Ryan: Reasonable Chance of a Debt Crisis

Подписаться 2 млн

Просмотров 39 тыс.

50% 1

Paul Ryan, Former Speaker of the House and Teneo Vice Chairman takes us through some of the economic issues that the next president might face, including a debt crisis. He speaks to David Westin at the Milken Global Institute Conference in Beverly Hills.
--------
More on Bloomberg Television and Markets

Like this video? Subscribe and turn on notifications so you don't miss any videos from Bloomberg Markets & Finance: tinyurl.com/ysu5b8a9
Visit www.bloomberg.com for business news & analysis, up-to-the-minute market data, features, profiles and more.

Connect with Bloomberg Television on:
X: / bloombergtv
Facebook: / bloombergtelevision
Instagram: / bloombergtv

Connect with Bloomberg Business on:
X: / business
Facebook: / bloombergbusiness
Instagram: / bloombergbusiness
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@bloombergbusi...
Reddit: / bloomberg
LinkedIn: / bloomberg-news

More from Bloomberg:
Bloomberg Radio: / bloombergradio
Bloomberg Surveillance: / bsurveillance
Bloomberg Politics: / bpolitics
Bloomberg Originals: / bbgoriginals

Watch more on RU-vid:
Bloomberg Technology: / @bloombergtechnology
Bloomberg Originals: / @business
Bloomberg Quicktake: / @bloombergquicktake
Bloomberg Espanol: / @bloomberg_espanol
Bloomberg Podcasts: / @bloombergpodcasts
--------
More on Bloomberg Television and Markets

Like this video? Subscribe and turn on notifications so you don't miss any videos from Bloomberg Markets & Finance: tinyurl.com/ysu5b8a9
Visit www.bloomberg.com for business news & analysis, up-to-the-minute market data, features, profiles and more.

Connect with Bloomberg Television on:
X: / bloombergtv
Facebook: / bloombergtelevision
Instagram: / bloombergtv

Connect with Bloomberg Business on:
X: / business
Facebook: / bloombergbusiness
Instagram: / bloombergbusiness
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@bloombergbusi...
Reddit: / bloomberg
LinkedIn: / bloomberg-news

More from Bloomberg:
Bloomberg Radio: / bloombergradio
Bloomberg Surveillance: / bsurveillance
Bloomberg Politics: / bpolitics
Bloomberg Originals: / bbgoriginals

Watch more on RU-vid:
Bloomberg Technology: / @bloombergtechnology
Bloomberg Originals: / @business
Bloomberg Quicktake: / @bloombergquicktake
Bloomberg Espanol: / @bloomberg_espanol
Bloomberg Podcasts: / @bloombergpodcasts
--------
More on Bloomberg Television and Markets

Like this video? Subscribe and turn on notifications so you don't miss any videos from Bloomberg Markets & Finance: tinyurl.com/ysu5b8a9
Visit www.bloomberg.com for business news & analysis, up-to-the-minute market data, features, profiles and more.

Connect with Bloomberg Television on:
X: / bloombergtv
Facebook: / bloombergtelevision
Instagram: / bloombergtv

Connect with Bloomberg Business on:
X: / business
Facebook: / bloombergbusiness
Instagram: / bloombergbusiness
TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@bloombergbusi...
Reddit: / bloomberg
LinkedIn: / bloomberg-news

More from Bloomberg:
Bloomberg Radio: / bloombergradio
Bloomberg Surveillance: / bsurveillance
Bloomberg Politics: / bpolitics
Bloomberg Originals: / bbgoriginals

Watch more on RU-vid:
Bloomberg Technology: / @bloombergtechnology
Bloomberg Originals: / @business
Bloomberg Quicktake: / @bloombergquicktake
Bloomberg Espanol: / @bloomberg_espanol
Bloomberg Podcasts: / @bloombergpodcasts

Опубликовано:

9 май 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 194

@radar0412 24 дня назад

Paul Ryan put together the Simpson/Bowles deficit reduction Commission, and then quickly proceeded to vote AGAINST their deficit reduction plans. 😅😅

@Pug318 25 дней назад

Personally, I liked Paul Ryan but when he was speaker of the house, he gave President Trump budgets that added $1 trillion deficit. He’s no better than the rest of the politicians and when he had his power, he added to the deficit just like they all do.

