Seether - "What Would You Do" (Official Audio)

Подписаться 1,5 млн

Просмотров 1,1 млн

50% 1

Listen to “What Would You Do” from The Purgatory EP: found.ee/WastelandThePurgatoryEP
Order SIGNED and EXCLUSIVE bundles (U.S.): found.ee/seetherofficialstore
Order SIGNED and EXCLUSIVE bundles (UK/Europe): found.ee/SeetherOfficialStore...
Shaun Morgan: “We are really excited to release The Purgatory EP as a companion to our latest single, "Wasteland." I'm especially proud of how the alternate version of the track turned out and really happy that people will finally hear it!” The 5-track set includes the fan favorite, “Wasteland,” from the band’s most recent album, and features three never-before-heard songs, and an alternate/stripped down version of "Wasteland”.
Stream/Buy "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum" here: found.ee/SiVisPacemParaBellum
Follow us:
found.ee/SeetherWebsite
found.ee/SeetherInstagram
found.ee/SeetherTwitter
found.ee/SeetherFacebook
Seether is:
Shaun Morgan - lead vocals/guitars
Dale Stewart - bass
John Humphrey - drums
Corey Lowery - guitars/vocal
Lyrics:
(by Shaun Morgan)
Gotta find a better way to quit the cigarettes
Gotta drink another drink until I can forget
Gotta find a way to feel like I’m myself
Whoa
With the whiskey came the things that I do regret (well this erodes my body, erodes my body, erodes my body, breaks my body down)
and I know there were things I should not have said
I believe you’ve already got them written down
Whoa
When the world around me can feel so rotten
I am sorry for making you feel so low
Never gonna lose these feelings I regret
always gonna be the same old tired shit
What would you do
What would you do
There will never be a feeling I suspect
All apologies are something heaven sent
What would you do
What would you do
I lie awake at night I’m trying not to break a sweat
Mind is racing there’s no comfort for me yet
Gotta find a way to get away from myself
Whoa
I really wish I could erase all the things I did (well this erodes my body, erodes my body, erodes my body, breaks my body down)
I really wish I had a path to the wreck against
I really wish I had a way to cleanse myself
Whoa
When the world around me can feel so rotten
I am sorry for making you feel so low
Never gonna lose these feelings I regret
always gonna be the same old tired shit
What would you do
What would you do
There will never be a feeling I suspect
All apologies are something heaven sent
What would you do
What would you do
Never gonna lose these feelings I regret
always gonna be the same old tired shit
What would you do
What would you do
There will never be a feeling I suspect
All apologies are something heaven sent
What would you do
What would you do
What would you do
What would you do
What would you do
What would you do
#Seether #WhatWouldYouDo #ThePurgatoryEP

Видеоклипы

Опубликовано:

29 июл 2021

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 795

@Frosty_tha_Snowman 2 года назад

I can't believe they didn't release this song on the album, it's one of the best sad songs they've had.. this really hit me hard.

@jamesriantrip3018 2 года назад

For me is .broken

@timshanemelton 2 года назад

🚬 = 🚭" you can quit " 😎

@Frosty_tha_Snowman 2 года назад

@@timshanemelton I don't smoke cigarettes:[ that's actually the 1 part I don't relate to lol.

@zachmccraw1237 2 года назад

The lyrics that makes the hardest times easier..

@brielleholle7594 2 года назад

I've been a seether fan since I was little, and I absolutely love this song

@thebigv8644 2 года назад

Still a band I can hit play and listen to every song on every album, they just don't disappoint me!!!

@Awakening_from_darkness 2 года назад

Totally agreed , only Seether can do this!

@sandraeverhart4744 2 года назад

Same here, I ❤️ them

@jessicastephens3693 2 года назад

😈

@joelbowman9417 2 года назад

Come on every song

@RebelBlues 2 года назад

They're even better in concert

@brandonperry857 2 года назад

Loved this band back when they were called Saron Gas and they have only improved each year. Shaun is a talented relatable man.

@XxSEETH3RxX 2 года назад

They have been Seether since 2001. They were only known as Saron Gas in South Africa

@brandonperry857 2 года назад

@@XxSEETH3RxX Yeah I know and they released an album before they were called seether I believe it was titled fragile or something. Had a few songs that would be ported to disclaimer and a few that didn't make the cut

@mthompson3509 2 года назад

@@XxSEETH3RxX they were known as Saron Gas since 1999 till 2002, they changed name when they moved to the United States to avoid confusion with the deadly chemical known as sarin gas.

