Тёмный

Rubber-Tire Trams in Medellin, Colombia 2020 

Timosha21
Подписаться 91 тыс.
Просмотров 51 тыс.
50% 1

What kind of tram is this?! This does not run on rail, rather on pavement like a bus!
Comment your thoughts below on the benefits and drawbacks of this interesting technology.
Medellin is the 2nd largest city in Colombia with a population of 2.5 million.
-
Comment below so we can all have a productive 'conversation about transportation!'
Thank you for all the support!!!

Опубликовано:

 

7 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 165   
@jirimelnicky1472
@jirimelnicky1472 4 года назад
One of the most beautiful trams. Congratulations to Medellin!
@DBM1234-d1f
@DBM1234-d1f 4 года назад
hello, as we all know the trains, the subways and the trams are designed according to the needs of the land, for this reason the Medellin tram has pneumatic aids to be able to quickly climb the slopes of Medellin, if this tram line was flat obviously its Wheels would be made of steel, (as usual) but since this line was made mostly on slopes, its wheels are pneumatic to have more acceleration and grip on the slopes, since a patinary metal wheel and easily slip on a steep incline.
@siachoquero
@siachoquero 4 года назад
This is not a tram it is translohr ;)
@siachoquero
@siachoquero 4 года назад
And it si not designed for Medellin it is just a French quite horrible products which stopped production aready.
@DBM1234-d1f
@DBM1234-d1f 4 года назад
@@siachoquero The Medellin tram line was built by the French, but the trains are made in Belgium and are very beautiful and resistant.
@DBM1234-d1f
@DBM1234-d1f 4 года назад
@@siachoquero In addition, Translohr is a tram only of another type, as there are several types of cars, and several types of subway: underground, level, mixed, elevated, monorail and suspension, the Medellin tram is another type of tram, but it is trolley car.
@siachoquero
@siachoquero 4 года назад
@@DBM1234-d1f the vehicles are also French it is not important where they are being assembled.
@matiasgrioni292
@matiasgrioni292 4 года назад
As others have said, the rubber tires are usually used for more inclined slopes (or in some metros such as Montreal they also accelerate and brake faster, and are quieter). But apart from that, the tram system itself is lovely. It works well with the pedestrianized area around it, and the lack of major rails keeps it this way. It is also quiet, and obviously partly a social improvement project through the more informal neighborhoods on the surrounding hillsides.
@mariabaier3080
@mariabaier3080 2 года назад
I agree. The system is beautiful, modern, very efficient and nice to ride . It
@grassytramtracks
@grassytramtracks Год назад
Why not build a trolleybus or a funicurlar?
@scottyerkes1867
@scottyerkes1867 2 года назад
Transit systems usually are built with with topography, power source, usage in consideration. Medellin chose rubber tires for a good reason. Mexico City Paris and Montreal have rubber tired subways Thank you Tim for posting this video😀😀💙
@__JH_
@__JH_ 8 месяцев назад
The problem I see is that they sold us a guided bus at the price of a tram, and to have a 4km journey it was not really the best option, for a 4km area a normal articulated bus would have been cheaper and fulfilled the same function. Or just a real tram, that section is not a roller coaster either, a real tram could handle it
@luis-qx2mp
@luis-qx2mp 3 года назад
Saludos desde colombia, medellin es llamda la mejor ciudad del territorio y tiene el apodo de la ciudad de la eterna primavera en el 2013 fué conocida como la ciudad mas innovadora del mundo
@strassenbahntk
@strassenbahntk 4 года назад
To answer a question repeatedly raised here in the comments: why did Medellin select a tram on tyres and not a real one? - Medellin is (in my view) the only reasonable Translohr implementation in the world, because it makes full use of the system's only advantage over a conventional streetcar: its ability to climb. Medellin is a city of hills. The translohr can climb up to 13% while still retaining full operation speed upwards and downwards under surface conditions from dry to wet, while streetcar / light rail can climb up to 10%, but only with dramatically reduced acceleration upwards on wet tracks and very slow operation speed downwards on wet and dry tracks. The Ayacucho line could not have been built in an affordable way based on conventional streetcar and light rail technology. Sections of tunnels and big excavations would have been needed to flatten the inclines and this would not have been possible to fund in a threshold country like Columbia (probably it would even be infeasible there due to the presence of illegally erected unstable buildings). So, this was a perfectly right decision for Medellin. - Just recently I have been in Italy, to Venice, spending a day to have a look at the Translohr system there. They have two lines, line T1 connecting old town Venice with its onshore downtown in Mestre over a sea dam, the whole stretch being flat like a pancake, and line T2 connecting downtown Mestre to the railway station and a highrise suburb, also being totally flat except one of the both tunnel ramps into the underground station below the railway station. This one ramp is the only steep graded section in the whole Venice system, making use of the system's only advantage. Now talk of clever transportation investments... I suspect that somebody earned good money from the decision back then made by Venice officials and this was probably the only reason there to select Translohr, because there just is no other actual reason. I guess they will at some pont in the future either convert the system to real streetcar or abandon it, because Translohr clearly has drawbacks in the flat, of which being the worst that there is only one vehicle manufacturer who can dictate a price for the replacement vehicles needed in 20 years...
