[SFM Creepypasta] A Trick-or-Treater Has Been Coming to My House Every Night 

I think it was great to not show what the trick or treater actually looked like, giving us a sense of imagination of whatever grim or terrifying it looked like.

Eldritch entity attempts to get candy on Halloween. It does not know the date of Halloween.

Fact: the word “trick or treat” was a word used by delinquents back in the day. They would say “trick or treat” by telling the house owner. “Give us a treat or we will vandalize your property.” For the house owners to not get their properties vandalized, they give the children an offer to prevent them from vandalizing. In present day, the word “trick or treat” is now used to ask the house owner for candy

It sounds like this thing didn't actually break into the house because it's never used the side windows yet, what seems likely is that he had an actual burglar break into his house who was unlucky enough to open the door for that thing 🤔🤔

burglar: "great! no one's home, time to steal this guy's money-" burglar: **turns into a fast runner**

Literally took “when death comes knocking at your door” to a whole new level.

The reason why Lara and the Taxi driver was terrified because there might be some kind of effect or imagination that causes them to go panic, giving the fact that they might seriously think that it was the Grim Reaper itself. We can't just call it a simple prank, that makes the story is a little disturbing

Wow. And after going to the same house twice you'd think the cops would at least check in on him every night or maybe he would buy a new security camera

Forgot how much I loved this creepypasta. It isn't some cliche fest with a big send off like "and then it turns out Laura was a cultist who chose me yo be sacraficed to satan", it's a horrific anomaly that's vauge enough for our imagination to run wild. We don't even really know the intention of the monster, and that's what freaks me out.

“The first time that he came was four days ago, around 9 pm. I was sitting at my office working on a document, when I heard a knock at my door and a characteristic little kid voice saying.” “Hi, we’re here to talk to you about your cars extended warranty.”

You're one of the only channels that can make my hair stand up straight consistently. All of your videos are so well done, and I have mad respect that you're able to use SFM.

Not being able to see that thing's face really enhanced this experience, and it shows that you cared/remembered the feedback you got from your EAS video

Honestly terrifying on two levels. 1. The fact that we don’t actually see anything makes us draw our own conclusions. I like the thought that we weren’t meant to see it because we wouldn’t even be able to comprehend it. Almost like in the call of Cthulhu when people saw Cthulhu they were driven mad. 2. MY MANS’S XBOX AND LAPTOP WERE THROWN ON THE FLOOR. I MEAN I WOULD BE CHECKING MY XBOX DOING OPEN HEART SURGERY…………But anyway this video was very well made and I applaud the effort gone into the video.

What's strange about this is that the taxi driver saw the creature through the car window and he was severely traumatized. While the main character saw the creature multiple times through the peephole and still remained unaffected. From that we can assume that the monster didn't want him to be afraid... Which is not good.

all i can picture when i look at the small hooded figure is *one shudders to imagine what inhuman thoughts lie behind that "mask" (human disguise) what dreams of cronic sustained cruelty(what inhuman horror is hidden underneath such innocent countenance of a child and what its desire is to achieve witch such disguise?)*

This story makes you wonder what that “kid’s” true form really was. If it was really the Grim Reaper or it was some other horrible creature we don’t know

Bro please make more the fact you're working with a game that is really old and yet scares me more than the horror movies I've seen this year is just amazing!

Maybe the grim reaper entity follows the rule of ghosts like ask permission to enter in the house but in a more clever way, using the halloween to lure instead of just knocking

I like how this Creepypasta is like Stephen King’s the finger. The main guy isn’t silent and stand-of fish like most. He has a bit of a sense of humor and isn’t hesitant

God the animations keep getting better and better! I wont lie Lara's intense expressions of fear was a little jank-looking, but everything else was astonishingly high quality, that is like the only criticism I gan give but I know it seems more like a constraint of the ragdolls. You're one of the best sfm-horror content I've ever seen which actually got me a bit

Amazing work as always dude, the animation really complements the story in a way i didn't really expect them to, when i first started watching your creepypasta series i was surprised at the quality of the narration and animation. This is top notch dude, keep up the good work!