@tatianastarcic 24 дня назад

The US economy cannot survive without continuous credit and debt creation. The FED will print more money and the average American will go just that much further in debt. Meanwhile, foreigners lust for the greenback. Their economies are in worse condition than the US... if that's even possible. Someone is going to be left holding the bag...

@Michaelparker12 24 дня назад

They do say gold will crash in a liquidity crunch However, many of those holding precious metals are preparing for such an event. So they are unlikely to be forced sellers. The paper market would tank and hopefully collapse.

@berniceburgos- 24 дня назад

Hearing from an experienced investor who has survived adversity and prevailed is always motivating. It may be frightening when your portfolio goes from green to red, but if you have invested in strong firms, you should maintain growing them and stick to your goal.

@nicolasbenson009 24 дня назад

It's often true that people underestimate the importance of financial advisors until they feel the negative effects of emotional decision-making. I remember a few summers ago, after a tough divorce, when I needed a boost for my struggling business. I researched and found a licensed advisor who diligently helped grow my reserves despite inflation. Consequently, my reserves increased from $275k to around $750k.

@BridgetMiller- 24 дня назад

This sound interesting. I’m not really one to use pro analysts, but I guess it would not hurt to try one. My portfolio is in the red waters right now

@nicolasbenson009 24 дня назад

Certainly, there are a handful of experts in the field. I've experimented with a few over the past years, but I've stuck with ‘’Melissa Terri Swayne” for about five years now, and her performance has been consistently impressive.She’s quite known in her field, look-her up.

@marko6657 24 дня назад

Ryan had many times to fix the government debt problem and did nothing. Can’t complain now.

@gddlsllc 23 дня назад

While in congress he brought the debt from 5 trillion to 20 trillion. This man is a disgrace

@tjsokkerplayer 14 дней назад

What a ridiculous point of view. As if one man is solely responsible for the debt bubble. Also do you want to give him credit for the stock market going up during the same time period?

@gddlsllc 12 дней назад

@@tjsokkerplayer You might consider that congress IS the entity with the power of the purse. Congress is also about the ONLY entity with oversight over federal agencies, real (agencies,) or imaginary (The Fed). Not only he sat in congress and oversaw the debt go from 5 to over 20 trillion, but he was majority in congress for a good part, and he himself held the highest post, for a good while. His power over the purse was direct and indirect, by way of the laws, regulations, wars, failure of oversight, measures and every single action that he took, or did not take, which in the end, led us astray. He is culpable, to be sure.

@asc5882 8 дней назад

System problem. Debt has become a function of time: Debt at year D[y]= 2^((D[y] -1983)/8). System is incapable of making difficult decisions

@apex3821 6 дней назад

@@tjsokkerplayer He is the PRESIDENT this means its ALL on him. That is the standard.

@GrahamTube4u 23 дня назад

2 years ago I watched him in an interview say America will never default on its debts.

@ronsilva7394 24 дня назад

This man orchestrated the mess we are in today .

@enhancedutility266 24 дня назад

Right it could have been fixed 2011-2012

@KK-pm7ud 24 дня назад

Did he? Or was it the Koch's?

@jamesklaatu9359 24 дня назад

Been decades in the making.

@martinpalm5 24 дня назад

@@enhancedutility266 which was the best time to fix it. Covid was the last nail in coffin.

@willrose5424 24 дня назад

Proxy wars

@GrantDWilliams82 25 дней назад

It's easy to complain about how nobody on the Hill has the guts to talk about entitlement reform... when you're not on the Hill anymore. This guy was everything he just criticized... when he was there. Don't let him lie to you.

@enhancedutility266 25 дней назад

Yeah he's been in office since 1999 and the only legislation he's ever passed is garbage

@radar0412 24 дня назад

Yep. Ryan voted Against HIS OWN deficit reduction Commission Simpson/Bowles.

@bretrudeseal4314 22 дня назад

People being stupid enough to buy our bonds is what has enabled the Congress' spending addiction. You can't wish away this debt, you either repudiate it or you cut the budget.

@donaldharlan3981 25 дней назад

That guy you're blaming for Paul Ryan on Bloomberg is much taller and meaner than the real Paul Ryan. I would never buy flowers from a person like that.

