This ten minute clip is drawn from the famous 1950s game show, and it's quite surreal. I don't use the word surreal loosely: the special guest is Salvador Dali.
Great comment for a great material. I just found this on YT and I´m liking it. It reminds me of a show I used to watch as a kid in Cuba. Who knows, perhaps "inspired" by this one.
@@user-fe8de2gu5v They have the wits but aren't allowed to use them, the jokes always needs to be lowest common denominator. One important thing to remember is that we no longer have celebrity artists. Outside of Banksy, no one has any real fame.
DIY Improver You kno wat? I had that exact same thought! Sadly I suspect it was just thrown away. I too would love to have it! Apart from its sentimental value I'm sure it would be worth a lot of money now.
just to make a note. living in spain and knowing english, spanish and french is something VERY remarkable for that time here in spain. many people say Dalí was simply a weirdo but let me tell you this dude's brain was on another whole league.
@@nrn312 I actually think he didn't move out of the country because, unlike other Spanish painters of the time like Picasso, he was sympathetic to the Franco regime. Anyway, he could have moved around for other things, I don't know...
Are you a writer? Yes. Are you an athlete? Yes. Have you ever performed surgery? Yes. If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around, does it make a sound? Yes. Are you a tree? Yes.
I would say under certain conditions that we would have to accept the possibility that our guest could be considered of a tree variety, but it isn't necessarily germane as to what we're trying to arrive at.
You should have seen the episode with Leonardo Da Vinci. Are you a painter? A sculptor? A doctor? A scientist? A writer? An inventor? A cryptographer? A scientist? A poet? An urbanist? An anatomist? A musician? A botanist? Come on!
@@empnadajhhh9469 HE would not describe himself as "scientist" as that term was created in mid-19th century. Also, anatomist and doctor are rather redundant.
Looking back on these old game shows from the 50s/60s/70s, it's remarkable how intelligent the hosts, panels, and many of the guests were. Even the humor displayed a high degree of intelligent wit and literacy.
I honestly don't think he was trying to mislead them, he was being honest, the things he's done I'm sure required athleticism and writing and have him as the leading man.
Many comments mention Dali as egotistical. He was known for his flair for the dramatic and constant need for attention. But nonetheless, he was indeed a painter, a sculptor, a fashion designer, an author, a filmmaker, artistic photographer, set designer, architectural designer and jewelry maker. He was just very creative and expressed it through many types of media. He understood the questions, he just kind of did everything!
Then the anecdote would be lost. It would translate as "Picasso is a communist, me neither" as once uttered by Dalí. Later became the inspiration for the Serge Gainsbourg song "Je t'aime...moi non plus." (I love you...neither do I)
Want your mind really blown? Google Hieronymus Bosch a guy who was on the same level as Dali but better and way more weird but.....he was 500 years BEFORE Dali !!! The Garden of Earthly Delights is the best IMO.
Funny how language evolves so quickly. It's a game show, but they're talking like they're at a fancy dinner party with the Queen. Edit: ....This whole "society has devolved" mess in the comments is just as pretentious as the high class accent in the clip.
It's called the trans-atlantic dialect. Most people in broadcasting or in the upper class learned to speak this way. Average people didn't talk like that.
@@RoderickVI It's a common foreign misconception to think catalonians don't speak spanish fluently, because the huge majority of them do as much as any other spaniard. But it's even worse to think Dali didn't speak fluent spanish because of being catalonian, because he was in fact very oppose to catalonian independentist movement and that's exactly the kind of thing which makes Dali a less valued artist by catalonian ultranationalists, which had to promote plain shitty artists like Miró or Tapiès instead as catalonian marketing tools. Shame on them, because Dali was and always will be the greatest catalonian painter. And boy did he liked to be spanish.
"This is not to say that It is not within the compass of his enjoyment to endulge in this particular endeavor." My my, how eloquent. You don't hear sentences like that anymore today.
IT's up to the USA to get this show back on and I hope they do and it did cover Australia as well when it aired coz my mother used 2 watch it and I wasn't born at the time.
+Eric Taylor LOL! Mine, too! The man was a genius! No matter how surreal a painting could be, as a viewer you could imagine just "stepping into" the scene and everything was really normal & ordinary!
In case anyone was wondering, Dali did an illustrated (English) edition of Don Quixote with Random House in 1946-I believe that's the book referred to in this clip. The original edition currently seems to go for 200-300 dollars. There was reprint in 1979 that's in the mid $100 range.
