’ renewable generation and storage delivering a significant percentage of overall needs

@lengould9262 Год назад

Seems like internation relationship management, esp wrestling it away from the financial class, is the project.😢

@alana8863 Год назад

Yes, it's great if as much energy as possible is generated locally, but once every country also has multiple sources of energy coming from others, then no country will have the ability to hold others to ransom. That has been the problem in the past with Russian gas, OPEC, etc, and that's why these changes will prevent such abuses in future.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

Energy security requires _more_ interconnections not less.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

It might be interesting if the Crown Estate built some wind farms rather than just charging 'ground' rent. Perhaps the King himself might build some? Over the last century & more the Monarchy has been more interested in the Public Good than the Government...

@Dmitri_Schrama Год назад

So dense... Another great video. Thank you!

@Lord.Kiltridge Год назад

We are going 120 mph towards a cliff and certain death. The 'experts' are saying to apply the brakes as hard as can be done immediately, and the people driving not _just_ keeping on the gas, but are also whining over how 'difficult' it is to use the brakes. It boggles the mind.

@miguel5785 Год назад

The fact is that, far from using any brakes, we are accelerating GHG emissions. All this talk about electrification while we do nothing to reduce current fuel consumption.And we need not only reduce it, but suck it back, get GHG out of our atmosphere.

@guesswho6038 Год назад

"Experts say" is usually followed by some b*shit. Media...

@magnetospin Год назад

An even bigger HVDC transmission project currently underway is the Australia-Asia Power link(en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australia-Asia_Power_Link). It would be a 4500km transmission line.

@Phariseehunter Год назад

We were hoping but it was cancelled.

@maxthaysen5399 Год назад

good point, did he miss that? or did he treat it as a given... I think he mentioned it. Said georgia could send powed to uk when the sun goes down, while UK sends powerback when the wind blows -- but he aimed that point at the peak demand issue... adjacent problem.

@timtravelnomad Год назад

Paused rather than necessarily cancelled... it may be revived now that Mike Canon Brooks has wrestled control of the project. My understanding is Twiggy wanted to cancel the HVDC component and Mike wanted to continue the HVDC component.

@simongross3122 Год назад

@@timtravelnomad I wondered about that. Surely the HVDC component is the only thing that makes it actually work. Also, I'm surprised that Mr Forrest would cancel that part of it. Perhaps he's worried it might compete with his plans to sell H2 to the world.

@jimgraham6722 Год назад

Unlikely to ever happen. HVDC as a one way supply line simply too lossy beyond 1,000km. But it makes a bit more sense over long distances when it is part of a matrix of users and suppliers. Forest's approach of using the energy in the Australian grid and to make H2 makes a lot more sense. If the cable to Singapore goes ahead it would only meet 15% of the city's demand and has no levelling. If Singapore wants to go solar it makes much more sense to lease some land in Indonesia and install the panels there. Indonesia is also installing new nuclear power stations that work in tandem with solar power.. Singapore could also tap into that or install a nuke of their own. One medium sized nuclear plant would easily power the whole city.

@davidl.howser9707 Год назад

Very informative content, and production effort, and video. Nice Work !

@davidhughes7174 Год назад

Thnak you for your thoughtful and concise explanations of technologies.

@everettputerbaugh3996 Год назад

I hadn't thought about DC being a viable long distance option. Thanks for causing me to check it out.

@altrag Год назад

It wasn't for a long time - that's why we went with AC. Its been known for ages that the transmission itself is less lossy than AC, but the stepping up and down on either end of the HV line was always a problem. Modern technology has improved however and that's no longer quite as much of an issue. Its still more troublesome than AC stepping of course, but its now less of a problem than the transmission losses, so we're slowly making the switch.

@rickb3650 Год назад

Have you looked into the numbers of moving away from this 19th century model of centralized production and transmission to end users? It seems to me that, as with so many other things, decentralization translates into much higher efficiency and reliability through interconnected redundancy.