@sergiocorrea63
@sergiocorrea63 2 года назад
Thanks to the Explanation Sir, that will clarify the Stupid Comments from some IGNORANTS HERE they don't have any idea what they talking about, but they think have a Expert opinion for Everything.
@strassenbahntk
@strassenbahntk 2 года назад
@@sergiocorrea63 Thanks for reading my rant :D It's a complex topic though.
@brianjones7521
@brianjones7521 Год назад
“Yeah, well, you know, that’s just, like, your opinion, man.”
@luifercd9581
@luifercd9581 Год назад
​@@strassenbahntk el factor económico no creo que fuera problema, la ciudad actualmente está construyendo otro sistema de tren ligero con dos túneles y parte de un viaducto, además varios intercambios viales para este proyecto, así que no fuera representado un problema económico hacer está inversión también, creo que acá también aplicó el factor histórico, en los barrios de alta ladera las casas si son de construcción ilegal, pero en los otros barrios ma abajo son barrios patrimoniales con lugares históricos y casonas protegidas por ser patrimonio de la ciudad.
@LQC2556
@LQC2556 4 года назад
You can easily tell that they chose rubber tires in order to go up the slopes more easily.
@jamesneilsongrahamloveinth1301
@jamesneilsongrahamloveinth1301 4 года назад
LQC, Yes, I imagine rubber tyres would grip well on hills (as long as it's not raining), but there are plenty of tram systems on hilly terrain that use metal wheels on rails - for example, Stuttgart in Germany . . .
@mariabaier3080
@mariabaier3080 2 года назад
Several international companies were included in the bid . Medellin selected the best for the city and being quite was a requirement
@luifercd9581
@luifercd9581 Год назад
​@@jamesneilsongrahamloveinth1301también en suiza habían tranvías con pendiente altas, la cosa es que ninguno mantenía está pendiente por tramos largos y no eran comboyes de más de dos vagones y además eran pequeños, el de medellin transcurre en una sola calle en la mayor parte de su recorrido y está va a en línea recta y en subida hasta que por fin puede descansar antes de llegar a una curva, además son cuatro vagones grandes por convoy
@jbdelphiaiii7637
@jbdelphiaiii7637 4 года назад
looks to be quieter, the fewer rails mean the street is more bicycle friendly.
@Thomas1980
@Thomas1980 4 года назад
Fantastic!!!👍👍👍great Tram Video👍👍👍
@cal2201
@cal2201 3 года назад
Love Columbia, especially the coffee!
@eduardokano6819
@eduardokano6819 3 года назад
No. The coffee from Tejupilco and Tlatlaya in Mexican State is better, softer and more tasty.
@AR-15caribeno
@AR-15caribeno Год назад
@@eduardokano6819 el mexicano menos antipático:
@__JH_
@__JH_ 8 месяцев назад
@@eduardokano6819 No te engañes ni el mejor café de México entra a un top 10 de los mejores cafés del mundo, las marcas colombianas de café siempre están entre las mejores del mundo, hasta Guatemala supera a México en cuanto a la calidad del café
@BarbarossaTheOcean
@BarbarossaTheOcean 2 года назад
The best solution for rugged terrain.