@suesutton9226 2 года назад

He is rather awesome - and I must listen to Saron Gas - also I hot into the band Veruca Salt who had a song called Seether which is where they got their name from.: ))

@loganbremerman1248 2 года назад

Leaps and bounds. Hell, even rerecording Disclaimer from Saron Gas to Seether was a big change. They actually got a good producer

@alexbarbarich5273 2 года назад

immediately within the first 10 seconds i could tell this would be a banger, but what else do you expect from Seether. love you guys.

@crystaldawn9529 2 года назад

Me toooo

@Mariajosea27 2 года назад

SAME HERE I just heard the intro and I liked the liked button, there's no way

@AnwarRosly 2 года назад

you read my mind!

@RebelBlues 2 года назад

Same!! Saw them live back in 2017, they were so fucking badass!!! Best concert of my entire life, it was such an escape. Like Shawn was reaching out to all of us saying, it’s going to be okay.

@beezybeez7231 Год назад

This is good but you must hear “Whispering Wolf” by SLT 🤘🐺🎧🎸🎶

@sorrycantvizualize 2 года назад

Gotta find a better way to quit cigarettes... Hits home

@jimmyp2720 Месяц назад

Anyone who smokes is stupid anyway

@CallMeBigWorm 2 года назад

This song should have been on Si Vis Pacem Para Bellum... and it should be a freaking single. The lyrics hit so close to home for everyone out there fighting for all the reasons to survive. This song definitely pulled at my heart strings. Very heavy. Very emotional. Absolutely amazing!!! Love you guys!!! You guys are the true definition of what music is supposed to be about.

@richardfranklin7638 2 года назад

Totally Agree! 👍

@johanburger6109 2 года назад

Morgan said the album could have had 16 songs but they chose this route instead. They did the right thing. It's better than whacking extra songs on an album although I must say it worked out really well on disclaimer 2

@paxtonwalker7162 2 года назад

Feast of famine should have been there too!

@redinkaddicted 2 года назад

*Seether in 2021... The nostalgia tho.*

@Maedrya 2 года назад

20 years of career in 2021 :)

@danman6669 2 года назад

@@Maedrya They've actually been around since 1999 when they were called Saron Gas. They changed their name to Seether in 2002, the same year they released their first album, Disclaimer.

@fireboltaz 2 года назад

This is great music. Glad to hear it feels like 2002

@MrShannonmoll 2 года назад

Try thinking of them as Saron Gas in 2021. Cliffy's PMB. That's nostalgia

@shanehinkle1734 2 года назад

They have their own sound, noone else can even touch em

@hustlazmuzik70 2 года назад

This instantly became one of my all time favorite seether songs. Thank you for leading me out of my own demise and continuing to help me through the darkness. To anyone reading this, stay true to yourself and stay strong you'll get through it stronger!!

@matematicarka 2 года назад

🍀🍀🍀

@kurtramsauer9731 2 года назад

I am always impressed by the great material Seether always brings. This depth and strength in the lyrics are overwhelming. Whenever I hear Seether I dive into another world.

@iAssassins 2 года назад

I fuck with this comment foreal 🤙🏼

@ajobdunwell2585 2 года назад

I've seen them live a few times... They jam thru. A friend of mine purposed to his wife at their show. Dunno how he slipped backstage but they helped him set the stage.

@sergioach 2 года назад

I love how this track sounds like early 2000s

@ixhilkalaskiiver792 2 года назад

" 'Cause If I Stand Up, I'll Break My Bones, Everybody Wants To See A Fall Unfold." Reminded me of that one. Which is not a bad thing.

@derekedge2089 2 года назад

That opening riff that keeps circling back. Pure gold.

@turtleraiderttv1010 2 года назад

The lyrics from "Words as Weapons" speak through me the line when he says "Take what you want and feed me to the wolves" that hit me. Bad ex experience.

@neisan92 2 года назад

@@derekedge2089 The opening of See You At The Bottom as you load up a new album and hit start on track 1 was so hype. It goes in heavy and I love that.

