Тёмный

Sergei Bortkiewicz ‒ 10 Preludes Op. 33 

Medtnaculus
Подписаться 31 тыс.
Просмотров 142 тыс.
50% 1

Sergei Eduardovich Bortkiewicz (1877 - 1952), 10 Preludes, Op.33 (1926)
Performed by Jouni Somero (2014)
00:00 - No. 1 Maestoso
06:08 - No. 2 Vivace
07:23 - No. 3 Andantino
09:04 - No. 4 Sostenuto
10:19 - No. 5 Andantino semplice
11:37 - No. 6 Sostenuto, con espressione dramatica
15:25 - No. 7 Andantino
19:31 - No. 8 Andante sostenuto e cantabile
25:03 - No. 9 Andantino
28:45 - No. 10 Patetico
I'd recommend No's 5 to 10 if you want to hear what these preludes at their best.
Bortkiewicz was Ukrainian (he was born in Kharkov, 16 February 1877) and studied at the St Petersburg Conservatory-in his spare time at first, for his father insisted that he study law. ‘I inherited my mother’s pleasure in music-making’, he wrote. ‘And what a blessing it was that we made much music when I was young. My mother played the piano very well and I was passionately fond of music.’
Unlike some of his Russian contemporaries (Rachmaninov, Medtner, Scriabin) Bortkiewicz was not a sufficiently gifted pianist to make a career as a soloist, though after his debut (Munich, 1902) he made several European tours.
‘I am a Romantic and a melodist’, he wrote in an essay towards the end of his life, ‘and as such and in spite of my distaste for the so-called ‘modern’, atonal and cacophonic music, I do hope that I composed some noteworthy works without getting the reputation of being an epigone or imitator of composers who lived before me.’ Bortkiewicz’s compositions are dominated by those for his instrument and many are well worth investigating. Perhaps they lack profundity and originality in the widest sense. But does the only music we appreciate have to be by the great composers who overturned systems, struck out for the unknown, and challenged their muse? One hopes not. There must always be a place for those like Bortkiewicz who reflect so elegantly and expertly on what has gone before, rather than shake us by the ears and grab us (sometimes screaming) into the future.

Видеоклипы

Опубликовано:

 

7 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 167   
@smb123211
@smb123211 4 месяца назад
I like the way Bortkiewicz keeps referencing previous works. The first prelude is the soulmate of the Etude "La Brunne". You see this constantly. He, like Chopin, is also a favorite of pianists.due to his melody and "story telling" in each piece. But what a tragic life! Love the 8th Etude - such a gem both to play and hear.
@benji104
@benji104 5 лет назад
discovering Bortkiewicz's music feels like Chopin put out a new album :-)
@joshuarosenkranz8379
@joshuarosenkranz8379 4 года назад
You. Win.
@pmwkiy6879
@pmwkiy6879 4 года назад
Benji104, I am so, so pleased that you discovered Bortkiewicz. You are right, it's very florid, hundreds of notes to the beat (hyperbole- being hyperbolic) and all the notes are in perfect harmony, like Chopin and Liszt. All of Borkiewicz's compositions are superb and beautiful, always brings tears to my eyes. There is another pianist called "Koji Attwood", who appears to love to play Bortkiewicz. Watch K Attwood On RU-vid, he does something suspicious under the piano. I am so proud of Bortkiewicz and love him so much, it pleases me that you are so impressed with him. I am happy for both of you and not being arrogant nor condescending. We love Bortkiewicz!
@MajorAndMinor
@MajorAndMinor 3 года назад
Probably more like Scriabin
@robert.m6755
@robert.m6755 3 года назад
@@MajorAndMinor Bortkiewicz's piano works in majors such as his Maestoso No.1 does ressemble Scriabin. It has a sense of despair at the beginning, and slowly, it rises to a greater range. His slower more majestic pieces ressemble Scriabin's piano works whilst his faster paced pieces such as Vivace or andante cantabile do feel like Chopin's piano works.