@anzakson
@anzakson 4 года назад
Hello Tim! Hope you are doing well. I'm always envious of you being able to travel all around the world and are all the wonderful places. This video is extra important for men as it shows an awesome solution to the slopy terrain issue. Perhaps this is not the only place this has been applied, but this is the first time Ive seen it. Thank you so much for your excellent work and your sharing it with us. Take care and keep well.
@timosha21
@timosha21 4 года назад
They have these in China, Venice, and Paris - places off the top of my head: anybody else can confirm additional locations where these trams operate that would be appreciated!!
@jamesdinsdale1376
@jamesdinsdale1376 2 года назад
looks better than what we have in melbourne and we have too many
@jesusse9757
@jesusse9757 4 года назад
Hi Tim. It is true that it is not a conventional tram as we know it. It has only one rail and uses pneumatic wheels. I have seen this system in the Italian city of Padua (Padova). I think there is also in some French city. There are also undergrounds that use pneumatic wheels without conventional rails such as line 1 of Paris, or the metro of Mexico City or Santiago de Chile. Very good the realization of your video and very beautiful this tram of Medellín. Best regards from Spain. Hola, Tim. Es verdad que no es un tranvía convencional como lo conocemos. Tiene un solo rail y utiliza ruedas neumáticas. Este sistema lo he visto en la ciudad italiana de Padua (Padova). Creo que también lo hay en alguna ciudad francesa. También existen metros que utilizan ruedas neumáticas sin railes convencionales como la linea 1 de París, o el metro de la Ciudad de Méjico o de Santiago de Chile. Muy buena la realización de tu video y muy bonito este tranvía de Medellín. Saludos cordiales desde España.
@DBM1234-d1f
@DBM1234-d1f 4 года назад
Si este es otro tipo de tranvia y tiene ayudas neumáticas para tener tracción y agarre en las pendientes de medellin, así como hay varios tipos de carros y metros hay diferentes tipos de tranvia y este con ayudas neumaticas era el más óptimo para la geografía de la zona. 😊
@isabelbaumann4298
@isabelbaumann4298 3 года назад
Excelente Medellin Colombia Tranvia Felicitacion Argentina 👌👌👌👏👏👏👏👌👌👍👍
@MrSquareart
@MrSquareart 4 года назад
very very interesting!!!!!!!
@marcoshenriquesaat3121
@marcoshenriquesaat3121 4 года назад
Este meio de transporte melhora o entorno. Melhor que o transmilenio de Bogotá. Gostaria que autoridades brasileiras visitassem Medellín para implantar este meio de transporte em várias cidades brasileiras.
@williamerazo3921
@williamerazo3921 Год назад
No. Translor tech sucks.
@brianjones7521
@brianjones7521 Год назад
Beautiful video. Artful camerawork.
@timosha21
@timosha21 Год назад
Thank you so much 😀
@shaunmckenzie5509
@shaunmckenzie5509 2 года назад
Nice, smooth and quiet Also speeds up and slows down faster
@streetcar6896
@streetcar6896 4 года назад
Very smooth ! I like it!
@siachoquero
@siachoquero 4 года назад
It is not smooth at all, very bumpy.
@xmarxsthespot4844
@xmarxsthespot4844 4 года назад
Wow cool tramway
@pedrorodriguez8020
@pedrorodriguez8020 4 года назад
Amazing!!
@KevinFields777
@KevinFields777 4 года назад
The technology is Translohr. Originally from Lohr Industries, owned by Alstom since 2012. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Translohr
@prabathkumarasinghe2187
@prabathkumarasinghe2187 2 года назад
Very nice train system
@BeryJensen
@BeryJensen 2 года назад
I like it its so silent, and looks very pretty nice.