@wiehahmwagner9930 2 года назад

First time I listened to seether was around the age of 11, 12... I'm 25 now and still listen to them every single day. Greatest band of all time in my opinion🤘🏼

@Lance57H 2 года назад

Same story for me, they defiantly fill a void that no other band can fill for me.

@JS-nd1po 2 года назад

My only criticism of seether is that I like their songs and wish each song was longer, and had one more chorus.

@shawndecker6727 2 года назад

Same for me first song I heard was saron gas and I was like woah this band is something else.

@nthomas87 Год назад

Welcome! Go find their album when they were known as Saron Gas (it’s on RU-vid; just spell it like that though). Fantastic album. Unbelievably raw emotional roller coaster. It’s a less-finessed version of some of their best known Seether songs. These guys were letting it all out on the line before they broke through as Seether.

@beezybeez7231 Год назад

This is good but you must hear “Whispering Wolf” by SLT 🤘🐺🎧🎸🎶

@jackbaldwin2135 2 года назад

Shaun is an amazing man. Coming through drug addiction, alcohol addiction, a break up with Amy lee, this man is a strong human. His voice is just incredible and I’ve loved them for over 12 years !

@justinhetrick3472 2 года назад

Drug addiction and alcohol addiction is hard to overcome I have respect for anybody that does it. I was a heroin addict and alcoholic for years and it destroys everything around you. It's so hard to fight through the sickness and change ur life to stop using. I have 5 years clean now so songs list this I can fully relate to.

@LcBoy131 2 года назад

@@justinhetrick3472 awedome work. Respect from germany . You went through so much to walk on the straight line. Never forget what you have achieved!

@justinhetrick3472 2 года назад

@@LcBoy131 thank you. I work in the drug and alcohol field now as a recovery specialist. I spend everyday trying to help others get off the drugs and showing them it is possible and I'm living proof of it. So many look down on addicts like they choose to be that way, but most of the time that isnt the case. Most of the time they get hooked before they realize it and cant get away from it no matter how hard they try. And so many are afraid to seek help because of all the stigma facing it.

@beezybeez7231 Год назад

This is good but you must hear “Whispering Wolf” by SLT 🤘🐺🎧🎸🎶

@skimaskman 8 месяцев назад

The death of his brother was also something too, but everything else yeah it's amazing he survived through it & he kicks ass at guitar and vocals still

@darkfalcon7097 2 года назад

Always incredible. This band never disappointed me. They always talk to tired souls. Tks.

@kelliesmith2189 2 года назад

Tierd souls. Damn man, that describes it perfectly.

@darkfalcon7097 2 года назад

@@kelliesmith2189 They are great

@hawkstrike18 2 года назад

Tired, or cynical, lately? I'm not so sure yet.

@jethrowessels 2 года назад

Van my land af

@beezybeez7231 Год назад

This is good but you must hear “Whispering Wolf” by SLT 🤘🐺🎧🎸🎶

@ramonalders1909 2 года назад

This is - Fine again - 2.0. Amazing. Great band and a great song

@dawn1568 2 года назад

Your comment brought a smile to my face😊

@Jason0800 2 года назад

As always impressed one of the best bands around for over a decade

@clarkgriswald7030 2 года назад

Do you know Hugh? HUGH DAMN RIGHT!

@Jason0800 2 года назад

@@clarkgriswald7030 Yes I Do 😄 🤣 😂

@johnnydarko2736 2 года назад

I felt that shit. Seether, one of the realest bands. It feels like this guy picks apart my brain and searches for my thoughts to write music. Thank you bro.

@notyetdefined98 2 года назад

I can't believe that the band that survived the golden era (2002-2007), continues to create rock music that can be listened to in the 2020's

@sonjaboon3280 2 года назад

Love this song. The words mean a lot to me. It’s at a time where I can really understand the words so much. It’s beautiful. Thank you for your music! Your the best💕

@sleepydog9047 2 года назад

Definitely in the top ten bands to come out of South Africa

@darkmachine165 2 года назад

I never knew they came from Africa always figured Australia cool.