@snbtauranga 10 месяцев назад

Great overview, as always, many thanks.

@garethnoble11 Год назад

great video again. Running new transmission alongside existing infrastructure (railway lines) ... useful ... potentially powerful. I'll get it into the opportunities list for our project team.

@timothykelly9267 Год назад

The SOO in SOO Green is a reference to the old SOO rail line that spanned a portion of the upper midwest. It’s cool that the folks behind the DC project thought that up. Great video that showed we the ae ways arong the NIMBY issue. Keep up the great work.

@dee7199 Год назад

Questions / Video Suggestions - between agrovoltaics, roof tops and parking lots (I’m in Canada and we have monsterous parking lots) there seems to be under utilized space where local green power production could occur - reducing or skipping the need for this massive infrastructure element. Why not paradigm shift to micro local production rather bigger centralized continental production? Plus, India selling power to African countries? One of the largest populations is going to sell power to nations that should have power autonomy? Doesn’t make sense outside of profit gain. Basic question is this, what could be done more locally with an equal level of capital & resource investment? What’s the delta between the two scenarios? Cheeers

@tomarmstrong1281 Год назад

One of the best regular video channels on RU-vid.

@stephenbrickwood1602 10 месяцев назад

Being a Construction Engineer and having worked on these transmission lines I still am surprised that the cost of these national transmission grids is never analysed. 5 times more electricity will be needed with no fossil fuels in the future. Can you do a video on this topic please ? 😊

@terenzo50 Год назад

It's a shame Michael Crichton didn't live long enough to see Just Have A Think. I like to think he'd have benefitted from it and engaged with you on many topics.

@symphantic4552 Год назад

Anything in particular?

@incognitotorpedo42 Год назад

@@symphantic4552 Well, he was kind of a wingnut, as I recall. Hard to say what he'd be on about with Dave, but climate denialism comes to mind.

@JustHaveaThink Год назад

Praise indeed! Much appreciated :-)

@alanhat5252 Год назад

@@incognitotorpedo42you're confusing him with someone else, he did a lot of reading around of then-current research & added a few threads together to weave a story, usually a terrifying story because it was built on facts you can track down on Wikipedia & academic document servers. Climate-denialism most _definitely_ was not his style.

@Ikbeneengeit Год назад

Hi Dave, really appreciate your peaceful and technically capable literature reviews.

@bobdeverell 7 месяцев назад

Keep in mind the UK peak demand is already over 60GW. so the HVDC projects you mention about are relatively small and suitable for top-up rather than to support the UK's core need. We can envisage UK needs rising to 100GW later in this century. Also in the past, fossil fuel generation was fairly localised and reduced the need for the National Grid to carry an extensive transfer of power. The future architecture of the UK power generation will be interesting. There are 2 competing scenarios. One is where renewables dominate and we rely on a massively upgraded National Grid. This is the approach preferred by the EU and buyers and sellers of power. The other approach is a network of small nuclear power stations serving their local communities with a significantly reduced need to upgrade the N Grid. I suspect the business community will opt for the first approach as it makes the most ROI in the short term, but this approach risks being displaced by local power generation as consumers rebel against high energy prices.

@user-ek6nj5jw2w Год назад

Great video that simplify the concept and very well explain what is going on that field

@ToneyCrimson Год назад

Sun doesn always shine and wind doesnt always blow, except it does.

@timothyclemson Год назад

Omg I love this channel so much.

@JustHaveaThink Год назад

Cheers Timothy :-)

@dannybauman1454 Год назад

You bring hopeful news. Its always in short supply, thanks.

@OzyRooster Год назад

Great article! Super informative as always ... Thankyou

@paperburn Год назад

You did not mention the Nebel HVDC transformer that will be rolling out further reducing Transmission cost by about 5 percent at half the cost. It does not sound like much but it is a game changer as well. At least on the infrastructure side.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

have you spelled it correctly? A web search produces no results.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

even Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nebel produces no results

@HiAdrian 11 месяцев назад

Wrong timeline *@paperburn* - the Nebel project never materialized in this one!

