Тёмный

'Russia is not going to be beaten' | David Owen on how the Ukraine invasion should end 

Times Radio
Подписаться 961 тыс.
Просмотров 619 тыс.
50% 1

The former Labour foreign secretary David Owen has said Keir Starmer is "wrong" to suggest Putin be put on trial at The Hague.
When asked whether he agrees with Keir Starmer, Lord Owen told Matt Chorley on Times Radio:
"I'm pretty wary of that. Firstly, it's not going to happen unless Russia is beaten, and Russia is not going to be beaten. I think it's the wrong language to use, quite frankly. We are not going to destroy Russia, so much so that they will offer up to The Hague. We're not going to send the SAS into Russia to seize Putin and take him to the Hague. A lot of these legal solutions, it's perhaps no accident that Starmer is a lawyer.
"We were able to do it in the Balkans which I know very well because we got a resolution through in the UN and we had support for international action and we had the special court that we set up to try war crimes committed in Yugoslavia, carried by the UN. We're not going to get that in Russia."
On whether the UK should send fighter jets to Ukraine, Lord Owen said:
"I personally think the best offer would be to go back to what was thought about, namely, let the MIGs in Poland go to the Ukrainians, and put our aircraft into Poland. That would be very quick.
"A new plane that they are not used to is not going to be that. What they need now is more MIGs. Their pilots fly MIGs, they could do it immediately. And Poland is ready to do it. But they can't give up all their aircraft themselves. They have to have replacements, so Britain could step in and supply aircraft to Poland."
---
Times Radio brings you the latest breaking news, expert analysis and well-informed discussion on the biggest stories of the day.
📻 Listen now - www.thetimes.c...
Follow Times Radio on social:
🔵 Facebook
/ thetimesradio
🔵 Twitter
/ timesradio
🔵 Instagram
/ timesradio
Subscribe here: / @listentotimesradio

Опубликовано:

 

7 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 3 тыс.   
@francisbacon7738
@francisbacon7738 Год назад
Never thought much of this man's opinions, still don't.
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
We must all think the same on all issues at all times.
@stevenwilson5556
@stevenwilson5556 Год назад
@@evolassunglasses4673 not all issues but the important ones, yes
@PETE4955
@PETE4955 Год назад
Nevil Chamberlain.
@coxhoe789
@coxhoe789 Год назад
He didn,t have a clue then and still hasn,t a clue now
@Andrew-rc3vh
@Andrew-rc3vh Год назад
So he is a typical British politician then.
@paixducoeur
@paixducoeur Год назад
@@Andrew-rc3vh moreover he is s puppet of the usa and nato!!
@Andrew-rc3vh
@Andrew-rc3vh Год назад
@@paixducoeur I'm getting the strong impression that Times Radio is also another mouthpiece for the Pentagon, hence why they have him on.
@paixducoeur
@paixducoeur Год назад
@@Andrew-rc3vh without no doubt: here is an other sound: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rnut-E_eEM0.html
@stephenholmes1036
@stephenholmes1036 Год назад
​@@Andrew-rc3vh correct with more faces than a town hall clock and power mad.
@RHP9898
@RHP9898 Год назад
David Owen never fails to disappoint.
@jamesbradshaw3389
@jamesbradshaw3389 Год назад
I refuse to disagree with you on this
@toke7560
@toke7560 Год назад
Typical worthless Labour man. Look at the damage BLAIR caused.
@ahartify
@ahartify Год назад
I only remember how ineffective, contrarian and weak Owen was during the Yugoslavia conflict. He was also Milosevic's buddy - not a good look. He probably thinks Putin is a rather nice guy and would like to have 'dinner' with him one day, if he hasn't already. You should never allow medical doctors near a peace conference - they're always the worst. No, Russia is going to be defeated all right - Big Time.
@z.t.500
@z.t.500 Год назад
Well, it seems he's still a useful idiot for genocidial maniacs.
@russellspeed1693
@russellspeed1693 Год назад
wow
@QuizmasterLaw
@QuizmasterLaw Год назад
yeah people confuse medical expertise and benevolence with political wisdom and cunning.
@bryandimery6509
@bryandimery6509 Год назад
Lol. He also thought he could send the SAS into russia to get putin. Those guys would be slaughtered. But i guess project strength when you are weak and all....
@staticgrass
@staticgrass Год назад
There are plenty of socialists out there who think Putin is okay because they both hate NATO and the US. This idiot thinks that the war will end with a negotiation but acknowledges russia will break it and pretends that a Ukrainian victory is impossible. Remember at the time we were all told that we would never get Milosevich either.
@artmcteagle
@artmcteagle Год назад
Well Owen makes some valid points but regarding Crimea he is wrong, after all that the Ukrainians have suffered and the countless war crimes, they will not accept Crimea remaining in Russian hands. As for Putin, who knows what the future will bring. Slobodan Milosevic thought he was untouchable too.
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
Exactly. Even if, and repeat if we only think in terms limited to the Ukrainian and Russian confrontation without looking at the big picture of this conflict, it is crystal clear that Putin's Russia has crossed the line in this war, and by crossing that line they've disqualified themselves from any other acceptable end to this war except being brought to total defeat, and Mr. Putin himself being brought to face trial at the Hague.
@williamfarquharson
@williamfarquharson Год назад
Also Crimea is a conundrum, it is dependent on fresh water supplies from Ukraine, so cannot belong to Russia unless Russia takes even more land from Ukraine.
@zanbarnabegoue7873
@zanbarnabegoue7873 Год назад
@@Katoshi_Takagumi Dream! And awful joke. Russia will win that war. Story of bringing Putin to justice is not serious. Russia is stronger then this joke.
@wolfswinkel8906
@wolfswinkel8906 Год назад
If Milosevic had nuclear weapons NATO wouldn't have invaded Serbia.
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
@@wolfswinkel8906 Possibly not, but they would have placed heavy sanctions on them.
@MegaOev
@MegaOev Год назад
Ludicrous, good men have to stand up to evil!
@lindabowman2868
@lindabowman2868 Год назад
Watch Ukraine Agony, The Concealed War.... for clarity on youtube
@DannyBoy777777
@DannyBoy777777 Год назад
@@lindabowman2868 👋 troll
@harlequingnoll5
@harlequingnoll5 Год назад
Alternate title "how to stop being bullied - just give him your lunch money"
@Macdoradow
@Macdoradow Год назад
Perfect sum up of the video 👌🏻
@wolfswinkel8906
@wolfswinkel8906 Год назад
Negotiation is not appeasement. Negotiation requires great wisdom, sadly it's in short supply among Europeans and Americans nowadays.
@kd2239
@kd2239 Год назад
As usual, most people on RU-vid dont listen to the full interview. He said, most wars end in negotiation which is historically and practically accurate. He also said: 1. It was a disgrace that Europe allowed the first invasion of Crimea and the Minsk agreement was an utter failure on the part of France and Germany. 2. The challenger and leopard tanks need to be sent to Ukraine immediately, not in a few months 3. Ukraine could possibly defeat Putin in the summer
@harlequingnoll5
@harlequingnoll5 Год назад
@@wolfswinkel8906 well the stated negotiating goals seem to be "any piece of Ukraine is Russia's" and "all of Ukraine is Ukraine even Crimea". Negotiating starts when both sides are tired enough of fighting to actually negotiate.
@nopants4259
@nopants4259 Год назад
He doesn't say anything of the sort?? bizarre comment
@antoineharel6923
@antoineharel6923 Год назад
Hat off to Poland and the polish people for their help to Ukraine...
@clauderebello5362
@clauderebello5362 Год назад
The POLES are a decent bunch of folk..they were a GODSEND in the second world war..with the HEROICS of their pilots with 303 squadron..and now bearing the BRUNT of providing succour to the 3 million or so desparate women and children who have crossed their borders.. FOR SAFETYS SAKE.. STAND UP AND TAKE A BOW!! POLAND.....
@mikoajwisniewski4878
@mikoajwisniewski4878 Год назад
Polish - capital P, dude!
@dchappy6985
@dchappy6985 Год назад
No one ever accused the Polish of being the brightest bulb.
@mikoajwisniewski4878
@mikoajwisniewski4878 Год назад
@@dchappy6985 Care to develop this?
@dchappy6985
@dchappy6985 Год назад
@MCADHD666 VOL2 Many European countries East and West are former "Colonial Masters." Do you propose their former and present vessel states should fight proxy wars on their behalf? 🤔 I think not. Let them fight their own wars.
