A sister is in prison for over 20 years her name is Aafia sadiqui she has been tortured and been subjected to the most atrocious abuse please make a video on her it would benifet the muslim ummah more.
I am so shocked at my muslim brothers aiming at each other and then dog each other in social media?? This is soooo wrong brothers..you are all good da'wah givers that we all love and inspire from...please stop this now...haters of Islam will be enjoying this...please Ali and Muhammed stop this...not fair..At all
I agree, so many Muslims look up to those young men. Its a Shame they are backbiting another brother publicly on social media. Hajib and Ali need to think twice about this.
There's an ancient Arab saying: The wall asked the nail why are you ripping me... so the nail said to the wall: ask he who is hitting me (ie the hammer).... In other words those brothers are only reacting to the oppression they suffered at the hands of this group and in this case defending another Muslim who has been oppressed by those people may ALLAH guide them and guide us all Ameeen
You have to point evil out though. If you dont point it out then it festers and spreads to the ummah. This is like a cancerous cell, if its not treated earlier then it spreads to neighbouring cells.
Not the same thing, but remember when the Prophet sallallahu alaihi wa sallam died, the Sahaaba were told that the Prophet had died, but not Islam or our duty to Allah. Words to that effect. Alhamdulillah these brothers helped you come to the Deen. And in sha'Allah you will remain steadfast irrespective of how you entered the Deen. Allah is more than sufficient for us alhamdulillah ❤❤❤
The other saudi brother is Saleh Hamameh, he is an activist known for critisizing saudi regime, their cooperation with zionists and other stuff they do. He does content in arabic and he is always attacked by these madkhalis who threaten him n so on..
@@RaineRay-gn3bn That's a good question, since according to alLah, animals have umma too. So, al Lah sent pig messenger to pigs, lizard messenger to house lizards and black dog messenger to the black dogs. And monkeys of course. They were the first muslims.
Two things i wholely respect about Islam is, 1. Islam provides great principles for followers to live by. 2. Islam does not budge on its principles. Respect, makes me want to convert.
Alhamdulillah very well said. It seems you have understood Islam well. I highly recommend you go through with converting. May Allah make it easy for you and bless you, Ameen.
Respect is not a good reason to convert dear brother in humanity. I urge you to study it with an open heart by asking the creator of all things to help you see the truth and submit to it. Thank you for your kind words and may Allah Ta’ala guide you to Islam.
I 100% agree with pointing out brother’s mistakes and advising them, but if we keep judging/being against them it won’t bring us no where. May Allah SWT guide us all and grant us more knowledge 🤲🏽♥️
The man who is debating (Shamsi) in this video has abandoned Islam and become a Shiite. He abandoned Islam because of (Yasser), who impugned the honor of the Messenger of God (may God bless him and grant him peace) and the honor of Aisha. Muhammad Hijab and Ali Da'wa, still classify him as a "Muslim" and defend him.
@@lutpbuhbrother please have some sitra for you brother in Islam , I may not know a lot about him nor his character, but from i know he contributed a lot to the umma and he is a sincere student of knowledge, a good Muslim in the eyes of Allah inchallah, don't slander your brother for only you are taking his bad deeds for you and give your good deeds for him. This makes me sad .
@@Smz1sh because shamsi is grilling them everyday on lot of issue with giving the proper reference of the authentic books. To cover up that they are doing this and see how desperate they are what kind of titles they are keeping to gain the audience they are doing dis service to dawah. May Almighty Allah guide them and guide us too
I knew from the moment this shamsi guy started speaking arabic that he was algerian. Hijab mocking his dialect comes of as completely high brow and uneducated about the nature of arabic in north africa.
The other brother Shamsi is talking to is very popular in the Arab world Salih Hamama. He has a RU-vid channel as well @YakathahChannel. His family members are in Saudi prison and he speaks out about the injustice there. So this is actually quiet the scene because on a deeper level, the Madkhalis defend, enable and justify the injustice committed to this man. He's a mazloom. You could find the debate between them in Arabic by searching هروب شمسي من امام صالح حمامة
He changed his doctrine from the doctrine of the Sunnis and the community to the doctrine of the Shiites. In one of the calls he had with a Shiite sheikh on television, he declared his adherence and loyalty to the Shiite doctrine. He appeared in a clip with Yasser Al-Habib But he still presents himself as a Sunni. Is he a hypocrite?🤔
I haven’t watched the video yet but stop attacking each other please and give advice to him in private 😢 if he took ur advice then great, if he doesn’t then it’s on him, you did your part. It’s just my opinion ..