@jeffreymassie1375 2 года назад

Seether, set's back and reflects on past. ✍ song and hits nail on the head. 55 and crying 😢

@jtfrancis1745 2 года назад

This is Shaun's most powerful song lyrically to date. Takes a real man to expose his regrets, especially to the world. My respect for him has gone through root. Hes a good dude that has been through shit and made mistakes like we all have. I can totally relate to this song. I wonder it he really knows how much his music has helped people? Seether is not only the best kick ass band of their generation, but they're also therapy. Now make this a single!!!!

@sam_i_am6410 2 года назад

If all other bands just faded away overnight, I'd be set with just Seether. Can't think of any other bands I can say that about.

@notveryamused 2 года назад

I hit "Like" before "Play". well done Seether as always! 🤩

@shawnaldrich7868 2 года назад

did the same,just knew it would be great

@wmc128 2 года назад

Seether NEVER disappoints. Thank you for everything you do. You got a lot us through those dark times brought us serenity.

@Chrisdead27 2 года назад

To me its has the rhyme of Staind and Nirvana. But also a very great song.

@atticusstephenson2895 2 года назад

Yeah it kinda does sound a little like its been awhile lol

@Chrisdead27 2 года назад

@@atticusstephenson2895 i know right

@ingrown_cactus9178 2 года назад

Good assessment 👍 I had my playlist on shuffle and immediately thought this was nirvana. Not so much staind, this is way better than anything they did imo.

@Chrisdead27 2 года назад

@@ingrown_cactus9178 i really do appericate it, my friend.

@mattclarke4574 2 года назад

Right!

@milagrosaleman7902 2 года назад

I regret not living more spontaneous moments. The fear of leave my family when I was young, and adventures in another place. But far away I don't regrets my two beautiful son/daughter ❤ 💕 ♥ 💖 Blessings🥰 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

@DubstepRavr 2 года назад

I've loved Seether since my emo days in highschool, and they just keep releasing music that makes life bearable 🖤💜💚

@denisereigns2906 2 года назад

The "what would you do" part is legendary

@kennypowers3984 2 года назад

Intro "It's Been Awhile" Vibe......Love Seether!!!

@TaraZaraChara 2 года назад

I thought the exact same thing!

@jtmarkham6821 2 года назад

This song actually sounds like some from Disclaimer great job

@darrenbishop1614 2 года назад

Immediately what I thought !!

@eddiebrock3353 2 года назад

Yea thought the same thing as well

@aussiecook167 2 года назад

The guitar at the start reminds me a lil of stained also they did great as always

@NoMercyXtreme 2 года назад

It is insane, ain't it? So rare for a band to come back THIS hard to their old and loved style. I am completely in love with the song.

@thestu059 2 года назад

Definitely

@abigailneethling2233 2 года назад

I DO LOVE THIS BAND. I am South african and feel so proud. no one talks of Seether but i have been following since saron gas days and they are just amazing. GO BOYS.

@jerrid19 2 года назад

A band that's been that one hand I can grab in the darkness...thanks a million fold

@bethadkins5428 2 года назад

Everyone has a band they love and can't get enough of. A band you always see live when you can, when they come to town. Seether is mine. I love those guys!! 💖

@lynhope268 2 года назад

Agree!!

@levireese8454 2 года назад

Same! Just saw these guys live a few hours before commenting this and they put on a hell of a show!!! They never disappoint us

@achimwitcoustic9585 2 года назад

Yesss

@kiedis13f 2 года назад

Gotta find a better way to quit the cigarettes Gotta drink another drink until I can forget Gotta find a way to feel like I'm myself Whoa (Well this erodes my body Erodes my body, Erodes my body Breaks my body down) With the whiskey came the things That I do regret And I know there were feelings I should not have said I believe you've already got them written down Whoa When the world around me can feel so rotten I am sorry for making you feel so low Never gonna lose these feelings I regret Always gonna be the same old tired shit What would you do? What would you do? There will never be a feeling I suspect All apologies are something heaven sent What would you do? What would you do? I lie awake at night I'm trying not to break a sweat Mind is racing There's no comfort for me yet I gotta find a way to get away from myself Whoa (Well this erodes my body Erodes my body, Erodes my body Breaks my body down) I really wish I could erase all the things I did I really wish I had a path to recompense I really wish I had a way to cleanse myself Whoa When the world around me can feel so rotten I am sorry for making you feel so low Never gonna lose these feelings I regret Always gonna be the same old tired shit What would you do? What would you do? There will never be a feeling I suspect All apologies are something heaven sent What would you do? What would you do? Never gonna lose these feelings I regret Always gonna be the same old tired shit What would you do? What would you do? There will never be a feeling I suspect All apologies are something heaven sent What would you do? What would you do? What would you do? What would you do? What would you do? What would you do?