It's funny because Miguel de Cervantes, author of Don Quixote, was once kidnapped and held hostage for 5 years in late 1500s, untill his family paid ransome, by a mediterranean pirate named Dali Mami, who may have been Salvador Dalis ancestor. He thought so anyway.
Absolute genius. If you like Dali and you are ever in St. Petersburg, Florida, go to the Dali Museum there. It is fantastic ... an unexpected revelation!
If you want to see a true work of art, visit his home in Port lligat near Cadaques, or the Dali Museum in Figueras and also Gala Dali Castle in Pubol where you can find the elephant statues in the gardens.
As of August 2014 she is still living, so one must say she has not yet "peaked." But I meant to say "peeked." I was surprised to see that Arlene Dahl is the mother of Lorenzo Lamas.Tall Gary
miloesalazar This has the ring of a famous aphorism, and yet I do believe you've coined it! (Correct me if I'm wrong.) It does, humorously enough though, remind me of the hypocritical avant-garde artist Paul Newman plays in the 1964 film "What a Way To Go" (satiric screenplay by Comden and Green), who proclaims to his girlfriend (Shirley MacLaine), "Money corrupts; art Erupts!" "Ohh, that's a beautiful saying," she replies admiringly. "It's immortal. I just made it up," says he.
@@makaveli201071 Unnecessarily - I've said it's getting harder, not that it's impossible. I also have a good amount of other interesting activities, beside "watching", so feel free to breathe a sigh of relief ;)
The ironic thing is that while the constant "yes" answers were humorous and certainly in line with Dali's perception of himself, almost all was true. In addition to being a ridiculously talented artist, he was an accomplished sculptor, designed sets for ballets and films, designed a very limited run of cutlery, co-designed fashion with Christian Dior and at the time this was aired, true to his word, had published one fiction and two non-fiction works. The one exception that stands out is that none of his published works at the time were by Random House. He wasn't a leading man in the context of the question, but I'm sure that in Dali's mind, performing the daily role of Salvador Dali qualified. :)
This man truely was one of the most unique, talented and funny human beings of all time. I have a lot of respect for him as I’m an artist as well. Sadly he died one year before I was born. If he was still alive I would really like to meet him and talk about various kind of art.
Dali wrote Fifty Secrets of Magic Craftsmanship about how he conceptualized, his habits as an artist and philosophies. A great read with lots of notes, doodles and inspiration.
Dali's work is so good. It just jumps off the wall when you look at it. People didn't like his politics or his unapologetic commercialism. But his paintings are just wonderful. You don't have to be an art lover or a student of art or anything.....They are full of imagination and color, and craft.....
Dali didn't troll in the least. Few people know the extent and variety of his accomplishments. And yes he was a leading man at least in the field of Surrealism.
@@thefart He was not a leading man in the regular understanding of the term. He was a man who lead his field, but he was not an A-lister male hollywood celebrity that was regularly cast to star and draw in larger crowds for blockbuster feature films.
He was misunderstood. It's hard enough to appreciate him now let alone then. They did recognize him immediately when they realized that he was primarily an artist also known for books and film production.
This is my absolute favorite show. I wish I could have lived during that time where personal strengths were recognized. Handwriting, wit, honesty and truthfulness seemed to matter. My grandfather: Johnny Shade Tramel was the example of what a man should be. When I watch this show, I wish he could have been a guest. He holds the record in DeKalb Co.,TN for the most goats born from one goat at once..5. I love this show and I miss my grandfather SO much. Long live "What's My Line."
It was actually a complicated question because the question was phrased "do you do drawings, like comic strips?" rather than asking if he is a cartoonist. I would have definitely said "yes" too.
I've said it before, watching these 'Mystery Guest' clips: Just imagine the thrill of being on that panel, and shaking hands with some of the most legendary people who ever lived. Amazing.
He wasn't trolling. I mean, he was notoriously a troll, but he wasn't in that particular context. He was just answering honestly. He had a poliedrical talent. He painted, sculplted, wrote, directed movies...he did a number of things, in fact.
@Finn Goldberg Oh yeah, everyone at that time that wasnt allied to the communists were fascists. Even americans and George Orwell(and well known anarchist) were all labed as fascists by the reds.
Everybody is so polite and well-spoken, was this broadcasted on a popular station back than? I wish we'dd get such refined entertainment on the teli today.