@mikeadvice2253
@mikeadvice2253 Год назад
Poland has plan to occupy their historic land in the west of Ukraine in case the Russians get closer do Dnipro river. Ukrainian army committed atrocities over Poles in WW2 and they will never forget that.
@doubleplusgoodthinker9434
@doubleplusgoodthinker9434 Год назад
I remember the time when Owen was Foreign Secretary. He just got about everything wrong. Nothing has changed.
@goranmilosavljevic1393
@goranmilosavljevic1393 Год назад
D.O. did a lot of things wrong in the former Yugoslavia.
@paixducoeur
@paixducoeur Год назад
He is simply a fool because Russia will win!!
@doubleplusgoodthinker9434
@doubleplusgoodthinker9434 Год назад
@@paixducoeur and what makes you think this?
@paixducoeur
@paixducoeur Год назад
@@doubleplusgoodthinker9434 You just need to inform you beside the mainstream lies!!
@doubleplusgoodthinker9434
@doubleplusgoodthinker9434 Год назад
@@paixducoeur Your English is terrible and which " mainstream" lies are you referencing?
@cgaud1n69
@cgaud1n69 Год назад
Lukewarm assessment and very transparent in acknowledging European appeasement which has led us to this point. All territory must be returned to Ukraine or this war will NEVER end.
@alainlefebvre9860
@alainlefebvre9860 Год назад
💯
@ngantnier
@ngantnier Год назад
Nah, just hand him Poland It worked out great last time.
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
A little more will be needed, some form of guarantees that the Kremlin won't ever get to try this again. Whatever that means, it won't mean a worthless piece of paper with Mr. Putin's signature on it.
@kimmoj2570
@kimmoj2570 Год назад
@cgaud1n69 Very much agree. We are not moving forward listening opinions like that.
@raulmelo5881
@raulmelo5881 Год назад
If you think Ukraine is taking back all its territory you are going to be pretty disappointed when we settle and they lose a decent amount of land
@thinman8621
@thinman8621 Год назад
Russia giving up is wishful thinking. Ukraine winning would be nice but that's hard to envision from here. Some kind of negotiation makes some sense.
@davidedbrooke9324
@davidedbrooke9324 Год назад
Russia does not need to be totally defeated but enough to get Ukraine independent!
@ArianeQube
@ArianeQube Год назад
"My good friends, for the second time in our history, a British Prime Minister has returned from Germany bringing peace with honour. I believe it is peace for our time. We thank you from the bottom of our hearts. Go home and get a nice quiet sleep." - Neville Chamberlain , September 30th 1938 ...
@nopants4259
@nopants4259 Год назад
what ? this has nothing to do with this interview.
@pacmanc8103
@pacmanc8103 Год назад
@@nopants4259 nonsense. Of course it does.
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
Completely different. We/ the NeoCons/ Victoria Nuland should never ever of backed the coup against the ELECTED government of Ukraine 8 years ago that started this nightmare off. Let the oppressed Russian minority brake free. 14,000 dead BEFORE the invasion. The burning alive of Russian civilians at ODESSA destroyed Ukraine for many ethnic Russians. This is not our war.
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
The NeoCons destroyed Iraq Syria Libya Afghanistan and will end up destroying Ukraine.
@pacmanc8103
@pacmanc8103 Год назад
@@evolassunglasses4673 Blah blah blah. Sound like ‘neo-cons’ is your pet word.😂
@1KingCharlesSpaniel
@1KingCharlesSpaniel Год назад
David Owen, this is the man who lost to the Monster Raven Loony Party
@TesterAnimal1
@TesterAnimal1 Год назад
Raving.
@ciaranryan5265
@ciaranryan5265 Год назад
If you dredge up the swamp you get swamp creatures.
@DMZDMX1
@DMZDMX1 Год назад
He never had a chance against an opponent that had a clear understanding of right/wrong and who made much more sense.
@thomasstyan2066
@thomasstyan2066 Год назад
I've rarely felt more angry or disgusted with a British politician than in 1987. This was when David Owen called a vote of the SDP membership over whether it should merge with the Liberals. He campaigned against the merger, but he lost the vote. He then spent the next few years trying to claim that that decision of the SDP had not happened. How he had the sheer gall to complain about parliament over Brexit shows the shamelessness of the man.
@MsFerdinand93
@MsFerdinand93 Год назад
Russia has been beaten many times in its history.
@MrLu4o
@MrLu4o Год назад
But , never lost war ?
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
🤣
@sorinbalanescu6819
@sorinbalanescu6819 Год назад
@@MrLu4o, one example: Russo-Japanese war 1904-1905: "The complete victory of the Japanese military surprised international observers and transformed the balance of power in both East Asia and Europe, resulting in Japan's emergence as a great power and a decline in the Russian Empire's prestige and influence in Europe. Russia's incurrence of substantial casualties and losses for a cause that resulted in humiliating defeat contributed to a growing domestic unrest which culminated in the 1905 Russian Revolution, and severely damaged the prestige of the Russian autocracy."
@bobrail733
@bobrail733 Год назад
They got slaughtered in Afghanistan and her to leave with their tail between their legs 😇😇😇
@MrLu4o
@MrLu4o Год назад
@@bobrail733 I ment, war. Not tiny conflicts .
@rodneybeard5533
@rodneybeard5533 Год назад
Former commander of Europe General Ben Hodges tends to disagree on Ukraine beating Russia
@mickser101
@mickser101 Год назад
Ben Hodges is a war mongering psychopath who's on the payroll of the Defense industry. Total warhawk
@frankyfourfingers1382
@frankyfourfingers1382 Год назад
I think Hodges' mandate in his myriad interviews is to sway public perception as to keep the money and armaments flowing to Ukraine. I imagine his own beliefs about the possibilities of outcome are somewhat more measured than those he puts forth to the media. Also, I think you misinterpret the statement that Owen made. He doesn't seem to discount the possibility of Ukraine taking back their own territory. He was stating that to put Putin on trial for war crimes and such, you'd literally have to invade Russia, and thus the idea of dragging Putin to the Hague is preposterous.
@hymns4ever197
@hymns4ever197 Год назад
He has also stated that Ukraine would be indefensible if Crimea remains in Russian hands.
@hmmcinerney
@hmmcinerney Год назад
Which is why he says that Crimea is doable and desirable.
@randar1969
@randar1969 Год назад
Kicking them out of Ukraine beating Russia. To beat Russia Ukraine should add Russia to it's territory and i don't think even the hardest supporters of Ukraine see that happen in their lifetimes nor do they want too.
@viliridell199
@viliridell199 Год назад
How dare you say such a thing😤 In west we say Ukraine is bravely advancing backwards and Russia is cowardly retreating forwards🤡🤡🤡
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
Master class in appeasement.
@boink800
@boink800 Год назад
Some people never learn
@Nas_Atlas
@Nas_Atlas Год назад
literally watch the video in full
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
@@Nas_Atlas I did.
@squirepraggerstope3591
@squirepraggerstope3591 Год назад
@@Katoshi_Takagumi Then you're clearly just too thick to grasp the points Owen makes.
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
@@squirepraggerstope3591 Oh I grasp most of them. The west's response to how Putin grabbed Crimea in 2014 was pathetically weak and amounted to borderline appeasement. Clearly any of the sanctions that were enacted then weren't strong enough to achieve anything. However, we are past the point when letting Putin keep Crimea and maybe little pieces of Ukraine will satisfy him, and that's the fundamental mistake the appeasers always make whether they are technically correct on some points or not.
@84Actionjack
@84Actionjack Год назад
Russia wasn't beaten by Germany in WWI but they suffered a serious defeat with the result a political change. Russia wasn't beaten in the Cold War but they did suffer a serious defeat and again the result was political change. Russia doesn't need to be beaten by Ukraine; a significant defeat should be enough to trigger a political change and maybe this time unlike the previous two, Russia ends any form of autocracy in favor of a more pluralistic government. Only then will there be peace.
@Blanka1100
@Blanka1100 Год назад
Russia wll never change. They don't know any better. They are raised to be passive. Greetings form Poland.
@boink800
@boink800 Год назад
The Putin Nazis will collapse just like the USSR did
@alainlefebvre9860
@alainlefebvre9860 Год назад
@@Blanka1100 then we need to keep them demilitarized, once Ukraine is done decimating them.
@sp7873
@sp7873 Год назад
well if the effect is that the governmental structures change so that war cannot be continued than it is a form "beaten".
