Тёмный

Scientist Quit Research because Academia is Toxic 

DrawBioMed
Подписаться 17 тыс.
Просмотров 3,7 тыс.
50% 1

The dark sided of academia is exposed by Sabine Hossenfelder in her video: My dream died, and now I'm here. I think this is a much watch video for everyone who is interested in having a career in scientific research.
➡️My dream died, and now I'm here • My dream died, and now...
SOCIAL MEDIA
📷INSTAGRAM » / drawbiomed
💬TWITTER » / drawbiomed
👾TWITCH twitch.tv/drawbiomed
👾LIVE STREAM RECORDINGS Watch the archive in RU-vid Membership or Patreon / drawbiomed
GET IN TOUCH
✉️ Business Inquiries » jon@drawbiomed.com
TERMS OF USE
shorturl.at/cdK05

Опубликовано:

 

8 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 47   
@DrawBioMed
@DrawBioMed 4 месяца назад
What is your experience with academia?
@josephvanname3377
@josephvanname3377 4 месяца назад
Academic institutions are really unprofessional.
@luizbotelho1908
@luizbotelho1908 4 месяца назад
If the question is for me : I have had a lot of chances .I have take full professional profits on some , others not so good . But I have followed successfully my scientific projects ALONE and have published my papers in good journals without collaborators and out of the main streams of Physics in mostly of my papers . I was full professor at the age of 29 in Brazil and now I am retired at 64 .My list of publications .scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=list_works&hl=pt-BR&user=8_GsKRsAAAAJ&fbclid=IwAR2qnyU9-ZJkbIosZjdml9TdEeB-CwP93LE0PzLvCIjkzifP7Zz-yRQ8ijQ_aem_AVuCBWreFbIv6X2SEtw-zGhZznm0e6ppr0oF3bmi2ln8bKj1GjBafezRuAtAZ1_HTsHQ8bC8pbUE2OBPj9n5xJu_
@luizbotelho1908
@luizbotelho1908 4 месяца назад
@@josephvanname3377 Are you mad ? .
@josephvanname3377
@josephvanname3377 4 месяца назад
@@luizbotelho1908 I was a professor.
@luizbotelho1908
@luizbotelho1908 4 месяца назад
@@josephvanname3377 I have been a FULL professor either ! . Of course that Academic Institutions have a lot of problems as any other Institutions . But believe me : Perhaps Bad with them . Certainly much worse without them!.
@Thomas-gk42
@Thomas-gk42 20 дней назад
I´m a layperson and follow Sabine´s channel for about two years now. Her books both belong to the best I´ve ever read about physics and science. Thank you for youruseful addition to her "coming out"- video.
@RamGlez
@RamGlez 4 месяца назад
Great discussion Jon, I agree with everything you and Sabine said. I think is important for new students to recognize this side of academia before committing to a masters or a PhD. My views have also changed throughout my PhD, and now I think of academia more as a business where scientific production and getting grants is the main objective. I try to work towards that while also remaining ethical and trying to establish good collaborations.
@RamGlez
@RamGlez 4 месяца назад
Also, well summarized by you: have your expectations in the right place, so you don’t get traumatized when you enter the system. Hard truths, to be honest, but truths nonetheless.
@DrawBioMed
@DrawBioMed 4 месяца назад
Exactly. I think very science people should watch the video of Sabine so they are well informed before joining academia.
@HumanPP
@HumanPP 4 месяца назад
In principle I agree with Sabine, only what would be the alternative? There are many things wrong with academia, but we must always remember that in the end it is the only entity capable of doing research independently (this is not always true of research done by private companies). So young researchers must change the system from within, not destroy it, because the alternative is much worse than academia.
@kerzman
@kerzman 4 месяца назад
Maybe if Einstein followed a direct academic path, we wouldn't now know his name? I mean, a senior professor may have taken credit?
@DrawBioMed
@DrawBioMed 4 месяца назад
Hahahah most likely true. He was working at the Swiss Patent Office at the time so no colleague could steal his work.
@serialarchitect
@serialarchitect 9 дней назад
No, Jon, getting paid to do what you love is how knowledge and humanity progresses and this should be your job in academia. You cannot and you should not compare it to monetising a hobby. Sabina describes a paper-mill toxic research environment where nothing new or innovative is ever produced, as in many cases current projects that get funded are based on flawed fundamental basic principles.
@malariologist
@malariologist 4 месяца назад
I completely agree with her. I had the same experiences.
@DrawBioMed
@DrawBioMed 4 месяца назад
Hugs
@AlgeistNydream
@AlgeistNydream 4 месяца назад
Schau hier um zu sehen wo er die Idee mit dem Anfangszitat her hat. Der Witz ist, dass Sabine sich über den Institutsleiter beklagt, der die Ideen für Textbücher von den Doktoranden erpresst/stiehlt. Er gibt sich hier mitfühlend, dabei macht er genau dasselbe. Oder warum ist der zeitliche Ablauf genau so wie im Sabine Video außer bei der Anfangssequenz?
@aquahood
@aquahood 4 месяца назад