@chessdad182 25 дней назад

35T in government debt is 35T in assets for non-government. To eliminate government debt, need to take 35T from others. Would create a depression. Review the history of balanced budgets by US government and the corresponding recessions/depressions that occurred in US history.

@albertfernandez6315 25 дней назад

Ryan lost me with those pants

@NPC-bs3pm 25 дней назад

Those socks! 🫣

@bvssrsguntur6338 19 дней назад

No wonder why there is no control or focus on debt

@jsudlow12 24 дня назад

I did like at the end when he said “we can solve these problems if we have serious politics, we don’t have serious politics right now”

@robertlelis3410 24 дня назад

Ol Lyin' Ryan

@dang328 22 дня назад

Thanks for helping with the debt! Helping grow it I mean

@774kblake 23 дня назад

GREAT idea!!! Let's listen to the ARSONIST who helped start the fire now suddenly COMPLAIN about the fire HE STARTED?!!! WTF?!

@markburnham7512 25 дней назад

Issue #1 is out of control debt. How can you decide how to tax when spending is out of control?

@ThatonedudeCR12956 25 дней назад

Obviously by cutting taxes for the top 1% and raising them on people making minimum wage. That's their actual answer. They are not serious people and should not be taken seriously. This has been obvious since the 80s and they are either flat out ignoring reality or being dishonest.

@romeomargot-picquendar1281 24 дня назад

Well it's not rocket science, you either increase taxes to support the spending, you cut the spending, or a little bit of both. The dilemma for a politician is that both are costly politically, and since all they care about is staying in power, no one has the willpower to do anything on the issue. If nothing is done, Social Security will run out of funds by 2034.

@manatee419 21 день назад

Instead of cutting spending on Medicare , how about cutting spending? On government pay raises and giving money to other countries in incorporate hangouts.

@nicholaselliott2484 25 дней назад

He had me til he mentioned stable coins

@ThePlastic111 20 дней назад

How come? Do you know a lot about stable coins?

@eliseumalo4069 20 дней назад

Paul Ryan should be running for President.

@lisizecha9759 22 дня назад

@11:50 "Bond finance the boomers" means that GenZ does three things at once: Pay the high apartment rents to create Boomer retirement income Pay interest on bonds to finance Boomer health care Put money aside for their own retirement That must be a real go-get-them attitude by these GenZs On the other hand: Have you met them

@jro7815 22 дня назад

These politicians are despicable and truly hate young people. We can reduce deficits by cutting every entitlement that solely benefits the boomers and the military and just focusing on helping the younger generations succeed.

@user-se2uv8cl4p 21 день назад

Gen Z'ers have a road rage problem. They are all pissed off at the world.

@DaveWells300 25 дней назад

Peewee Herman?

@Rust_Belt_Capital 22 дня назад

Paul… you don’t support Trump as a “Republican” then you can’t complain with the alternative

@clarencehoover6748 25 дней назад

The Federal Reserve has only one product: Debt. The system is inherently flawed to eventually fail from the very first FRN issued with interest attached; whether or not this was the original intent is irrelevant. Even Keynes knew this and privately admitted to the eventual collapse of this scheme. Mathematically, debt can never ever be paid off; otherwise the system would implode. Rather, the debt must continue to grow and more importantly, grow at increasing rates for the system to sustain. Yes, temporary tapers can be imposed, but that is followed by a gush of currency creation to satisfy the quantity of FRNs to catch up with the required point on the underlying monetary creation curve that must be satisfied like a rigid secret foundational law of this system based on the underlying mathematics. But this Ponzi has its limit. The wall approaches.

@id10t98 19 дней назад

You and Keynes couldn't be more wrong. Particularly when one entity spends $1 trillion every year under the guise of defense.

@tjsokkerplayer 14 дней назад

Sounds like a very sensible and reasoned perspective from Paul Ryan. Who would have thought stable coins would be another measure to strengthen the US Dollar. But it makes sense.

@briantep458 25 дней назад

35T DEBT

@Whitemink32 25 дней назад

1 turd in the toilet

@user-ec3rm9wr1n 25 дней назад

My my my ...

@ThatonedudeCR12956 25 дней назад

We better reduce taxes to 0% for billionaires and use all the money we make on that for...for..what are we taxing people for again? So cut taxes and zero out spending and let America rot? Is that the answer?