@Blanka1100
@Blanka1100 Год назад
@@sp7873 It's not a matter of one Putin in the office. It's Russia/USSR which created Putin, not the opposite.
@divermike8943
@divermike8943 Год назад
I'm an American and had to Google who David Owen is. From THIS discourse I would say he seems to have things well understood. Much is going on in the United States where opposition to the current administration is beginning to ask, "How much money should the U.S. spend on military aid to Ukraine?" Nothing wrong with that. That's democracy. Such things are debated for the benefit of the system. I just hope it does not degenerate into partisan fighting. I hope against all hope these days in the USA, but at present, it's a healthy question to ask. But ultimately the US and the free world cannot let this expansionist aggression go unchecked. Putin's only argument is that NATO is encroaching on Russia. He's right. It IS!. Why is that? Perhaps decades of Russian/Soviet rule have galvanized now-free people to say, "Never Again". This they choose willingly and democratically. Too bad Mr. Putin. We reap what we sow. Perhaps the better course for Russia is peaceful economic cooperation with the West. It was working. Russia was profiting. Just not the Russian people. That's for Russia to sort out itself. That takes no small measure of courage by the Russian people AND a decent chance at success. The latter is what Putin has seemingly squashed. For the time being.
@danmayberry1185
@danmayberry1185 Год назад
Putin would starve his own before admitting defeat. Desperate times ...
@cfosnock
@cfosnock Год назад
True but the Tsar tried the same thing in 1917
@muckle8
@muckle8 Год назад
Putin only wanted peace - zelensky and the CIA instigated this
@cfosnock
@cfosnock Год назад
@@muckle8 War is peace. Ignorance is Strength.
@finnjacobsen684
@finnjacobsen684 Год назад
Aircraft to Poland and MIGs to Ukraine. Great idea. Should have been done yesterday.
@michaziomek
@michaziomek Год назад
Im pretty sure they already moved to Ukraine last year as 'spare parts'. You knows, IKEA your own MIG.
@kite7214
@kite7214 Год назад
Which RAF aircraft to Poland? We don't have any spare Typhoons or F-35s. It is easy for David Owen to say, but he does not know the facts. Ben Wallace and the PM do know the facts.
@cloudpoint0
@cloudpoint0 Год назад
See news article *Poland reportedly delivered MiG-29 fighters to Ukraine as ‘spare parts’* dated 2023-01-27 Poland has already delivered operational MiG-29 fighter jets to Ukraine in secret, local media has reported. The claims were first reported by the local daily paper Dziennik Gazeta Prawna, citing governmental sources. The fighters were allegedly delivered disassembled, labeled as spare parts. ‘The fuselage or wings are also a spare part,’ the sources commented. The exact method used to ferry the aircraft was not disclosed, though with the Ukrainian airspace closely monitored by Russia, it is likely that they were transferred by train.
@CJ_Ludwig501
@CJ_Ludwig501 Год назад
Agreed, they should give Ukraine every weapon system on their wish list and then some. They should treat it like a bandaid, the quicker you pull it off the less painful it is. We should pressure our government until they do. The US Army can deploy whole armies anywhere in the world in 48hrs.
@michaziomek
@michaziomek Год назад
@@CJ_Ludwig501 48h is only after darpa finishes work on teleportation, still, sending everything is a good thought.
@andreykaminskiy2391
@andreykaminskiy2391 Год назад
The old man knows how to be not just a US vassal, but a lackey. It's not enough just to follow the master's orders, you have to anticipate them. You must want war more than the US government and show your diligence and enthusiasm.
@marcopalazzo9349
@marcopalazzo9349 Год назад
This man doesn't actually have a scobby doo about what he is talking about. Russia has invaded 3 time Donbas Crimea and now. EU has no control of EU countries military. Seriously how can you let that slide in an interview.
@nemo6282
@nemo6282 Год назад
it's you that has no idea
@MGGitari
@MGGitari Год назад
How will Russia survive with Ukraine taking back large swathes of territory in a week and Russia unable to make any gains across a 2000 km frontline in 6 months? I don't understand your logic David Owen
@russellspeed1693
@russellspeed1693 Год назад
and you haven't heard him, so is the clever one?
@MGGitari
@MGGitari Год назад
@@russellspeed1693 oh I have. Perfectly predictable guy this Owen
@alainlefebvre9860
@alainlefebvre9860 Год назад
@@MGGitari agreed. Russia's made "progress" lately, but at extraordinary costs. Ukraine CAN defeat Russia if we stop listening to weak people like Owen. We need to stop trying to convince ourselves that we can't or shouldn't defeat Russia. It's not that we can, but we must.
@HungryGhost999
@HungryGhost999 Год назад
@@alainlefebvre9860 absolutely
@mickg7299
@mickg7299 Год назад
Well it wasn’t this week that’s for sure 🤣
@boink800
@boink800 Год назад
I will invade Owen's house, and of course Owen will let me have it.
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
We destroyed the house when we/ NeoCons/ Victoria Nuland backed the coup against the ELECTED government of Ukraine 8 years ago. 14,000 people died BEFORE the invasion. The burning alive of Russian civilians was the end of Ukraine for many ethnic Russians. Let the oppressed Russian minority brake free. Independence and freedom for the Dombas. This is not our war
@dianafriedman2384
@dianafriedman2384 Год назад
If you have nuclear bomb on you,Owner's probably would
@16thdave
@16thdave Год назад
@@dianafriedman2384 Not my house u would need to use the nuke to get my house but then its nuked no good for anyone never give up never surrender!
@shavedbroom
@shavedbroom Год назад
Russia won't use nukes... He (pootin) even said it recently claiming he never threatened to use nukes
@percyfaith11
@percyfaith11 Год назад
@@dianafriedman2384 So where's it stop then? I guess every small country needs a nuclear bomb then.
@williamwyllie7072
@williamwyllie7072 Год назад
It would be nice if Russia agreed to withdraw from Ukraine and pay reparations. It is sad that the West sits back and watches as Ukraine is systematically destroyed only supplying enough for a stale mate outcome.
@bjrnhjjakobsen2174
@bjrnhjjakobsen2174 Год назад
With a deficit of about 7 trillion rubles the Russian coffers are empty by June or July…
@alainlefebvre9860
@alainlefebvre9860 Год назад
And it's going to get worse as the screws tighten and military costs escalate.
@StillAliveAndKicking_
@StillAliveAndKicking_ Год назад
Perhaps someone should suggest that Owen talk with military experts, and not assume that he knows it all.
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
The "experts" that destroyed Iraq Syria Libya Afghanistan and will end up destroying Ukraine?
@travman1987
@travman1987 Год назад
Like the ones who said Iraq had weapons of mass destruction? Like the ones who took us to Vietnam? Those the experts you’re referring to?
@StillAliveAndKicking_
@StillAliveAndKicking_ Год назад
@@travman1987 Those were politicians that made those decisions. Like Owen. He is a fool. Doubtless he doesn’t have a clue who and what Putin is.
@lw1zfog
@lw1zfog Год назад
good lord, how terribly embarrassing for you ! 😂
@deeestuary
@deeestuary Год назад
Can’t disagree with anything anything David Owen says here. Don’t understand the negative comments in this thread. This war has to end sometime, and negotiations are the obvious way that is going to happen. We have to accept that Russia itself won’t somehow be defeated and surrender. Defeated within Ukraine may be, but not in Russia itself. That’s all David Owen is saying.
@occamraiser
@occamraiser Год назад
Why would anyone be interested in what David Owen thinks? No one is interested in what I think and I'm absolutely comfortable that I am more intelligent and better informed of real world issues and geopolitics than he evidently is. In fact, I think my cat probably edges him out on competent decision manking.
@myshepspud1
@myshepspud1 Год назад
Bad day or inside knowledge?
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
Bet you backed the Iraq Syria Libya Afghanistan bloodbaths.
@TIM612826
@TIM612826 Год назад
And spelling 😜
@davidkennedy8929
@davidkennedy8929 Год назад
Manking? Did you forget the W!
@enigma1000
@enigma1000 Год назад
Can we hear what your cat thinks, please?
@Bobbydyland
@Bobbydyland Год назад
Victory is actually quite easy to describe. Push Russians back to boarder, supply SAM's to protect Ukrainian airspace and then negotiate the possibility for Russian solders to stop dying for nothing. If Russia refuses, Ukraine should go free Ossetia and Abkhazia from Russia.