@sm30405
@sm30405 3 года назад
Mixed Rachmaninoff ,Chopin, Scriabin
@doctoratroposxr9828
@doctoratroposxr9828 4 года назад
00:00 - No. 1 Maestoso 06:08 - No. 2 Vivace 07:23 - No. 3 Andantino 09:04 - No. 4 Sostenuto 10:19 - No. 5 Andantino semplice 11:37 - No. 6 Sostenuto, con espressione dramatica 15:25 - No. 7 Andantino 19:31 - No. 8 Andante sostenuto e cantabile 25:03 - No. 9 Andantino 28:45 - No. 10 Patetico
@Perryz7
@Perryz7 2 года назад
respects dude
@jeffreybryan8377
@jeffreybryan8377 2 года назад
No. 7 and no. 8 of this set are positively breathtaking. As a composer myself it's music like this that drives me and keeps me writing! Such exquisite beauty and tranquility. 💕🙂
@robandlisagoldin2402
@robandlisagoldin2402 5 лет назад
Glorious. The ghosts of Chopin, Rachmaninoff and Scriabin. Wonderful playing!
@steveegallo3384
@steveegallo3384 4 года назад
Yes...Echoes and Ghosts...though not of Chopin, I think...but of the others, yes, BRILLIANT! Bravo from San Agustinillo!
@nghiavan8952
@nghiavan8952 3 года назад
Except Rachmaninoff was still alive
@gsm5104
@gsm5104 2 года назад
He was alive the same time as Rach and Scriabin lol
@PushkarCarlotto
@PushkarCarlotto 2 года назад
@@steveegallo3384 No? Doesn't No.4 remind you of the B minor Sonata? Oh, and No.7 a bit like the 2nd Impromptus?
@andreassorg7294
@andreassorg7294 Год назад
Excuse me... this music is a blade copy of them. And the playing seems as if not prepared, even for a studio recording
@kliberalsing
@kliberalsing 3 года назад
Back to Bortkiewicz and his uplifting, magical harmonies! After listening to modern day film scores, this music simply takes you higher, and it allows you to create your very own variety of images.
@emilyhutjes
@emilyhutjes 6 месяцев назад
I love Bortkiewicz. 🌷🌷🌷 (The Netherlands)
@MoldySoup
@MoldySoup 5 лет назад
Some of the most beautiful pieces I have ever heard.
@Poeme340
@Poeme340 2 года назад
A river of beauty-I hear elements of my favorite, Scriabin. Thx for opening my ears to this music!👍👍
@marinadela1361
@marinadela1361 Год назад
Preludes no. 7 and no. 8 brought me to tears. Such brilliant romantic music.
@MrOlafJr
@MrOlafJr 5 лет назад
Wow! A 'melodist' indeed. No. 7 and No. 8 are songful to an extent seldom seen outside of the works of Chopin, Rachmaninoff, and other much more well-known composers. Bortkiewicz appears to be very underrated, in my opinion!
@usernamehyt
@usernamehyt 6 месяцев назад
no 8 is copycat of mahler symphony no.5 famous slow movement
@SoupyMold
@SoupyMold 2 года назад
These pieces never cease to move me. Thank you for uploading.
@Whatismusic123
@Whatismusic123 7 месяцев назад
They're awful
@789armstrong
@789armstrong 4 года назад
quite outstanding. more pianists should play these great works.
@adalbertogomesdossantos4545
@adalbertogomesdossantos4545 4 года назад
É sem dúvida um bom compositor.Muita inspiração! Geralmente o foco é só nos compositores mais conhecidos mas a gente acaba descobrindo jóias muito preciosas como esse compositor.
