After 8 yrs of bjp rule there is no such big step towards sanskrit from govt. . Indeed ravish told it 8 yrs ago u all will come to power and then forget sanskrit like in 1998.
though i m not great admirer of bjp but i found sudhanshu trivedi's argument very logical.. specially about the sanskrit's compatibility for voice command technology.
3 года назад
Pls english and your mother tongue sounds better South ke alava sab hindi samajh hi lete hai South mei bhi log non (South Indian languages ) speakers se hindi, English mei baat karne ke liye taiyyar rehte hai
Mr. Harsh Kumar this debate should be end here , because we cannot use sanskrit in our daily life or in our professional life, but I agreed , with last line of your comments.
@@prabirkumarroy840 ..you are fool and will be fool as always.. Languages always evolve in generations and you will see when Sanskrit will be on Top one day.
@@harshavardhanj2970 Because it is the mother of all Indian languages(exception -tamil), And when you use the root language, you no longer need to rely on a foreign language (english) to be used as a common medium for communication, and Foreigners must know and use it...Moreover, most of our ancient scriptures are still not be able to read by us properly due to our poor knowledge over it. Again, clash between North Indians and South Indians over language issue may be ended as words and pronunciations are very close to Sanskrit. Most importantly, the next generation computer language will be Sanskrit.When Indians will be fluent over the language, it will easy for them to operate..and many more reasons are available to learn Sanskrit
@@parikshitkakoti7289 In India four types of Language family are spoken . Major two are Indo European languages in North India and Dravidian languages in South India
काश यह बात (संस्कृत मेरी मातृभाषा है) आप संस्कृत में लिखते तो समझ जाता कि आप की मातृभाषा संस्कृत है लेकिन भारत में हर राज्य की लगभग अपनी एक मातृभाषा है जैसे गुजराती पंजाबी मराठी मलयालम
We should learn ancient Indians' language. Whose language is sanskrit? who speaks sanskrit? You must have read some fabricated stories with political agenda. Tamil is the ancient Indians' language
If Sanskrit was prompted instead of Hindi, there wouldn't have been a Dravidian movement, because all Southern languages have enormous Sanskrit contribution. May be even more than that of any Northern languages. Congress sucks
@@KrishnaGannavaram Actually we have a pure Indian words for all those English words in Every language but we do not respect our language and use English words because if we speak pure Indian languages than people laugh at us this is our mentality we have taught from childhood. In English medium schools we are not allowed to talk in Indian languages in English period but in the period of Hindi, Bengali, Gujarati etc.. we are allowed to talk in English. When someone mix Hindi or any Indian languages in English people laugh at him/her but when someone mix English in Hindi or any Indian languages people think him smart. Due to this mentality we are slowly losing our own languages and cultures. I am not against English but I am against mixing English words in Indian languages.
@@ravi-gx2qc2qz4r Sanskrit is dead language. We are not interested in learning it. Our state language is enough. Dont impose Hindi/ Urdu / Sanskrit on us.
@@KrishnaGannavaram I can understand that Hindi-Urdu is imposed and it should be opposed by you but I can't understand why do you people oppose Sanskrit which is not a language of a particular state. If your state language is enough than why do you learn English or any foreign languages and If you are proud of your state language then why do you use any English loanwords in your language keep it pure.
Those who say their mother language is Bhojpuri , they must remember that Modern Bhojpuri use 50% words directly from Hindi. Other words are also simplified Hindi words and Some simplified Sanskrit and Urdu words.
@@leemi8931 Bhojpuri is not a language but a dialect of Hindi. There is a difference between a language and a dialect. They want Bhojpuri to become a language but this will create a problem because Bhojpuri itself varies from distinct to district and still it will remain to a dialect.
Sanskrit is fit for nation's official language it's our pride ! Everybody learn Sanskrit talk speaking in Sanskrit to all Indians ! Sanskrit is our future ! We will conquer whole planet by powerful Sanskrit and Tamil !