The monster is hiding his true form but only from the main character, its like the thing is chasing the mc only Idk if you just read and animated someone's story or actually made it, but if you did, please surkee bring a part 2, this one was interesting as hell, if i wasn't broke and living in a shitty country like brazil i'd pay for a part 2

This guy is criminally underrated. You need more attention

I was scared that u wont upload for a while but thank you for uploading i was needing this also this is scary ngl

What I got from this was, the trick or treater is some eldritch abomination like Cthulhu where if you gaze upon it's true form you go mad. Everyone else could see through the fake image and got traumatized, the reason why the main character wasn't scared and never went mad was because the monster was putting up an act to make him open the door (as he wouldn't open it if he was able to see what it was) before the main character got home in the taxi a burglar broke through the basement and starting checking everything to find valuables, hence the money and xbox, etc on the floor. When the main character got home the trick or treater was at the door and knocked, they then sped off. The burglar (maybe seeing that there was a kid at the door) opened the door expecting to help the kid, but the kid then killed him (because the monster was trying to get main character to open the door to get killed, but the burglar was mistaken for main character) the trick or treater cleaned up the mess and left to go onto more people.

Top notch animation as always.

So I think I figured out why the MC doesn't seem to be as freaked out looking at the thing as everyone else. Its an Angler Fish and the reaper costume is the lure. For whatever reason the main body is invisible to him but at least partially visible to everyone else. It explains why the voice comes from above and behind it.

This was a fantastic story, and I would love to hear what you guys think people were seeing. My interpretation is that they saw either a floating cloaking with nothing in it since I heard one of them say "nothing," or they could see whatever thing was talking behind it that the main character can't see

This thing learned that it can disguise it's self during Halloween and perfectly blend in. But it has a horrible sense of timing and only knows the words that'll bring prey to the door, "trick or treat!"

I like to think that while the events of this video is happening, the poor man at the Train Station is still sitting there. This event would've taken him a good 1,000,000,000,000,000 years.

Bro this reminds of a dream I had were it was similar to this but it took place at my childhood house, and it felt like a loop. In it it was me and my mom each time when we looked at the figure we jumped back in fear. Then it end when I went to my bedroom to try to get a better look.

That’s probably Jeremy before he worked at the Gas Station lol

Dude, you NEED to continue this series! It is soooo good and addictive almost!

These animations demonstrate how good of a voice actor mr creepy pasta really is

This is the type of creepypasta that makes me yell. . . "WHERE THE SECOND PART." Like damn, that was very interesing concept, so story to tell and adapt. Ever since I subscribe to this channel, it just has been a good waste of time, don't take it wrong, it really worth it to watch all your content man, keep it up!

You say ‘freaky child demon,’ I hear ‘child sized eldritch organs waiting to be sold.’

Just leave him a bowl of candy labeled "take one" you'll be fine

Everyone complimenting the SFM but not the narrator. The man puts emotions into the words, we gotta appreciate it.

This is really perculiar and interesting. My theory is that that the girlfriend and taxi saw the 'kid' true form,and were traumatized by it. Maybe the main character didnt get traumatized because the kid didnt want him to scared,thus meaning that it wouldnt be let in But,since its cognitohazardus effect doesnt work on the main character,it might want to be let in,or something more sinister

ALWAYS love to see an upload from you in my sub box! As others are saying, you are one of the only channels I've seen that can genuinely terrify me, and the ammount of effort you put into your videos is great.

Excellent job. I am always waiting for these uploads. Good pacing, animation and sound as usual. The lighting is also great. I think someone else said it, but I'm glad you didn't show the face. The imagination is ample enough.