@alainlefebvre9860
@alainlefebvre9860 Год назад
If the west pulls their thumbs out of their arses, Russia will be out of Ukraine, including Ukrainian Crimea, by late summer. Decimate everything Russian inside Ukraine, join NATO, defend Ukraine with NATO forces like Poland of today, and dare Russia to try a repeat. Ukraine is a sovereign country and has every right to self determination. Do this at any cost. Because... China is watching.
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
Ursula van de Leyen said Ukraine has lost 100,000 troops killed in action already. Alternative media puts it at 157,000 +. Ukraine was very close to negotiate at the start (former Israeli PM said) but America and Boris persuaded them to stop negotiations. The NeoCons destroyed Iraq Syria Libya Afghanistan and will end up destroying Ukraine
@ivancho5854
@ivancho5854 Год назад
Indeed when Russia is beaten back to the pre 2014 border if Russia does not stop it's aggression it should be the aim of the West to destabilise Russia until it stops or Russia fragments. Slava Ukraine. 🇺🇦🇬🇧
@francisegwu9083
@francisegwu9083 Год назад
Useless though
@stevenwilson5556
@stevenwilson5556 Год назад
@@ivancho5854 lots of ways to do this. The Russian infrastructure can be dismantled by sabotage, cyber warfare, lots of other ways to bring Russia to its knees if need be, but start with getting them out of Ukraine
@fulknerra6116
@fulknerra6116 Год назад
doctor imagining that medical training somehow qualifies him to speak on any other subject with authority.
@antekovac5644
@antekovac5644 Год назад
We in Croatia remember this horrible non-person Owen very very badly.
@cristiancea85
@cristiancea85 Год назад
Can you elaborate that please, he sounds very reasonable
@squirepraggerstope3591
@squirepraggerstope3591 Год назад
Probably your own fault then, to be honest.
@mickg7299
@mickg7299 Год назад
Alzheimer’s?
@antekovac5644
@antekovac5644 Год назад
@@cristiancea85 to elaborate: Owen was appeasing in 1991 serbian dictator aggressor Milosevic like he is apppeasing today your KGB dictator Putler. Didn’t help. Croatia won the war against aggressor Serbia…same will happen with Ukraine that will win the war against aggressor Putlerstan
@antekovac5644
@antekovac5644 Год назад
@@mickg7299 a lot of ruzzian vatnik orcs in the forum. Soon they will be 🌻🌻fertilizer🤓very very soon🤓
@alanchristensen5735
@alanchristensen5735 Год назад
Victory for Ukraine means Russia will lose. Slava Ukraini from the United States of America.
@ivandemko3360
@ivandemko3360 Год назад
Yes sirrr god bless
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
The NeoCons/ Victoria Nuland should never ever of backed the coup against the ELECTED government of Ukraine 8 years ago that started this nightmare off. Have you seen Seymour Hersh Substack on America blowing up Germany's gas pipeline? The NeoCons are out of control. They destroyed Iraq Syria Libya Afghanistan and will end up destroying Ukraine.
@JoeyBlogs007
@JoeyBlogs007 Год назад
That's why longer range missiles are useful. i.e. to destroy the invading Evil Orcs depots and supply lines further out. i.e. like 300 miles out.
@deanmoxom1330
@deanmoxom1330 Год назад
He will use sarmat 2 in the end
@petersmith6974
@petersmith6974 Год назад
Zelensky needs to have talks with Russia or wave the white flag
@deadvatniks
@deadvatniks Год назад
@@petersmith6974 nope ruzzian troll. putin will be hanged as a war criminal after russian military defeat.
@devrerffs
@devrerffs Год назад
@Theo 30 Do you don't see the common theme in what you yourself are writing. Missile SHIELD, sending defensive weapons to Ukrainine AFTER Russian invasion 2014. All this are defensive reactions to what Russia is doing.
@adamhinde9538
@adamhinde9538 Год назад
A Satan 2 means Russia will not lose unfortunately
@scottishbanjo
@scottishbanjo Год назад
Before we take Putin to the Hague perhaps we could offer up Tony Blair ?
@clives344
@clives344 Год назад
And empty his pockets of his money
@jameslawrence3666
@jameslawrence3666 Год назад
Crimea is geographically Ukrainian, this has been made very clear by the war ironically (water supply and logistics..... ) - the use of the Russian language does not mean an area is part of the new Russian Empire, otherwise half the world would be British.....again!
@ZhovtoBlakytniy
@ZhovtoBlakytniy Год назад
Oh no, some people are speaking English in russher *Rule, Brittania! starts playing* 🇬🇧
@alainlefebvre9860
@alainlefebvre9860 Год назад
There are legal borders.the UNGA voted 143:5 that Russia must leave and respect the Ukrainian legally recognized borders, which includes Crimea. The situation is crystal clear. Russia won't leave on their own, so we need to help force them out. It's really that simple.
@Marvin-dg8vj
@Marvin-dg8vj Год назад
Crimea was only handed over to the Ukraine in 1954 for no particular reason certainly not a democratic vote amongst it's people .Previously it had been part of Russia and before that a Tartar Khanate or Ottoman possession
@RainerMichelle
@RainerMichelle Год назад
@@Marvin-dg8vj no, Crimea was part of Ukraine when they voted for independence after WWI, before ! they got invaded and annexed by the newly formed USSR in 1921, here is the map from 1919 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Map_of_Ukraine_%28postcard_1919%29.jpg
@Marvin-dg8vj
@Marvin-dg8vj Год назад
@@RainerMichelle your map from 1921 also shows Ukraine spreading over most of Southern Russia north of the Caucasus. This is completely crazy .
@trentriver
@trentriver Год назад
With all due respect to David Owen - there is NO negotiating with Putin. "Agreements" mean NOTHING to Putin. Putin MUST lose this decisively. Putin must go down and his cronies with him. There is no other option.
@boink800
@boink800 Год назад
Appeasement did not work with Adolf
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
None.
@joed192
@joed192 Год назад
Regime changers lol so strong
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
Merkel confirmed the Russian position that the West lied to Russia with the Minsk Agreement and just bought time to flood Ukraine with arms.
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
Russia has the Global South particularly China and India on its side.
@zachthornton8337
@zachthornton8337 Год назад
The idea that Britain, after leaving the EU, now makes foreign policy decisions completely independently is absurd. I support Ukraine to the hilt and we have led the argument in many respects but ultimately we do tow the American line. EU membership didn’t prevent us from taking a leading role in the disastrous Iraq invasion that spawned a decade of violent sectarianism and jihadism across the Middle East. I see no reason why Britain wouldn’t have supported Ukraine strongly from inside the EU.
@AB-sr9mc
@AB-sr9mc Год назад
"russia is not going to be beaten",. and why not? This is the Ukrainians no.1 Goal.
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
Should be everyone's goal, unless they fancy seeing several European countries fall into Putin's hands and bring about the end of NATO as a serious counter to Putin's terror.
@alainlefebvre9860
@alainlefebvre9860 Год назад
Russia can be beaten. They're already on their knees. Constantly having to mobilize hundreds of thousands isn't a good look. And the equipment losses are enormous. The Soviet stockpiles are not endless.
@alistairw.6394
@alistairw.6394 Год назад
Defeated in Ukraine but not in Russia, unless his own people offer him up he will never be tried for it.
@hellsjamfleas
@hellsjamfleas Год назад
I think it is silly to suggest beating the Russians only counts if Putin is arrested or Russia stops all assaults on its neighbours. Ukraine's standard for victory is reclaiming it's border. Then there is further demands or ending conflict, returning kidnapped people, stolen goods (art, history, money), trails and other issues. Russia is unlikely to agree to it all but I doubt the Russians will consider what amounts to a raid on Ukraine worth 300,000+ lives if that's all both sides get. I think Russia would consider it a defeat and Ukraine a victory. Just not a total victory.
@lani6647
@lani6647 Год назад
Well, if you think Moscow is going to fall, and a beaten Russian command capitulates, then perhaps you’re right. Not just that, but a permanent member of the UNSC decides to direct that Putin be offered up at The Hague. But…. Er….. I suspect it won’t happen like that.
@20quid
@20quid Год назад
Why are journalists still giving him the time of day? He has completely discredited himself with his own words.
@MoireFly
@MoireFly Год назад
Note that many of times guests have similarly irrational positions that sometimes happen to coincide with political expedience. They just hide political pandering behind a false veneer of superiority. Quite disappointing.
@pulaski1
@pulaski1 Год назад
@@thetruth9210 Only from the neck up, apparently. 🙄
@chrishooge3442
@chrishooge3442 Год назад
which words did he discredit himself with?
