I agree the best midfielder in the Prem late 90s/early 00s. It’s pretty embarrassing and shameful that the Scholes’ career revisionists now seem to have him as the better player when, at the time, Keane was the first name on the sheet whilst Scholes was sometimes dropped for Butt or Park!
@@brentmeistergeneral6074 that’s very true. But Scholes is just a different breed of player. But you’re right. Remember it was Scholes who had to accommodate for Veron and the England team when Lamps and Gerrard came through, he was on the left wing! But Scholes could dictate tempo, Keane couldn’t do that.
Coming from a city fan I agree. Never liked Keane growing up but as soon as I found out their story and how open they've been have a lot of respect for them. Love how Gary has put his biases aside for punditry
The fact that players still refer him as best to push the standards is what makes him special. Miss players like him . Hard and determined to win at all costs
If Keane was English he would have been the first name on-the England team sheet every time . Wouldn’t have been any arguing about lampard or Gerard being central midfielders . It wound have been Roy Keane and everyone else afterwards .
Well said John, I certainly agree with you about Roy Keane if he was English, Gerrard and lambard would be shinning his boots, keane would have wan the wc for England period.
It's such a compliment the way they hold him in Great esteem boh as a person's and a player. These are great men themselves, outstanding sportsmen. Respect
I have never seen a better leader on the pitch. I have never seen a midfielder who took possession of the blades of grass in the middle of the pitch. Immense, immense.
Roy Keane was unique in all aspects. He was the perfect reflection of Man utd attitude then . He was the engine which pulled the team towards glories. Wish we could clone Roy and induct the clone now. Because we desperately need that mindset now, more than ever.
Them days are gone, there are no more players who love the game that much and in keanes mindset and ways..... the majority of players nowadays are business men first, only a few left who bleed the colour of a club...
I watched Roy Keane in absolute awe , to hear players talking about him makes me delighted I watched the right things . How you improve on brilliance and drag them to greatness is something really special
Different generation!, he wouldnt last 15 minutes in the modern game, sent off for looking at a player funny,resulting in the conclusion of body shaming
Nevermind a keane I would take an Evra, a vidic, a neville, a bruce... Pretty much any guy who was even half a leader. The team is so void of character at the moment. Maguire is supposed to be a leader but he can barely get his own housr in order in terms of his own defending. You cant start getting others together if your a shambles yourself.
@@francismurphy7708 agreed yeah, honest analysis for the most part. Tough game on yous yesterday, hopefully VVD isn't gone for long, not having him is a massive loss, lot of hate on social media about him, really nasty wishing a player be injured long term.
When utd first won European Cup under fergie, the match against juventus keane was an absolute warrior, box to box and his goals . A one off generation player
Agree Roy keane was best midfielder of his generation from a liverpool fan slightly better than stevie g and steve gerrad was a top top midfielder one of best in world.
@@LoscoeLad you could be Right viera was unreal player and leader also won world cup so you could be Right never was afraid of a battle with keane or anyone and dominated midfield and scored goals complete midfielder 👍
I'm a liverpool fan and I would have keane in any of the great liverpool teams of the past. He was just relentless, a proper midfielder could do a bit of everything. Maybe not the most eye catching footballer but still world class in my opinion
United captain: From Keano to Maguire. That's how far we've fallen. With all due respect to Harry Maguire, but he of all people, probably needs Roy Keane shouting in his ears more. He's still young.
Bar Teddy Sheringham (I'm a Tottenham fan) Roy Keane has always been my favourite football player, for all of the reasons that people know and say about him. He was a captain in every way shape and form and a magnificent footballer.
Never been replaced, where do you sign a man of his mentality in this day and age. Modern players are snowflakes by comparison. Roy never melted in the heat of battle.
Even tho Im a liverpool fan, I think its clear Keane sensed issues deep down in the team and he was proved correct the next wk against Villa ! they still a great team but not what they were for 3/4 of last season.
Can you imagine if Keane was playing now with empty stadiums, and you could hear every word he's saying? I think there'd have to be a lot of soundless televised games 😂
Couldn't agree more the man was outstanding it's just a shame with the way football is now he wouldn't be a good manager but as a player on the field you would want to win for him by the way he played
I Loved Bryan Robson as a player but I’d have to take Keane ahead of him and there’s no greater accolade from me. Part of Man Utd left me the day he did, it’s the never been the same since.
greatest skipper ever..it really hurts me when i see people pick the greatest MU team ever, and Roy Keane isnt in it. Should be the first name on the list. Roy Keane and Alex Ferguson two men that made the other great, fergie won so many battles on the edge of Roy Keane"s sword...he should remember that!
I'll never forget bill o herlihys face when didi haman said Vieira was better the poor lad was crestfallen never seen a bubble burst so spectacularly, beautiful.