@catherinehoelscher1758
@catherinehoelscher1758 2 года назад
So grateful to have this music available to listen to
@andreassorg7294
@andreassorg7294 Год назад
As a good therapy against sleeplessness... It's romantizism at its worst, near to Richard Clayderman
@adalbertogomesdossantos4545
@adalbertogomesdossantos4545 4 года назад
Muito lindo esses 10 prelúdios! Muita riqueza de melodia e principalmente de harmonia! Gostei demais!
@ronaldbwoodall2628
@ronaldbwoodall2628 7 лет назад
Beautifully expressive etudes that are worthy to stand with the best of them. Thanks for the upload, and for the opportunity to follow on the printed page.
@rodrigoramoselorduy4930
@rodrigoramoselorduy4930 4 года назад
Música increíble, hermosa, bravo!
@carlkulzer5982
@carlkulzer5982 6 лет назад
These preludes are marvelous, and played beautifully, with great feeling.Thanks for making them available on you tube.PS with my head phones the sound is excellent.
@connorrichardson368
@connorrichardson368 4 года назад
my brain explodes at 22:58 ...how is this so underplayed.
@jamsheddelvadavala1972
@jamsheddelvadavala1972 7 лет назад
Such grace & elegance in the 10 preludes! Bortkiewicz deserves a proper place in musical history! Somero's portrayal is superb. Thanks for the post! Jamshed K Delvadavala, Mumbai
@pmwkiy6879
@pmwkiy6879 4 года назад
Jamshed Delvadavala, I am getting emotional while I write this. Bortkiewicz is being discovered by many new Classical music followers, particularly followers of great composers of piano music. There will come a day, hopefully soon, when he will be a household name and on the tips of everyone's tongue. I discovered Bortkiewicz and Nikolai Kapustin about twenty five years ago and listened to them frequently. They are the new kids on the block; they will surpass the usual great composers from the periods 1650 to 21st century. composers. Someone wrote about what a tough time (financial) S Bortkiewicz had during his musical career. I wish I lived during this period, I would have helped him. I care about struggling composers/ pianists (especially the ones who could bring tears to my eyes like Rachmaninov, Scriabin, Kapustin, Bortkiewicz and a few others) and my other passion is dogs. If I am blissful, sad or dying, it is the music of Rachmaninov, Kapustin, Scriabin and Bortkiewicz I want to listen to most of all. Jamshed Delvadavala, they don't get better, watch them rise to the top. I LOVE THEM.
@pmwkiy6879
@pmwkiy6879 4 года назад
Perry Kiy, London.
4 года назад
Seriously, Bortkiewicz is one of my favorite composer of all time. I performed No.8 partially so check out if you’re interested.
@churnyeechong2427
@churnyeechong2427 2 года назад
Hope you will play the whole series soon!
@andreassorg7294
@andreassorg7294 Год назад
Favorite composer of all time???? You have a very special taste...
@andreassorg7294
@andreassorg7294 Год назад
Wanted to check out, but didn't find Bortkiewicz. But listened to your Lord of the rings Suite. All I can say: You are able to play the piano, but your taste is not mine
Год назад
@@andreassorg7294 Thank you. Yes Bortkiewicz is in my top5 favorite composers. My RU-vid channel is only for business. I have near zero interest and liking to what I play on RU-vid. I personally enjoy playing Bortkiewicz but don’t make a video.
@andreassorg7294
@andreassorg7294 Год назад
@ Who are the other 4?
@pmwkiy6879
@pmwkiy6879 4 года назад
Beautifully played Jouni Somero. I am mad about Bortkiewicz. If all my favourite composers were Gods, I would worship them. I hope you felt utterly content having played them. Sitting under a large tree on Waikiki beach, after my gruelling hours of tennis, I would listen to Rachmaninov, Scriabin, Kapustin, concertos by Chopin, Saint Saens, Liszt and others, of course, Sergei Bortkiewicz. My eyes would be flooded with tears. I don"t know why beautiful music does this to me. Even when I try to sing, my eyes get flooded , this is why I don't like to sing. Anyway, very well played. You pressed all the right buttons for me.