There is a word " SEPTEM" . It has meaning 7 in both Languages I.e. SANSKRIT AND English respectively. Please clarify from all experts participating in the debate whether this word has been taken in ENGLISH from SANSKRITor Sanskrit has taken it from English.
This is laughable ignorance of ravish. Sanskrit comprises of 80 percent of my language malayalam....likewise the percentage of sanskrit loanwords in other indian languages are huge except tamil, assamese bodo,Tripuri and urdu where the percentage is small. No other language qualifies that criteria for a link language. So its not an alien language to indians when they are infact using over 60% of vocabulary from sanskrit words. And its certainly not difficult as people think to learn. As a malayalee i found it incredibly easy. But if people don't have intent, then it won't happen. Because ' its important to have intent ' ok..
Bhai bjp ne bola tha Sanskrit lanyenge to ravish baar baar yhi bol rha h ki kaise layenge Sanskrit aur yhi main sawal tha kaise aayega Sanskrit Puri india me wapas to main sawal puchne ko tum tokna bol rhe ho😂😂😂😂
Ravish Sir is biased no surprise. He always says that he conducts fair debates but he himself speaks most of the time than any panelist. It seems that he asks question and wants to hear only what he or his channel thinks is right. In any debate, he speaks more than half of the time himself and tries to make viewer's opinion. Ravish Sir, you r so good at your reporting and anchoring skills but I think more importantly you should be unbiased at least during these debates.
Regular debates me log baat ko gol gol ghumate h isliye ravish puch rahe h yaha par sudhanshu bhi plan nhi bata rha h kaise layenge implementation laise hoga sirf ghuma ghuma rha ab Aisa ghumayega to tokna hi padega ki apka plan nhi h
Ab ravish fact bol rha h ki bjp iska implementation ko lekar koi plan nhi layi h godi debate hote to vo log counter bhi nhi kar pate h aur fact bhi nhi bolte h unhe dar lagta h
@Xavier Then why do they write and speak english if their language is the best !! In my opinion, Sanskrit is the best one as it is mother of all languages !!
Since all Indian language is from sanskrit, It is really quite easy to understand with little academic efforts. example about 60% Telugu, 30% gujrati, 25% Hindi, 20% Urdu are from Sanskrit.
@@subratamodak895 He is telling to unite India's diversity not India . Better you read what he wrote. Suppose if you are from north part of India if you go south, people may not understand Hindi or may be you not understand their language (if you don't know) But English connects us. Similarly why not Sanskrit . It's our own language so it will be better for us.(its world language) Sanskrit can also help us connect with people from different parts of India. Because most of the people in India(except north india) understand Sanskrit better if compared to hindi. (Sorry if there are grammatical mistakes. I don't know much of english ).