It's all about connections there are millions of smart people it's about being in the right place at the right time with the right skill set and then getting struck by lightning 😁
@user-oj4xh8cg2l
@user-oj4xh8cg2l 4 месяца назад
Dude, before commenting on her accent you should consider yours...
@realnuggetz
@realnuggetz 4 месяца назад
I agree, her accent is not “very heavy”, and this guy here doesn’t speak like a BBC reporter himself either, so he should better stfu.
@DrawBioMed
@DrawBioMed 4 месяца назад
Haiyaaaa Uncle Jon so upset, I put my leg down from chair en eat egg frei rei 🤤🍚
@MoreOnPleeez
@MoreOnPleeez 4 месяца назад
Im pretty sure he was being sarcastic 😂
@yokaisamaful
@yokaisamaful 4 месяца назад
But where do you get grants from?
@DrawBioMed
@DrawBioMed 4 месяца назад
The government, funding bodies of rich people (e.g. chanzuckerberg.com/), corporations with same research interests
@yokaisamaful
@yokaisamaful 4 месяца назад
@@DrawBioMed I wonder if the results of the research is not in the best of interest of the funding corporation, would it be published🤔
@DrawBioMed
@DrawBioMed 4 месяца назад
@@yokaisamaful You can try and see what happens
@aquahood
@aquahood 4 месяца назад
Jim Al-Kalili I'm very famous and very good science educator who's a professor of physics at the University of Surrey. He said his most cited article was 200 and I started science late in my life and one of my articles has only a hundred and I thought that that was bad but I guess it's not so bad....
@Uri1000x1
@Uri1000x1 4 месяца назад
Why is Sabina's audio lower quality than her original?
@DrawBioMed
@DrawBioMed 4 месяца назад
So you can appreciate her amazing original video
@lyubaabbud8778
@lyubaabbud8778 4 месяца назад
"Heavy German accent"? She has an accent but nothing heavy about it.
@DrawBioMed
@DrawBioMed 4 месяца назад
German accent is hot an ex of mine is German
@leon_noel1687
@leon_noel1687 3 месяца назад
​@@DrawBioMedYou don't know how bad some people speak english here in germany. 😂
@aquahood
@aquahood 4 месяца назад
It's almost illegal actually because they have to advertise the position to the public even if they've already filled it and this is essentially fraud I'm a lawyer.q
@serialarchitect
@serialarchitect 9 дней назад
It also creates an "inbred" little group where every generation is worse scientifically than the previous one while they are all subservient and submissive to the bosses that hired them because they know that they didn't get the position based on their merits.
@tnijoo5109
@tnijoo5109 4 месяца назад
Great video. 👍
@DrawBioMed
@DrawBioMed 4 месяца назад
Thank you! Wish you a happy science career after knowing the secrets 🧫
@aquahood
@aquahood 4 месяца назад
She is right the grant / publish and perish paradigm must change for us to propel faster.
@AlexanderMauricio
@AlexanderMauricio 4 месяца назад
Haha almost become scientific illustrator 😂 I felt that
@DrawBioMed
@DrawBioMed 4 месяца назад
We have so much in common 🥰🥰🥰
@AlgeistNydream
@AlgeistNydream 4 месяца назад
BE FAIR! Don't erase this comment. We can coexist. You apparently came up with same idea of putting the BS sequence in the beginning and leaving the rest in chronological order two days after me on your own. Fine with me. We cater to different audiences anyway. Me: Physicist at Sabine's level pointing out contradictions in an intellectual funny way one week after first watching her video. You: compassionate reaction video with nice personal insights, I admit that.
@aquahood
@aquahood 4 месяца назад
B.A., M.P.H., J.D. published in peer reviewed journals and the United Nations.
@unknownaccount8411
@unknownaccount8411 4 месяца назад
No she quit because she cant discover anything important while focusing on silly videos
@Thomas-gk42
@Thomas-gk42 20 дней назад
She profoundly influenced the developement of different fields of physics. Everywhere she has worked, she helped to create new ideas and left a theoretical framework that others minded for years. Sir Roger Penrose, Frank Wilcek and Steven Weinberg gave her interviews that are published in her books. In a recent interview, Lee Smolin named her as his most important idea giver. Though not anymore payed in academia, she published two scientific papers this year. Are you that megalomaniac by birth or did you take lessons?
@serialarchitect
@serialarchitect 9 дней назад
She also uses her real name while you hide behind a throwaway account, you coward
@Thomas-gk42
@Thomas-gk42 9 дней назад
@@serialarchitect Hihi👌
Далее
My dream died, and now I'm here
13:41
Просмотров 2,9 млн
Huberman POSTS on Twitter X - SAVAGE Reactions
4:06
Просмотров 3,6 тыс.
▼ЮТУБ ВСЁ, Я НА ЗАВОД 🚧⛔
30:49
Просмотров 380 тыс.
I wasn't worried about climate change. Now I am.
21:37
I would never go back to academia. Here's why.
11:54
Просмотров 82 тыс.
the postdoc exodus
37:04
Просмотров 508 тыс.
Academia is TOXIC! Here's why...
15:58
Просмотров 236 тыс.
Is Academia a Ponzi Scheme?
5:52
Просмотров 475 тыс.