@renardbleu71
@renardbleu71 3 года назад
Bortkiewicz, un génie comme Chopin.Mais enfin pourquoi l'avoir oublié.C'est inadmissible.Je suis révoltée.Honte aux grands décideurs et merci à you tube
@dustinlaferney3160
@dustinlaferney3160 Год назад
Very beautiful. A pleasure to listen to.
@PushkarCarlotto
@PushkarCarlotto 2 года назад
Thank you for the upload. No.1 is lovely. No. 2, at 6:20 has the theme of Tchaikovsky's piano Concerto. No. 4 the B minor Chopin Sonata, and No. 7 feels like Chopin's Impromptus No.2 And No. 6 and No.10 clearly feel very much like Scriabin.
@piano_man7416
@piano_man7416 5 лет назад
Beautiful piano music!
@vakhtangsoupymoldishvili230
@vakhtangsoupymoldishvili230 2 года назад
Preludes #2 and #10 are my favorites!
@SCRIABINIST
@SCRIABINIST 2 года назад
No.6 is an extension to Scriabin's Op.2 No.1. But more advanced harmonically and also more drammatic
@maxwoefull3460
@maxwoefull3460 Месяц назад
It also has some of Chopin prelude op 28 no 4!!
@PetStuBa
@PetStuBa 3 года назад
for some reason this wonderful composer always intrigues me ...
@charlesdavis7087
@charlesdavis7087 3 года назад
Charming and worthy of piano students everywhere.
@briansunday7099
@briansunday7099 10 месяцев назад
These are indeed beautiful. I am currently learning nos. 1, 6 and 7. I actually find that his piano music fits my hand. Also learning two etudes from opus 29.
@teunvandesteeg7836
@teunvandesteeg7836 6 лет назад
I thought that only Chopin could make such music but I was mistaken (nr. 2 and others). This is a revelation.
@fredericchopin7538
@fredericchopin7538 2 года назад
Marvvelous!
@emanuel_soundtrack
@emanuel_soundtrack 4 года назад
Chopin is way too beautiful, sometimes we just need to hear something very beautiful
@SeadogDriftwood
@SeadogDriftwood 5 месяцев назад
Excellent stuff! No. 3, 6, and 8 speak to me on a personal level: I must learn to play them!
@sulista-consulting
@sulista-consulting 3 года назад
What a discovery for me, love from Czechia!
@wuyipiano
@wuyipiano 3 года назад
So colorful and romantic.
@EmdrGreg
@EmdrGreg 7 лет назад
Wonderful set of preludes-- I am not familiar with his work, but I will be.
@thenameisgsarci
@thenameisgsarci 8 лет назад
Can I request for Bortkiewicz's 10 Etudes Op. 15 and, if possible, 12 Nouvelles Etudes Op. 29, please? @___@
@Medtnaculuss
@Medtnaculuss 8 лет назад
+thenameisgsarci To upload yourself? If so, go ahead! I have his piano concertos in the works and might touch Ein Roman and Im Takt 3/4 but other than that you're free to choose if you want to upload more of his stuff. :D
@Medtnaculuss
@Medtnaculuss 8 лет назад
+thenameisgsarci Though if you'd like me to upload them I'd happily do so!
@thenameisgsarci
@thenameisgsarci 8 лет назад
Medtnaculus I'm giving you the honor to do them.. :)
@TheALIMARS
@TheALIMARS 8 лет назад
My favourite is number 8......thank you for the upload..:)
@EmdrGreg
@EmdrGreg 7 лет назад
I can see why, Marshall-- it is marvelous. Sometimes he can sound a little like Scriabin, and I hear foreshadowings of people like Mompou. Delightful to the ear.