" संस्कृत की दुर्दशा के लिए जिम्मेदार कौन ? " माननीय प्रधानमन्त्री श्री नरेन्द्र मोदी जी भारत के विकास हेतु विदेश यात्रा पर हैं | जर्मनी के बर्लिन शहर में उन्होनें अपने भाषण के दौरान कहा कि यहाँ जर्मनी में रेडियो पर संस्कृत में समाचार आते हैं और हमारे भारत में हम संस्कृत की बात करते हैं तो हमें सेक्युलर कहा जाता है | अब मोदी जी को कौन समझाए की केवल लम्बे चौडे भाषण देने मात्र से भारत का और भारतीय संस्कृति का विकास नहीं होने वाला है | जिस संस्कृत भाषा के लिए प्रधानमन्त्री जी अपनी चिन्ता व्यक्त कर रहे हैं उस भाषा के लिए आखिर इन ग्यारह महीनों में उनकी सरकार ने किया ही क्या है ? संस्कृत के प्रचार के सन्दर्भ में बात करें तो संस्कृत भाषा के लिए भारत सरकार की नोडल एजेन्सी के रूप में स्थापित "राष्ट्रिय संस्कृत संस्थान " (sanskrit.nic.in) का कोई नाम भी नहीं जानता है | जबकी यह विश्व का सबसे बडा संस्कृत विश्वविद्यालय है | इतना ही नहीं मानित विश्वविद्यालय का दर्जा प्राप्त यह संस्थान सीधे तौर पर मानव संसाधन विकास मन्त्रालय, भारत सरकार से जुडा हुआ है | और इस संस्थान के विकास की बात करें तो पता चलता है कि दो वर्षों से यहाँ स्थायी कुलपति ही नहीं है | विश्वविद्यालय बस भगवान भरोसे चल रहा है | बहुपरिसरीय इस विश्वविद्यालय के पूरे भारत (नई दिल्ली, मुम्बई, भोपाल, जयपुर, जम्मू, लखनऊ, इलाहाबाद, पुरी, अगरतला, शृंगेरी [कर्नाटक], गुरुवायूर [केरल], गरली [हि.प्र.] में १२ परिसर हैं किन्तु प्रत्येक परिसर स्थायी शिक्षकों की न्यूनता, छात्र सुविधाओं की न्यूनता, प्रशासनिक असुविधाएँ, भवन, छात्रावास, छात्रवृत्ति, पुस्तकालय, प्रयोगशालाओं की कमी के कारण अपनी जर्जर एवं मरणासन्न अवस्था में है | यह आलम उस विश्वविद्यालय का है जिस विश्वविद्यालय की कुलाधिपति स्वयं मानव संसाधन विकास मन्त्री श्रीमती स्मृति ईरानी जी हैं, तो फिर अन्य संस्कृत विश्वविद्यालयों, महाविद्यालयों तथा विद्यालयों का कहना ही क्या है ? आश्चर्य तो इस बात का है कि भारत में संस्कृत की इतनी दुर्गति और दुर्दशा की जिम्मेदार यह सरकार अपने संस्कृत प्रेम का गुणगान करते नहीं थकती | पूरे भारत में फैले इस विश्वविद्यालय के प्रायः ३०० शिक्षकों में लगभग २०० शिक्षक संविदा नियुक्ति पर हैं जिन्हें हर तीन महीने में बाहर कर दिया जाता है | अब बताईये कि क्या इस विश्वविद्यालय में अध्ययन कर रहे ५००० (पाँच हजार) छात्रों का भविष्य गर्त में नहीं समा रहा है ? ऐसा नहीं है कि विश्वविद्यालय की इन समस्याओं से सरकार को अवगत नहीं कराया गया, कई बार कराया गया और कई नेताओं से कराया गया | संस्कत विकास के इच्छुक कई लोगों ने तथा कई सामाजिक संस्थाओं ने पत्राचार, ईमेल, फैक्स, साक्षात् रूप से मिलकर समस्याएँ बतायीं किन्तु कोई परिवर्तन नजर नहीं आया | विभिन्न प्रदेशों के संस्कृतानुरागियों ने प्रधानमन्त्री, शिक्षामन्त्री, तथा सांसदों को कई पत्र भेजे गये किन्तु किसी का भी प्रत्युत्तर तक नहीं आया | संस्थान के द्वारा सन् 2007 तथा 2012 में जो संविदा शिक्षकों की भर्ती की गयी थी वह भर्ती पूर्व कुलपति के के कार्यकाल में हुई थी | एकाएक उस साक्षात्कार में चयनित सारे संविदा शिक्षक अयोग्य हो जाते हैं और पुनः उनके साक्षात्कार का नोटिस आ जाता है | जब पूर्व कुलपति के द्वारा चयनित संविदा शिक्षक अयोग्य हो सकते हैं तो उसी कुलपति के कार्यकाल में नियुक्त कुलसचिव, प्रोफेसर, एसोसिएट प्रोफेसर, असिस्टेन्ट प्रोफेसर, कार्यालय कर्मचारी आदि कैसे योग्य हो गये ? क्या इन सभी का साक्षात्कार नहीं होना चाहिए ? हम तो प्रतीक्षा करते करते थक गये न जाने मोदी जी के अच्छे दिन कब आयेंगें ? और भले सबके अच्छे दिन आ जायें किन्तु संस्कृत के अच्छे दिन कभी नहीं आने वाले | मोदी जी और उनके सांसदों को समझना चाहिए कि केवल संस्कृत में शपथ लेकर वाहवाही लूट लेने मात्र से संस्कृत का उद्धार नहीं होने वाला | मोदी जी ! संस्कृत का विकास और उद्धार करना है तो संस्कृत की उन योजनाओं को पुनः शुरु करवाईये जो संस्कृत का ढोल पीटने वालीं आपकी शिक्षामन्त्री जी ने आते ही बन्द करा दीं |
Absolutely right 👍, in North India @all states are extremely proud about there official languages individually.But they believe that one and only Sanskrit is Our main ancient language. @they never never accept any language except sanskrit
@@KrishnaGannavaram Why not make Sanskrit the link language of North India, Tamil the link language of South India and English the link language of all of India? There, problem solved (if this was even a problem in the first place, which it shouldn't be). 😊