This is the best animation I've ever seen, the detail and the storyline making you think what the hell is the face of that hooded guy is just perfect

rare sighting of sfm creepypasta with good animation

I love the way the reader talks. He sounds very natural. Not scripted. Like he's typing it himself.

the fact they never show the kids faces makes you think that whatever they saw was something so dreadfull, so terrifying it had to be a eldritch horror or something, anyways, great animation!

the final sentence of this SFM made my hair stand up. Such a great video

Surkee appearing every month to drop top quality creepypasta sfms and then disappear into the night

This is probably one of the best creepypasta I’ve ever seen

I really enjoyed this SFM! This Creepypasta was really interesting! I was expecting the Trick-or-Treater's face to be revealed. But the fact it wasn't, honestly adds to the story! Also, when the Trick-or-Treater came by the second time, when his girlfriend was over there. When he went to look back at her after opening the door a bit. I honestly kinda thought his girlfriend was going to be missing or something xD And to answer what I'd do in a situation like that. Well, I'd probably invite it into my house, for a nice Mug of Coffee, or some other drink, in the attempt of making the Trick-or-Treater my friend, in the hopes of it sparing my life. Because I feel like temporarily living in a friend's house, or just leaving the neighborhood entirely wouldn't be an option, since it'd probably just follow me, and continue trying to accomplish whatever goal it has.

Been binging these animations recently. Awesome work!

my new favorite gmod creepypasta animation by surkee

Ooh! I loved this story when I first listened to it a few years ago! It’s so cool to see it come to life like this! Well done!

Everyone talking about how scary the story and animation is but I'm talkin about how beefy that pc is

I was watching your videos before sleeping , had endless confusing murder mysteries . I was sick before that and I think me being sick and then these nightmares about the brain speed video you made really fked my sleep. I woke up at 2.22 and literally tried to sleep but still couldn't till 4.45. Idk what to say

I'm always so happy when Surkee posts. I love these videos so much. Keep it up!

I really want a part 2 to this.

Its an expected joy to hear a story on a different channel by MrCreepyPasta 😍

"What was I supposed to say to [the cops]?" Uh, that there's a lone five year old kid in a Halloween outfit that keeps knocking on your door in the middle of the night, who doesn’t respond to you at all and walks off only to come back again, and that you don't know what his deal is but that you don't want to open the door for him in case some robber is using him as bait? Even if the police wouldn't believe the Lovecraftian horror part, they *will* believe some kidnapper(s) using one of their victims to get to more people.

That kid pulled out the greatest trick in history of trick or treating

why is this so cool, it seriously gives me chills

wheres part 2 ni- This sh*t too good to not be finished

When you leave cousin in your room alone : 10:47

Now this is high quality animation, nice work gentlemen

Please never stop making these, there really good my dude

I'll always wait for this kind of animations. This is so good.

I am guessing a thief was in his house when the kid showed up and scared him away.

Someone in the comments mentioned it sounds like a good SCP, so I used ChatGPT to quickly whip this up: SCP-9616 Object Class: Keter Special Containment Procedures: Due to the uncontainable nature of SCP-9616, containment efforts have been suspended. All previous attempts to contain SCP-9616 have resulted in demanifestation, making containment impossible. The Foundation's focus is now on monitoring and documenting SCP-9616's activities, as well as minimizing its impact on civilian populations. Mobile Task Force Epsilon-11 ("Nine-Tailed Fox") is to be dispatched to affected areas to ensure public safety and investigate potential leads. Description: SCP-9616 is an entity that manifests as a child wearing an old Grim Reaper Halloween costume, commonly found in stores during the Halloween season. Its appearance indicates that it is a child, although its facial features are obscured, preventing accurate visual identification. SCP-9616 exhibits anomalous behavior by randomly appearing at suburban homes between the hours of 11 PM and 2 AM. Upon manifestation, SCP-9616 will knock on the door of the targeted residence and vocalize the phrase "trick or treat." No further vocalizations have been observed. Attempts to engage SCP-9616 in conversation or detain it have resulted in immediate demanifestation, with no trace of its presence remaining. SCP-9616's motives, method of selection, and means of demanifestation are currently unknown. Of significant note is the anomalous effect experienced by individuals who directly observe SCP-9616's face. Those who make visual contact with SCP-9616's obscured facial area have reported entering a state of manic psychosis shortly after the encounter. Symptoms include hallucinations, delusions, heightened aggression, and self-harm tendencies. Affected individuals require immediate psychiatric intervention and isolation for their safety and the safety of others. The impact of SCP-9616's anomalous effect on mental health poses a significant threat to public safety. The Foundation is actively researching methods to counteract or mitigate this effect and explore the possibility of developing protective measures for personnel involved in SCP-9616 investigations. Addendum 9616-1: Incident Report During an encounter on ██/██/████, SCP-9616's face was inadvertently observed by a Foundation researcher. The researcher displayed immediate symptoms of manic psychosis, engaging in self-destructive behavior and causing harm to other personnel. Despite containment efforts, the researcher expired due to self-inflicted injuries. This incident underscores the severity of SCP-9616's effect and the need for extreme caution when dealing with its anomalous properties. Efforts to understand the origins and purpose of SCP-9616's manifestation are ongoing, with an emphasis on finding ways to neutralize its anomalous effects and protect the public from potential harm.