@FeeLikesChriZ
@FeeLikesChriZ 7 лет назад
the middle part has similarities with rachmaninow op 39 no 5 with these triplets and the accentuated notes in the left hand
@torinperreyclear1377
@torinperreyclear1377 6 лет назад
Beautiful, you can hear bits and pieces of motifs chopin used
@karolakkolo123
@karolakkolo123 3 года назад
You can also hear a lot of chords that Chopin used. For example dominant chords in which the fifth is replaced with minor or major sixths. Used sometimes in chopin's ballades and nocturnes
@torinperreyclear1377
@torinperreyclear1377 3 года назад
@@karolakkolo123 True, they were starting to really explore extensions and alterations. Nice to hear that liberation
@JouniSomeroMusic
@JouniSomeroMusic 8 лет назад
Jouni Somero are first pianist who recorded Bortkiewicz complete piano works. All 9 Cd availlable www.fcrecords.fi ,www.fuga.fi. More information about Somero: www.jounisomero.com
@Medtnaculuss
@Medtnaculuss 8 лет назад
+MrMakemies A fine pianist and I am very grateful for his Bortkiewicz recordings!
@gwilymprice4442
@gwilymprice4442 6 лет назад
I expect he would be glad to see his recordings cropping up across RU-vid and thus being visible to the public eye, what with the fantastic work he has done to promote Bortkiewicz's music. That doesn't, of course, stop RU-vid from inserting an advertisement for Herbie Hancock's masterclass into the middle of no. 4...
@sywedis4019
@sywedis4019 6 лет назад
19:31 - No. 8 (Andante sostenuto e cantabile) ...This could easily be adapted for use in a romantic pop song...all on its own merit! Catchy tune as they said on Tin Pan Alley !
@Medtnaculuss
@Medtnaculuss 6 лет назад
That's my favourite of the set (also why I uploaded these). The ending always gets me.
@paulcapaccio9905
@paulcapaccio9905 3 года назад
I play his music and live it. Please give chopin a long rest
@LukeFaulkner
@LukeFaulkner 5 лет назад
No. 6 is like Scriabin Op.2/1. I've found several of his works seem to be homages to Scriabin.
@gwynbleiddroach2589
@gwynbleiddroach2589 4 года назад
Luke Faulkner sounds a lot like Liszt Mephisto waltz in parts.
@r0mmm
@r0mmm 2 года назад
20:04 is way to beautiful to be ignored like that!
@stephenjablonsky1941
@stephenjablonsky1941 Год назад
Two of these preludes are in the very rare key of F sharp major (2 and 7).
@samaritan29
@samaritan29 4 года назад
The 7th etude reminds me a lot of Gattsu from Berserk (1997) OST.
@nghiavan8952
@nghiavan8952 3 года назад
It’s a prelude
@Ar1osssa
@Ar1osssa 4 года назад
4 and 10 are my favorites)
@emanuel_soundtrack
@emanuel_soundtrack 4 года назад
the last 0ne is a good example of how hard it is to be perfect: it sound amazing but is too short, it contradicts its own energy forwards and growing. Maybe one page more would the perfect measure.
@carlhopkinson
@carlhopkinson 3 года назад
Quality music.
@sywedis4019
@sywedis4019 6 лет назад
12:15 is a very passionate movement
@gwilymprice4442
@gwilymprice4442 6 лет назад
Agreed. That's probably my favourite of these works, and it doesn't seem too difficult either, so I might have a go at it at some point. If you haven't already come across it, his étude op. 15 no. 6 is similarly dramatic.
@pianist-moko
@pianist-moko 2 года назад
👍🎶✨
@katerynataier-ulianova8462
@katerynataier-ulianova8462 2 года назад
In order to refute some allegations displayed as a discription that ostensibly his music lacks profundity, I would like to point out that all composers without exception have their most and less popular opuses. Moreover, there are over- and underrated artists as well as musical pieces. Therefore, feel free to choose your favorite ones and do not try to diminish other's contribution to the world's culture.