I’ve watched and benefited from all their dawah, Allahumma baarik, for many years and am unbiased towards the situation however the statement at 15:40 is unjust; the first video that comes up when you type in “Shamsi Uighur” on RU-vid is a video about Uighurs and Palestinians and i’m sure if you dig a little bit further you’ll find other videos where he talks about their plights…let us always be just even if it’s against our selves
This has been the real side of shamsi from day one, he is unqualified person who labels people innovators lol. He literally will warn you against every single daee or shiekh accept himself and his 2 ignoramus teachers. Alhamdulillah people can finally see why we expose him. The guy attacks Muslims at all costs!!
@@mk-ld8ih when you identify a bad manner from your brother, talk to him in private. I am sick and tired of their childish fights for both camps. It’s a shame for the Oumma. Seriously guys this need to stop. It’s boring and annoying 🤦🏾♀️
Ali brother maybe he didn't mean what happened or there is something that needs to be explained A podcast would be better in this situation Shamsi is doing a great job in speaker corner so for the love of allah let's give him another chance We all do mistakes and learn from them
The man who is debating (Shamsi) in this video has abandoned Islam and become a Shiite. He abandoned Islam because of (Yasser), who impugned the honor of the Messenger of God (may God bless him and grant him peace) and the honor of Aisha. Muhammad Hijab and Ali Da'wa, still classify him as a "Muslim" and defend him.
@@lHeatedl Then that Du'a would not be sincere. I really from the bottom of my heart want them to get destroyed, the same I wish for Zionists like Ben Shapiro
🎉Rukn ud din vs Guru nanaks fe et rukn ud din was raped stoned and killed after guru left Have unread the guru granth sahib it is evolution of religion with no child incest
@@kiisteric He is named after the tribe he’s from, there was another Sheik that they used to promote from the same tribe as well called Muhammed Bin Hadi Al Madkhali before some fitna arose.
﴿وَاعتَصِموا بِحَبلِ اللَّهِ جَميعًا وَلا تَفَرَّقوا وَاذكُروا نِعمَتَ اللَّهِ عَلَيكُم إِذ كُنتُم أَعداءً فَأَلَّفَ بَينَ قُلوبِكُم فَأَصبَحتُم بِنِعمَتِهِ إِخوانًا وَكُنتُم عَلى شَفا حُفرَةٍ مِنَ النّارِ فَأَنقَذَكُم مِنها كَذلِكَ يُبَيِّنُ اللَّهُ لَكُم آياتِهِ لَعَلَّكُم تَهتَدونَ﴾ [آل عمران: ١٠٣] (103) And hold firmly to the rope of Allāh all together and do not become divided. And remember the favor of Allāh upon you - when you were enemies and He brought your hearts together and you became, by His favor, brothers. And you were on the edge of a pit of the Fire, and He saved you from it. Thus does Allāh make clear to you His verses that you may be guided.
Bro you said it yourself, we don't know who the other person is and the whole context of the discussion yet , i saw Shamsi before having a similar discussion with a Saudi person ,the person was bashing the Saudi government and the "Freedom of speech" there and Shamsi told him even in the UK you can't criticize some things out loud..Exposing his Hypocrisy . Allahu Aallam . May Allah guide us and unite us upon Haqq
Can I actually say both are wrong? I watch both video addressing this video clip..first of all they should not be shouting just to prove a point.. secondly, please know the context before making videos.thirdly , not be harsh with one another because it's hard to back down when both egostatically try prove a point.. Both side have make mistake and we should learn not to do this kind of thing in anger or without reflection..
@@nplify2389How is shamsi wrong? Obviously ali and hijab were lying behind his back for years. Shamsi's response video was quite clear, unless your iq is below 0. You have to be fair and say that one side was wrong which was hijab and ali. Shamsi wasn't egotastically since he is trying to defend himself against falsehood and it's his right. Hijab and ali were taking videos out of context and trying to make shamsi look bad.
