SCUF REFLEX FPS OR DUALSENSE EDGE CONTROLLER? (WHICH ONE IS BETTER?) [PC, PS5] 

‼️FYI ‼️Battery life are the same for scuf and edge. ⬇️⬇️⬇️

I was top 100k is call of duty , 4 times master , and diamond in overwatch. I don’t have a problem with the dual sense edge or scuff. I’ve come across more problems with scuff compared to the edge. I feel the video was set in scuff favoritism from the jump but still overall good video.

You must've gotten a bad controller cuz this leather feel you are talking about is not true on mine. The back paddles feel fine. You are bashing this controller and it's not bad at all. Your friend pulling the PlayStation off could happen but it's not made for what you said it's for a gamer's edge by having it plugged in. I have 2 Aim controllers and I love those but I paid about $300 each and they have stick drift after about 8 months or so of playing warzone alot. Aim has a lifetime warranty which is great but they charge you to fix stick drift at like $30 plus you pay shipping to them. Now back to the edge controller it functions almost the same as the Aim controller. The only difference to me is the digital triggers on the aim that I paid for. However I see why Sony didn't go with that because the edge controller is for all games and not just shooters. I think $200 isn't bad for all you get but to each their own .The replaceable module is a game changer. As far as the software goes and trying different curves with the sticks I tried a few and default felt best to me. The weight isn't that big of a deal in your hand unless you have an old woman's hands or something. I'm sorry bruh but you have to be a scuff fan boy to be honest because everyone that I've seen in almost all videos I've ever watched talk about how shitty scuff controllers are. I'm not saying to run out and get an edge controller but it's a Sony controller and has a lot of advantages over some of the competition and the price being right up there as with being able to change out your stick on the fly.

Yesterday tested edge about an hour, and i have to say that in my opinion Sony nailed this one. Totally different level compared to scuff or even astroc40. If 2 back buttons are enough for you, i recommend to buy the edge. The half dome back buttons are nicely placed if playing claw. +12month warranty. Scuf really feels like a toy compared to this

I disagree with what you said with durability of the thumb stick on dual sense edge because once you set them to your preference you wont be changing them constantly

I’m SOOOO happy I found this video I was literally just about to buy the dual sense edge for my PC 🤣

Heavy is good. Heavy is reliable. If it does not work, you can always hit them with it.

Right, like if somebody tripped over my cable I would rather it get unplugged cleanly , than the controller get ripped from my hands lol

i dont know when steam implement the support for the edge. but at this moment the back paddles can totally be remapped on steam. the back paddles can only be remapped when the default profile is active. Then it works.

Dualsense edge is so good it comes over locked without u needing to overclock it and has a response time of 0.5ms to 1ms while scuff has 3ms

I've got 2 scufs both have had a hardware issue when I get really intense in cod my movement stalls out and I can't sprint without pressing the left paddle which is pretty dam awful in important situations im ready for the edge I mean come on now its made from Sony 🤷‍♂️

How is it not compatible tf

That’s cable lock piece is actually for pc user, it’s so that do USB doesn’t fall out of the controller when gaming, because when using a controller on PC and the USB falls off the controller turns off which interrupts the game especially when playing CoD

How do you only have 600 subs

after about a month of using the dualsense i had to return it for a refund because the spots to put the paddles like you mentioned. did indeed wear out, the paddles wouldnt rest where intended so the paddles sunk lower and wouldnt click at all. other than that it was a great controller. but im just not gonna contstantly go through getting anew one every month

Y'all do know the software on the edge helps with the trigger u have to adjust it

I have had 3 scuf controllers and they all drifted right after the warranty ended. Every single one

I really want the scuffs, but they don't sell here. Had been dreaming some day scuff will be sold here.

Coming from Xbox both of these options are meh for me. DualSense Edge with only 2 back paddles means I still need to take off my right thumb to click on 2 buttons, and Scuf have HORRIBLE warranty (6 months compare to 3 years including accident insurance I got for the Elite Series 2, and some Redditors said the repairs with Scuf are very expensive). So for now I keep buying FPS games on Xbox just because of the Elite Controller, and my PlayStation is just for exclusives and games in PS Plus Catalog.

You have a code for the hex controllers ? Just grabbed a Edge today going to try it out

Good video man… I was considering the Edge, but based on the reviews I’ve seen so far I’m just gonna pass on it..maybe if they come with a black 1 I’ll buy it or I’ll just wait till the 2nd gen

Yo bro what do u think i should get the scuf fps or pdp victrix ps5 controller i mostly play fortnite but i also play apex and fifa witch do you think i should get this gonna my first paddle controller

Folks up in the air… Why not just buy it from BestBuy and if you are not satisfied just return it. Scuf is not worth it IMO. I have both, and I can tell you that my controller has malfunctioned during game play and has been so frustrating. The problem with Scuf is their warranty sucks and if you buy one and are not satisfied there return policy sucks.. hence red flag and stay away from. Odd thing is before the Edge came out I bought one of those $20 mod kits and added the paddles to my PS5 controller and my game play was better with that verse the scuff. Also like others mentioned in the chat your too focused on PC. And weight shouldn’t be a factor. If a controller gets too heavy then it’s time to go outside and stay away from the TV.

