Convinced he's thinking of Syd when he sings it. But maybe this night, somewhere deep in Roger's unconscious, he wished David were here too. in any case thank you guys, you made my life
So, so you think you can tell Heaven from hell Blue skies from pain Can you tell a green field From a cold steel rail? A smile from a veil? Do you think you can tell? Did they get you to trade Your heroes for ghosts? Hot ashes for trees? Hot air for a cool breeze? Cold comfort for change? Did you exchange A walk on part in the war For a lead role in a cage? How I wish, how I wish you were here We’re just two lost souls Swimming in a fish bowl Year after year Running over the same old ground And what have we found? The same old fears Wish you were here
Roger, thank you. I play this song for my Dad. He passed away on June 23,2022. In 3 days it will be a year. I miss, love and wish he was here. Thank you for helping through this tough time.....
Chantal: Which magic? I saw and heard nothing yet!! You dreamed of PF but you saw and heard an old and bittersweet man who‘s hating PF in search of the lost chords. PF is history and Roger is the walking dead!
Хотелось бы, чтобы ты был здесь Итак, вы думаете, что можете сказать Рай из ада, синее небо от боли? Можете ли вы сказать зеленое поле из холодного стального рельса? Улыбка из-под вуали? Как вы думаете, вы можете сказать? И они заставили вас торговать ваши герои для призраков? Горячая зола для деревьев? Горячий воздух для прохладного бриза? Холодное утешение для перемен? И вы обменяли прогулочную часть на войне за главную роль в клетке? Как я хочу, как я хочу, чтобы ты был здесь. Мы просто две потерянные души плавание в аквариуме, год за годом. Бег по той же старой земле. Что мы нашли? Те же старые страхи. Хотелось бы, чтобы ты был здесь
The world's most expensive Tribute Band....Roger showing again he contributes very little to these concerts....save your money and go see Aussie Floyd instead.....at least they don't mime ❤
Когда я был молод и слушал разные западные рок группы, я как то сказал, что Пинки-лучшая группа всех времен! Сейчас я давно не молод и согласен с собой молодым!!!
He can not sing, he can not play the main riff, he can not play the solos. Why should I pay for a show of a guy, who's not even the main star of the whole performance? The whole situation is difficult to understand, you can reply to this comment and use the argument that he was the main songwriter for Pink Floyd, you won't be lying, he was a great composer, better than Gilmour, however, as a musician, he can not be considered as "professional". Don't tell me the reason why he can't deliver a better performance because of his age, that's a cheap excuse for someone who was never a good musician. Remember guys, someone can be a great composer without great musical skills.
Vergonha: depois de velho e acabado passando pelas cidades dos países subdesenvolvidos que no seu auge não vinham! E os trouxas pagando um absurdo! Parabéns a todos os idiotas que pagaram ou parcelaram, no cartão que não vão pagar, para prestigiar alguém que no passado viria ou SP ou RJ!
I just don't like it when the audience's voice drowns out the singer's. I come to the concert to hear the author sing damn it! not a chorus of kids with cell phones in the hand!!!!!
Che bello vedere che anche molti giovani cantano a memoria "Wish you...", questi brani sanno emozionare le generazioni...Mi sono emozionato...Roger uno dei piu grandi artisti viventi.
Awful….If I went to see a Pink Floyd tribute act and they performed like that I would want my money back. Hang on….this is a Pink Floyd tribute act, just one with a bitter and angry front man.
Поддерживаю полностью. Никогда негатив не исходил от Гилмора, Мейсона и Райта. Да, без Уотерса Pink Floyd уже не тот, но их альбомы слушать приятно. Уотерс без Pink Floyd - просто Уотерс. И злоба от него исходит и негатив, а не спокойствие и мудрость, обычно свойственные такому возрасту...
@@t20f70 ah ok per la corda spezzata ! grazie 😀 non l'avevo nemmeno notato... Per quanto riguarda David, non lo so nemmeno io, non è apparso nemmeno sullo schermo durante il concerto
04:17 Good to see Roger not omitting this part and actually scatting along. Too bad I will never watch a Pink Floyd concert with 3/4 of their classic formation.
David Gilmour ist ohne Frage ein sehr guter Musiker - doch Pink Floyd war mit "The final cut" beendet. Pink Floyd lebte - anfangs - durch Barrett und Waters. Nichts gegen Mason und Wright, die beiden hatten jedoch nur wenig kreativen Anteil. Gilmour's Gesang und Gitarre waren auf sehr hohem Niveau; keine Frage! Doch sein kreativer Beitrag zu Animals, D.S.O.T.M, Wish you where here, The Wall und The final cut war "überschaubar".......hätte D.G. nach "The final cut" - solo - weiter gemacht; ALLES wäre gut gewesen. Diese Möglichkeit ließ er leider - scheinbar - unbeachtet. - - - Kurioser Gedanke: die Beatles OHNE John Lennon? Die Dire Straits OHNE Mark Knopfler? Santana OHNE Carlos? The Cure OHNE Robert Smith? Die Doors OHNE Jim Morrison? - - - "Genesis" ist DAS Beispiel für erbärmliches Festhalten an einem großen Namen; einer großen MARKE! - Peter Gabriel verkörperte Genesis ebenso wie Roger Waters Pink Floyd verkörperte. Und dann sangen "Genesis" "I can't dance".......Gabriel ist gerade auf Tour, wie eben auch Waters. Mit IHRER Musik!
Haber..soy muy enfermo de floyd desde su primer.simple(arnol lane) Nadie se acuerda de un tal Sid Barret? Las composiciones de waters son inigualables..y las de Sid Gilmour tremendo guitarrista y muy buena voz..lo vi a gilmour..fantastico .era Floyd....Pero cuando vi a Waters era waters.. Sin Barret no hubiese existido floyd...no se tu edad yo empece con ellos..arnold lane y luego todo ..el mejor disco q escuche en mi vida...dark side of the moon...y nada ni genesis Crimson yes.e.l.p. Csmel jethro...nada como dark side...disculpen mi ignorancia..
