RTAA & Source - The One in the Hole 

One of the best MC Let's Plays they've done. Gotta love how Team Lads are left speechless while Team Gents revels in Ryan's sadism.

“Edgar is the one in the hole” might be the most deeply terrifying thing I’ve ever heard.

Haha man that little 'wot?' noise Gavin makes at 1:57 is the best thing ever

Geoff Killed Edgar. If you watch the video Michael Left Edgar in the cactus field and then soon after that Geoff killed a cow in the cactus field

I wonder when Edgar is gonna come forward and tell his story.

*_”EDGAR IS THE ONE IN THE HOLE”_*

I miss these days, this gave me laugh but now I’m just stuck with haunting realisation… We will never have this again…

"Edgar is the one in the hole!" I lost my shit

My favorite part of this is not that they freed Edgar, or Ryan's quote. It's the fact that even though Michael says he's happy that he freed the real Edgar, Geoff had actually killed the cow for leather in the same video."

“Ryan, you disturbing person”

To this day Geoff losing his shit starting when Ryan says he grew wheat to pretty much the end still gets a big laugh from me ♡

Cant believe this actual moment is over 10 years old now. That is wild.

Man, Jack and Geoff's laughs are the best lol

i now know where Port (From RWBY) Got the "Edgar is the one in the cage"

Geoff killed the original Edgar

Forget a T-Shirt, I want Edgar’s hole as a rug

“You don’t understand. *Edgar is the one in the hole.”* Jesus, you can hear both lines laid over each other. Ryan sounds like he’s possessed!

man you can tell that jack and geoff have worked together for a long time at 3:14 when they have the exact same laughing pattern

excellence at 1:37, covering up the work under the pyramid, love it

I love how the second he frees Edgar, Michael is like "We should probably save"

Pre-2015, pre-Fullscreen buyout, this is what Rooster Teeth was supposed to be, not the over-scripted/curated stuff they make these days(some of it is great, but it is not what I loved RT for). 2003-2013 was amazing content. Geoff, Burnie, Hullum's occasional appearance, Joel, Jack, Gus, Gavin, Michael, Ray, and Ryan was a golden cast across 99% of the stuff they made(shout-out to Nathan Zellner in "Chain of Thought", in my top 3 RT shorts ever... the sound of the wind!). Note that this was not just before we knew about the Ryan stuff, it was before any of it happened, before he sullied himself and hurt people. I came to RT from the DrunkGamers website that started it all, it is an era of the internet I miss!

"Somebody knocked the Kung Fu off my house!" - I'm surprised we haven't had a t-shirt of this yet!

The real Edgar was killed by Geoff not too long after Michael freed him.

This moment always makes me laugh, its my favourite minecraft moment

Still hilarious over a decade later

7 years later and is is still probably the best RT minecraft moment

The real Edgar got killed by Geoff.

0:12 Why am I not surprised by Gavin's actions?

Lol, I went to watch both episodes right after the short. I'll still re-watch this.

In the business we call this foreshadowing

Little did we know what kind of true monster Ryan was.

When ray was like 'im lost' i laughed so hard

The noise Gavin makes is fucking unmatched

Ryan: "No you don't get it Edgar is the one in the hole" Geoff: "you are a disturbing person Ryan lol" lol

“Edgar’s the one in the hole” Jesus Ryan... there’s a reason you’re my favorite

3:04 “You grew Wheat!” 🤣🤣

Geoff just saying, "Ryan, you're a disturbing person." Gavin saying, "Ryan is a lunatic." When the controversy came into the public's eyes, these sentences became 100% true in reality and not just in game. Reminds me of a sentence in Red vs Blue of Wash and Church saying, "wtf is with this guy?"

Ryan's maniacal laughter and Geoff's hysterical laughter are both fantastic.

It's been YEARS and this still makes me laugh out loud

my favorite thing about this is later on in another episode theyre playing the king game and ryan has them all go in a hole (turns out its THE hole) and directs the group to kill edgar. they kill a cow down there and are confused why ryan wont let them out until he says again "no, edgar is the one in the hole"

"I was gonna expand his hole" -Ryan "Mad King" Haywood

This one of those sources that I think a majority of the people who watched the AA new the source

I miss this. Such a classic. I miss Ray.

This is my favourite Minecraft moment.

Didn't Geoff kill the real edgar later in that Let's Play

You can hear Michael having a minor brain aneurysm as he looks at replaced Edgar, beneath King Ryan's mad cackling.

This is probably the best episode of AH, and it's all because of this story lol

EDGAR IS THE ONE IN THE WHOLE

Be what it may.....still one of the best lines in the history of AH. Imo. Have to separate the art from the artist. Otherwise we would have very little left. My thoughts and sympathies to the victims.

I love it when Geoff laughs so hard.

Best LP Minecraft moment ever lol!

his name is robert paulson

Joel's break down is in a video podcast but it was back when it was the drunk tank MONTHLY podcasts.

Where has the time gone...

Big oof 2020

3:33 "i was gonna expand his hole" O_O

Honestly, I'm curious where Ryan is right now. I wouldn't be surprised if he moved out of Texas to avoid seeing everyone he worked with.

I absolutely love this videos dude, keep doing them!!! :)

if I had any animation talent I would make an animation of this moment with no evil/sadistic effect and see how many people get pissed off

This is a glorious piece of history.

Free Edger 2014-15

We are all Edgar now.

The Mad King Ryan strikes back.

That echo on the hole.

Ryan references this in today’s episode of Galacticraft

Unfortunately, someone actually killed Edgar without knowing.

The adventures of Edgar continue!!!

Thank you for doing this

almost 7 years ago was Edgar temporarily freed.

Excellent work in the fusion!

Always a classic

Edgar died in the cactus field

I love how you do this!

3:03 you grew wheat!

A simpler time in achievement hunter...

Iconic

Welp, my cancer's gone. Chinese? Anyone?

damn I've been watching them play minecraft for a long ass time.

Would have loved if they had face cams on

i forgot did this happen when he was on the couch or when he had a proper desk

That is so Priceless! XD

So basically whoever is in the hole becomes Edgar,Edgar is not an actual person but more so an idea

This is just too classic. They can make better let's plays than this, but because this is this it can't be topped. It's too classic.

If you look at the full video. Edger gets killed by one of them. To make clothes. Rip Edger “ You are free”

You have to FEAR edgar!

I miss Ryan, what ever happened to that guy

I feel asleep faster knowing the real egar is out there😮

Yikes dude.

Ryan's insane

3:11 EDGAR IS THE ONE IN THE HOLE

Imagine if they used face cams during this

3:10 What everybody came here for. 😂

Yeah! He did it!

What’s up Edgar?

How is it they keep Edgar from de-spawning anyway?

You don't understand.

This didn't age well.

#FreeEdgar!!!

lol i was looking for this one

I always lose it after the rtaa cause of Ryan saying I was going to expand his hole. Dirty minds will understand