Robert Sorby ProEdge Sharpening System

Подписаться 185 тыс.

Просмотров 140 тыс.

50% 1

A quick look at the Robert Sorby ProEdge sharpening system which Robert Sorby were kind enough to lend me for this review.
Less of a review really, I simply take a look at its main features and demonstrate the sharpening of woodworking chisels as well as shapening skews and a fingernail grind on a bowl gouge, two jobs which can be particuarly difficult for woodturners.
alex harris thiswoodwork teenwoodworker teen woodworker

Опубликовано:

2 окт 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 89

@rm42749 10 лет назад

I think you have a very bright future. Your parents should be proud of you.

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

Just to clarify this tool is on LOAN whist I do the review. Whether I decide to buy it or not we will have to wait and see. :P £250 is a lot of money, but is very similar to many other sharpeners. Alex

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

Very good point my friend, I believe that you can get a honing wheel attachment if you are looking for those results but you are right that straight off the belt they are not that sharpe.

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

Very true, that could be done using the 240 belt just before the final pass on the edge or using the honing wheel attachment.

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

Woodcraft definatly sell it but it is over $500. So there is no doubt that it is an up-market sharpener. Puts it in the same price bracket as the Tormex and those sorts of sharpeners.

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

If you buy a belt sander I guess you could modify it so it could give some better results.

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

Fair enough, I have seen ones about going for £250 but you are correct in saying they are likely to be more around the £315 mark. Was it me who blocked you or someone else? Anyways, stick to what you prefer this was just just a look at one type of sharpening system there are a number of other to consider. Alex

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

Hey, how much would you say a slow speed grinder with diamond wheel would go for. It may be worth taking a look, thanks.

@kickpublishing 9 лет назад

Too much sodding about swapping belts IMHO - rather have multiple wheels on a bench grinder and go from one to the next without even turning it off

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

Fair point my friend, this video may be useful for some, we shall see! The guy that suggested getting in contact with Robert Sorby about this machine did in fact modify his own beltsander to perfrom the same function. I will prob not do a video on the lathe as it can be a bit boring watching product overviews like this, I will however hopefully do a little article on the website at some point. Alex

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

Actual grinder is a lot cheaper, with the addition of the wheel the price works out about the same. Because of this I think it just comes down to prefrence.

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

Now thats an idea! Hope you have some luck with that tree, I wasn't paying attention when I planted mine, now I have sacks of pennies I don't know what to do with! :P

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

I did following the video, dicounted price but I did in fact spend my own money on this machine.

@Craftcreations. 8 лет назад

I have one but I don't think it is as good I thought it was going to be putting the skew to the left side is awkward and as a tool gets smaller it gets worse.

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

Ha! Robert Sorby asked for my input actually and that is exactly what I said to them.

@srslyusuck 12 лет назад

very nice video, wish they would send me one :) oh! if you want a true long grind on your bowl gouge first you need to re leave the top edge of the tool to create a slightly more pointed cutting edge at the tip. other wise your wings will be to steep and when you get a catch it will be nasty, don't ask me how i know LOL.

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

Certainly did, it was only a matter of time before someone noticed. :P

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

At the moment the plan is to send it back, we will have to wait and see I guess! :P

@ivoryquays6661 3 года назад

Great presentation. Clear and on topic. And no nagging "Please like and subscribe blah blah blah.) " I liked and subscribed.

@robertmunguia250 Год назад

I wonder if you can modify and put Kalamazoo parts? Drive wheel and belt kit.

@johnivarjakobsen6725 3 года назад

I like this video , have the oneway system , an a grinder, thinking about upgrade, there s a hooner wheel that also fit with the machine, anyone out there who has experience with this? Have red that ceramic belt are the best , 60 and 120 grit , and a diamond belt are also awaylebol, i do not do any woodcarving yet , but this tool looks great John

@summerswoodworking 12 лет назад

Alex, isn't it time for a new video?

@thiswoodwork 12 лет назад

Very True!

@1873Winchester 7 лет назад

I built my own wooden sorby copy. Not as compact as this, but I got three speeds and the ability to choose between a pretty large belt range (780-1100mm), it works pretty great, I still need to build that fingernail jig.

@ThatWoodWorking 12 лет назад

I'v just started turning and haven't bought a grinder/sharpener yet. Do you recommend the bench grinder or the belt sander? I know you have both now so id like to hear your thoughts. ,Thanks

@MikeWaldt 12 лет назад

Very informative Alex...thanks for sharing Cheers Mike

@thespanielinquisition7167 6 лет назад

Heat denatures steel, and friction of dry belts is basically grinding and friction creates LOTS of heat. This can give you a sharp edge but it will be a weak edge that will quickly blunt - unlike a wetstone that creates a razor sharp edge that is true hardened steel - only downside of a wetstone is the mess and water everywhere

@labrat7357 9 лет назад

I just wish Robert Sorby would include Tech specs like nealy every other manufacturer in the word does. dimensions etc .