There are only a few people on this squad that would SURVIVE a season with Keano: Marcus Rashford is humble and seems hard working; as does Scotty Mac; Fernandes is smart, fiery, and hard working (kinda in the Keano mold) Van de Beek is box to box; and AWB is a solid defender (if they stop trying to make him a flying fullback). I think after he slapped him around a bit Mason Greenwood would be his new Becks. I know he doesn't like de Gea, but I think he likes Romero, and am sure he likes Henderson. Throw in the part time kids Fosu Mensah and James who he can mold and I doubt the great one wants anything to do with the rest.
@@CreatureClub777 Very well, I am originally from Derry although residing in London for 32 years. Persistently over the years English soccer fans have attempted to chide me that no Irish players would have got in the English national side.
The writers of Ted Lasso must be long-time Manchester United fans. Brett Goldstein said the Roy Kent character was based on Roy Keane and Eric Cantona.
Look at nearly every PL team that has won the league and they inevitably have a great captain. We had Keane, Arsenal had Vieira, City had Kompany, Chelsea had Terry, and even to a lesser extent Liverpool last season had a solid captain in Henderson. Look at Man Utd now and we have the wet lettuce Harry Maguire instead of Bruno who actually seems to want to fight for the club..
These kind of characters are not getting born these days generation gone now the mobile Instagram baby boys with agent becoming their father.. what a pity for fans we won't see any of these products now
People always argue who's the best midfielder the EPL has ever seen. Scholesy, Frankie Lamps, or Stevie G. When I say neither and Roy Keane is the best midfielder the EPL has ever seen, I get looks from others like I'm a lunatic ! There's only one KEANO !!
A lot of notice is on Keane's leadership and fearlessness. However, if truth be known Eric Cantona was THE player that no one bothered. Not even Roy Keane or Sir Alex Ferguson...
@@Jmith-su3ze .....Did you actually watch Robson play regularly ??? You clearly didn't ! Keane was in fantastic sides, while Robbo didn't have the class of players around him. He was absolutely commanding on the pitch, constantly organising players. He led by example and raised his game even higher when United were up against it. His engine room and drive were incredible. Robbo played around the same number of games in the same position as Keane, but he scored twice as many goals, that in teams that didn't have the fire power of the teams Keane was involved in. They had a poll on the United website I'm on and Robbo polled 98%. Don't get me wrong Keane was a fantastic player but Robbo was something very special. Anyone who saw him play regularly will tell you the same.
They could put Vieria in the same sentence as KeAne., not those two. Keane was busy rubbing shoulders against the likes Zidane not players at their level, which is one or two rungs below. They weren’t as consistent, tough or had as much in their locker as him. Neither of them would ever dominate players like Zidane David’s Vieria list goes on
In Keane's times, all that players wanted to do was to win; but all that today's players (including Pogba, Maguire, de Gea, Shaw, A W Bissaka, Rashford, Martial, Jones, Rojo, Mata etc..) want is MONEY. This is what makes them happy, and to hell with football, or wins, fans, or MU. This is the sad state of affairs of the football industry.
Paul Scholes and Roy Keane is a very very good CM partnership. These two encapsulate everything in them that a midfield pairing needs. Today's footballers are too soft, they live in an alternate reality fabricated around them by their greedy agents, much like the Hollywood stars. Ricky Gervais probably needs to take the modern day footballer to the cleaners as well.
As an LFC fan I wish we had signed Keane. A Souness style winner. The spice boys generation were soft lads and show offs. We loved them and They entertained but they did not have the will to win. Too busy counting their millions and planning there transfers to Real Madrid not caring a jot about the fans. Now they are back commentating on the current team as their punishment for being slack. None of the spice boys are fit to lace Roy Keanes boots.
All of yous Utd fans wishing you had Keano around now don't have a clue how much us Sunderland fans want him back here now. We've got a mega rich owner now we need Keano back to sort the place out from top to bottom.
But Keane was legendary just as big as Ferguson better as a player pitty Ferguson slagged him as Keane was a fundamental part of Ferguson’s success as manager it proved it as he tolerated him at his peak until he had the knee injury
Cavani: "The Daily Mail reported Cavani will sign a two-year deal at Old Trafford worth £210 000 ($270 000) a week after tax. " I thought United were going in a different direction? Short term signing. He man is 33. Unsubscribe manchesterunited dot com. Ed Woodward you are clueless mate!
Not nescessarily a bad deal but it's a panic one. And everybody is laughing at United regarding their way to do deals. Could've had Bruno for 1 more year, could've had Sancho now, then there's the plethora of options that were irrelevant as options because neither of any deals were made because of Ed incompetence and board leeching.
It's strange, I'm not excited and I'm not angry, however it is too expensive with the wages and I'm extremely annoyed with the reported 10 million euro agent fees when the board are haggling over the Telles fee...
Roy Keane needs to be at United they are missing exactly what Roy Keane is drive commitment high standards work rate not the show pony pogba who makes the team worse
One Champions League medal. Domestically successful but a failure internationally. It is a blot on both Ferguson and his captains’ claim to true greatness. The reality is they were both minnows of European football.