@jaegonekim
@jaegonekim 7 лет назад
gonna practice the eighth one
@smb123211
@smb123211 6 лет назад
I was also drawn to the eighth - it seems so complete and incredibly beautiful. I noticed a structural similarity to the D Major Prelude of Rachmaninoff but with an even more alluring melody. Will check Virtual Sheet Music
@marijan1808
@marijan1808 5 лет назад
@@smb123211 I was also thinking how it reminds me of Rachmaninoff
@smb123211
@smb123211 5 лет назад
@@marijan1808 I found a free download of Opus 33 and immediately went to work on No 8. It is one of my favorites and with those broken thirds, polyrhythms and rolling beautiful chords it's like love child of Rachmaninoff and Brahms.
@marnieholdsworthgreen8449
@marnieholdsworthgreen8449 Год назад
2:30 Super reminiscent of Rach Piano Concerto No. 3 - the rhythm in the finale
@emanuel_soundtrack
@emanuel_soundtrack 4 года назад
one of the top preludes for piano, i always forgot him because of his name
@andrewc9643
@andrewc9643 Год назад
@15:25 for future reference. amazing piece
@fulviopolce9785
@fulviopolce9785 4 года назад
Scoperto un genio pianistico. Perché solo ora?
@esMusicalus
@esMusicalus 2 года назад
I love no. 8 (I'm learning it actually); it could be a tune off a Frank Sinatra torch song album!
@jeroenwarner4834
@jeroenwarner4834 5 лет назад
It's played a semitone up right?
@gianlucapiombo
@gianlucapiombo 4 года назад
Jeroen Warner nope
@Wuozlinga
@Wuozlinga Месяц назад
No. 8 sounds like straight out of a Ghibli movie. Hisaishi probably took notes here :D
@emanuel_soundtrack
@emanuel_soundtrack 4 года назад
11:37 Piazolla
@caitlyn1708
@caitlyn1708 Год назад
(personal comment for later) no. 7 15:25
@lewbretz
@lewbretz 4 года назад
Significantly more appealing than Medtner in my view, and at his best easily the equal of much minor Rachmaninov and Scriabin-- even if he couldn't (as we're told) play as expertly. Quite a find!
@thomasbarnich2004
@thomasbarnich2004 4 года назад
You can't compare both really. Bortkiewicz might be more appealing at first sight (or at first hearing) but if you listen a few more times you'll quickly get bored. It is a bit like a surface and not much below it (I'm not criticizing him, I quite enjoy listening to Bortkiewicz). Medtner is the exact opposite. At first hearing he's a bit off-putting, but his music is just incredibly rich and deep, it's a whole universe with a tiny door. I needed a long time to love his music but now I've been obsessed with his music for years and can't seem to get out.
@connorrichardson368
@connorrichardson368 4 года назад
@@thomasbarnich2004 Completely agree. For those who aren't drawn to medtner immediately, i highly recommend the sonata-ballade and his 2nd concerto. Those are masterpieces.
@jacobleis5673
@jacobleis5673 8 лет назад
"Unlike some of his Russian contemporaries (Rachmaninov, Medtner, Scriabin) Bortkiewicz was not a sufficiently gifted pianist to make a career as a soloist, though after his debut (Munich, 1902) he made several European tours." Talk about setting the bar high. Rachmaninov was voted by "leading pianist, Sokolov, Brendel, Schiff, and Lewis [in a Limelight Poll]" as being the greatest piano player ever recorded. However, it is likely that Liszt was the greatest piano player ever, but there are only written reviews to support. So as they say, shoot for the moon, if you miss, you land among the stars. This composer is definitely underappreciated. leading pianists including Grigory Sokolov, András Schiff, Alfred Brendel and Paul Lewis - See more at: www.limelightmagazine.com.au/Article/272642,sergei-rachmaninov-voted-greatest-pianist-of-all-time.aspx#sthash.uI9byYbr.dpuf leading pianists including Grigory Sokolov, András Schiff, Alfred Brendel and Paul Lewis - See more at: www.limelightmagazine.com.au/Article/272642,sergei-rachmaninov-voted-greatest-pianist-of-all-time.aspx#sthash.uI9byYbr.dpuf leading pianists including Grigory Sokolov, András Schiff, Alfred Brendel and Paul Lewis - See more at: www.limelightmagazine.com.au/Article/272642,sergei-rachmaninov-voted-greatest-pianist-of-all-time.aspx#sthash.uI9byYbr.dpuf
@goflowjoe
@goflowjoe Год назад
Number 6 must surely be a homage to Scriabin's Op. 2 No. 1 C sharp minor etude.
