Well, games are far too long anyway, we need another huge alpha, burst & DPM monster that makes thickest armour obsletet & itself remains invulnerable anyway... At least it has 220 mm "weakspot" that is larger than 3 pixels. But again, if you mange to hide it, then you can block an entire flank. Can't see how adding such a tank will improve the player experience & overall health of the game.
Ya as if the quick 4 mins games were not enought - WG trying to make games more turbo, which will eventually kill the whole experience of a strategic game play and make WoT a FPS game to full effect, as it is already half way through there.
i think it's a balanced tank nothing special except that 800 dmg at 50m ... kilana is faraway better TD. if Q.B can do 2.5 k dmg to 4k dmg with this tank ... so average players will do arround 1 k dmg to 2.5 k dmg most of the time in average...it's not easy to make it work.... that's my opinion
@@jagdpanzere.onehundred911 i think so mate ...cause this tank is hard to play .... need to push most of the time and never camp beheind ... it's not for begeiner players ... need experiend players to make it work
Ya know what's depressing .... Look at the tier 8 match maker you barely see any tech tree tanks in that match (I'm not including tech tree artillery ...) Back in the day Tiger II, Centurion mk 1, Ferdinand were the best tanks to play nowadays is BZ-176, Skoda T-56, Bourrasque and Progetto 46 in every match what's the point having stock tech tree tanks anyway (On the bright side at least my O-HO doesn't even have is own premium counterpart which I'm glad)
Dude whenever I play tier 8s I barely see any tech tree tanks on each team that's why I pick the O-HO to use it to let's just say "NERF" premium tanks >l;)
@@AetherYes oh I am not saying you are wrong, I was just stating something that a lot of players don't seem to know, the caern is actually INSANELY good
Good to see that Tech tree tanks are still relevant and still fight to continue the forgotten IS-3, Tiger II and Ferdinand (I couldn't sworn you were my one of my subscriber)
I've just made it to their tier 9 in the polish TDs, guess I'll have a crew trainer for them now. I disagree with the assessment that the tanks are boring, and are in fact quite the opposite for me. I find them to be incredibly dynamic and much more interesting to play than your usual heavies where you just sit on a corner, sidescrape, and fling gold at the other team's weakpoints until eventually someone wins out. I really enjoy playing both the tier 8 and tier 9 on the medium tank flanks of most maps, and you can have a huge impact on the match. My average damage in the Kilana was something like 3200, and took my account damage record away from my STRV 103B with a 9800 damage and 9 kill game vs tier 10s. The carry potential is insane for a TD
Ya as if the quick 4 mins games were not enought - WG trying to make games more turbo, which will eventually kill the whole experience of a strategic game play and make WoT a FPS game to full effect, as it is already half way through there.
Another brocken tank, why? The gametime is very fast and goes faster. Wargaming says we must nerf tds there do too mutch dmg. A tier 8 td can reach tier 6 tanks! How is this balanced?
@@hebrewhammer4086 Obj. 704 is slower, no armor, and is tier 9! Bullet speed 880! Has less dpm! In what world is tier 8 better then tier 9? And the tech tree vs. is way worse! Why the better tank is the premium? That can t stand in front there have a weakspot on top.
@@JadigertheReal the tech tree version is not way worse lol. Better armor, less alpha drop off at range. Better camo. Better accuracy. This tank is strong. But to call it broken is just ridiculous.
To be honest, despite the Kilana beeing the best T8 TD on paper i can't get it to work at all. I am a 62% win rate player, but this tank just breaks me. I feel like i want to get this tank up close and fight heavy tanks, but you just die there *way* too quickly, without achieving much because your aweful gun handling + narrow gun arc mean your snap shots won't hit and you get obliterated when trying to aim your shots. You can't realy wiggle and hope your tracks eat the shots either, because this tanks side armor is absolutly trash and your hit box of the lower hull sides is so far inwards, that the angle becomes bad *very* quickly. Sure, hulldown the armor is decent, but there aren't that many positions where you can get close to the enemy and hulldown using your medioker 7° gun depression, and if you don't use the gun depression the armor doesn't work...
So I’m 61% and kilana is my best performing tier 8 tech tree tank- I’ve found it works best if you push medium flanks and can find more squishy targets so you don’t have to stop and aim. Granted I play in platoons and it’s much easier to get pushes going in duos and trios
@@cirrus2761 Maybe i was too much focused on the short range fights heavy tank flanks usually provide. But yea, i can imagine this is a great platooning tank due to the sheer stopping power and DPM it provides during a push. Sadly i usually don't platoon, so...
To me...the real competition to this tank is the WZ-120-1G FT, just on the basis of its mobility; I'll take on damaged BZ-176s in that machine. Still intend to grind for this machine; one can't have too many premium TDs!
Don’t know why QB recommends the concealment skill for every tank and every crew member, especially this tank when the point is to get into close quarters.
I already despised the kilana line enough, so ofc they make an overpowered premium version of an already op tech tree tank that has an absolutely bs mechanic. This tank will just be added to the pile of terrible decisions wg has made over the years, which truly helps show how incompetent they have become
The prem Italian tier VIII autoloader td has +300mm effective upper frontal armor. And it has a turret. Better in every regard compared to what I saw in this demo imo. I think it a minor disaster that these Polish assault tds don't have the frontal armor to be played as assault tds.
A few days ago quick babes made a video saying WG should nerf some premium tanks in order to improve the gaming experience! Now what he's doing?? He's happily playing another premium tank better than the tech tree one! So cute...
Hard no, Grom has way better armour and basically zero sniping capability outside HE shells. 122 54 was a quite good sniper with ability to trade hp to put in 2, 3 shots against low dpm targets when you had to make pressure. Coming from a person that loved old 263 line, the only thing I'll never forgive wg for removing