Is this a joke? Because languages are meant to be easy and easily understandable. Google can't translate because they haven't programmed their systems for sanskrit.
If you observe this debate, we can see that Rabij Kumar is continuously interrupting Sudhanshu Ji and D K Jha Ji, but given clear ground to anti sanskrut persons.
"As long as Hindus Stayed away from Samskruta It's Easy to Convert All Hindus into Christianity"- Missionary. Mass Conversion is a 100 years of Efforts. It all started in Tamilnadu from opposing Samkruta and Bhramins, later it spread to Whole country. As Bhramins are last preachers of Veda, Upanishads, Mahabharata, Ramayana, Gods history, Hindu poets and kings were already stayed away from Practicing Vedas and Upanishads and were busy in Wars and these Long stories were written in Small Shlokas, everything was written Samkruta. If they killed Samkruta language Generation by Generation will loose/forgot All Knowledge. Finally They ask Proof of our Gods which we discontinued our knowledge. Than it is very easy to Convert Whole village or city in "one Address" by defaming Hindu Gods.
@@mscreationworks5787 yes i agree no entry for main temples but it was history... Today it is impossible...There are many temples for Every people in India... Area wise temples also built since 2000 years old... You are spreading baseless, false news in today's world because All Hindus don't go to temples... it was old people who go to temple daily, .... No Muslim or Christian are there in past... They are new to country...
Why not make Sanskrit the link language of North India, Tamil the link language of South India and English the link language of all of India? There, problem solved (if this was even a problem in the first place, which it shouldn't be). 😊
@@Rishi123456789 bro that can't happen ...as most of south indian languages are heavily influenced by sanskrit and it's Vocablury... tamil , punjabi, bengali, marathi , Kannada can all be the regional and state languages like today but sanskrit should replace English as link language of whole india...in this way we will not suppress any indian local language ..
Sanskrit should be our national language since time immemorial our ancestors are using Sanskrit as the mother tongue. We should also imbibe the same. I speak Malayalam which contains around 80 % Sanskrit. And also for Tamil people, they also have more than 50 % words from Sanskrit root( It was actually its british idea to make Tamils believe that Dravidians and stuff( Part of divide and rule idea). Actually we are one🧡, And the sad part is that Nehru aint got enough brain and followed the same British Raj) It is easy for us to imbibe this culture of learning Sanskrit than Hindi I would say. And for learning Vedas and puranas this language is needed. Sanskrit is considered as Deva Basha(Language of Gods) Sanskrit originated from the cosmic dance sound from Lord Shiva.Hari 🕉🧡 Panini Mahirshis and many other mahirshi's contributions to the grammar part is soo clinical that artificial Intelligence can be powered with it. Robots will learn this language one day, wait and see. Sanskrit is a poetic Basha and is very melodious. Many Indian and European language has Sanskrit root in it. We need to pull our Bhasha Mother from the dirt. Jai Hind🧡 One nation one central language🧡 Namaskaram🙏🙏🙏
JAI JAGANNATH I'M FROM ODISHA, MY MOTHER TONGUE IS ODIA BUT SANSKRIT MUST BE THE NATIONAL LANGUAGE. RAVISH SIR TALK ABOUT FACT SUDHANSHU SIR TALK ABOUT LOGIC BOTH ARE INTELLIGENT PARSONS.