@paperburn 11 месяцев назад

@@HiAdrian look again, different name same goals

@HiAdrian 11 месяцев назад

@@paperburn Blimey, you're right!

@richardcoundley Год назад

The problem with this analysis is that, while these technologies e.g. DC inter-connectors will continue to make a contribution, they will not solve the central problem of what the Germans call Dunkelflaute. This is where typically in January high pressure settles in across Northern Europe such that there is little wind or solar. In which case a number of countries e.g. the UK, Belgium, Holland, Northern Germany, Poland and Scandinavia with huge electricity demands will simultaneously require electricity when their renewables stop producing much electricity. For example the UK's neighbours will also be short of electricity when demand is at a maximum.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

it's not that big a problem, especially as the _whole_ EU is interconnected (on 2 grids) as well as most surrounding countries. Also dunkelflaute is a *_reduction_* not a absolute cut.

@richardcoundley Год назад

@@alanhat5252 To power our homes, offices and cars with electricity requires the UK to add 1.7 times current capacity to the system. This amounts to a total capacity of 160 GW or more. With a little nuclear and the rest renewable by 2050, and only nuclear providing reliable capacity and with the contribution from wind and solar reducing to 20% during Dunkelflaute, the UK would have a shortfall of the order of 100 GW. And with our neighbours suffering similar pro-rata shortfalls, it is highly unlikely that there would be hundreds of GWs of spare capacity available in Europe, and that there would be sufficient capacity in the DC inter-connectors many of which are yet to be built. The problem with videos like these is that the authors latch onto an existing and useful technology, and then represent that it provides a solution to a much larger problem. It is the same issue with the idea that battery storage will solve this problem. You need to understand the system at a macro level and then push the numbers. I recommend you watch a presentation by Michael Kelly, a professor of engineering at Cambridge University, on the engineering and cost implications of Net Zero at ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-NkImqOxMqvU.html

@kenoliver8913 10 месяцев назад

You're quite wrong about this. The whole point of long ultrahighpower DC lines is that a countries' wind and solar can effectively be spread over VERY large areas. Those large areas massively smooth the variability. Got a dunkelflaute in the Baltic? Never mind - it's windy down in the Bay of Biscay, and if that's not enough it's sunny in Turkey. And if that's still not enough just open the gates a bit more on those Norwegian dams ...

@richardcoundley 10 месяцев назад

Yes, theoretically it is possible but currently there is only 7.5GW of DC inter-connector capacity coming to the UK from continental Europe. This is only a small fraction of the capacity required to supply the current demand of 60GW in the winter and an even smaller fraction of the capacity required to make up for an 80% or more reduction of 160GW of generation from unreliable renewable power generation required to meet Net Zero on cold windless and sunless day in January.@@kenoliver8913

@geezzzwdf Год назад

beg to di.....zhank you for the personal research you have carried out and make your own informed decisions

@Naturalook Год назад

taking on the hardest issues to describe here, buddy... Good on you!!!!!!!!! ....Good job, well done!!!!!!!

@JustHaveaThink Год назад

Thank you :-)

@JustNow42 Год назад

No complains, well done. I remember when we used mercury rectifiers in the HVDC. Much better now. However I wanted to remind you ( sorry if I overlooked it) of the project shipping dust and gravel from Greenland to Africa and Brazil as fertilizer. AFRICA Got 50% improved harvest and as a byproduct the dust and gravel suck up a lot of CO2 in the process ( >25% of the weight of gravel and dust if I remember right) and we may even see people stopping burning forrest to get the nessary minerals to grow their produce. To your next question, yes it is much cheaper to transport the dust and gravel than to grind it. So please make a video about it unless you already have done that.

@baneverything5580 Год назад

This propaganda (Made in China( will now be forever blocked. Total loons here!