@HodGabriel
@HodGabriel 6 лет назад
28:45 - Patetico - reminds of the scriabin op.8 no.12 etude 'Patetico' ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-uz3TqZtAkeQ.html
@tarski7010
@tarski7010 2 года назад
prelude 8, 10
@emanuel_soundtrack
@emanuel_soundtrack 5 лет назад
No.26 comes from Brazil.
@angellohector
@angellohector 7 лет назад
too quiet the recording
@markfowlermusic
@markfowlermusic 2 года назад
No.7 definetely borrows ideas/themes from Chopin Ballad no.4 and Rachmaninoff prelude no.4.
@carlhopkinson
@carlhopkinson 3 года назад
Scriabin's 2nd Cousin ??
@Dylonely42
@Dylonely42 Год назад
6:10
@Meow-ny6hg
@Meow-ny6hg Год назад
No.8
@mrmfwettlaufer3785
@mrmfwettlaufer3785 5 лет назад
A lot of Mussorgsky in that first piece.
@moonjunsu
@moonjunsu 5 лет назад
19:31
@joycitasmith
@joycitasmith 2 года назад
Chopin op25 11
@LkFia_
@LkFia_ Год назад
No 10 has similarities with scriabin op. 8 no.7
@user-fy4it4db9d
@user-fy4it4db9d 8 месяцев назад
Жаль что его не изучают музыканты
@maxwellkalio9705
@maxwellkalio9705 8 лет назад
Was Bortkiewicz Russian or Ukrainian? As Kharkov (Kharkiv), his birthplace, is a Ukrainian municipality, he would properly be considered Ukrainian.
@DailyKosia
@DailyKosia 8 лет назад
I think, an Ukrainian with Polish ancestry. he studied in the capital of the Russian empire (he was born in this country), then he lived a much in Germany.
@eldiev2996
@eldiev2996 5 лет назад
Russisch. No Ukraine in 1877....
@esfirross6800
@esfirross6800 5 лет назад
Polish roots
@user-rk6us5fk9u
@user-rk6us5fk9u Год назад
@@eldiev2996 no Russian Federation soon too :*
@user-rk6us5fk9u
@user-rk6us5fk9u Год назад
@@DailyKosia you're right! to be honest, he's more cosmopolitan, then national composer. but we can't deny the fact he was born in Kharkiv (that is being bombed by russians, would russians bomb russian city?) and if u were ukrainian, you would also hear a lot of ukrainian themes in his piano works, for example "Віють вітри буйні" in his "What the Nurse sang".
@emanuel_soundtrack
@emanuel_soundtrack 5 лет назад
Strange, it seems to have nothing with Tinder to do...
@mobilephil244
@mobilephil244 Год назад
Interesting. Glimmers of greatness and lots of promise mixed with occasional flashes of inspiration. Sadly, as so often with Bortkiewicz, this doe just does not finish rising. Comparing these preludes with, for example, early Scriabin, you can see the difference between an almost-great and a real-great.
@andrewpetersen5272
@andrewpetersen5272 Год назад
Dough
@nss4472
@nss4472 3 года назад
Bortkiewich was nothing "Ukrainian", for your information: all the time before 1917 Kharkov was inseparatedly Big Russia (it is divided from Polish-Austrian "Ucraine" by river Dniepr). Mostly Russians lived in Kharkov (in difference with Galitzia). This composer had polish roots and may be Russian too.