i love this style of story videos, it's like setting the scenes in Gmod i guess

This is almost like Bird Box.

bro we need part two

My theory of the kid it's that is a ghost that most likely was murdered on that house and he has turn into a vengaful spirit who wants to kill the murderer of the house, but instead of using a weapon or something is that he simply wants people to look at his face until they go crazy, now the girlfriend of the protagonsit? Most likely was someone she fully knew as a kid, a friend or family member? Not sure, this is the best i have, other than that, it was really well animated man and that moment in which the taxy driver saw the kid sure gives me the creeps. in the best way of course

Good choice to use Mr. Creepy pasta.

Gordon freeman would have put satchel charges or slams at the door from outside and wait 💀

you are one of the only SFM youtubers that actually makes good SFM animations. Keep up the good work.

Mr Creepypastas Have New Narrator Career What a nice One !

This deserves more views!!! I've been watching ur videos since april and u don't disappoint me unlike the other channels!!! KEEP IT UP

Plot twist: the entity is a cognito-hazard. When people see it, it gives them a sense of terror and shock, this effect gets wiped off in a few days and the people who saw its true form gets their memories wiped off.😊

This is one of the only channels that give me chills i wish you made second parts for you're creepypastas as it leaves me wanting to see what happened

I haven’t felt this scared in awhile

Im really enjoying these sfm creepypastas, they are so well made keep up the great work man 👍

“Relatively safe” *bomb goes off in background*

it could be an a being related to Halloween because... well you can tell by the reaction of the viewers of the phenomenon that whatever they where seeing was clearly not something happy ! whatever the Grimm reaper costume was... it was no child

This is bird box all over again

I was waiting to hear whose voice it was gonna be, yay for MCP

Another great animation. Please keep this up. Your stuff is aweseome!

I'm under the impression the break-in was the thing breaking into the house looking for him, then bolting out the door after the cab when it realized he was in there and then the driver took off.

What did the kid in the grim reaper costume look like to make people terrified?

Amazing story. Love these vids man it looks almost like a video game! Keep making these

Ughhh this is actually so creepy to think about. Had he been home that night...who knows what could've happened to him.

I love how you use SCP Containment Breach Ambience

bravo. Emotion is 100%, story is 10/10 and the animation was insane.

Please make more of these, they are absolutely chilling!

“Dea- duh- dead- didn’t see.” Likely a trail of dead bodies.

This is my favorite so far!

“Trick or treat!” This dude: hmm..fundraising

alfin alguien que no pone screamers y es muy bueno contando historias de terror

I love that the horror movie they watched was emisis blue lol it’s a nice little touch

So my theory about the break in was that a robber broke through the basement window and was indeed going through his stuff , then there was a knock at the door , through the peep hole , he saw the kid opened to tell him to get lost and saw the thing that is apparently behind him , he dropped all the money , laptop and xbox and either ran off or the thing did a little trolling to the robber

6:38 That knock was more terrifying than any horror movie nowadays

highest quality horror i have ever seen with out a price tag!!❤❤ keep'em comeing (first video= alreddy subscibed)