قال تعالى: إِنَّمَا الْمُؤْمِنُونَ إِخْوَةٌ فَأَصْلِحُوا بَيْنَ أَخَوَيْكُمْ ۚ وَاتَّقُوا اللَّهَ لَعَلَّكُمْ تُرْحَمُونَ الاخ حجاب وعلي دعوه وشمسي، الهدف من الدعوة هو توحيد الله والتقيد بما جاء في كتاب الله وسنة نبيه وقال الرسول صلى الله عليه وسلم: إنَّ مِن خِيَارِكُمْ أحْسَنَكُمْ أخْلَاقًا فمثلوا الاسلام خير تمثيل و تقول الله فيما يقال
After watching the whole video u guys were extra merciful with this brother may ALLAH guide him and guide us all. Jazaakum ALLAH Khair for leading by example and actually embracing and conveying the good mannerism of Al Quran
The man who is debating (Shamsi) in this video has abandoned Islam and become a Shiite. He abandoned Islam because of (Yasser), who impugned the honor of the Messenger of God (may God bless him and grant him peace) and the honor of Aisha. Muhammad Hijab and Ali Da'wa, still classify him as a "Muslim" and defend him.
this is unacceptable guys, You should not attack him publicly. If you think he did something wrong tell him privately between you and him and if you still are not in agreement turn it to a higher-knowledge scholar. Now it will appear to non-Muslim individuals how divided we are.
Nah man Shamsi is 100% more divisive than these two. The video with Daniel is evidence enough he didnt even let him speak. Respectfully I believe you are showing extreme bias, as regardless of viewpoint (even tho he’s usually wrong because guys like Umar basically offered meccans a fight before going to medina) he is always rude and constantly interrupting the ones that are trying to raise valid points. Jzk.
I would really like to see hijab and Ali and shamsi doing a podcast to talk about what happened It's really confusing to me in this context that shamsi did this kind of action and maybe he had something to explain or maybe he didn't mean what happened Allah said in the Quran : { واعتصموا بحبل الله جميعا ولا تفرقوا ﴾ And hold fast, all of you together, to the Rope of Allah (i.e. this Quran), and be not divided among yourselves Āl-‘Imrān -103-
It's not confusing for me. The moment i saw shamsi saying philosophy is haram okay fair but then he used philosophy time and time again. That's hypocrisy in the open.
guys for the love of allah let's not judge the guy so quickly Shamsi is doing a great job in speaker corner and maybe he didn't realize the mistake that he have done
I remember when a brothers dawah stall got attacked in Birmingham city centre & brothers from spubs stall stood by then tweeted it was because of their baatil they are attacked 🤦🏽♂️
They don't want the responsibility of the problems of the ummah and find it easier to just make tabdee3 of everyone other than them as if they are all mubtadi3een then there is no responsibility on them to help, support, defend etc.
To be Honest, i love them all. But Shamsi character repels any normal Muslims or Non-muslim away from Islam. He may be knowledgable but his character speaks otherwise.
I don't think so, I find shamsi comes across as very sincere and passionate about Islam. But I find these 2 very off putting. Speaking like roadmen and making backbiting videos. What dawah is that ?
Mohammed hijab and Ali dawah have not properly studied aqeedah and slander scholars like rabee al madhkali. Shamsi has actual fear of Allah and doesn’t speak Without knowledge and respects the scholars
Muslim mocking another Muslim, that's why Allah quoted: Al-Jathiyah 45:6 تِلْكَ ءَايَٰتُ ٱللَّهِ نَتْلُوهَا عَلَيْكَ بِٱلْحَقِّۖ فَبِأَىِّ حَدِيثٍۭ بَعْدَ ٱللَّهِ وَءَايَٰتِهِۦ يُؤْمِنُونَ English - Sahih International These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what Hadith after Allah and His verses will they believe? English - Tafsir Ibn Kathir (Abridged)
Wallahi that's the most heartbreaking to hear and feel saddened more than the depression I am dealing with in my life right now. I am 36 no job, no wife, kids, prospects with alot of other debilitating issues in my life yet its more painful to hear bro Ali D saying he feels jelous of the treatment of shamsi towards non belivers. I look upto all these brothers and anyone who promotes no god but Allah even if they are crack heads and alcoholics let alone on dawah. Whoever that may read this I pray you realise you guys have an effect on layman muslims like me and I'd rather be locked away in my room away from all of yous because of the doubt, confusion this creating. If anyone really fears Allah they would do the same just at the mear chance of being in thr wrong. There was a time where scholars that are considered revivers of the deen would shake like a leaf before giving advice and nasiha let alone gunning one another down regardless of what and how much you know. Remember your graves people. Remember. It's not long now for anyone of us.