मैने कक्षा 6 से 10 तक संस्कृत पढ़ी है , मुझे भारतीय वैदिक शास्त्र, ग्रंथ, रामायण, गीता आदि पढ़ने में दिक्कत नही होती इसलिए सभी भारतीय संस्कृत जरूर सीखे पढ़े
Log Sanskrit ko puraana, Muskil , Brahmano ki bhasha kehkar taal dete hain. Unhen is baat ka gyan nahin ki Sanskrit yadi seekh liya jaaye to India ki Kai bhaashon ko aasaani se seekha ja sakta hai aur videshi bhashaon ko seekhna bhi aasaan ho jaayega.
Up to 1911 Capital city was Kolkata In fact Bengalees were found Samskruta Colleges and universities, instead of Bengalee colleges which means Samskruta was Common language of India After 1911 Capital City was moved to Delhi Everything changed to Hindi and Imposing Hindi over every state. If Hindi become National Language 1.Imposition of Hindi will be on 60% of Non Hindi speaking. Remainig 40% are Hindi speaking. 2. Connects to west of india(Afghanistan, Pakistan) If Samskruta become National language. 1.Imposition will be on 100% of Indians.(This will Satisfy the entire nation) 2. We can Connect to south east nations(mostly from Iran to Indonesia) Why Hindi should not become National language 1.Hindi is Apabramsha Language. 2. Hindi is Distorting Samskruta language. 3. Samskruta was helped to consolidation of Indian languages. But Hindi is Deconslidating by its Apabramsha nature. 4. South Indian languages are as strong as Samskruta so they don't want Hindi as NL which is effecting to their languages. 5. Rajasthani, Bhojapuri, Gujarati, Marathi were already effected by Hindi. 6. Hind is weak language such that they don't know the difference between (Rha and Dha ex Chandigadh there is no Rha word in any of Indian language we have only Ra), La and Lha(Zha). They use Gya instead of Jna. They distorted Samskruta words while borrowing ex Simha became Sinha, Samskruta became Sanskrit, they don't know where to use n and m. Everybody should support Samskruta so we can tackle Hindi speaking people in Parliament and PM post will be free from Hindi mandatory.(this line is for Tamilhians to divert them from angry comments 😂). People already Started accepting Sanskrit as National language just to avoid Hatred from South India.
Mr anchor firstly you should learn how to respect your own culture. Why are you so anti against sanskrit language . which is mother of all language. Really sanskrit is the most beautiful language of the world as well as real national language of our country.
Not only in South India, but in North East also people know 3, 4 or even more Languages. 3 language formula as well as linguistic diversity of the region helped in this regard.
@@sknicholas are u a tamil fanatic? Or maybe karunanidhi's disciple. Tamil isn't the oldest language, sanskrit is. If not can you explain why shlokas and mantras are recited in sanskrit even in tamil nadu by tamilians and not in tamil?
@@iagreewithyou4328 if sanskrit is oldest language why Thiruvalluvar wrote thirukural in Tamil and tolkapiyam was written in Tamil and why 60000 stone inscription found across India are in Tamil and why tamizhi letters found in indus valley civilization and why your leader Modi confessed in front of cameras that Tamil is the oldest language in India, ?
अगर नॉर्थ इंडियन साऊथ इंडियन भाषा सीखना चाहता है तो उसे बहुत समय लगता है लेकिन अगर व्यक्ति को संस्कृत भाषा आती है तो वह बहुत जल्दी कम समय में साऊथ इंडियन भाषा सीख सकता है इसलिए यह भारत की मूल भाषा है चाहे कोई माने या ना माने
@@KrishnaGannavaram Sanskrit is not dead it's Vedic Sanskrit the dead language and the so-called language of Brahmins. Classical Sanskrit is still alive and it is easier to learn Sanskrit than English for an Indian person.