@alanhat5252 Год назад

I forget what the application is but mercury rectifiers are still the first choice for something.

@janisreifsteck78 Год назад

Excellent presentation as usual, but there is one unmentioned advantage of HVDC tech. Geomagnetic storms can disrupt AC transmission of electric power by saturating the core of transformers. HVDC should not be suceptible to this hazard.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

DC switchgear is based around semiconductors which also aren't keen on Voltage excursions. The lines themselves though are more likely to be isolated by being underground or under water.

@room5245 Год назад

Man so happy didnt see any of the doubters on my feed, but I did get recommended this nerdy beaut of a video and channel based on my algorithmic housekeeping

@Phtang-phtang Год назад

Another great video. Love what you’re doing

@JustHaveaThink Год назад

Cheers Richard

@jaredweaver6889 Год назад

My biggest concern is with these multinational projects. What's to prevent those in the producing countries from nationalizing the infrastructure and then flipping the switch or otherwise rationing the output in order to artificially raise prices? OPEC did it during the Carter Administration. I don't want to be held by the "short and curlies" again.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

Massive income streams like power supplies don't tend to get interrupted while payments are up to date. The CIA's 1953 coup in Iran was because BP hadn't kept payments up for 40 years. (BP ended up paying more & losing exclusivity).

@JonathanSwiftUK Год назад

That's great. I had heard about HVDC but didn't realise anybody was using it. In the UK we've got a massive problem where I read we can create huge amounts of renewable energy but don't have the cables / capacity to get it to the consumer. Can you do a video about that. In some cases I read that with planning permission some of these renewable projects may take 15 years to go live, but it seems this is mostly about planning and approvals and construction time is relatively quick. It's like our government is putting barriers in the way of saving the planet.

@alana8863 Год назад

I believe that some steps are being taken to address these issues, but it's like the government's promise of forty new hospitals - many of the few that will be built won't appear for at least another decade, but most are refurbishments and additions to existing buildings. We need a degree of scepticism!

@caterthun4853 Год назад

We need wind turbines on land in England. If you visit Scotland you will see their government has invested in land based wind turbines. On the Yorkshire moors the grouse shooting owners are opposing any changes to their land use that will reduce their few weeks per year of sport shooting..

@alanhat5252 Год назад

@@caterthun4853 Scotland also has the much more reliable tidal-flow generators ready to drop in the water but Westminster is blocking that too, the same in Wales, the Swansea Lagoon project just wanted the final signature from Theresa May when she was PM but it's still on ice (she preferred the single most expensive infrastructure project in the history of humanity on the other side of the estuary) & there's a repaired tidal-flow machine that's been sitting on Pembroke dock for half a decade waiting for approval to go back on-line. There's tidal projects all round the coast waiting for Westminster.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

@@caterthun4853 grouse, ptarmigan & pheasants don't fly high enough to hit big windmill blades (they are stupid enough though) so I don't see what the problem is? The Crown Estate pulled in £1billion in 2021 just from 'ground' rent from offshore windmills, I don't have any idea why these people would baulk at that level of income. (The King has redirected the income to public benefit though it wouldn't surprise me if the Torys have redirected it again but to their mates).

@alanhat5252 Год назад

@JonathanSwiftUK, we have the cables but they're sitting in warehouses waiting for planning permission, usually for more than a decade. Our first foreign HVDC interconnector, as you would expect, was from Kent (Sellindge) to Calais, it was connected in 1986 & has been operating continuously ever since apart from a brief outage while they sorted out a fire in 2001. We now have 9 running & plans for more, it sounds like the next one is Scotland to Iceland. (They have lots of geothermal to sell). Previous to that we have had many 330KV lines criss-crossing Britain for many many decades, we were coal-fired when they appeared, back in the days of the CEGB though I suspect they were AC not DC as the semiconductor switchgear hadn't been invented. (DC has the advantage you can put it underground or underwater without enormous losses).