-لا تختلفوا فتختلف قلوبكم . -ولاتفرقوا . -تعاونوا على البر والتقوى. -يد الله فوق الجماعة. -نهج النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم: مابال أقوام يفعلون كدذا وكذا. -من وعظ أخاه سرا فقد زانه، ومن وعظه علانية فقد شانه. اسأل الله لكم التوفيق والسداد وأن يجمعنا وإياكم على الخير ويؤلف بينا قلوبنا وقلوبكم، ويجمعنا على كلمة رجل واحد.
may Allah reward you brother, the sad ☹️ truth is, these 2 brothers here are willing to extend an olive branch and are willing to make peace, but those on the other side will never do it . may Allah forgive us all
Sectarianism has become the biggest scourge in the Muslim community, as it harms his Muslim brother rather than helping him The Prophet ﷺ said, "A Muslim is the one who avoids harming Muslims with his tongue and hands. الْمُسْلِمُ مَنْ سَلِمَ الْمُسْلِمُونَ مِنْ لِسَانِهِ وَيَدِهِ ( متفق عليه)
Please continue these brothers. You are destroying them seriously. They have never encountered such a beating before. They usually go unchecked attacking everyone else. When ismail Beaumont rhm died i know some of these sickos were happy because he was apparently an innovator, posting that when an innovator dies people should rejoice. They have hatred for Muslims and love for the kufaar like the munafiqs.
@@paimei26and yet wallahi they are worth more than you can ever hope to be paimei26. U will be an anonymous loser and they will continue giving Dawah, serving Allahs religion and earning their Jannah Insha’Allah!!
To all Muslims , a reminder to be just to one another and have mercy to one another as we are one ummah of Muhammadan Rasullullah , we are living in dangerous times and now more than ever we need to stand by each other and in unity. The fact is , no Muslim is perfect , all Muslims are striving to adhere balance in the middle path of the guidance of Al-Islam .. with taqwa and steadfastness, knowledge we will increase our Iman , we all try our best toward ihsan. But these days it's hard ... We are living in times where false information can easily destroy an individual or a nation and it can reach global lengths .. we as the individual Muslim should seek out truth especially for men as we are leaders in the household .. so seek teachers and learn from many as we are in dire times ,find teachers who have sanad that's credible InsyaAllah ... All of us are on a journey , so stop traveling from creatures to creatures like a donkey rounding a mill with the goal same as it's departure ... Cover your brothers sins ... continue seeking because knowledge can remove ignorance, and the more we learn the more we realise how little we know .. so fear Allah , when we speak ... I respect these brothers for the general da'wah they do but to see these brothers fight has caused me hurt .. even when I don't know you all and half the world away ... Remember when we want to point out something we all need witnesses .. we need hard solid evidence , like who and who saw this and that.. and the credrebility of the person.. so whatever you guys are upset , settle it privately .. Realise that this way you prove yourself to be the same or worse ... So this is just a reminder from a stranger half the world away who came back to Islam, it's better to remain humble or get humbled .. unite and respect one another ... Everyone has sins no one is free from error ... InsyaAllah let's reflect and be more cautious about what we see online ... No one can see the heart of sincerity of the person but Allah Swt , remember a person who does one simple thing and a poor man can be closer to Allah than the knowledgeable one or the rich one who becomes arrogant and causes fitna amongst each other ..
Masya Allah. Wallahi Allah is the most Merciful. The most I feels so secure was a lot of muslims call Brodah each other and hug is the best sunnah that I've felt. ❤❤❤ Alhamdulillah *3🤲🤲🤲
@@trey1293 show me first where is your arabic level before judging🤣 and for your information there is no arab country in North Africa why do they have to learn arabic properly?
@@bb4024morocco, algeria, tunisia , Libya, Muritania, Egypt are not Arabs arabs are you for real brother, by saying this this also means that middle eastern countries don't speak ?