@reythomas3922 2 года назад

Thanks brother, appreciate u

@molliethomas2585 2 года назад

Thank you so much!

@adamspitfire 2 года назад

Wrong song

@kiedis13f 2 года назад

@@adamspitfire It is the right song.

@adamspitfire 2 года назад

@@kiedis13f oh shit sorry

@noneya1987 2 года назад

This song hits home in every way. The lyrics couldn't be any more real. I was bawling by the end. Just amazing.

@Mariajosea27 2 года назад

This song gives me sort of a Finding beauty in negatives spaces vibe. Seether's signature sound! Love it

@dragonite2780 2 года назад

Это просто восхитительный EP. Завораживает ♥️

@delorfate2909 2 года назад

Согласен, понравилось. Вообще одна из любимых групп:)

@mx.horrorwood5003 2 года назад

one of the most touching songs seether has ever released. this song can reach deep within your soul and pull out the deepest parts of yourself that you never wanted to see again...and help you work through the shit. only seether can make a song like that.

@sandyjoss1683 2 года назад

The world without Seether would be empty... thanks you guys for your music, it follows me since so much years...it helps me to get up and continue to live

@Wozniak_15 2 года назад

Goodness Rock is back Watta lovely early 2000 sound

@GustavoCosta-lb2co 2 года назад

The best song on the EP, no more, no less. Just the best lyrics and the best melody

@danielgibeault8060 2 года назад

The beginning of this song gave me stained- it's been awhile vibes

@baddvoodoo6442 2 года назад

I am hoping that they play this song at their shows. This is one that would sound great live. As always Shaun doesn't disappoint.

@embraceharmonies 2 года назад

This is one of my favorite song from the purgatory album.

@sarahill8703 2 года назад

this song is really hitting me in the soul right now.

@shawnaldrich7868 2 года назад

seether has a way of puting you right where you need to be,when you need to be there

@seanwetrich8299 2 года назад

This song is AMAZING! It has so much feeling.

@NellyEIEI 2 года назад

Talk about consistency. This band hasn't lost their sound since day one!!

@mycahclements380 2 года назад

I have been a huge fan for so long.

@marvinsan_ofc 2 года назад

So have I. Seether never disappoints! 💙

@butchcassidy3373 2 года назад

I've seen Seether live several times. They never disappoint. Saw them open for Nickel Back and they blew nb away. Both bands on stage together covering Nice Shot Man was great.

@Madchris8828 2 года назад

The hate for NB always seems unfounded. If Shaun likes those guys enough to go on stage with them? Good enough for me.

@Volluble 2 года назад

🔥🔥🔥

@Hellxkitten Год назад

FOREVER MY FAVOURITE BAND

@beezybeez7231 Год назад

This is good but you must hear “Whispering Wolf” by SLT 🤘🐺🎧🎸🎶

@thecarsonigen 2 года назад

Shaun Morgan, one of the best singers of all time.

@buttonincharge9721 2 года назад

This man's voice touches my soul ♥️

@hackergaming1651 2 года назад

I usually keep my music to myself but man I'm gonna get my whole friend group into this song including my crush 🤘🏼

@fraganadefraganade 2 года назад

your a brave soldier, i applaud

@irie.sunset 2 года назад

Grunge isn't dead!

@TheFlamerWolf 2 года назад

The album's name speaks to me and this song relates to me in many ways I cannot explain

@shawnaldrich7868 2 года назад

seether has matured so much as a band,i think they just get better with time,killer tune right here

@joe2.039 2 года назад

Yall never disappoint love yalls music to death.

@seanmichael599 2 года назад

This is a great song.

@amethystaquariusglendagree1070 2 года назад

MORE! MORE SEETHER....

@Nikki-gn3sr 2 года назад

This song just seeps into my bones....love it

@tamunasabelashvili8123 Год назад

Shaun and Gavin both of them are amazing. I would love to hear their duos again!