@zlauriault
@zlauriault Год назад
He got it all quite well except that bit of Russian soft propaganda saying that Russia can't be beaten. He should check the news. Get Ukraine what they've asked for and Russians great grandchildren will still feel the shrapnel.
@paulmessenger9836
@paulmessenger9836 Год назад
Where's the money for all of this coming from
@geoffreylachner6779
@geoffreylachner6779 Год назад
Why does he ignore Nato expansion v. the promises not to expand past E germany, why does he ignore signing the Minsk Accords as a ruse to provide time to arm and train Ukrainians v. Russia? Seems very selective in deciding the equitable interests on either side. I do not trust this aged man, who is not wise despite his age.
@RonsarLo
@RonsarLo Год назад
What a joke Somebody never learned their history
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
That's not what this is about, this about the 'Save Putin Campaign'.
@cenccenc946
@cenccenc946 Год назад
If "lord" is in anyone's title, they should not be in any government position period.
@niallcarr9253
@niallcarr9253 Год назад
Alas, that's not how the UK works....diluted democracy
@richardmoloney689
@richardmoloney689 Год назад
Yeah, so get rid of the first Lords of the admiralty and treasury.
@bigblue6917
@bigblue6917 Год назад
The title was awarded after he was no longer in parliament. Though why it was awarded at all in unclear as he never did anything worthwhile.
@Aeronaut1975
@Aeronaut1975 Год назад
Position period?! Are we American now?!
@catmonarchist8920
@catmonarchist8920 Год назад
@@bigblue6917 he lead a relatively large party.
@anthonystar
@anthonystar Год назад
good to see Lord Owen still going absolutely a smashing debater
@heinedenmark
@heinedenmark Год назад
He clearly doesn't know what's actually is happening in Ukraine.. Russia will lose. There's no way Russia can turn this around.
@Robert-xy4xi
@Robert-xy4xi Год назад
What fantasy!
@heinedenmark
@heinedenmark Год назад
@@Robert-xy4xi Try and explain how they'll do it?
@MrLu4o
@MrLu4o Год назад
@@heinedenmark Mate , you are delusional . Stop the tv and take a look around . Dont be sheep .. :D
@heinedenmark
@heinedenmark Год назад
@@MrLu4o You're completely clueless.. Aren't you? Just another Putler fanboy 🤷‍♂️
@alainlefebvre9860
@alainlefebvre9860 Год назад
@@heinedenmark you're right, Soviet stockpiles are not endless. Poo-tin can keep mobilizing, but eventually his troops will be using axes and pitchforks. And the west will still be sending weapons. Maybe even some of our better ones when the outdated stocks run out. Notice that some arms producers have already started increasing production capacities. This won't end well for Russia.
@wayhome5
@wayhome5 Год назад
Migs from Poland were sent already just registered as spare parts, it was done without much fanfare but this is confirmed
@jonatikoisuva2695
@jonatikoisuva2695 Год назад
You do know Mig-29 are outdated. Russians build those Mig during the soviet era and they know its weaknesses and it is outmatched with Russia's Su fighter jets.
@wayhome5
@wayhome5 Год назад
@@jonatikoisuva2695 Yes, so if they are outdated certainly Western jets would be better. I was mainly clarifying on the point that was brought up in the interview was not correct any more because Polish Migs are said to have been transferred already so cannot be considered a substitute for transferring western jets anyway
@jonatikoisuva2695
@jonatikoisuva2695 Год назад
@@wayhome5 Migs were designed by Russian way back in the 80's, the new generation fighter jets are the mig35,Su27, Su30, Su34, Su35 and Su57. Poland only has 23 Mig Soviet Union Era fighter jets, that's the only mig they have. And no fighter jet has been delivered to Ukraine, it's just rumors...Poland has a total of 71 Fighter jets and sending some to Ukraine is no no.
@slavicapiponska888
@slavicapiponska888 Год назад
Pols like German people who practically destroyed them in the 2WW
@dragonmartijn
@dragonmartijn Год назад
@@jonatikoisuva2695 This David Owen doesn't know what he is talking about.
@JoSh-uj9pw
@JoSh-uj9pw Год назад
They don't make politicians like David Owen any more. The world is stuck with pound shop politicians.
@bbbf09
@bbbf09 Год назад
If you mean David Owen is the 50p shop politician then that observation is salient one.
@Trubripes
@Trubripes Год назад
Russia can be beaten, they cannot outproduce the west and will go bankrupt before the west does. Think of it as a long term investment. Military aid to Ukraine is extremely cost effective at depleting Russian military power, thus reducing the need for future military spending.
@nerdyali4154
@nerdyali4154 Год назад
The need for military spending is always there. The problem with Russia is that contrary to the delusions of the Mearsheimer faction, Europe and the US were not that concerned about Russia and really would have preferred to let them stew in their own dysfunction. Polish and Baltic badgering to increase NATO forces were an inconvenience and not part of a plot to "encroach" on Russia. The same mistake should not be made with China. Putin has woken these complacent leaders up to the fact that there are still archaic warlord throwbacks in the world who actually mean it when they give speeches reminiscent of the 1800's.
@fritzeckstein95
@fritzeckstein95 Год назад
he says while GDP is proposed to rise as the most sanctioned country ever btw (IMF), in a wartime economy and basically not dependant on the west as its rich in resources. cost effective - you got to be joking, america has spent more than the entire russian defense budget in a year (some of it loaned from the chinese btw). i really do hope people wake up to this, or not - we dont know what war is like anymore maybe we should be reminded.
@Trubripes
@Trubripes Год назад
@@fritzeckstein95 Russia's budget deficit is 24.8 billion USD in January. US strategic oil reserve and interest rate is crushing the Russian economy by accident. Russia is trying to increase taxes, but since Russian revenue is mostly state oil and gas export, and not taxes, there is a limit on what they can do.
@RussiasSufferingInUkraine
@RussiasSufferingInUkraine Год назад
What nonsense. Someone else has come out of the woodwork.
@gerhard7323
@gerhard7323 Год назад
Heavily disappointed in Owen here. Terribly out of touch, especially for someone once so immersed in foreign affairs.
@swift_learn
@swift_learn Год назад
How nice of lord Owen to come onto your programme to promote his book. 😂
@wettham715
@wettham715 Год назад
😊😊😊🤪
@aubreydrinkwater3236
@aubreydrinkwater3236 Год назад
He was useless when sitting as an MP., and from his view point, one can, see that he hasn't improved with age, whilst sitting in the House of Lords. I believe he's a complete idiot! It's only my personal view.
@michaziomek
@michaziomek Год назад
Russia obviously can be beaten back to the hole they came from. It happened in Afganistan, it happend during the first chechen war. When Ukraine retakes Crimea and the rest of their territories russia will concede.
@alainlefebvre9860
@alainlefebvre9860 Год назад
And by then they'll be mostly demilitarized AND their true weakness exposed to the world. No sane country will want to deal with Russia for generations.
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
They won't concede while this regime stands, but they need to be beaten back for starters and then, possibly, the rotten regime will fall.
@blackcatdungeonmastersfami5311
"when"
@michaziomek
@michaziomek Год назад
It's inevitable. Crimea is Ukraine. They will kick every russian murderer out of there by the end of summer 2023.
@Robert-xy4xi
@Robert-xy4xi Год назад
What fantasy😀
@conner.9262
@conner.9262 Год назад
A defensive alliance you state …. BUT ….. Ukraine is NOT a member of NATO ….. DEFENSIVE ??? Tell that to to citizens of Serbia ??? It comes a time in life when we all get so much older there’s confusion…… clearly it applies here !
@whyukraine
@whyukraine Год назад
He is living in a mythology of the past.
@jasperlawrence5361
@jasperlawrence5361 Год назад
What the Actual does Owen know about flying a plane? Really I mean, as a devoted patriot who wants to learn as fast as possible and who already knows how to fly various fighter jets. Give them the old planes, and stock Poland up with our new fighters and ground attack aircraft. you know victory when you see it? What did you ever win Owen, apart from office under Callaghan?
@sergekudrynskyj6662
@sergekudrynskyj6662 Год назад
If Russia is not to be beaten, it should at least be shovelled back to Russia, and to not intefere in other countries.
@martinsFILMS13
@martinsFILMS13 Год назад
Appeasement got us to today's War
@blackcatdungeonmastersfami5311
So nothing to do with breaking promises like the promises not to expand NATO eastwards and the promises made in Minsk I and Minsk II?