I am not qualified to talk academically/islamically about this situation for I do not have ilm/knowledge. But, any body who has a big circle of tabdea (Making tabdea en masse) I stay away from. My humble and miniscule knowledge of the Ulama, Ibn Othaimeen, Ibn Baz & and the early scholars may Allah forgive them all and forgive, is that they do not make tabdea unless with a proof so obvious like the sun. I am always careful and keep my tongue held unless a brother is undoubtedly and non-mistakingly an innovator, and even then I leave it to the scholars and qualified people for I am scared of Allah of being held accountable. Because I love my bretheren the muslim Umma, I advise you, the tounge the tounge, do not make a judgement or a claim unless you have a proof as obvious as the sun in the hottest day on earth. May Allah Forgive me and brother hijab and brother Ali and May Allah guide shamsi and forgive him.
@@ahmadqazi2648 Brother, with all due respect, use intellect for a second and look at the video carefully. It was ALREADY being filmed by the Saudi guy's friend. They ALREADY knew. If you think Shamsi tricked him into saying it, then please do visit the source (written in the video) and watch for yourself. Does that mean the Saudi guy's friend is trying to put his friend in jail by already filming him doing this? Also, Shamsi did not upload the video, the Saudi guy's friend did. Who's trying to put who in jail...?
You just slanded us as algerians and I'm assuming you ain't got a prblm , shamsi even if he got problems we all do he is giving dawah in a country which is not his mother country and in a language which is not his primary language I'm curious what have you done to the deen !!
that Libya comment shook me... I've been trying to deny that the madkhali situation in Libya is that bad, especially that they keep using the argument of "there's no such thing as madkhalism the madkhalis is just a family name we're ahlul salaf" but to see that even you guys would use Libya as an example of the madkhali fikr is scary. I feel so sad for my country we used to have pride in that we're all sunnis and have no separation of religion and sect, but now we have 2 different Eid days, some masajid which used to bring people together are empty in taraweeh just bc someone said someone who prays there is "ikhwani", and when you ask them to define what an ikhwani person is their answers are vague, and tell you it's very subliminal and their favourite phrase is "ikhwanis put the poison in the honey" which made people have trust issues and created such a partition in the country....
Libya was broken up for its resources Oil. The people always suffer as Iraq. Don’t lose hope hold on to the Quran and the hadith. Do not desert the mosque. Pray at home also in the mosque.
Please stop, Lybia was a grave yard before the Dawah of the prophet was revived there, you guys destroyed your own country because France and Italy gave you money and you guys took it with no hesitation.
@@Harounelmrabetthe Khawarji rebelled against their leader, 2 militias of Muslims fought against each other in the civil war and destroyed themselves from within while the enemies of Islam plundered the resources of the country Libya. They hypocrites and Khawarji want this to happen to all Muslim countries. For example Morocco had a militia in the desert called polisario who want to overthrow the king. Read the hadiths and it forbids this rebeller/Khawarji behavior because it causes Muslims civil war where Muslims kill each other. Hadith says he who picks up arms against us is not from us and if a Muslim kills another Muslim, both are in the hellfire.
Leave this incident aside let's not even talk about it but does it change the fact that these madkhali sellouts are more focused on declaring fellow muslims as innovators etc than talking about rights of muslims being oppressed...
@@mahdiabdu4329 you right, but sometimes shamsi does this to scare the other person or to prove a point, That's why we need to see the full video. im not here to defend shamsi. to say this is an act of hypocrisy over this clip is something outrageous. may Allah guide us all.
bros u r both tried and tested and we love u very much .. my tip would be to make shamsi understand that "salaf" startss at sahaba and ends on sahaba . the rest are as much average scholars as any persian or tajik scholar . shamsi thinks from prespective of a frog trapped inside small puddle . i remember i hated him for him doing indirect takfeer on all muslims except his creed , he didnt say it but clearly implied .. anyhow nuf with him . u two are best and we respect and adore u like our own blood
When you don’t have a real job, you can just hang around the park for years and years and eventually you can get paid to be there. Some of these brothers doing “Dawah” lack basic manners, etiquette, actual qualifications, and are super harsh. The only way a decent human being would respect a person giving dawah is if they actually respect your opinion. It’s sad to see how toxic we can be with each other, non Muslims laugh and pray we continue the fitnah. Believers gotta look out for each other and elevate each other. If we don’t have each other backs, why should Allah help us? We gotta get back to the way of our beloved prophet Muhammad. The blueprint is all there for us.. don’t waste our precious moments in the dunya, especially dealing with each other. Nobody is better than each other, the people of knowledge who studied under great teachers have wisdom and manners.