@danaross Год назад

Great video. Super interesting. I didn't know about HVDC at all. Gracias.

@melmixpita543 10 месяцев назад

Don't let the critics get you down. You have an amazing channel with currently 530.000 subscribers. Obviously you're doing something right. The internet has in many ways become a very toxic place. It's hard but focus on the positive and the constructive (criticism).

@xenocampanoli815 Год назад

I hope we can use these tech to make our impact more humane, as well as our future less terrible.

@joemccarthy7120 Год назад

The future looks fine as long as the climate hysterics don't prevail too much.

@incognitotorpedo42 Год назад

@@joemccarthy7120 Nor the denialists.

@alana8863 Год назад

@@joemccarthy7120 Don't think you need to worry about 'hysterics' - they may be proved right, but the denialists have no chance of being proved right!

@joemccarthy7120 Год назад

@@alana8863 That is certainly strange logic.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

@@joemccarthy7120 only strange to you.

@beautifulgirl219 Год назад

Small modular nuclear reactors will become the go-to energy source - built to run consistently and as a flexible, carbon-free resource. Those right-sized reactors are emerging now that the U.S. government has incentivized them, making them more attractive for lenders and utilities. “You simply must have some form of reliable, baseload power because you can’t get there with assets that operate (part of) the time,” says Jeff Merrifield, partner, Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman, and a former Nuclear Regulatory Commissioner. “A nuclear power plant is more costly upfront, but it is an asset that OPERATES for 80 years. If you compare that to wind and solar, they generally have 20-year lifetimes and batteries of around eight years. If you compare renewables and batteries to nuclear, nuclear stacks up VERY, VERY well.” The more of them you build, particularly in sites like former coal plants, the more you hook them up to existing grids, or local micro-grids, and ELIMINATE or MINIMIZE the need for new or greater TRANSMISSION infrastructure. The U.S. Navy operates over 160 ships powered by more than 200 small nuclear reactors (aircraft carriers, submarines, ice breakers, etc.)

@AndyFletcherX31 Год назад

Sorry, the entire lifecycle cost of SMR or any nuclear power solution per MWh is far higher than slapping down a bunch of PV panels or wind turbines along with a sensible amount of battery storage. The US navy nuclear power programme isn't designed for low cost but to put power in difficult locations.

@beautifulgirl219 Год назад

@@AndyFletcherX31 Popular myth that is FALSE. Majority of large nuclear plant cost is financing over a very long period. Small repetitive designs are built quickly and cheaply. Multiply the solar cost by the 4 times you replace the panels and the 10 times you replace the batteries. Add the cost of recycling the panels / batteries or pollution in landfills. Nuclear is the ONLY energy source with the necessary ENERGY DENSITY to be CARBON NEGATIVE when combined with carbon capture. The ONLY adequate solution is not insufficient when insufficient solutions are sometimes less expensive in the short term by virtue of a failed / incorrect analysis.

@AndyFletcherX31 Год назад

@@beautifulgirl219 Nope, panels will last 30 - 40 years before major degradation, LiFePO4 batteries will do >5000 full cycles so will be good for about 20 years. Wind turbines are typically repowered after about 25 years. Nuclear power has a massive environmental footprint from mining and refining to the construction, long term storage and decommissioning. We also have security and safety issues with nuclear which you don't have with renewables that can be fully deployed within 2-3 years after permitting. It is worth noting that EDF in France are effectively bankrupt because of operational and decomissioning issues. In the UK the contract price of Hinkley per MWh is about 3 times that of current bidding for wind power. Hinkley is going up in price and wind still dropping in price. No myth there.

@The_JAC Год назад

Keep the good work up!

@jameswells2826 Год назад

I Really Enjoyed Today's Video So Much And I Definitely Learned Something New In This Video

@Ken00001010 Год назад

Dave, are advances in robotic underground tunneling providing support for this? If so, that would be another good video subject for you.