How is the scuf in terms of ergonomics? I find the dualsense uncomfortable, too big Thanks

What kontrol freeks fit on the scuf? And the Dualsense edge?

Very nice review but if you cant hold for hours a controler GO TO THE GYM! and then it gone look to you like a feather LOL.

Just got an edge

Hey guys so probably this process didn’t work as you expected then probably I can help the moment I start playing warzone 2 every time I press to run a keyboard will pop up don’t worry there’s a setting in steam that you need to change to make the controller work how it supposed to and it will fix it

didn't put the same video out a month ago? unsubbed

Whelp....4 paddles on the scuff sold me. Don't need to hear anything else.

Bro whose buying a dualsense for a PC , Xbox makes way better controllers

Does scuff comes with a one year warranty? Or is Sony just flexing

Bro scuff is not that good idk but he just gave scuff the win each time but it is his ompinoin so that’s ok and I had to buy two controllers because if stick drift

And you can change the speeds of the triggers btw his test is very bad on the controller

Lol hex and scuf controllers don’t compete get this controller and I used to be a 4 paddle addict and it’s not necessary at all

Which one is good for fortnite

1 year warrenty

nice vid

Scuff is trash

Man says scuff is the best,has 3 that are broken down.

Scuf warranty 6mo vs Sony 12mo, Scuf cost $199 starting to $249 (not including shipping) vs Sony $199 (free shipping), Scuf permanent sticks vs Sony replaceable. These alone have me preferring Sony. Ultimately everyone is entitled to their opinions, but Sony isn’t pulling any punches in wanting to be competitive here. Not to mention that Sony keeps adaptive triggers AND adjustable throw, something you have to pick between with Scuf

Scuf will last you a few months, Sony DS edge will last you a few years. Debate over

I couldn't make it minutes in this video. Every other word was "man" extremely annoying

This guy must wiegh 90lbs. He's complaining about the weight of the dual sense controller? Like seriously, u must be a tiny fella. I barely noticed any weight at all. Maybe ur just physically weak dude if u think the dual sense edge is heavy.

For those who don't know, the makers of DS4 have released DS5, which was made for the edge and allows the extra buttons, even the FN, to work for your desired action. Be sure to send them some love for doing what Sony consistently fails to do.

My SCUF reflex broke 2 days ago, no warranty any more. I won't buy any other SCUF in my entire life.

The responsiveness of this controller is insane,Sony def put some good juice in these controller's 👍

I do like that you include information about using the Edge controller for PC but if you really think about it that’s not Sony’s target audience. PS5 users are their priority, so I wouldn’t consider the lack of easy PC support a real downside.

You said that the replacement sticks you get arent control freak friendly, well easy fix. Just don't use the replacement sticks

Those joy stick as ons aren’t even apart of the scuf and you didn’t even use the extended dome caps for the dualsense edge. Also the scuf doesn’t have vibration and haptics with adaptive triggers like the edge so it’s not good in every game type. That’s a huge disadvantage with the scuf

Bro, you look like a big dude. You really gonna complain about hold a controller that’s 100 grams heavier? Also I like the feel of a heavier controller, doesn’t make it feel as cheap as Scuf

Dualsense Edge is a great controller, only real issue is the battery life…

This was a really biased comparison. I feel like you just love scuf which is dope but you definitely have a favorite because you prob customized the controller yourself and paid a bunch more for it !

I own both of the products, imo in short multiple gameplay the PS5 edge, for call of duty games etc Scuf, durability so far the PS5, both have modular sticks, the PS5 edge right stick separated from its base, Scuf Reflex has not, however, the scuf inner ring encompassing the both sticks are a big issue for me, the left inner ring has separate several times during game place and once I cracked the faceplate as well, if scuf made a faceplate without those detachable rings it would be great but they don't. So far it's pick your poison.

Do some research, the cable lock is for completion use ie fighting tournaments they actually have to run cables and get penalties for disconnects

Man is on PC complaining about a PS5 custom controller 🙄

This guy a 65 inch TV player foshoo 😂how are you going to let your friend step on your cord bro , bot activities

The fact that you can change the joystick that’s a win!! End of story

I don't understand people that talk about how their scufs break. I've had 3 controllers over 10 years and none of them ever gave me any real issues (that weren't caused by me). They've all worked perfectly for 3+ years and only got affected by your normal wear and tear.

I'll prob end up getting the edge, mostly because I'm not a person who plays wz/cod a lot so for me, replaceable sticks + case + haptic triggers is a better pick over the clicky 4 paddles on scuf. Ur 100% right when u say scuf is number 1 for fps and I think that's the question you have to ask when picking which to buy. Do u want 4 clicky nice paddles or replaceable stick modules. also lowest setting on the trigger for edge have way more travel than the scuf triggers 😂

my ps5 scuf mouse click trigger broke over 3 times. It hasn't even been a year since release. So i think the duel sense edge triggers area better design.