@KinoTechUSA69
@KinoTechUSA69 Год назад
@Black Cat Dungeon Master's Familiar You are parroting a tired, bullsh*t narrative, and you know it.
@blackcatdungeonmastersfami5311
@@KinoTechUSA69 Holland, Merkel, Poroshenko and now even Zelensky admit Minsk II was a sham to BS the Russians.
@fortunecookie3765
@fortunecookie3765 Год назад
@@blackcatdungeonmastersfami5311 America never had any right to speak on behalf of Eastern Europe and Russia knew that. NATO doesn't make membership easy so it's not as if they're actively recruiting countries. It's Ukraine's right to turn to Europe and join NATO because they're a sovereign nation that makes its own choices. Russia broke Minsk I & II agreements when Putin declared they no longer existed. Russian officers and troops were in LPR and DPR and bombing both sides throughout then blaming Ukraine. Putin lies because he wanted to destroy and control Ukraine and he suckered D/LPR to achieve that. Ukrainian separatists are f*ckwits who believed Russian propaganda so go live in post-truth Russia because your cities and homes will be destroyed before this war is over and you're little more than traitors to Ukraine. Reap what you sow.
@blackcatdungeonmastersfami5311
@@fortunecookie3765 It's not that you're completely wrong, it's more that you only have one side of the story. Yes Ukraine is a sovereign nation. Where the US state department sponsored a coup overturning the democratically elected government and then went on to appoint a new government. Which murdered a lot of anti-Maidan ethnic Russians. Anyway pretty soon the Americans will dump the Ukrainians just like they dumped their allies in Afghanistan and Iraq and before that Vietnam. And you pro-Ukraine simps who only know the NATO propaganda will move on to the next big thing the propaganda tells you to get outraged about. Which is probably going to be China by the looks of it.
@yuthok1
@yuthok1 Год назад
The worst colonial country in the history of the world is having a discussion about Russia taking defensive action which was provoked by NATO, UK and America in the first place. How ironic
@DJFAmenHeavy
@DJFAmenHeavy Год назад
Lol 😂. We’ll see. Once Putin is gone, Russia will fold like a pack of cards.
@QuizmasterLaw
@QuizmasterLaw Год назад
YEP!
@StillAliveAndKicking_
@StillAliveAndKicking_ Год назад
No, Russia is led by a bunch of crooks, plenty of candidates to replace Putin.
@wolfswinkel8906
@wolfswinkel8906 Год назад
Pardon me, where is Putin going and who's taking him there? Lol
@MrLu4o
@MrLu4o Год назад
I bet , you believe in fairytales .. :D
@DJFAmenHeavy
@DJFAmenHeavy Год назад
@@StillAliveAndKicking_ There is, but one would hope a new dictator won’t have the fear factor over the Russian nation, and that some coup would be attempted. Time will tell.
@bcfortenberry
@bcfortenberry Год назад
Old man yells at cloud ☁️
@jrobertsoneff
@jrobertsoneff Год назад
Putin went back 1200 miles after the west said thy would not move an inch east.
@JHaupt6314
@JHaupt6314 Год назад
David Owen - A disciple of Neville Chamberlain.
@frankb5603
@frankb5603 Год назад
Good one!
@cfosnock
@cfosnock Год назад
Click bait headline he openly says appeasement will not work, and to arm Ukraine tot he teeth.
@SCZim
@SCZim Год назад
Good analogy!!
@8-Tryzub-8
@8-Tryzub-8 Год назад
Actually, they will be beaten'.
@neilnelmar8007
@neilnelmar8007 Год назад
By whom?
@vaskodimoski5690
@vaskodimoski5690 Год назад
If you didn't want an invasion you should have implemented the Minsk agreement instead of just using the time to arm Ukraine.
@stephendenehey2809
@stephendenehey2809 Год назад
there is no fool like an old fool....
@fishingstevie8830
@fishingstevie8830 Год назад
Always said Nato should have went in strong from the beginning this as soon as Russia went in heavy handed .. Nato should have been at the ready to meet like for like or bettered what Russia had and this with better planes above on side for Ukraine ...and better tanks as then war would have been done and dusted by now . Quick edit - But all this dithering by Scholz is not good enough a coward seems as well as some others who are not fit to be within Nato as a leader of men at all . No country should have to go through what Ukraine still is going through and that country Russia allowed to bully their way in and take control as all countries in Nato should be at least handing out to Ukraine whats needed to conquer evil .
@groundworkcivils7506
@groundworkcivils7506 Год назад
Type in ''Colonel Douglas MacGregor Ukrainian annihilation "... See what a man with relevant experience is saying about the situation, instead of listening to this clown....
@groundworkcivils7506
@groundworkcivils7506 Год назад
@@resistdisinformation9931 ooh you big pessimist you 👍
@christianleblanc2842
@christianleblanc2842 Год назад
Russia doesn't need to be beaten. It just needs to decide Ukraine isn't worth the cost.
@gettingfactsoutthere
@gettingfactsoutthere Год назад
Not the entirety of Ukraine but the 4 regions they claimed. That is what they are fighting for as of right now.
@clives344
@clives344 Год назад
Very true
@timmyjimmy3647
@timmyjimmy3647 Год назад
" We need to focus internally on paying off debt etc" That's incredibly difficult to do while you're under artillery fire. First you secure your borders, then you rebuild. Your borders are still threatened.
@hymns4ever197
@hymns4ever197 Год назад
I generally agree, but is Britain under artillery fire?
@timmyjimmy3647
@timmyjimmy3647 Год назад
@@hymns4ever197 just repeated threat of nuclear war. For now.
@dragonmartijn
@dragonmartijn Год назад
I hope EU and USA are paying UK with better trade conditions, because otherwise UK only loses.
@mikoajwisniewski4878
@mikoajwisniewski4878 Год назад
First, dear Lord Owen, were the 200+ Polish tanks which were used in the Kharkiv offensive. The idea with our Migs - right on!
@Jack-wq1hu
@Jack-wq1hu Год назад
😮
@Scriptorsilentum
@Scriptorsilentum Год назад
please elaborate. my regrets your comment is unclear. ps: polish migs to ukr and uk to ask poles if raf base(s) welcome in poland.
@vivvpprof
@vivvpprof Год назад
skąd niby 200 polskich czołgów?
@smilesfordays8946
@smilesfordays8946 Год назад
Lord Owen, the death star is complete. Fear will keep the other systems in line.
@borisreljanovic7292
@borisreljanovic7292 Год назад
Owen wanted for Croatia to negotiate in 90 s and give territory to Serbia(back then Yugoslavia). Thank God we didn t listen to this man.
@cyberash3000
@cyberash3000 Год назад
the fnniest bit of all this is that he doesnt seem to understand the EU or the difference between EU and NATO. we could makle our own descisions even IN the EU. as a founding member we had that ability
@tawektawek3838
@tawektawek3838 Год назад
Agreed. I was a member of the SDP which was founded by pro-Europeans in 1981. When Owen supported Brexit in the Referendum he showed again how he had moved completely away from the party was a leading member of. He's a clever man, but his continual misrepresentation of what the EU is makes me think he's either dishonest with us, or dishonest with himself.
@2msvalkyrie529
@2msvalkyrie529 Год назад
It's Qualified Majority Voting so Britain could NOT act unilaterally . Poland and Hungary both tried to act according to the democratically expressed wishes of their electorates . They are both now being threatened with expulsion . E U and Democracy are 2 opposing concepts.
@cyberash3000
@cyberash3000 Год назад
@@2msvalkyrie529 yes it could and we have acted on our own before mate
@cyberash3000
@cyberash3000 Год назад
@@2msvalkyrie529 we often acted on our own without the EU yet another one of those anti eu nut jobs making things up.
