No video :(

Robbie Collin reviews Lucy

Подписаться 252 тыс.

Просмотров 23 тыс.

50% 1

Robbie Collin reviews Lucy. A woman who is accidentally caught in a dark deal, turns the tables on her captors and transforms into a merciless warrior evolved beyond human logic.
Please tell us what you think of the film -- or Robbie’s review of the film below. We love to include your views on the show every Friday.
www.bbc.co.uk/5...
Fridays at 2pm on BBC 5 live.

Опубликовано:

28 авг 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 50

@SaintZ42 9 лет назад

Am I the only one here who thought the film was absolute garbage! I wanted Mark to walk in, bitch slap him and call him an idiot, it's a terrible film.

@comanchio1976 7 лет назад

The only thing I found even more shocking than how bad it was - were the positive reviews it got. Absolutely baffling.

@bennoclassico 10 лет назад

Anyone else not really like Robbie Collins' reviews? They scratch the surface and just make superficial observations without actually giving us any impression of what the films is like. Seemed like he was talking about Besson's influences for the film rather than the film itself...

@cracklingcharles 10 лет назад

I agree with you. I dislike his reviews there was a lot to talk about with this film there was a lot going on I thought and had so many smart and clever ideas that could have been pointed and observed.

@JRgsy 10 лет назад

He didn't thank the guy for the hot beverage, bad form.

@Kzzz1369 5 лет назад

Totally agree! Clear he's a Luc Besson fanboy. How much of this film is wasted by pointless visuals?

@lkuzmanov 7 лет назад

Please don't call a work science fiction when it violates a law of science every 30 seconds. Thank you.

@evesapple 10 лет назад

Okay, first off, I just have to say- MODESTY BLAISE! If the film industry is seriously scratching their heads about coming up with strong female characters, they couldn't do much better than her. Anyway, liked this review. Could be very easy to pick apart this film- which, ironically enough, is very brainless, but is still very entertaining and fun to watch.

@BrownstoneWalkUp 10 лет назад

I really like Robbie. He hasn't got a quiff or big flappy hands. But he's got a magnificent beard and a lovely cardigan.

@98smithg 10 лет назад

How is his Danny Dire impression though?

@xgonne 10 лет назад

When is the good doctor back? The number of factual errors makes me think Collins didn't watch the movie and is just give a blind thumbs up based on the press notes.

@michaelboitnott9925 10 лет назад

I think it is really tough to fill Kermode's shoes when people step in. I feel the same way about Robbie Collin and James King (King might be slightly better). Both are good, but living up to Kermode is very challenging. Not knocking their ability, just praising Kermode's. Now Edith Bowen does a great job. Nothing wrong at all with her adding to the conversation.

@liamj2363 10 лет назад

Does it attempt to explain why the '10% of the brain' thing isn't complely absurd? Because it is.

@jamesluby6705 4 года назад

What percentage of your brain are you using to reach this conclusion?

@luke-alex 2 года назад

Of course not. I respect what Besson was attempting here, but I think his reach exceeded his grasp immensely and the result is really naff. I say this as a fan of sci-fi.

@milijen3816 10 лет назад

This is one type of film I hope to see more of soon. Dealing with empowered female leads and highly conceptual. Similar to Christopher Nolan, but not shafting every single female character.

@RobRidleyLive 9 лет назад

I never believed the 10% myth, however having watched this turgidataintment confection,I am prepared to belive that no one involved used even that much of their mental capacity during it's production.

@willowandglass7599 9 лет назад

The film does have flaws (the random clips of animals and some cheesy lines particularly), and I would have liked to have seen some more character development before she went robotic other than making a phone call to her Mum, but overall it had a key idea and went with it for the film really well. It wasn't too long, it was well acted, fast moving, and ultimately highly enjoyable.

@FredSpade 10 лет назад

Hear hear. Of course she can easily carry a superhero film, just as easily I would say as carrying a movie where in later years she revisits Japan in some way in a role reversal with Lost In Translation's Bob Harris character (Bill Murray). You heard it here first folks, years ahead of its time ;-)

@alphabetaxenonzzzcat 7 лет назад

The film goes completely bonkers in the last act but - I still liked it.

@johnPaul-qn3dg 10 лет назад

I seen Luc Besson's name on this and I just said NOooooooooo. He has that effect on me. But after listening to this review I quite fancy it now. So Sold Robbie Collins,

@GeoNeilUK 10 лет назад

Luc Besson has the opposite effect on me, probably something to do with Leon and The Fifth Element

@johnPaul-qn3dg 10 лет назад

GeoNeilUK I love those films, but lately Taken, Taken2 transporter 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10, Lockout, Columbiana (Not bad) etc his films hit on a formula he keeps mushing out, of which I know he can do better but doesn't bother and just goes for the dosh rather than the heart. Which is OK, but I jusr don't enjoy those films.