@juliocalderon2962
@juliocalderon2962 4 года назад
Q bien. Saludos desde Barranquilla 👋👋
@MIKEJ788
@MIKEJ788 2 года назад
Wow! Nice
@__JH_
@__JH_ 8 месяцев назад
Lo bueno: Es muy bonito, es estético, y gracias a esto en Colombia se están considerando los tranvías como opciones viables en las obras de transporte del pais Lo malo: Tiene un trayecto muy corto y tecnicamente no es un tranvía, es un bus guiado y creo que les vendieron un bus a precio de tranvía.
@Leo-66994
@Leo-66994 2 месяца назад
Seguramente se expandira mas adelante. Nada de amarguras !!!!
@eduardokano6819
@eduardokano6819 3 года назад
In Valle de Chalco, there are a similar context. When You Cruise the Xico Vulcano by combi, You may suffer stealings, You Are very unconfortable, unless space... Also, Valle de Chalco Solidaridad could be a Great client of Translohr, because it would replace old kombis and buses and adapts to the ilidical slopes into the city Center. I wish someday that Del Mazo governor visit Medellin, for the posibility to apply the Translohr instead of the actual storbous MexiBus. PD. Valle de Chalco also is a good place if Makoto Shinkai would film a Live-Action version of Your Name. It looks like Itomori. 🇲🇽🇲🇽🇲🇽
@jdavid932
@jdavid932 4 года назад
made in medellin, me cambie de carril
@sergiom544
@sergiom544 8 месяцев назад
No es un tranvia, es un trolebus guiado. El tranvia circula sobre rieles, con llantas metálicas.
@marcgo_78
@marcgo_78 Месяц назад
Te entiendo
@Kaymon7
@Kaymon7 4 года назад
any other countries's tram than better best great tram in the world
@user-vo4yj6lk7f
@user-vo4yj6lk7f 4 года назад
Like 👍
@angelgarcia4127
@angelgarcia4127 4 года назад
❤‼
@ackchyually9461
@ackchyually9461 4 года назад
Are these tires pneumatic?
@e.d.gproductions7989
@e.d.gproductions7989 4 года назад
Yes
@d947
@d947 4 года назад
Just one track?
@brianjones7521
@brianjones7521 Год назад
Do some sections of Medellin Metro run on Steel Wheels & two rails?
@luifercd9581
@luifercd9581 Год назад
Todo el metro de Medellín funciona con ruedas de metal a dos rieles, solo está linea de tranvía funciona con un riel una rueda metálica guiada y dos ruedas neumáticas, medellin cuenta con 3 líneas de metro, una de las cuales es solo de uso interno y las otras dos prestan servicio comercial, y además tiene 1 línea de tranvía, 3 líneas de BRT y 7 líneas de teleférico y un sistema de bicicletas públicas gratuito, la cuarta línea de metro está siendo construida, la tecnología será metro ligero, diferente a las tres anteriores que son metro pesado, también está próxima a iniciar construcción la primera línea de tren interurbano de cercanías y se planifica la quinta línea de metro pesado y 7 líneas más de teleférico
@brianjones7521
@brianjones7521 Год назад
@@luifercd9581 thank you
@yashshah1936
@yashshah1936 4 года назад
how is this different from trolley bus?
@siachoquero
@siachoquero 4 года назад
It uses tram catenary and tram pantograph. also a guidance rail.
@chrismckellar9350
@chrismckellar9350 4 года назад
@@siachoquero - but less flexibility than a trolley bus.
@siachoquero
@siachoquero 4 года назад
@@chrismckellar9350 well yes, but it transports much more people, trolleybus can at most 25 meters long thus having 24 meter turn circle. And this one has it only 10 meter cause of short sections and guidance rail.
@yeisoncanon284
@yeisoncanon284 4 года назад
This is a translohr
@antoniojose8606
@antoniojose8606 3 года назад
👍👀
@rx2847
@rx2847 4 года назад
Americans Can Only Dream about this Tram which are in Columbia
@changeoflife3658
@changeoflife3658 4 года назад
Nah i like trams that has tracks
@sebastianmazo7325
@sebastianmazo7325 4 года назад
Colombia*
@micheljimenez5619
@micheljimenez5619 4 года назад
Is Colombia, nou Columbia.