@@dwsir2448 yeah he gets paid to spread his cults message lmao, his youtube channel stinks, and his manners dealing with people who have a different opinion is pathetic. Tell him to learn Arabic, since he already got schooled by Hijab whos a native arabic speaker. Shamsi doesn't unite people, he thinks him and his other cult members are the most wise and on the right path. I don't care what good you think he does, there's so much negative and he is not humble enough to admit his mistakes. Where does he mention Palestine, china, or other Muslim countries? Ive heard this guy call people the worst things.
A real job?? So calling people to Allah isn’t a real job. Sit down you pathetic keyboard warrior. these brothers are doing the best of jobs there isn’t a realer job in creation.
@@dwsir2448 exactly imagine talking down at brothers who are doing dawah and saying it isn’t a real job.. they face the kuffar and attack at face on a daily bases
No muslim daee is getting paid to be in speaker's corner...but Christians yes.. Regarding opinions... we're not supposed to just respect and accept any opinion especially if it's against what had been prescribed in the Quran and sunnah
I remember i visited speakers corner in 2018 the day when this fued between Hijab and Shamsi started (white tank top video). It's a shame that this has still continued for so long and is not any closer to being resolved. I just hope that Allah SWT guides whoever is in the wrong in this situation towards to the truth. Imagine a untied team of Shamsi, Ali Dawah and Mohammed Hijab. Would be unstoppable
@John-zi3pn Firstly, No one said you should cooperate with Ahl Al-Bidaa. Secondly, You're not a scholar to make Tabdee on someone just because he did a Bidaa, that IF it's really a bidaa ! Thirdly, Bidaa is like Kufr, you don't make tabdee on someone without looking into conditions. Lastly, It's Haram to backbite Muslims just because they made mistake, that IF it's mistake ! And the matter goes on, I'll stop here. May Allah guide us.
Regarding Abu Khadija, (and I'm not slandering here to our brother may Allah guide him and all of us) I know someone in person who studied in Pakistan under Abu Khadija, and he listens to his lectures in RU-vid. He sent some of them to me and I listened out of good faith. The one lecture I heard (not complete) he was screaming about being proud calling ourselves Salafi. I'm A Salafi, but I heard from great scholars such as Ibn Othaimen (may Allah have mercy on him) and Saleh Al-Fawzan who showed that Salafism is acting as the Salaf did, not calling ourselves salafis, we should call ourselves Muslims as Allah said in the Quran. Second important thing that he told me directly, Abu Khadija isn't a scholar, he's a translator to the book of salaf. And they teach some good books, AND they teach some of Rabee Al-Madkhali's books.
@John-zi3pn You're an absolute ignorant And you also slander your brother as liar without asking for more details or giving excuses ! And then straight to call the manhaj an Ikhwani manhaj This is the what Madhkalism is To teach you, Calling yourself Salafi or Sunni to differ yourself from other sects is permissible But the righteous name is Muslim as mentioned in the QURAN !!! Are those who call themselves Muslim are Ikhwanis in your perspective ! This is a mere ignorant and whoever say so is ignorant also Sheikh Mustafa AlAdawi a great salafi scholar in the level of sheikh Saleh AlFawzan says we should call ourselves Muslims as Ibrahim peace be upon him said in the Quran, do you call him Ikhwani ? May Allah guide you and help you brother.
@John-zi3pn Why don't you go into details ? Who told you that you can't cooperate with Ahl Al-Bidaa completely? Who are these Ahl Al-Bidaa you're talking about ? Who made Tabdee to them ? Is it a Tabdee such as Shamsi's Tabdee to other Muslims ? Leave these issues to scholars.
Wasn't u doing the same prison bait questions to brothers in speakers corner 🤔 ie . U support I.s or condemn anjem . I think no one understands until it affects them 😂
عندما ينتقد الدول العربية و الاسلامية فهذا شيئ عادي ولابأس به و لا خوف عليه ولم نسمع صوتا لأاحد اما عند طلب الاخ انتقاده للدول الغربية فهنا الخوف عليه و فلما الزدواجية في المعايير
@@najkon1 so when you see something wrong you need a PhD or a a masters to talk about? I suggest you to go get qualification before commenting on such topics.
@@MrIslamdeen bro just move on if you're not gonna answer the question. He is questioning Shamsi's qualifications, so he should have some. Otherwise he is just being a hypocrite. I agree Shamsi is probably wrong on this but don't question qualifications when you don't have any yourself.