@SameAsAnyOtherStranger Год назад

The difference of "break even distance(s)" between HVAC and HVDC depending on whether they are overhead or underground is something I was totally unaware of. I have always liked the idea of supplying road vehicles with electricity via transduction; something like toy slot cars powered by electric toothbrush chargers. There's at least one trolly system powered this way in Japan. Integrating a transportation system using conventional contact or transduction over underground powerlines could capture electric bleed off.

@incognitotorpedo42 Год назад

It would never be done with a transmission line. Transmission lines need to be in an area where digging will not happen, and must be buried fairly deep to protect against incursion. With a HVDC line, there would be almost no power lost to induction, so there wouldn't be any to get in that way. Creating "charging roads" has been talked about, and there are even a few demonstration projects, but they are a dead end. They are far more expensive than a regular charger, are inefficient, so you lose a lot of power, and it would be very difficult to charge drivers for the power. Cars would require expensive extra hardware. Maintenance on such roads would be very expensive.

@davefoc Год назад

Great video. Thank you. I have wondered why there hasn't been more development of HVDC transmission lines. I didn't realize the premise of curiosity on this was wrong.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

if you're investigating from the UK the reason is that it's far too socialist for the Tory's voter-base & their supporting Press. In reality they put in new HVDC lines to Scandinavia & northern Europe last year (3 lines I think, maybe 4). Also, there's work on tidal power & additional windfarms & solar that aren't being reported.

@Dysiode Год назад

"For reasons that I'm sure are abundantly obvious..." I appreciate the not so subtle color change on the map at that remark

@pdxyadayada Год назад

I’m realistic, but leaning more toward pessimism given the world economical systems that prioritize profit, or ‘wealth development,’ over global ecological sustainability. I keep watching your channel with hopes of being persuaded otherwise, someday…

@5th_decile Год назад

What is "earth development"? Where is it mentioned? (A WEF thing?)

@joemccarthy7120 Год назад

What is globally ecologically sustainable about promoting uneconomic technologies that cannot even fulfill the role prescribed for them? Besides, what is wrong with CO2? Is it bad to have a more productive, greener, more prosperous earth?

@silverstake88 Год назад

Yes, heaven forbid anyone makes a "profit." Sure is a good thing you provide all of your labor and expertise to others for free as you have no bills or liabilities, right? Um, right?

@incognitotorpedo42 Год назад

@@joemccarthy7120 Are you talking about technologies like wind, PV, and EVs? Some of these, in some countries, are being subsidized in order to ramp the industries up to the scale we need by developing their markets. The tech is certainly ecologically sustainable, especially when compared to carbon-based fuels. I can't believe that in this day and age, you would even ASK what is wrong with CO2. Yes, higher CO2 helps plants grow, all else being equal. But it's NOT equal. Increased temperature variability with extremes in both directions, droughts and huge storms are all BAD for crop production. The net result of more CO2 will be a huge cost to humanity.

@Tron-Jockey Год назад

@@joemccarthy7120 - I have a few better questions. What's wrong with continuing to try new technologies and why do they frighten people like you? To make such a benighted comment about CO2 shows your willingness to push an unfounded bias. By the way, Bull Shit is good for plants as well, unless there's too much of it.

@jmr Год назад

Trying to explain the benefits of DC transmission to some people is like trying to talk about religion. They were taught AC is better as children and won't accept other possibilities.

@iller3 Год назад

That's allegedly because Edison lied about an experiment involving an Elephant and somewhere around 5,000 amps of Direct current to slander and defame Nikola Tesla's DC transmission designs

@steverobbins4872 Год назад

I visited the Sylmar facility back in 1985 when I was an engineering student at CSUN and taking a class in power electronics. It was really impressive. I don't know if they still have public tours.