@ThatWoodWorking 12 лет назад

I have, i think I'll go with a grinder, they're mostly cheaper than these sanders and more durable to heavier work, Thanks anyway.

@amertonartsstudio7718 6 лет назад

The people who use these seem to swear by them. The big advantage is the speed it takes to sharpen over a wheel such as a tormek. I have been mulling over buying one or buying a disc belt sander and rigging up some jigs.

@chelleneedle3616 8 лет назад

Your review was very informative and I thank you for that. I have just purchased one of these and I am figuring out how best to use it with minimal fuss. I bought the package with include all the extras so wish me luck!

@smijman 12 лет назад

Friendly Tip: I'm not sure, but it sounds like your microphone is right in front of your mouth when you are recording. If you were to move the microphone to either side, it might help to stop that *poof* sound when you make 'P' sounds and the like. Cheers.

@waltwales1342 10 лет назад

hi, i've been trying to decide on the best type of sharpening system for my needs and i have to say your review here has certainly moved me towards this Sorby rig. Thanks for an excellent clear and precise review [unlike soooo many on youtube!] cheers walt, wales

@BNSFfan1996 12 лет назад

If the tool steel is of a good quality it should handle the heat and keep its temper. But if its not a good quality TS it will loose its temper and become like normal steel.

@squiggofant 12 лет назад

A wet grinding machine will give you better results and is better for your tools. Dry grinding is always bad if you want to have a really sharp edge.

@deezynar 12 лет назад

Ya, I'm no genius, it's a pretty obvious flaw. I don't know how it made it into production that way. As I said before, it looks great otherwise. I'd like to have 5 of them so I could have a different grit on each one. I'll buy them as soon as my money tree starts to bear fruit. : )

@bessiebraveheart 9 лет назад

i bought one of these sharpeners two days ago. it is the best i've used. i restore antique pocket watches and clocks and this tool is ideal for shaping parts. it has many uses. the build quality is top notch.

@01sigh 12 лет назад

since your comment previously was about cost. I'll use that argument for my defense. Why buy a grinding wheel which would cost many hundreds of quid, when you can buy a 300 quid belt sander with belt sanders which would cost much less?

@Woodentoolcompany2 11 лет назад

Be a nice rig to have around for sure.

@deezynar 12 лет назад

Very good review, Alex. You have talent showing a tool and talking about its features, not everyone is good at that. It looks like a very good machine. The only thing about it that I don't like is the way they have the belt guard attached. They need to set it up so you just turn a catch and the guard hinges open. The current method of unscrewing 2 finger bolts is too slow and too inconvenient.

@jdubb1265 12 лет назад

Haters are gonna hate! Good review and great tool. It's not that people don't know how to take care of their tools properly this just makes it quicker and simplifies the process. Good work Alex. I enjoy your videos greatly!

@12Brian12 9 лет назад

can't i just use the 240 grit for the woodturning tools ? instead of using both grits .

@jdubb1265 12 лет назад

why would his opinion change at all whether it was free or he had to buy it? It's still a great piece of equipment and he did a great job of showing it/reviewing it! Sounds like somebody is jealous, he didn't get to demo one...

@Bob_Burton 12 лет назад

It seems very expensive for what it is, no matter how well it performs, As to the side guard, I suspect that many people will simply leave it off regardless of safety.

@Jeffreykum 6 лет назад

is the price worth it. ? I'm using a grinder . How long does the belts last ?

@mogbaba 7 лет назад

At $ 524 Amazon price, it's good to hear that it works.

@sootydave1 11 лет назад

A integrated "Spanner" Lol. how nice to hear that word used. reason I say that is I have not lived in the UK now for several years. and they call them wrenches hear in the US.... Thanks for a good video and smile.....

@vincent7520 8 лет назад

How strange ! … All the good stuff never comes with the most essential information : HOW MUCH ???? Goddam it !…

@jewelvibebabo 6 лет назад

My feelings exactly.I even went on the the Robert Sorby site and found I had to register or sign-up or join something to find a stockist!!!!!

@01sigh 12 лет назад

the flexibility of the belt sander far out weighs the cost difference between the two choices

@page358 12 лет назад

you have come a very long way in your videos mate, very shy to begin with now you dive right in there, keep up the good work :)

@stianskar7866 11 лет назад

Do you have to do something with the tools after you have sharpened them with the belt sander or an bench grinder? (Like water stone)

@paolowolverine 12 лет назад

i still prefer a top class waterstones and good sharpening guide

@bigchad007 12 лет назад

Very nice machine! Just what you needed. Keep up the great work, love the video's.