Already is more cheap Scuff controller after Edge release, for me Edge it's the win: full software support for Playstation 5, removable sticks module, adjust trigger, it's a huge win.

Let’s agree to disagree with the lock it’s grate for me especially if I am going to use it on my pc it will make the usb c last longer and not break easily. You can fix better trigger if you fix the darkzone on the ps5 settings having them set 1-75 or lower as you like .

He is biased toward scuff. Everything he says, he counters with scuff is better.

Scufs are built like crap. Stay away from these over priced controllers.

so funny i have that same fake plant in my room i just bought haha

Ive played with both and the edge is just better to me.. scuf will fail within a year. Also the edge is just better made and smarter. Scuf is good with customization but as far as quality,what it can do,and how much it helped the edge wins by far

Well, for me, I don't like that replaceable button. I mean, they can just change the analog stick of their controller to a hall effect one or, at the very least, add the drift fix PCB to their controller. I found one online, and it costs around $2. As Sony is a big company, they can order millions of them and make it significantly cheaper. This means they can easily incorporate it into their controller without needing to change the price! ( One more thing, I'm not a native English speaker, and I use ChatGPT to check my grammar while writing this. So, can you guys like tell me if it is correct or not? )

“If you got stick drift, just replace it.” That should NOT be a selling point of a 200 dollar controller. Stick drift shouldn’t be a thing EVER

Scuf is way better

What about the constant stick drift issues on scuf which happens every 6 months especially if u play COD regularly? How does this not get a mention? I’ve had to buy 3 scufs in 2 years due to stick drift ..

Him: its not a software thing fam the controller is so smart it has its own software

I bought a scuf FPS in the beginning of last year 2022 when they were going through that whole out of stock. crap high demand. I love that controller. It’s lightweight. The triggers are amazing and the grip my God the grip but the R2 button is down. I’m trying to hear back from scuf right now I’m using a the new dual edge controller. I wish it had 4 back petals and more grip right now I’m just confused on what to do

Overall, I think it comes down to your experiences with either brand. I haven’t had issues with either controller and I game consistently. I’ve had SCUF since PS4. The biggest piece for me were the different analog pieces. Concave and domed/short and long. Everyone has their input to your video in regards to what you should’ve said but at the end of the day we have to find what works for us or what we’re looking for in that item. I personally will wait about 3-6 months to see more reviews and see what issues are arising. Hard to tell what’s better without that data. I’ll follow up by the summer to see what updates you have.

Someone please just give me a short answer for which is better for my 9 year old to play Fortnite with. I’m tired of him yelling about how much his controller that came with his PS5 sucks. 😂 Thanks ❤

If you are playing competitive use scuf. The ps5 DualSense edge is heavier and just not as snappy in terms of getting that extra edge in first shot in shooters like Cod.

Getting my ps edge controller this week and can't wait to use it.

I’ll stick to my SCUF reflex fps

Spending $250-$300+ on a controller that’s damn near guaranteed to break is CRAZY. If the dual sense edge controller turns out to be durable in the future then it’s no question what the better controller is.

Scuff reflex is my favorite controller of all time and I have used a million controllers. They have quality control issues but I cannot even use another control now after gaming on my reflex.

How are you already scratching the controller? Must be a sweat 😂😂

can change the trigger deadzone on the dualsense edge for cod on the ps5... can basically make them hairline

Go figure, you need a ps5 to use a ps5 controller. Good job Sony. To hell with all these PC tryhards.

Have u tried aim controller

I’ve got the scuf reflex fps and just ordered the dualsense edge controller strictly for Hogwarts Legacy when I’m playing that on PS5. I think you hit the nail on the head with the comparisons. Almost makes me feel like I don’t need to put out my own versus video, but I love the insight you’ve provided here. One of the first good comparisons so far on RU-vid!

Scuff is better because it has instant triggers that are called mouse click triggers

How come no one give Aim controller more credit I see a lot of RU-vidrs comparing the edge with scuf but in my opinion I like Aim controllers better with the 4 paddles that are not so closed to each other

there is a lot of men in this review

No its not the weight, scuff owns a patent for the 4 buttons so people have to pay them a fee to implement 4 buttons onto their controllers

Grip is very disappointing

Idk which one I should get

I have the Scuf Reflex and I want to pick up the Edge but I need to know which controller has the best triggers? I mostly play FPS games.

Which controller is better for fortnite. Scuf for edge?

4:48 I completely disagree. That’s your own fault.

Great video very informational but I have one question Is the scuff triggers mouse clicks

Sounds biased

What is the battery life for the scuff... You didn't compare those two

The problem is that I want swappable thumbsticks AND 4 backbuttons!

And I was your 600 subscriber your welcome 😊

Gullikit is making replacement sticks with hall effect sensors