@dodgygoose3054 Год назад

I just realized how much Mr just have a think looks and moved just like Wallace ... from 'Wallace & Gromit'. Once you see it you can't unsee it, but it does explain such a technical mind & love for the environment as it's in the family. =)

@jon1913 Год назад

Whenever I hear people say that our current infrastructure can't support electric vehicles I like to remind them that my EV takes less power to charge than my electric oven uses to heat up. Everyone in my neighborhood has an electric range and nobody bats an eye, but as soon as you plug in an EV everyone loses their mind.

@dustinherk8124 Год назад

then explain Austalia's rolling brown outs? Or California having consistent grid problems with not being able produce for the State's EV charge stations and their need to be supplimented by Diesel generators, because the grid alone cannot sustain it?

@nickkacures2304 Год назад

@@dustinherk8124 Australia 🇦🇺 has been governed by the right for a long period and you get what you pay for it’s really quite moronic to think about all the renewable energy resources that Australia has and not be pissed 😡 off at the foot dragging that’s causing a huge energy economic boom from happening faster the problem is your expensive use of fossil fuels not extremely cheap solar wind and battery storage.

@custos3249 Год назад

@@dustinherk8124 All due to EVs? Wow, I'd love to see your research showing it's EVs that are causing known phenomena that have been happening for decades before the popularity of EVs. Certainly can't be caused by power grids that were already inadequate and irrespective of what devices you plug in, brown outs are inevitable as power needs only grow, i.e. you can no more cite EVs than you can basic population growth.

@nickkacures2304 Год назад

@@dustinherk8124 California has always had expensive electricity but so has Texas in peak demand events like the infamous ice storm.The amount of renewable electricity that you have will determine your success as a community,region,state and country .

@jeremycrisp4488 Год назад

You are quite correct. Everyone does have an electric range with no problems. But if everyone ran out and got an ev, they more than likely would be charging their ev after getting home from work. Many people take hot showers after getting home from work, and then they make dinner. Running the oven can heat up the house, so the ac kicks on. This happens in millions of homes, and the power companies can barely keep up. If everyone was charging their ev, the grid would nor be able to keep up. It's as simple as that.

@inflationstation1 Год назад

The trick to sorting this out would be to pull subsidies from all energy production and let the market decide.

@joemccarthy7120 Год назад

Agreed. We also have to take away the mandates that give wind/solar power a preference.

@Tron-Jockey Год назад

Gee, does that include the nearly $5 billion in subsidies the fossil fuel industry receives every year? They've been receiving subsidies for many decades so, in the interest of fairness of course, can we continue with the renewable subsidies until we get close to what the fossil fuel industry has received? I'm sure you trolls wouldn't be opposed to that right?

@joemccarthy7120 Год назад

@@Tron-Jockey Gee whiz. That alleged $5 billion, even if true, is vastly dwarfed by "green" subsidies. If adjusted for amount of power generated, then it is vanishingly small compared to wind/solar subsidies. We are likely well past any notions of cumulative fossil fuel subsidies, real or fictional, with wind/solar subsidies of the last 10 or so years. And then there are the comparative benefits... Can you hysterics explain to me why I should feel good about paying a heavy carbon tax to drive my old car and heat my home and to grow my food so that I can help pay for the EV subsidy that my richer fellow citizens receive for buying their virtue signaling machines?

@van123446 Год назад

excellent production, as usual!

@JustHaveaThink Год назад

Thanks Van :-)

@ct1igu401 Год назад

Great video, very interesting. Would love to hear more about the technology etc. e.g. overcoming dc loss in the cable etc.