@Diego-ix7xx
@Diego-ix7xx 3 года назад
@@sebastianmazo7325 en inglés creo que columbia
@norelaelenajimenezgonzalez1849
@norelaelenajimenezgonzalez1849 3 года назад
@@Diego-ix7xx jaja ja....muy bruto pongale cero profesor
@manny6068
@manny6068 2 года назад
👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿
@tjejojyj
@tjejojyj 3 года назад
The Wikipedia entry has a good list of the problems with this system. I think these will be superseded by autonomous guided buses in the future. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Translohr The Chinese ARRT “trackless tram” hasn’t exactly taken off but it’s better than this, saving the cost and complex of the rail.
@CreatorPolar
@CreatorPolar 2 года назад
The “trackless tram” is just a bus
@kekessalman
@kekessalman Год назад
The tram cult have made big efforts to record their rants about Translohr everywhere. Vlogs, forums, wikipedia..
@luifercd9581
@luifercd9581 Год назад
Sufre los mismos problemas que el metro con ruedas neumáticas y aún así la línea de París sigue existiendo, y sigue siendo el sistema mayoritario en ciudad de México y fue el escogido en Lausana. El único problema son las ruedas neumáticas que se desgastan con el tiempo y hay que reemplazarlas con el tiempo y solo se le pueden comprar a pocos fabricantes, pero la empresa que maneja este sistema patentó un método que es el reencauchado para no tener que comprar ruedas neumáticas tantas veces y ahorrar, es el mismo problema que tiene los buses, pero en un bus no se puede reencauchar una rueda ya que sería peligroso, en este sistema si porque es guiado por un riel central.
@sergiom544
@sergiom544 8 месяцев назад
Este seguro tiene ruedas de caucho
@edgarvelasquez6385
@edgarvelasquez6385 4 года назад
Translohr
@certifiedforkliftdriver9987
@certifiedforkliftdriver9987 4 года назад
shame the slope forced it to use tires. must be a bumpy ride
@sergiocorrea63
@sergiocorrea63 2 года назад
Not at all, smooth as Butter.
@blue9multimediagroup
@blue9multimediagroup Год назад
@@sergiocorrea63 not from what we've seen and heard.....
@sergiocorrea63
@sergiocorrea63 Год назад
@blue9multimediagroup have you ever been,or Ride in the Tranvia? So, if you hear or see in a video is Irrelevant , til you do it personally, I can't give a opinion based in a video.
@alejandrosaninmolina9208
@alejandrosaninmolina9208 3 года назад
🔺It's not a train... !! It calls Streetcars
@siachoquero
@siachoquero 4 года назад
Technology is not interesting it is dumb and extremely useless in comparison to a tram. Ride quality is low and maintenance costs are higher than of a tram, also it has huge destructive impact on the surface it runs on, due to wheels running on the same spot.
@rhodesianwojak2095
@rhodesianwojak2095 4 года назад
It's because of the terrain
@intrepidurbanite995
@intrepidurbanite995 4 года назад
As mentioned above, they are using wheels on pavement to handle the steep hills. Also, the trams offer greater capacity than a standard bus. The low floors also offer better access to people with strollers and the elderly.
@siachoquero
@siachoquero 4 года назад
@@intrepidurbanite995 Normal trams handle steep gradients up to 11% technically passable. So this Translohr thing offers 13% slopes, I ask what is the maximum slope on Medellin line? Definitely not 13%. All modern transport has low floor.
@intrepidurbanite995
@intrepidurbanite995 4 года назад
@@siachoquero According to this site, there are sections of the tramway that are 12% at maximum, so it makes sense to use Translohr Trams and not standard rail trams. www.spanishrailwaysnews.com/noticias.asp?not=438
@tomv3361
@tomv3361 4 года назад
Ikr
@neilforbes416
@neilforbes416 4 года назад
You misspelled a word.... "Tyre", not "tire" The latter means to physically and/or mentally exhaust oneself while the former is the rubber rim on a wheel. If this vehicle runs on the road, then it's NOT a tram, rather it's an articulated trolley-bus.