@darylzorn7037 3 года назад

Good video, thanks

@MrSkeeter18 12 лет назад

Good job. I have been looking to buying some kind of sharpener. I think you have made up my mind. Thanks bob

@MrLeonard55 12 лет назад

Good review Alex. I think they should make the price so more people can afford it. Leonard

@resetter 11 лет назад

Is the bevel of the chisel rounded? Or is that just the barrel distortion of the lens.

@ThatWoodWorking 12 лет назад

Ok, i'll think about it, great vid anyways

@benthesheep24 12 лет назад

Did they actually give you it, or did you have to give them it back?

@WoodyWoodTurner 11 лет назад

Sorby ProEdge Plus Sharpening System $539.99 - Woodcraft Supply-USA price

@jasn5754 9 лет назад

To be honest - giving you a sharpener is pretty much the same as paying you for the review. Really good job filming and reviewing it by yourself though. RU-vid is monetised, everyone knows that - and by reviewing, you're effectively advertising their product. So it's not necessary to add disclaimers such as - This isn't a review, no financial incentive, etc. Much better to just say - Here's an honest review...

@thiswoodwork 9 лет назад

Jåsøn ß That's a fair point, but in this case I wasn't given the sharpener, it was on loan whilst I performed the review. I ended up liking it enough that I decided to pay for it, which after doing the review they sold to me for a discounted price. Which is similar I guess, but certainly not the same.

@jasn5754 9 лет назад

Can't believe Robert Sorby took money from you(?!) You did a great job for them.

@vincent7520 8 лет назад

+Jåsøn ß Sir you've got strange notions about manufacturing companies and other businesses !… No they don't give away their products even when you did a good advertising job by, for instance, writing an article in a magazine. All the home appliances I wrote about in the course of 35 years of publishing / advertising we either given back to the company of bought from them with no rebate price most of the time !… Got paid by magazines form reviews, never got a cent from the manufacturers even under the form of presents… and certainly no trips to the Bahamas !!!…

@65BAJA 11 лет назад

I ended up buying the Tormek T-7. Have you ever used one?

@casper1240 5 лет назад

Far too complicated for me sorry

@icespeckledhens 8 лет назад

A very good review, thanks

@shyshy503 12 лет назад

how much is it and do they ship to the usa?

@ialamont22312 12 лет назад

At 4:00 did you mean to say sharpener? ;)

@KravMagaCornwall 11 лет назад

you sound like Nigel Thornberry lol

@Book-Mark 10 лет назад

Nice review, thanks.

@shonnyNOR 8 лет назад

Have the guys at Sorby's pinched the idea of all the Tormek grinding jigs? Or does it just seem so? After all, English and stealing are synonyms ;-)

@verktoy_as 8 лет назад

Hørt om samarbeid?

@shonnyNOR 8 лет назад

Engelskmenn samarbeide når de kan rappe det?

@verktoy_as 8 лет назад

Vet at de har samarbeidet med Tormek om dette, men er litt usikker på om det har fortsatt..

@TheGazzer123 8 лет назад

Dose it look the same. Is it the same ? Or do you need glasses a white stick and a dog !

@mogbaba 7 лет назад

Har du hørt om samarbeid mellom sau og ulv?

@СашаСлутцкий 10 лет назад

а в украине есть такой станок и сколько стоит

@awesomeopp 11 лет назад

Nice review Alex.

@RGplayer101 12 лет назад

ooh nice

@jeffstanley4593 9 лет назад

Can you sharpen knives with it? thanx

@thiswoodwork 9 лет назад

Jeff Stanley Yes you can, although it does require an additional (optional) attachment unfortunately.

@yealife2947 7 лет назад

You can sharpen just about anything on it..

@kevinscurlock6673 10 лет назад

@sootydave1 we call them wrenches because.. well... they're wrenches :)

@redman1ism 11 лет назад

are you squeezing your nose to speak.. just asking lol

@BigFatTonys 12 лет назад

consider adding some comments to the video about the heavy duty construction of the Pro Sharp, There are some comments about the high cost of the tool, but these people have not hefted or used the tool. It is built to last.

@BigFatTonys 12 лет назад

I would have appreciated a YT email follow up about this success with Sorby. And also I think it would have been proper for you to reply to my review of Civil Engineering that you asked me to write, that took a bit of time to do.

@BigFatTonys 12 лет назад

Where did you ever come up with the idea to contact Sorby to do a review of the Pro Sharp. What a brilliant idea !!!