@cyberash3000
@cyberash3000 Год назад
@@2msvalkyrie529 here is a LEGAL assessment of it. but please dont let your xenophobia get in the way of facts :) The question of sovereignty lies at the heart of the UK’s upcoming EU referendum. Many in Britain believe that the process of EU decision-making has undermined British parliamentary democracy, and that leaving the EU is the only way for the British people to regain control of their sovereignty. This ignores the fact that successive British governments have chosen to pool aspects of the country’s sovereign power in the EU in order to achieve national objectives that they could not have achieved on their own, such as creating the single market, enlarging the EU, constraining Iran’s nuclear programme, and helping to design an ambitious EU climate change strategy. Apart from EU immigration, the British government still determines the vast majority of policy over every issue of greatest concern to British voters - including health, education, pensions, welfare, monetary policy, defence and border security. The arguments for leaving also ignore the fact that the UK controls more than 98 per cent of its public expenditure. The British economy has prospered in the EU. The UK boasts higher economic growth and lower unemployment than most major developed economies. It attracts the most foreign direct investment in the EU, and is ranked among the most open places to do business in the developed world. British economic weaknesses, such as low growth in productivity, are self-inflicted. However, a successful economy and free-movement rules have led to high levels of immigration from the EU. Overall, this has been positive for the UK economy, but it has exacerbated preexisting pressures on public services, may have restricted wage growth in some sectors, and is a source of widespread public concern. Is it time, therefore, to return economic and political sovereign power entirely to Westminster? The risks of doing so are extensive. For example, the UK would be excluded from the process of EU rule-writing, making it a less attractive location for foreign investment. The UK is unlikely to strike better trade deals alone than it has currently through the EU. And the UK would have no say in the design of more open EU markets for digital, financial and other services. Leaving would also have a destabilizing effect on the rest of the EU, which will remain Britain’s largest market. In contrast, the main risks to the UK of remaining are political. High levels of immigration from the EU would persist. However, it is inconceivable that the EU will enlarge to include Turkey in the foreseeable future, and the UK and other EU states retain a veto over this decision. Nor need the UK fear the emergence of a more integrated eurozone, which will continue to feature profound differences in national outlook and is unlikely to enlarge quickly. EU decision-making overall is also becoming more intergovernmental rather than centralized. Continuing to pool its sovereign power selectively in the EU would enable the UK to help design integrated EU responses to many challenges that it cannot resolve on its own. These include the challenges of energy efficiency and sustainability; energy security; internet governance; and the fight against terrorism. In a world that is more interdependent today than it was when the UK joined the European Economic Community in 1973, the notion of ‘absolute’ British sovereignty is illusory. It is also worthless if it limits the ability of future British governments to ensure the security and prosperity of their citizens. Judging from the UK’s experience and its future prospects, the opportunities from remaining in the EU far outweigh the risks of doing so, and the risks of leaving far outweigh the opportunities.
@peterfawdon6142
@peterfawdon6142 Год назад
As a "Social democratic" Peer sitting in the House of Lords, it is a pity Mr Owen did not mention anything about asking what the Crimean people want !
@natalieturko4808
@natalieturko4808 Год назад
So Mr. Owen, how do you negotiate with a country that is hellbent on your destruction? Medvedev has clearly stated that Ukraine must be wiped off the face of the earth. As far as expecting Russia to respect clear boundaries during negotiations, they didn't respect the terms of the Budapest Memorandum, so what would change?
@draganmilosevic1336
@draganmilosevic1336 Год назад
As Ukraine said Russia needs to be whipped out if the face of the earth, far before war started.
@nemo6282
@nemo6282 Год назад
No negotiations now, Russia has been lied to ( as have you ) by the west too many times
@OleDiaBole
@OleDiaBole Год назад
So you think those agreements were obligating only to Russia? Orchestrating coup in UKR, arming ne0-n@zis and instructing them to perforrm genocid over Russian MAJORITY by actual minority... That is not breaking of agreements, according to you???
@Jerry10939
@Jerry10939 Год назад
Soviets lost in Afghanistan, when they had a better army. Russia is not in a position now to win.
@utrian4148
@utrian4148 Год назад
Giving Ukraine MiG's is helpful but no solution. The aircrafts are old and not all are combat ready. That is especially painfull since there aren't a lot at all. Spare parts and ammunition for them are very limited and You won't get them from russia. What jets should Britain give Poland instead? Introduce Eurofighters that takes time and effort for a jet that discontinued ? Ukraine has to make the transition to western jets anyway. Training may take 6-12 months but even the few MiG's from Poland and Slovakia will not last any longer. Why do we run into the same delay again like we did with tanks already? First we talk about excuses and when Ukraine falls behind we urgently decide what was inevitable from the start.
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
These MiG's can still be useful as spare parts, though. Sooner rather than later, and I hope it's rather sooner, Ukraine will need more modern western fighter jets, or an equivalent weapon system that can achieve the same offensive and defensive capabilities.
@ivangalik7848
@ivangalik7848 Год назад
i am very sad how west is handling this. it should have been said and done that nato is there not to beat russia but defeat it in ukraine and establish peace. nato should have intervened by now. the war would be over already. this is just weakening russia at the expense of ukraine suffering.
@nerdyali4154
@nerdyali4154 Год назад
Ukraine don't necessarily need top notch systems. They need volume. They are fighting an enemy stuck in 1915. Any aircraft is good enough if it can be made to take JDAM or fire SEEAD weapons.
@Grimenoughtomaketherobotcry
It isn't about just giving Ukraine fighters, or even about training (an "accelerated" training programme would be at least 18 months or more, even for experienced pilots). Support technicians would also need to be trained and equipped, runways might need to be lengthened/upgraded, specified fuel/lubricants might need to be sourced, etc. It takes years of planning to incorporate new aircraft models into a modern airforce. Which is why, under the pressing circumstances, MIGs are the better option since the Ukrainian pilots/crews are most familiar with them, and they can be most quickly incorporated into the Ukrainian air force. And spare parts can be found for them on the international arms market, as many countries that don't support Russia still fly Soviet-era fighters.
@sunyboymafu6149
@sunyboymafu6149 Год назад
A continuous supply of weapons to Ukraine doesn't look like a solution if the sole purpose of these weapons is to defeat Russia militarily.
@nicholascazmay2126
@nicholascazmay2126 Год назад
Chamberlain 2.0
@bradhombre6912
@bradhombre6912 Год назад
The quote for used for the title is very misleading when taken out of context. He says Russia can be defeated in Ukraine. Later, when he says Russia won't be "beaten", he's referring to being "beaten" in the sense of toppling the Russian government completely. That's a far cry from kicking them out of a country they are invading.
@Formed123
@Formed123 Год назад
and yet the goal of much of western management is to use this conflict to do just that - topple the current govt !!
@NordStar7
@NordStar7 Год назад
in this case, at a certain stage, the use of nuclear weapons will become inevitable. For Putin, losing means losing power, and losing power means death or jail. when a person has nothing to lose, he will try any methods
@Chisel_Chest
@Chisel_Chest Год назад
@@NordStar7 Fortunately a few people have to authorize nuke use. I doubt his minions will destroy their families for Mad Vlad Putain codename ztard.
@cooldudecs
@cooldudecs Год назад
Putin isn’t stopping at Ukraine
@jonkite0071
@jonkite0071 Год назад
Looks like it's USA and it's NATO puppets that won't stop destroying countries
@chairde
@chairde Год назад
THANK YOU MR. CHAMBERLAIN.
@kingmacksmokerking
@kingmacksmokerking Год назад
Russia just kicked off their highly awaited Offensive with the Missle/Drone Attack yesterday so Russia is about to completely wreck the Ukrainian Military for good it's over for Ukraine by the end of March. Russia deployed 1800 Tanks for this Offensive while the UK sends 14 Challenger Tanks Lol 🤣🤣 what a joke. Come the end of March Ukraine will have no choice but to sit at the Negotiation Table because they want have a Military left to stay in the fight unless Putin decides to go all the way to Kyiv.
@sp7873
@sp7873 Год назад
sending Leopard 1s to Ukraine isnt silly. they can reinforce defense positions and free up other tanks for offensive operations..
@alainlefebvre9860
@alainlefebvre9860 Год назад
Everything that can fire metal towards the Orcs is helpful.
@Capitalist_Pig314
@Capitalist_Pig314 Год назад
It seems to me every time we delay, sending better weapons to the Ukrainians. It’s just costing thousands of their lives. I know training is an issue with some of the high tech weapons. We need to get it moving along and give them a ton of stuff so they can get the war over with.
@miroslavstevic2036
@miroslavstevic2036 Год назад
what if the weapons are not enough? what if, in the end, we need to send our lives, namely mine and your life to prevent them from loosing their lives? are you willing to sacrifice your life for such noble cause, to save ukrainian lives? you go ahead, i surely have some better plans for my life then to die in frozen wasteland.
@tomwhittaker9461
@tomwhittaker9461 Год назад
@@miroslavstevic2036 Only an idiot could have thought Ukraine stands a chance. It was all about "extending Russia" from the start, read the 2019 RAND report.
@miroslavstevic2036
@miroslavstevic2036 Год назад
@@tomwhittaker9461 Oh it was about "extending Russia" and not "extending NATO"? Right. You obviously assume that the rest of the world are blind imbeciles? I think you should tell yourself what to read and stop lecturing others. You go read the Holy Bible. RAND report ...