@johnPaul-qn3dg 10 лет назад

***** I never thought of it that way. I only found out La Femme Nikita was his, I know he has talent. SO lets hope all his bills are paid.

@stephaniewright1942 8 лет назад

I loved this.movie...I thought there was no character development purposefully to show how insignificant humans are and the brevity of the movie was to reflect time and how fast life really moves, I think the lack of physicality on Johansson's character shows how she transcends violence and the more violent the Japanese mobsters are the less she reacts to the world

@isw1ft626 3 года назад

I myself, am 14 years of age and I am heavily contemplating on whether I watch this film. I do not like overly bloody films like 'Deadpool' and i heard that it was a rather gory film. Could anybody advise me or inform me on whether this film is suitable or not?

@rogerlynch5279 4 года назад

The only point to be scaptical against this movie is LUC BESSON. He tends to stress the overly artisticall moments in his movies BUT some of them like LA FEMME NIKITA were also exellent. Also the remake of the French original and the spin off series were well done too Right now I have seen the movie on German TV but I also own the DVD. Funny thing in the cinema here the movie was allowed up 12 and the DVD it has the stamp up 16

@tenpinjohn89 10 лет назад

I wish Edith would stop interrupting with her opinions, I'm more interested in hearing the professional film critic's review

@ameliorated 10 лет назад

cant mark make reviews while on holiday?

@ameliorated 10 лет назад

buut... he likes films

@evilgn0me 8 лет назад

I quite I enjoyed this but then again I enjoyed Fifth Element and other Luc Beson films so knew what nonsense may be on the way and knew what I was getting into. The 100% brain mcguffin is nonsense but is an interesting framing device for what was as far as I'm concerned one of the best portrayal's if not the best of someone reaching transcendence.

@Kagemusha22 10 лет назад

Sounds more like a Akira retread, than a Limitless one...

@GeoNeilUK 10 лет назад

Scarlett Johannson as Wonder Woman? Oh wait, she's already been cast. Scarlett Johannson in the next Batman film as Harley Quinn? Scarlett Johannson as Harley Quinn in a Harley Quinn film? (and no, I don't care if they're DC characters and not Marvel characters, they're just films I want made)

@JustJohn85 8 лет назад

Very Ghost in the Shell (1995) I thought.

@ButtSauceversion1 10 лет назад

Just so we're clear if you were using 100% of your brain at once you'd be having an epileptic fit.

@deformative 10 лет назад

Thank you, doctor.

@DominicGudgeon 10 лет назад

Liberal use of the word 'using'.

@ursie1986 9 лет назад

A concept like this is so ambitious they need to put art to one side and just allow our finest physicists and philosophers to produce and direct it. Artists produce beauty but the beauty in natural processes is a byproduct of their spectacular truth. Or maybe I'm just too rational to "get" science fiction. This film bored me, cartoon T-Rex and all.

@Steadno 10 лет назад

Only steven seagal could have been more annoying in the role

@joshb2410 10 лет назад

I tried to enjoy it but I just couldn't. Her character was just not interesting and to claim it as the best summer action blockbuster is just ridiculous!

@Dani-th6cl 7 лет назад

Lucy was good?!?

@christopherdaly5356 10 лет назад

It does rip off Akira a lot. Akira does it a million times better than Lucy though.

@Asa_Greenwood 9 лет назад

you've got to be a bit of a simpleton to enjoy this film, utter nonesense

@ArizonaBaySwimming 10 лет назад

never mind all the dumb impossible stuff like controlling tv etc so the chemical made her into god or something for some reason like a jedi....what a joke movie

@MrE5785 10 лет назад

who are all these randoms invading the channel, please bring mark back... please

@dennispotter4236 10 лет назад

except it ain't no urban myth! ...and Luc Besson bashing? Really? He's great fun to watch.

@dennispotter4236 10 лет назад

Nonsense. I think it's true, but it should come with the caveat 'under normal circumstances'. We don't use our full brain's capacity all the time. We only need some it most of the time, you get me? For example, have you ever been involved in a collision? Have experienced that 'time slowed right down' thing? Is that not an example of your brain working differently in certain situations? What about when people use hallucinogenic drugs? What about things like telekinesis? Also, would you been good enough to link me to an article debunking the theory? Cheers

@dennispotter4236 10 лет назад

I was hoping you'd be a bit more 'text book; than sending me a wiki link lol, but thanks for taking the time to do it. Wrong place for this kind of exchange anyway, sorry Dr Kermode. Good luck!

@dennispotter4236 10 лет назад

i know, but you went straight for the wiki reference. You know that wiki is not allowed now as a reference when handing in a university paper? It's not a case of spoon feeding. You asserted your point as if you actually had a clue, when you didn't. You were probably reciting something you heard in the pub. To add to that, you dug out the most bog standards references the internet has to offer. I'm just pointing out that that's poor on your behalf, it's lazy. I was hoping you actually knew what you were on about, but you don't really. Good luck anyway, we'll not waste one another's time any more.