Raveesh ji ! apko ye kisne kaha k students padhna nhi chahte , apne shayd rata hoga Sanskrit , aaj k bachho ko Sanskrit samjh aata hai & they want to learn , now in these days olders , youngers , children learning Sanskrit, they are not in big noumber but also not in very small noumber.
केवल पढ़ने के हिसाब से पढ़ना चाहते हैंक्योंकि सुनी सुनी बातें मिलती है नंबर अच्छे आ जाते हैं यह तो थोड़ा भी मन में विचार आ जाता है कि हां संस्कृत अच्छी है मैं पढ़ना चाहिए करना लेकिन जिस ढंग से उसको पढ़ना चाहिए समझना चाहिए वह समझ नहीं पातेइसमें कुछ अध्यापकों की कमी होती है और शैलेश डंके कि उसे जुड़ते सीखते सीखते समझ नहीं पाते और केवल पढ़ लेते हैं उनमें कक्षाओं को पास कर लेते हैं और आगे जो है संस्कृत में कुछ कर नहीं पाते और ना ही संस्कृत के लिए कुछ कर जो कक्षा है उसको पास करके बैठ जाते हैं।
Bravo !, Dr Apoorbanand . The Assamese Mahapurusha named Sankardeva wrote medieval Assamese Bhakti literature in the vernacular because he sought to inculcate his teachings among the regional Shtree - Shudra populace !
If we speak pure Indian languages than people laugh at us this is our mentality we have taught from childhood. In English medium schools we are not allowed to talk in Indian languages in English period but in the period of Hindi, Bengali, Gujarati, Marathi, etc.. we are allowed to talk in English. When someone mix Hindi or any Indian languages in English people laugh at him/her but when someone mix English in Hindi or any Indian languages people think him smart. Due to this mentality we are slowly losing our own languages and cultures. I am not against English but I am against mixing English words in Indian languages.
A large portion of sanskrit is also taken from Tamil (Dravidian). Telugu is connected to Tamil. Malayalam is mixture of Sanskrit and Tamil. Marathi is extensively Sanskrit. Bengali, Bhojpuri, Haryanvi, Hindi, Himachali are all sister language to Sanskrit. Assamese derived from Bengali. Urdu made out of Arabi and Sanskrit. Punjabi made out of Prakrit and Sanskrit. It all connects to Sanskrit. It will help us connect better think beyond the language barriers that are today. Let's accept the facts first and then work on how we want it to come out.
Start bit --->Data containing messages--->Parity Bits----> stop bit. This is a digital data communication format. Any engineer who has studied DSP will know this. See the similarity with Hindu mantras. “Om Namah Shivay Om”. Om indicates the start bit, Namah Shivay-the data containing messages and finally, Om again indicates the Stop Bit showing the end of messages. The parity bit is optional. All European discoveries are a copy of Indian works. ISRO chief is correct. Indian mantras in Sanskrit can even communicate with God if properly chanted.
According to the situation of language in India - Hinglish is going to replace Hindi all over India and it may become a language of Global importance like French, Portuguese, German etc... because of the growth of Indian Economy many foreign countries are investing in India and Hinglish will be the language of communication in India.
I don't know why north Indians wasted 70 years... By spreading Hindi which is 200 years old.... 3000 years of Research and development worked in Sanskrit ....Wasted.... We should think of Pan India.... So Sanskrit is only solution....
People like Ravish Kumar blame likes of Arnab to be intolerant towards opposition during their debates. But his approach and line of questioning is no different from them. He hasn't given 10 proper seconds to Sudhanshu Trivedi to reply on a serious issue. His expressions are no less than mockery of our ancient language. He should be ashamed of it.