@user-rk6us5fk9u
@user-rk6us5fk9u Год назад
idk, but it's really strange to me, that in his piano work "What the Nurse sang" i can hear ukrainian folk song... or is it russian too?;)
@goalsfirst
@goalsfirst 6 лет назад
I really only enjoyed Etude 7 and 8
@VILAYATU
@VILAYATU 6 лет назад
Stephen Coombs plays better Very good and undiscovered composer for piano
@MG-ye1hu
@MG-ye1hu 3 года назад
It's interesting to find composers on RU-vid saved from oblivion. But some music is forgotten for a reason. These are pleasing and well done compositions. But there is hardly any real individuality, it all sounds "like" somebody else.
@Iightsuperior
@Iightsuperior 6 лет назад
CTRL+C/CTRL+V Chopin
@gwilymprice4442
@gwilymprice4442 6 лет назад
No, it's not Chopin. This is fundamentally Russian-influenced, and some of the harmony (for example, the opening to no. 4) is not at all Chopinesque.
@tedsta485
@tedsta485 5 лет назад
I actually thought at a few points that these pieces were intentional variations on a theme of Chopin
@HodGabriel
@HodGabriel 6 лет назад
It is nice but feels uninspired, melodies are not convincing.
@lapincynique
@lapincynique 5 лет назад
Not even in No. 7? You've got some pretty high standards then.
@sywedis4019
@sywedis4019 5 лет назад
Try pulling your head out of your ass perhaps it will improve your hearing
@smb123211
@smb123211 5 лет назад
Bortkiewicz is one of those composers whose melodies remain with you precisely because they are so lush and romantic. The Prelude (No 8) and Elegy have some of the greatest melody lines in piano music.
@Whatismusic123
@Whatismusic123 7 месяцев назад
​@@sywedis4019 says you 😂 this composer is totally incompetent, an absolute joke.
@davidluck1678
@davidluck1678 4 года назад
painfully slow interpretation. Twists the melodies all out of shape; Coombs does it better.
@Whatismusic123
@Whatismusic123 7 месяцев назад
Sounds like Brahms. Very terrible, unaware of his massive flaws, unconsciously hides them with large chords.
@craigcrawford6977
@craigcrawford6977 7 лет назад
trash
@steveegallo3384
@steveegallo3384 7 лет назад
"Trash"? Strong word from slacking improductive tasteless lout whose short miserable nasty life will go unremembered and unlamented for all æternity....!
@RemydeRuysscher
@RemydeRuysscher 6 лет назад
I encourage you to improve on those pieces and put a video up on RU-vid. Surprise me.
@bartwatts1921
@bartwatts1921 5 лет назад
Oh, is that your first word upon looking in the mirror at yourself? If so, you are unusually self-aware.
@farhadnawab7642
@farhadnawab7642 4 года назад
Craig, I know hip hop is much more suited to your taste.
@Whatismusic123
@Whatismusic123 7 месяцев назад
​@@RemydeRuysscher you can't improve that which is fundamentally garbage, it'd be a whole different thing.
Далее
1 класс vs 11 класс  (игрушка)
00:30
Просмотров 1,4 млн
Which one is the best? #katebrush #shorts
00:12
Просмотров 3,2 млн
Sergei Bortkiewicz - Lyrica Nova, Op. 59
11:17
Просмотров 33 тыс.
Sergei Eduardovich Bortkiewicz: 10 Preludes, Op.33
25:32
S. Bortkiewicz Prelude Op. 33 No. 7
3:45
Просмотров 1,1 тыс.
Sergei Bortkiewicz - 10 Etudes Op. 15 [Audio + Score]
29:40
Debussy: Rêverie, L.68
4:55
Просмотров 49 тыс.
Sergei Bortkiewicz - 6 Lyrical Thoughts op 11 (Somero)
18:43