@chessdad182 25 дней назад

Or 35T in assets held by others including the private sector. In order to reduce it to zero, you would need to remove 35T in assets from others.

@bleacherz7503 24 дня назад

@@chessdad182guy is a criminal - stole from poor and gave to the rich

@commentaccount2750 23 дня назад

I don’t recall him speaking out against CARES.

@douglaspmatheny 25 дней назад

Ryan always talks about cutting social security and taxes.

@craigbauer426 18 дней назад

I can’t tell who spun 180-degrees faster - Ryan on the Debt Crisis or Barr on Trump being technically fit to lead the country.

@craigcolbourn 23 дня назад

Debt crisis? What’s that? More like a money printing crisis.

@sandburgmartin7947 24 дня назад

Bet he's about to write a book. This is the initializer to bump up his "initial" advance on the book.

@user-vb5in3pu3s 25 дней назад

Can we hear more on what he means by a debt crisis

@enhancedutility266 25 дней назад

The debt has grown much larger in the size of the economy the debt to income ratio on the national day is running at 125+ percent anytime debt reaches that ratio alarm bells start to ring

@InnocentCardGame-sz2be 24 дня назад

Do we need to create a mild debt crisis to prevent a major one? Strange.. scares me i even wrote that... we don't have the mental and intestinal fortitude to do the difficult things that are necessary. I don't even want to mow the grass or work hard at my job. Let alone save the world itself. People are strange.

@babyimHOME 25 дней назад

Bitcoin duh

@stevenobinator2229 23 дня назад

Fed will force banks to buy, simple

@PaArriba 24 дня назад

💯🎯

@JscottMays 19 дней назад

Ryan didn't listen when Fed chair corrected his misunderstanding. Still hasn't.

@utube7917 21 день назад

- *MONEY* *DOES* *NOT* *REQUIRE* a ledger, just to simply exist. - Ledgers are just an optional service that you can use, as a record of ownership, for the money that is stored on your behalf. But a written ledger is never the money itself, because YOUR OWN money, when held personally in your own hands, does not require anyone to keep track of it for you!! - In the best case scenario, the sole purpose of a ledger is to track and trace ownership, but in the worst case scenario, it is to track and trace a population for total control. - If you have a ledger written out on paper, with no underlying physical asset, then it is just a worthless piece of paper. It's a physical claim check on nothing. If it is a digital ledger, then it is just a worthless digital record, that is a claim check on nothing. - Ledgers are clearly NOT MONEY and never will be. Its a scam.

@moneyevery3days7 2 дня назад

Depends on what you consider money. If you value precious metals and intend to store and transact with it personally, then a ledger is not required. Most people agree that money comes from a bank which comes from a central bank so by that definition ledgers would be required.

@utube7917 2 дня назад

@@moneyevery3days7 the definition of money goes back thousands of years. Today people who are uneducated think that currency is the same thing as money, but it is not. Money has several characteristics including being a physical commodity that is divisible, a medium of exchange, a store of value, unit of account, fungible, durable and transportable. Currency, like digital fiat or paper fiat, fails a number of these criteria, especially durability. Bitcoin is a fiat currency that is just a digital ledger that is recorded in electronics that is not durable. One single solar event like the Carrington event would wipe out all record of digital currency. Chemical elements of the universe like gold and silver, which are inert, don't react with water or oxygen and are not radioactive, last for eternity and are extremely durable metal. Being chemical elements, they are compmetely fungible down to the atomic level. They are divisuble, a medium of exchange, unit of account and a store of value for over 6,000 years. Best of all, easily transportable. When silver is too cumbersome, gold can transport 100,000 or more in just your pockets. 10 ounces is less than a pound and worth about $24,000 US fiat dollars atm. Real money does not depend on. Electricity or a ledger simply to exist. It is not an imaginary commodity in a digital record in your mind. Gold and silver are real and are a physical reality. They are sound money that cannot be inflated to oblivion, but have real intrinsic value in their utility due to their elemental properties that make them the most precious of all metals. You can use paper fiat dollars or digital fiat bitcoin, but they are just currencies and not real or sound money like gold and silver. What you like emotionally and by your opinion is just your subjective opinion, but it does not change these facts. A digital fiat ledger system like bitcoin can never be true money by its very nature. The most it can ever be is a fiat system to track and control people. The US government takes bitcoin right out of your wallet whenever they want, just like they did to those ransomware attackers.