@beezybeez7231 Год назад

This is good but you must hear “Whispering Wolf” by SLT 🤘🐺🎧🎸🎶

@brandocommando9370 2 года назад

Love you seether

@cheathamcountylife8307 2 года назад

I love this man

@samuelbiddison1560 2 года назад

This chord progression is something outta this world

@user-rq5pe8ne7r Год назад

Eh? This is E minor. Quite popular progression :D Althought the song itself is very good/

@Awakening_from_darkness 2 года назад

One remedy song for these dark days.....thank you Seether!

@gretchen7894 2 года назад

What would u do- a super great song to listen to on head phones!!!

@pubudusenarathne 2 года назад

This is classic Seether we all always love and loved and will love ❤️❤️

@marvinsan_ofc 2 года назад

The more I listen to Seether the more addicted I get! Am I the only one?

@lukevj 2 года назад

True to Seether form… music from the heart, and not from a producer.

@kariwarnock8085 2 года назад

Saw them in concert back in July and they sound amazing live. I want to see them over and over. They are my favorite band ever.

@chaoticchaos894 2 года назад

Not sure why every album these dudes get less views. One of the few bands who have been rocking at a consistent level for damn near 20 years!

@jmksuburban 2 года назад

great song as always

@shanesmith9289 2 года назад

Dig it fellas.. keep on rocking is what I want to do!!!

@crystaldawn9529 2 года назад

I’m so happy they’re still here. I literally thought hip hop is taking over and rock is slowly going down the drain. I’m glad bands like them are still sticking around. Breaking Benjamin, Korn, and them. They been around for years , and they’re still going on. I love the way they express their life and their feelings and their struggles and put in music. It’s sad of course, but at least they’re letting it out instead of taking it to another level. If you know what I mean. Music like this is like I’m not alone. And I can understand people.

@drapensmusic 2 года назад

One of my favorite song for the purgatory album...

@thereeldre6553 2 года назад

Lets go SEETHER 🤘🤘🤘🤘

@amethystaquariusglendagree1070 3 месяца назад

"i believe you already have it written down"💜

@daaryn5352 2 года назад

Finally the real seether stood up!

@NaturalHealingAlchemist 2 года назад

👏🏻 💯

@lizalvarez98 2 года назад

Una de mis cosas favoritas es salir a caminar y escuchar Seether mientras voy pensando en la vida, recordando cosas, trayendo ideas a mí mente para el futuro, sentir su música me da mil años de vida. Gracias porque me han ayudado infinitas veces... ❤️🤘🏼

@george5697 2 года назад

👍

@danielmundaca4207 2 года назад

🖤

@lizalvarez98 2 года назад

@Troy Red Eyes B

@fxGabrielOliveira 2 года назад

I am crazy in this is song 🤟🏽

@JamminJessi 2 года назад

Why isn't this song on the album? And why isn't this a single?! 🤯

@michaeljurney8354 2 года назад

I feel this song so much... it really kickkstarted some weird feelings

@DissocialPersonality Год назад

a top 5 seether song for me

@mrhuman9270 2 года назад

It's glad To see that Seether didn't change their music style 👍 , It's feels too good ❤️😍

@MrJt1020 2 года назад

That mid 2000's sound still shines bright, dudes!!!!! Love it. Saw these guys with A7X and BFMV on the Uproar fest in Grand Rapids over 10 years ago. Never a bad tune.

@zed1440 2 года назад

I Just Love this Band ....

@adelynnbaker7323 2 года назад

literally my favorite song OF ALL TIME, NO JOKE!

@tammydunn6117 Год назад

This is so cool song

@RebelBlues 2 года назад

This song, and The Gift are probably the most soul clenching songs they've ever written, I can never stop listening to this one. Shaun never fails to write relatable music, and he knows what's it's like to be lost, and hurting. Thank YOU, Seether!!!! 🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻

@fedecamusso 2 года назад

Sweet jesus! WHAT A TRACK! 🤘🤘🤘 🔥🔥🔥

@ALCALPONE888 2 года назад

Notificationsquad I love your music keep up the great music guys

@scout057 2 года назад

Can’t wait, Tuesday night LIVE!!

@richardanderson4161 2 года назад

After listening to the incredible music put out time and again there is something that stands out.There was a love that ran deep but was lost. The pain of it resonates in many of their best songs. What did she do to torture and scar one so deeply?