@transitvideosbayarea
@transitvideosbayarea 4 года назад
Look it up online. Tire is the US spelling of Tyre
@neilforbes416
@neilforbes416 4 года назад
@@transitvideosbayarea The US spelling is incorrect. TYRE is the correct spelling as it DISTINGUISHES the meanings one from the other. Tyre = rubber rim on wheel; Tire = physically/mentally exhaust oneself. the whole purpose of the two different spellings is to separate the meanings.
@transitvideosbayarea
@transitvideosbayarea 4 года назад
Neil Forbes There no real “correct” spelling because as I said, regional spelling differences. It’s like center/ centre or elevator/ lift, color/ colour. I’d say Timosha used the US spelling because it’s more common?
@neilforbes416
@neilforbes416 4 года назад
@@transitvideosbayarea The correct spellings are found in the Oxford English Dictionary. And the reason for the variation, Tyre vs Tire, I've already explained.
@RRansomSmith
@RRansomSmith 4 года назад
@@neilforbes416 OED uses both actually so you're wrong.
@RRansomSmith
@RRansomSmith 4 года назад
This is a guided bus built to look like a tram. Much like how trolley replicas are built to look like streetcars, but are actually buses. This is merely a bus without a steering wheel and guided by a center rail. Sorry, but trams don't use rubber tires. You tried it, but no dice.
@transitvideosbayarea
@transitvideosbayarea 4 года назад
Because it runs exclusively on a guided way, it classifies as a train, the same way rubber tire metros and people movers are trains.
@RRansomSmith
@RRansomSmith 4 года назад
@@transitvideosbayarea except that they're completely grade separated and cannot operate with traffic. This is a bus with a tram body. Trams don't use rubber tires. Just like a Trackless-Trolley is a bus with poles even though I'll always stick to the TT name. Accept the facts, my guy.
@transitvideosbayarea
@transitvideosbayarea 4 года назад
Rick Traveler Smith I’d say this classifies as a tram because the train is incapable of running outside of the guided rail, and has no steering, with operator controls being similar to a normal tram. This is unlike Bombardier’s system which can run independently of the rail and has a steering wheel. Also I agree that trolley buses are buses because they have flexibility on the road (the ability to change lanes to pass cars etc), whereas Translohr doesn’t.
@luifercd9581
@luifercd9581 Год назад
Me quieres decir entonces que el metro de ciudad de México y que la primera línea del metro de París también son autobuses???? El tranvía de Medellín si tiene un riel metálico en el centro pelmaso
@blue9multimediagroup
@blue9multimediagroup Год назад
@@transitvideosbayarea RRansomSmith here on my group account: Say it with me now, Guided Bus. Trams don't run without trucks for the wheelbase. Trams don't run on rubber tires. This thing can only run on streets, it cannot use traditional rails and mingle with other rail modes like a tram can. It's a glorified bus and it's not worth the money spent on it due to the increased maintenance costs. Gadgetbahn.
@assmatamir2174
@assmatamir2174 4 месяца назад
I don’t like colombia
@KlaxontheImpailr
@KlaxontheImpailr 2 года назад
That is not a tram, it’s a bus with a severe attachment problem.
@CreatorPolar
@CreatorPolar 2 года назад
It doesn’t have a steering wheel and can’t go anywhere without the guid rail so it’s a tram
@KlaxontheImpailr
@KlaxontheImpailr 2 года назад
@@CreatorPolar I know I was just kidding
@brianjones7521
@brianjones7521 Год назад
@@CreatorPolar “Yeah, well, that's just like, your opinion man.”
Далее
The Metro in Medellin, Colombia 2020
11:08
Просмотров 110 тыс.
Catenary-free solutions for tramway systems
2:50
Просмотров 30 тыс.
buses de Medellín y Antioquia (busologia paisa)
11:56
Tranvía de Ayacucho Medellín Colombia Noviembre 2015
3:14
Rubber-Tire Rail Transit is Weird
13:53
Просмотров 234 тыс.
Trenes del Metro de Medellín vol.1
7:23
Просмотров 19 тыс.
Riding the Metro of Medellin Colombia 🚆
15:00
Просмотров 6 тыс.