At the time this program began there were only 64 American cities with their own television stations; though most had only one, they could be affiliated with any of the then current 4 networks (DuMont, NBC, CBS, or ABC). What hurt the CBS network (which originally aired this show) was their advocating an industry-wide shift and restart of ALL American TV from the VHF band to the UHF band for their incompatible color TV system (it wouldn't work with the then current black and white system). Add to that the FCC putting an indefinite "freeze" on new television licenses that lasted until 1952 also didn't help matters. The number of CBS stations lagged behind the others for many years in the 1950's.
1950: "Have you a moustache that is rather well known, in fact could you be almost caricaturized just by that?" 2020: "Yo, are you that freak guy with f***ing weird whiskers?".
Tito Obaisi;Their r still people still around like that these days and even 60 years ago their were people that only spoke in slang.My mother told me this.
A game show?! Can you imaging a game show today with viewers and players sophisticated enough to warrant having the likes of a Salvator Dali as a guest?
@@aspider3254 Damn, you took the words out of my mouth. There are certainly programs probably like this out there. It's just that the tastes of the people who watch TV now don't prefer some dude in a suit talking like he's giving a speech at the country club for every little instance.
Well this kind of programs looks more healthy. Not only vocabulary. Nobody is fighting or shouting. Nodoby is doing something stupid. Just healthy fun.
He seems so fun ! He’s one of my fav artists ❤️I would love to have met him ... also it’s so strange to see an old film be so relatable and joyful. It’s just weird seeing people from the 1930s talk , I’m used to seeing “old” videos being boring and cold . But this feels so warm and familiar , it’s almost like a game show today !
Andre Breton and the other originators of Surrealism once had a big meeting with Dali, who they were all pissed off with, and said, "Dali, we're kicking you out of Surrealism..." to which Dali replied, "You can't kick me out of Surrealism -- I *AM* Surrealism!" I think Salvador Dali in the end will be the most well remembered of all Twentieth Century artists.
Betaboog Basically, they didn't like his subject matter. Surrealism is a representation of the subconscious. Basically, if we're being honest here, there is some real freaky shit in people's subconscious. Dali was right. They weren't true surrealists because they wanted to censor and shy away from true explorations of the subconscious mind. Ultimately, they were the enemies of this kind of art despite helping to pioneer it and delving quite deep into it. One example is that he had anuses in some of his paintings. They brought this to his attention. So then he hid anuses in plain view in his paintings. He was the master troll. You see that when you read his words and thoughts, I recommend doing so. Some really hilarious shit in there.
colbyricho That's all good but I believe that Dali was much more skilled than he. His level of detail is unparalleled. You really have to see it to believe it. Detail alone won't get you there, I realize but that's just 1 reason why I think he's the best. It nearly goes without saying that he's the most interesting artist I've ever heard of and that translated full-bore to his work. That's another reason. Basically, the public is only willing to go so far with art, that's why pioneers, legends, like Dali, will not be remembered as much. He went 'too far' and many people didn't 'get it'. Fear of the unknown and one's own self-imposed conditioning to the limited size of their box.
J'adore Salvador Dali et c'est un très beau spectacle. Je ne savais pas qu'il y avait une telle chose à l'époque. Merci beaucoup pour cette vidéo. :-) Je n'ai jamais vu Salvador Dali en direct. C'était un gars vraiment sympa ! 🙂
I absolutely love this video. I feel it really demonstrates how we don't have to define ourselves by a single trait, and even though others perception of one might be narrow, it does not always incapsulate a whole person. Although Dali was indeed exceptional, theres no saying anyone couldn't indulge in, and even find success in many different fields
@@andresmartinez2345 so you're telling me that supporting a nationalist dictator, who himself was supported by Adolph Hitler and Benito Mussolini, arguably the two most well known fascists in existence, does not make you a fascist?
i really do admire the eloquence of the people on the show and how precisely they were able to speak. i've tried speaking somewhat like that around my friends, but they always put me down and tell me to "stop using big words" whenever i do.
@@ToniGlick lol thankfully i did. one of my best friends and i actually have a little game between us where we say something and start listing synonyms to that word to test our vocabularies. things are a lot better now lol.
Neil Jo well his wife, Gala, signed him up for such ventures...money in them thar hills. And in the staid fifties, Dali and the Beats made for interesting cocktail conversation, so says my mom.
