This is beautiful.. Her voice is very much suited for songs like this.. She CAN sing, just that she has a soft lower voice. Not every singer has to belt out these notes.. So don't try to compare her to other singers out there because they are all different in how they sing.. She has a beautiful voice. SMH at those who say she can't. Hmmm I'd like to see you do it then..
@CastlesCrumbling we're talking about singing, not accomplishments. talent doesn't equal how many awards you get. like I said, I think Selena is a better singer than Taylor. Taylor usually sounds flat and dull, but Selena's voice in this song sounds sweet, yet it has that little huskiness. but whatever, think what you wanna think.
This is actually good! I was one of those ppl who said she couldn't sing cuz honestly.... well...she couldn't, but now. This is GREAT!!!!!! I LOVES!!!! The only thing that confuses me is that she was awful on the PCAs & this was done b4 that. WTH? She should sing THESE type of songs.
@CastlesCrumbling wtf? give her a break! Selena doesn't usually sound this amazing. I never knew that she could do all those singing skills. she even shows more range and style than Taylor Swift.
MY GOD! This one is filled with so much epic win! I really love the way she sings here. I want to hear more songs when she sings acoustically. I love that cute lady.
@JoxyAlexDexy I would say that her voice is above average. She has shown some vocal skills in this song and proved that she really CAN sing. get over it already.
@OfficiallyAbigail Nobody is trying to change your opinion. We're having a discussion, not an argument. So you need to calm the fuck down. The fact that you can't stand Selena pretty much tells me that I'm wasting my time with you. If you can't stand her, then don't watch her videos and post your stupid comments. It's that simple. It's quite obvious that you don't know shit about singing, because if you did, then you would understand that having a big voice means nothing if there's no HEART.
@OfficiallyAbigail That's fine, but there's a huge difference between "weak" voices and "light" voices. The singers that I mentioned all have light voices, and even light voices can be strong and/or unique. While you hear them as plain, most people can hear the depth of their voices. It's not always about who can sing the highest note or who can sing the loudest, none of that matters if there's no heart behind it.
@OfficiallyAbigail If you think Selena's voice is plain and weak, then you might as well say the same thing about Colbie Caillat, Taylor Swift, Ingrid Michaelson or Norah Jones. They all sing songs that don't require high notes or wide-range, but that doesn't mean they're any less of a singer. They may not have big, powerful voices, but at least they can work with what they have. 2:52 - 2:55 you call that plain and weak? pff. -___-
@CastlesCrumbling Even though they both sang this song, comparing them is pointless since Pixie's is slightly more upbeat and sang it with a wider range, and Selena's was slower and sang it acoustically in a more softer way. Plus, they both sound completely different from each other, and they made their own spin on it. Who cares about wide range? If you sing it in your own way, then that's all that really matters.
@OfficiallyAbigail It's my video and it's my commentary system. I can say whatever I want, and I can delete or block anyone from commenting here. If there are some comments here that I disagree with, then I will let them know my disagreement. I think you already said what you need to say, so I'm blocking you. Have a nice life.
@CastlesCrumbling Selena showed more range in this song than she ever did before. In my opinion, she added soul and kinda sultry to this song as well. She did a great job.
in my opinion i though she sounded so good! everyones saying she 'sucked' but her voice is built for these kind of songs. not those high pitched auto-tuned songs. i definitely think its time for her to make an acoustic unplugged album like Justin Biebz