@@najkon1 clearly not listening 11:35, first of all they weren't referencing any 'topics', clearly state here 11:50, Secondly he cant speak English or Arabic how you go to communicate those qualifications if any?
I'm not fan of any of u guys not even shamsi.. So you are talking about backbiting and stood against a Muslim bro. what are you guys exactly doing here?? Anything different?? You all are my bros but i hate it when you guys accuse someone the same way he used. Ali my bro you were also back lashed and humiliated few months ago I didn't see you locked up yourself but justifying. If he does not know either of languages then how come he is communicating with people and explaining Islam?? Did you ask him his explanation about the topic?? A video clip and you guys decide he is wrong?? No one is perfect here you should have asked him personally but not by making fun of a Muslim brother you RU-vid. You are giving dawa I appreciate that may Allah reward you but think also about vast population of other Muslims around the globe being killed humiliated raped locked kidnapped turned homeless just bcoz they are muslim and I'm from one of the places! Stop humiliating each other respect each other and clear misunderstanding between. May Allah show us right path.
Number 3 shemsy is arab and does master arabic language very well, so stick to the subject without using "lamz" and mocking his origin, you have no right to mock origins of people that's an arogant act in deed. And why are you sitting here discussing that among yourselves and slandering him instead of invinting him to clarify things? No benifit of such a video to be honest
@sp-files82 What's terrible here is not his language but your attitude... The fact that you re defending the other guy who is a promoter of "rebellion against rulers" and mocking shemsy who's reminding us about the prophet's (ﷺ) ahadeeth regarding rebellion is what seems paradoxal. My conclusion may be wrong but that's what I thought. May Allah guide us all ameen Shemsy was not promoting his own opinion but talking based on Kitab and SUnnah. Khorooj leads eventually to the spilling of innocent blood, the collapse of societies, disorder, the loss of Religion and Religious education for a generation or more! We have seen that with our own eyes!!! The Prophet (ﷺ) prohibited it in clear and decisive narrations that cannot possibly be opposed by desires, opinion and reason or by the erroneous judgements of men, regardless of their station the sight of the people and no one disagreed with it except the Khawārij, the Shi’ah, the Mu’tazilah and their offshoots until this time of ours. And what's rebellion (khorooj)? It's is defined as attempting to snatch away authority from the ruler, opposing him publicly, attempting to force him out of office, inciting the people against him (through demonstrations, rallies, public protests, strikes, etc), plotting against him and rising up to challenge him with writings, sermonising or the sword. Ahadeeth: 1- Muslim reported in his Sahīh (1847) from Wā’il Ibn Hujr that: Salamah Ibn Yazeed Al-Ju’fee asked Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ): “O Prophet of Allah, what do we do if we have rulers over us who demand their rights yet they withhold our rights?” He replied: “Listen to them and obey them [regardless]. Upon them is their burden and on you will be your burden.” 2- “Whoever sees from his leader something that he dislikes, then let him be patient with him because whosoever separates from the jamā’ah (i.e. the body of Muslims in a country) even by a handspan, and then dies in that condition, he will die the death of pre-Islamic ignorance (jāhiliyyah).” 3- “You are obligated to listen to the ruler and obey him in times of ease and in times of hardship, whether you are pleased or displeased and even when another person is given preference over you (while you were more deserving).” 4- “You will see after me severe preferential treatment (to those less deserving than you), so be patient until you meet Allah and you meet His Messenger at the drinking lake (Al-Hawd).” So they responded, “We shall be patient.” 5- “Listen to the ruler and obey him when it is hard for you and when it is easy for you, whether you are pleased or displeased, and when others are given preference over you, and even when they consume your wealth and beat your back.” (Delared sahīh by Al-Albāni; see Dhilāl Al-Jannah and At-Ta’līqāt Al-Hisān). 6- Ibn Abī ‘Āsim reported in As-Sunnah (2/508) from ‘Adiyy Ibn Hātim (may Allah be pleased with him) that we said: “O Messenger of Allah, we do not ask you regarding obedience to the ruler who has taqwā (who is pious and who fears Allah), and is good and rectifies. Rather, we are asking about the ruler who does such-and-such and such-and-such?“ And he mentioned their evil traits. So the Prophet (ﷺ) answered: “Fear Allah! Listen to the ruler and obey him.” (Also reported by At-Tabarāni in Al-Kabīr, 17/101, and authenticated by Al-Albāni in Dhilāl Al-Jannah) What Shaikh Al-Islām Ibn Taymiyyah (may Allah’s mercy be upon him) said is: “Being patient with the tyranny of the rulers is a fundamental principle (asl) from the fundamentals of Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jamā’ah.” (Majmoo’ Al-Fatāwa 28/179) And said: “There have not been a people who revolted against their ruler except that their condition after their rebellion was worse than before they rebelled.” (Minhāj As-Sunnah 3/231) Imām Ahmad Ibn Hanbal (may Allah have mercy upon him) said: “Whoever does that (agitators) is an innovator, upon other than the Sunnah and upon other than the Straight Path.”