@onebylandtwoifbysearunifby5475 Год назад

_You've gone too far this time Dave!_ I find these alerts to the dangers and impossibility of clean electric energy highly valuable. In fact, i went 100% solar partly because of all the power outages in my area. Now i can hear these warnings by Big Oil alerting me to the dangers of renewable electrification, even when my neighbors don't have power and cannot hear such warnings.... Putting them at great personal risk. In fact, i believe these adverts such as: (Homer Simpson voiceover): "['Your Area']... (woman's voice): is on a dangerous path to electrification driven by [Homer Simpson: 'Your current politician']... (woman's voice): which puts you and all ['Your Area'] at risk!" These warnings are so valuable we should join forces and all get solar power so we can hear these warnings of the dangers of going solar. Never again will we miss a warning. Imagine: Uninterrupted by power outages or oil shortages or refinery shutdown due to extreme weather. Where so many of ["Your Area"] are unable to reliably hear these important warnings Big Oil graciously and selflessly communicates to us for our own good. Yes, _go solar so you can hear the dangers of going solar!_ Without it, you may be left in the dark. And then who knows what may happen to you. Be afraid, be very afraid. Without renewable power to hear these warnings, you simply will never know the dangers you face by renewable power. Yes, solar is so dangerous and unobtainable we must immediately go solar as not to miss a single warning from Chevron, BP, Shell, Exxon and other tireless scientific educators. Perhaps your power was out so you missed the re-education of Fossil Fuels, and why we need them. There's no way a nuclear fusion reactor 1.3 Million times the size of Earth could possibly power Earth. I did the math, and they're right: Q2 profits would sink. Very dangerous. We must all go solar immediately to hear their Oil Salvation message. Spread the word, we must all go solar immediately. Quickly, before the World electrifies and doesn't need legacy Fossil Fuels! Act now; Go Solar to Save Big Oil before it's too late!

@scottslotterbeck3796 Год назад

Nuclear is the solution. Carbon-free, clean, safe, always on.

@alanhat5252 Год назад

@@scottslotterbeck3796 there is *_NO "one solution"_*

@alanhat5252 Год назад

@@scottslotterbeck3796 ...and even if it _was_ *The One Solution* it's too bl00dy late! If the Government right now, this morning, decides for definite it wants a new nuclear power station it will be 30 years before it produces its first Watt of electricity. 2053. *Too bl00dy late!*

@Tore_Lund Год назад

Yes, a lot of climate change denial and anti EV Video suggestions?? Guess some lobbyists are making an effort on YT!

@joemccarthy7120 Год назад

We are drowning in a flood of CO2 hysteria, EV, wind/solar propaganda. You should be able to handle some criticism of the narrative just fine.

@tentringer4065 Год назад

@@joemccarthy7120 how much are the fossil fuel industries spending on 'lobbying' politicians and funding global warming denialism again? They are the ones trying to creative a narrative that defies the overwhelming scientific consensus. But that's OK, Just as long as the worst consequences don't affect you in your lifetime eh?

@guesswho6038 Год назад

@@joemccarthy7120 Those tentacles of oil industry reaching everywhere with their dirty money, no, it doesn't sound like a conspiracy theory at all.

@peterjohn5834 Месяц назад

Stunning report, thanks heaps.

@drabbit61 Год назад

At 61goingon16 I grew up l with documentaries. Your're work is as well produced and as informative as any. Thanks

@IA52342 Год назад

Thanks again, Dave, for excellent research and presentation. The cross-over graphs will help us explain to the uneducated masses what is real-world physics. I would like to add 2 thoughts: 1) The need for transmission lines may drop almost to zero. If solar panels arrive on 50% of roof-tops world-wide, and battery mega-packs are deployed for regional balancing, along with a washing-machine sized rust battery in every garage, 99% of what the grid does now will become useless. 2) What India wants to do to Africa, combined with the flip-side of what England is up to, constitutes both a) India sells the product to African nations, keeps the generating technology for itself, and b) England uses the African resources to take away solar production that would benefit Africa more by making industrialization affordable IN Africa. And a small side note on the west coast HVDC line - at night, on a good night, California sends electricity BACK to the north, reducing their need to burn coal/gas for a few hours here and there! "During winter, the northern region operates electrical heating devices while the southern portion uses relatively little electricity. In summer, the north uses little electricity while the south reaches peak demand due to air conditioning usage. " Link for that: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacific_DC_Intertie#:~:text=The%20Pacific%20DC%20Intertie%20(also,voltage%20direct%20current%20(HVDC).