@pangmeister 23 дня назад

Ryan, I am in between too and I am with you.

@mikemcglauflin8985 18 дней назад

Baitcoin; It looks like currency but it's tech based government.

@cerealpeer 24 дня назад

rofl, what?! correction: WE ARE ABSOLUTELY CERTAIN OF A CURRENTLY ONGOING CRISIS OF DEBT

@ryanflippin1243 22 дня назад

Greasy politicians

@KingRat71 23 дня назад

We need to reverse the tax cuts on the roch and business from the last 70+ years. Business used to be forced to reinvest in growth to avoid taxation on profits. With those taxes reduced now they focus on stock prices and dividends. And the rich already own over 90% of everything. They clearly dont need any tax cuts and in fact need to make up for not paying their fair share. When they own 90%+ of everything they need to be paying 90%+ of the tax burden.

@1dantown 24 дня назад

Do you notice how our friend Paul here never balanced the federal budget, $15 trillion of lesser debt, ago. *_Now_* he whines about it.

@danielscott1409 25 дней назад

Flip why don't they just make this guy President, at least he's smart

@TheGenFem 21 день назад

I can’t afford anymore taxes

@class1188 9 дней назад

Cant understand word

@johnmccann7578 24 дня назад

Last quote: Healthcare entitlements are biggest drivers of our debt.

@sandburgmartin7947 24 дня назад

Only the "deserving" wealthiest, like him, should get health care, right??

@Here4TheHeckOfIt 19 дней назад

Military spending is the largest driver. Let's face it, people are not important to the Republicans 😂 We are nothing more than stats and numbers.

@billb89 25 дней назад

I'd say it's likely we'll see a debt crisis.

@user-ys5qp4bq4s 21 день назад

You can talk cute until the bond market gets Liz Trussed.

@BTC_Patriot 23 дня назад

Bitcoin fixes this.

@jasondude7566 14 дней назад

im a democrat, and I will vote for this guy for president. Never Trump, but this guy is normal. We need normal

@martinpalm5 24 дня назад

how much did the CCP pay this guy?

@class1188 9 дней назад

😅😅😅

@Questioneverything2050 6 дней назад

Interviewer talks like Jamie dimon

@stone1537 23 дня назад

No.! You don’t saay.!

@bluewatermiles 22 дня назад

Debt crisis is based on flat earther economics. Update to MMT and focus on actual issues

@dinkeydink9376 7 дней назад

Ryan has more energy than the two old pensioners, the President candidates, together. How could US end up with them? They never let Biden talk like this, coz he can't...

@stevechilcoat2353 24 дня назад

It's hard to listen to him seriously. He is so informed about tax policy and did some good things, and yet he's not going to vote for Trump? There is some kind of disconnect with this former politician.

@sheabilladeau1392 19 дней назад

How about this? Don't tax me for medicare or SS and I will provide my own plans to take care of my family for retirement and medicare so I am not funding someone else's life. Give me back the money I put into it already that I would never see otherwise. Stop the taxes and stop benefits. It is possible. This is the way.

@MarekKolenda-cr8vr 25 дней назад

Debt ceiling limit ends in January 2024

@suresh_elonbro 23 дня назад

i support tax cuts but i am worried about debt crisis. i support 3 wars in 3 continents. what else?

@kingtosin 23 дня назад

good people in congress, wtf have they done?

@user-vb5in3pu3s 25 дней назад

If the president doesnt have a plan for the debt then congress should have a plan for the debt crisis the president gets the blame but congress is who is at fault.

@class1188 9 дней назад

Ai robots taking over jobs not humans

@lisizecha9759 22 дня назад

The USD is about to become unstable Stable coins are stable, because they are pegged to the USD 🙂

@bjohns347347 25 дней назад

Ryan is way smarter than Trump.

@NPC-bs3pm 25 дней назад

All depends on how much you secretly LOVE the Republican party🫤

@ronsilva7394 24 дня назад

He lost which makes him a …….

@NPC-bs3pm 24 дня назад

@@ronsilva7394Ah... a 'Loser' 😓?