@tomwhittaker9461
@tomwhittaker9461 Год назад
@@miroslavstevic2036 How can NATO be extended, according to your narrative, it is "all powerful" and could easily defeat Russia, right? :)) Plus, I've never seen a single document or statement by Russia claiming their goal is to "extend NATO". By contrast, the RAND reports are important documents for US foreign policy and can be easily accessed online. In addition, the US CLEARLY is trying to do exactly what is outlined in the 2019 RAND corporation report. Obviously, your MSM faithfulness is further evidence of your inability to look beyond chauvinistic tropes about "US exceptionalism" and "barbaric Russians". I'm not lecturing, merely saying the uncomfortable truth.
@miroslavstevic2036
@miroslavstevic2036 Год назад
@@tomwhittaker9461 If you really think Russian goal is to "extend NATO" I think you shoud visit your physician. Russian goal is to shrink NATO, and NATO's goal is to expand itself to Russian borders using Ukraine as ramming log. Maybe you should read the newest RAND report from this year. You'll be surprised by its conclusions.
@anthonyryan9706
@anthonyryan9706 Год назад
This man helped to keep Thatcher in power
@LewisSkeeter
@LewisSkeeter Год назад
Good for him.
@DavidGetling
@DavidGetling Год назад
If we are talking about what's "perfectly legitimate", it's perfectly legitimate for American, British and Polish fighter pilots to clear Ukrainian skies of Orcs. And there is no shortage of these pilots just itching to waste as many Orcs as they can.
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
In many past conflicts that has happened. I don't see any relevant reason for that not to be the case with the current war as well.
@evolassunglasses4673
@evolassunglasses4673 Год назад
They will be destroyed like Russia destroyed Ukraines air force. Ukraine needs negotiations ASP
@fitzstv8506
@fitzstv8506 Год назад
@@Katoshi_Takagumi There is a reason it is called Nuclear war and if not for that possible threat then western forces would have already intervened.
@Katoshi_Takagumi
@Katoshi_Takagumi Год назад
@@fitzstv8506 It's called nuclear deterrent, because everyone knows you cannot win a nuclear war. The west has not directly intervened, they have intervened indirectly, of course. They seem intent on trying to contain the conflict. I'm not sure if that strategy isn't going to fail in the end, though.
@harmless6813
@harmless6813 Год назад
@@fitzstv8506 I don't see what the difference is between a member of the Ukrainian International Legion fighting with a gun in Bakhmut and a member of the Ukrainian International Legion flying a fighter jet.
@chrisboeman
@chrisboeman Год назад
The title is totally misleading. What Mr. Owen said is that the country of Russia itself is not going to be defeated. (No Ukrainians are going to be riding Leopard II or Abrams tanks victorious into Moscow) He clearly is of the opinion that Russia could be and likely will be defeated in Ukraine. Big difference.
@mfgillia7606
@mfgillia7606 Год назад
I just now saw your comment after my post along identical lines. I don't think most people commenting negatively on Owen's interview actually watched the full video.
@johnsmithers5044
@johnsmithers5044 Год назад
Give this man the white feather.
@cfosnock
@cfosnock Год назад
For wanting to arm Ukraine to the teeth? Did I miss something...the headline was click bait.
@DMZDMX1
@DMZDMX1 Год назад
He has plenty. He hasn't figured out yet that he is an embarrassment to humanity.
@tokasonumeanozie3096
@tokasonumeanozie3096 Год назад
Finally someone has to stand up and tell the truth instead of lying to the public! Both sides should seat at negotiation table as earlier the better
@albertinsinger7443
@albertinsinger7443 Год назад
All these western leaders are under the illusion Russia will lose. Right now Russia is winning. Ukraine has no more soldiers and is recruiting 15 and 16 year old children . Russia could win this war by summer. Way before even any tank arrives.
@AK-ej5ml
@AK-ej5ml Год назад
David Owen is right in saying that the west must do as must as possible to get equipment to Ukraine as soon as possible, including jets.
@muckle8
@muckle8 Год назад
No he isn’t - unless you want ww3
@AK-ej5ml
@AK-ej5ml Год назад
@clark kent The Russian dictatorship wants to stay in power, so they won't start a losing war - and, by the way, a war with Russia would not in itself be world war and China joining on Russia's side seems unlikely.
@nigelmansfield3011
@nigelmansfield3011 Год назад
There is a difference between Russia not winning and Russia not losing. It is not in the world's interest for Russia to be destroyed or broken up - what would follow would likely be a lot worse. So we have to have a compromise peace that gives freedom and democracy to Ukraine and stable democratic government to Russia. Russia must also be recognised as a great power with both rights and responsibilities. We had a great opportunity to aid Russia after the fall of the Soviet Union but the 'carpet baggers' moved in.
@z.t.500
@z.t.500 Год назад
It _is_ the world's interest that Russia is broken up and obliterated from existence. Well, the interest of the _civilised_ world, at least.
@MGGitari
@MGGitari Год назад
As long as we do advocate for a "reward aggression" peace formular
@alainlefebvre9860
@alainlefebvre9860 Год назад
Oh, you're quite wrong Nigel. Russia needs to be demilitarized so these endless invasions stop happening. Russia has proven it can never be responsible nor does it care about laws or rules. They're a cancer that needs to be dealt with. At any cost.
@Blanka1100
@Blanka1100 Год назад
Russia has never been a democratic country and never will be. They don't know any better. Russia will never change. It's not a matter of one Putin. Russians are raised to be passive. Russia is anything but great power. It's cheap gas station which can not stand its time of glory is over and Eastern Europe is not soviet backyard anymore. Russia is not the only one to have safety concerns and right in Eastern Europe. Russia's victims have it too. Stop being naive. Greetings from Poland.
@gettingfactsoutthere
@gettingfactsoutthere Год назад
@@z.t.500 So the “civilised world” appeals to destroying nations. Guessing thats why you hypocritical pigs were so quiet about Libya, Yemen, Iraq and countless other nations who suffered from the west.
@jeffsmall7526
@jeffsmall7526 Год назад
Its important to have dissenting views even if they are wrong, especially if they are wrong.
@douglastaggart9360
@douglastaggart9360 Год назад
It's only dissenting views if you disagree with them .i think you're probably wrong but it's your opinion
@michelpittaway7718
@michelpittaway7718 Год назад
when it's wrong, must fight it! Otherwise it gives too many Trump free to lie
@andywarburton4702
@andywarburton4702 Год назад
He was woolly minded back in the 70s/80s and is woolly minded still...
@andrewdogman1
@andrewdogman1 Год назад
Don’t underestimate D Owen. I remember when Honduras put troops on the Belize/Honduras border he sent a frigate plus RM’s in the area he talked but backed it up with force.
@franzmenzies5268
@franzmenzies5268 Год назад
That would be Guatemala, Belize's arch enemy. We have very little problems with Honduras.
@JarmilaMatousek
@JarmilaMatousek Год назад
Easy to back it up when your not the one fighting.
@johndoe6298
@johndoe6298 Год назад
@@JarmilaMatousek So who would make policy if not civilian politicians? The military? Several Latin American countries tried that in the 1970s and they became brutal dictatorships that killed tens of thousands of their own citizens.
@andysloan6722
@andysloan6722 Год назад
Misleading title yet again.
@CONTACTLIGHTTOMMY
@CONTACTLIGHTTOMMY Год назад
Putin is getting more fragile every week. Never say never...FYI.
@bellbookcandle3051
@bellbookcandle3051 Год назад
Was it Coco Chanel that said, "By 50, you get the face you deserve."? Dear _God,_ looking at Owen, was she ever _right!!_
@leonardgibney2997
@leonardgibney2997 Год назад
The man is in his eighties after all.
@RJPaul-px6vt
@RJPaul-px6vt Год назад
It was George Orwell actually. And David Owen is 84!
@1maico1
@1maico1 Год назад
@@RJPaul-px6vt Unfortunately Orwell never reached 50
@LeeSeanSullivan
@LeeSeanSullivan Год назад
Looks good for 84, my God what did you look like at 50.
@RJPaul-px6vt
@RJPaul-px6vt Год назад
@@1maico1 I know, but he still said it, or rather wrote it, in his notebook just before his death.
Далее
Fake watermelon by Secret Vlog
00:16
Просмотров 9 млн
UK’s 100 Year Economic Decline - No 1 to Failed State
13:14