@fallonmassey4714 21 день назад

*Paul Ryan looking for more ways for us to cheat! We want fairness, but refuse to give it!*

@surfbum8166 25 дней назад

Stable coins won’t save the dollar

@upticktrade 25 дней назад

$Dollar is always going to be king. Betcha, he rather hold $Dollar than any other currencies. Talk is cheap. So many talk the opposite what they do.

@Alex-de8kd 19 дней назад

Shyster.

@b_easy0823 19 дней назад

He has all the solutions after the fact now that he’s retired. What did you do while in Congress?!!?!!? Added trillions of dollars to the National Debt while speaker under Trump’s Admin. Who are you fooling?

@roc7880 23 дня назад

he forgot to mention his party repeated tax cuts led to deficits and higher debt. his solution was always more tax cuts. amazing logic indeed

@robertj8610 22 дня назад

what about the government cancer of overspending my money, Einstein

@bleacherz7503 24 дня назад

Criminal should be in jail

@expand9487 23 дня назад

Both party are stupid.

@DKK 19 дней назад

Screw Paul Ryan

@bkfabs 21 день назад

He was part of the problem when he was in congress…now he talks tough…typical politician.

@Here4TheHeckOfIt 19 дней назад

People like Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan helped create this debt crisis. They are now sounding the alarm, trying to come off like seers 🙄

@gregorygreene1940 24 дня назад

Hard to take him seriously when he was a contributor to why the debt is so high. He's a hypocrite.

@bleacherz7503 24 дня назад

Living lies

@KK-pm7ud 24 дня назад

Why isn't this guy a choice?

@user-ly7xe5mj8z 25 дней назад

RINO Ryan

@imtryinghere1 25 дней назад

I don't really care for Ryan, but RINO is such a pathetic label. Don't MAGA idiots get tired of using the same childish cliche to label everyone they don't like as RINO? Mitt Romney is a RINO. Nikki Haley is a RINO. Michael Steele is a RINO. Ron DeSantis is a RINO. Blah blah blah.

@nicholaselliott2484 25 дней назад

He is at least bringing up the debt, many populists are closer to Rinos than this position.

@SorosGeorg 25 дней назад

Bloomberg didn't mention Paul Ryan is a lobbyist for Chinese trade.😎

@KK-pm7ud 24 дня назад

Where is that information confirmed?

@karld6309 24 дня назад

8 trillion or so on the fed balance sheet. The debt has already been monetized.

@andrewkroger701 22 дня назад

You did NOTHING Paul.

@SingleSuccessfulMomMBA1422 24 дня назад

We need absolutely tariffs on foreign goods. America first, we need to protect ourselves and our workers.

@MarekKolenda-cr8vr 25 дней назад

Fed and Powell play political games before November election

@gumby7919 13 дней назад

Use the money you send to Ukraine and fund Social Security…it’s easy

@guru47pi 20 дней назад

This guy played someone who cared about deficits and fiscal responsibility on TV, but made many of the worst decisions possible during the 2000's to expand the deficit with unfunded tax cuts and many other poor decisions, like blocking many other reforms. In short, he's a clown hoping no one watching has a memory of his actual career.

@chrisslc1106 25 дней назад

He has literally been saying this for over 20 years, why do people treat it as news?

@PaArriba 24 дня назад

He should run for office!

@Kendye6 25 дней назад

gov't sucks at everything. The smaller the better. Stop taxing. Cut spending, it's absurd, taxation is already way too high and way too broad.

@christiancoronado 25 дней назад

He was doing well. Why did he have to bring stable coins

@noName-kn1lx 24 дня назад

Mr RIno

@bro.radcliffe9453 24 дня назад

RFK jr

@sumitomoO0O 25 дней назад

Europe pays $8/gallon for gas...USA pays $3/gallon. Just put a $5/gallon special sales tax on gas. That will raise revenue, reduce air pollution, reduce lung cancer, reduce the oil waste. Teach a lesson to big boys who commute to their office jobs driving big trucks. This non-sense only happens in USA. Nobody has the freedom to give me lung cancer

@user-ec3rm9wr1n 25 дней назад

😢..

@drscopeify 25 дней назад

The problem with that is it leads to inflation on things like food and goods and driving/transportation fares so the impact hits the most on the lowest earners. People who make the least suffer the most from that kind of tax. You can have a little bit increase like $1 let's say