@@sp-files82to be fair with you, I just finished a video of Mohammed hijab speaking Arabic with shamsi in a old video, and he was making mistakes and shamsi correcting him.
@pascalinapascalino I'm not calling to any type of rebellion. However those ahadith refer to obeying the Muslim Ruler not Tawagheet who have nullified their Islam by replacing the Ahkaam of Allah. You will never find daleel from Qur'an or Sunnah saying that doing this is anything except Kufr akbar but only by twisting certain ayat and ahadith. Again the ayat of Allah and Sunnah are clear that whoever does this is a Kaafir, Mushrik who has left the fold of Islam. The aqwaal of the Ulama also back this up and ultimately we will have to stand before Allah and account for our beliefs.
u guys: he is doing nifaq, not saying he's a munafiq, but just saying u r doing what munafiqs do them: if u criticize the ruler, ppl will hate the ruler, then they will do khuruj- thus u lead to khuruj- thus u r a khariji, then ppl will rebel- thus u lead to rebellion- so u r a rebel, then they will be killed by the ruler, thus u will be responsible for their death
Always be weary of a North African Salafi. It's not the way of the tribes there, but an import trend that has been imposed by the local authorities, who brought it from Saudi Arabia in the 80's, in order to counter the Civil and political dissidence of the Political Sunni Islam in the region. So, the writing's on the wall as they say.
Before going further, may Ali and Hijab, may Allaah bless you give a verdict on your hairstyles? As far as my little knowledge is concerned there is a hadeeth that ''cursed is the one who shave like your hair styles. A woman went with her baby to the messenger to ask the Du'aah for his baby and the messenger refused and told the woman to go and level the hairs of her baby which were shaven like yours? So i advice you upon the athari aqeedah and following the sunnah
IMPORTANT NOTE: Najashi (ra) NEVER believed isa is the son of god. He was concerned when he heard something from Amr bin al as that would anger him and see the Muslims as heretics of isa’s message. So he inquired about it. It is basic knowledge that (Amr bin Al as ) used a tactic to try & get the Muslims in trouble, since according to them Christian’s (in their view) all believe such a myth that isa ibn maryam is the 1 in a 1/3, but not everyone did. Many were Unitarian Christian’s. Many were not open about it. So anyway the plot failed. Because Najashi himself not only didn’t disagree with the Muslims but rather seemed to agree with the belief to the point that he said the beliefs “come from the same fountain”. There are also in the reports of him writing his correct belief on parchment that he’d keep with him.
إذا ادخلتم السياسة في دعوتكم ستخسرون. بارك الله فيكم ابتعدوا عن مشاكل العرب فهي معقدة وركزوا على دعوة الناس الى الاسلام واعتصموا بحبل الله جميعا فأنتم في جهاد.
Shamsi he is Not perfect like you and all of us. and his shortcomings are nothing compared to what he is doing. Soo don't make him look bad we love him for the sake of الله ❤❤❤ PEACE AND LOVE from Coastal Kenya
Leave this incident aside let's not even talk about it but does it change the fact that these madkhali sellouts are more focused on declaring fellow muslims as innovators etc than talking about rights of muslims being oppressed...
People saying deal with this privately are naive. Confronting the rainbow ideology and injustice of oppressive rulers are the two great Mihna (trials) of this era.
Stop stop stop talking about each other. Please forgive and correct each other. We are only humans and we all make mistakes. Stop talking about each other and belittling each other. What you guys are doing is dividing the Ummah. What would prophet Mohammad (AS) do when there are disagreements or differences? 🤔
and do not back-bite one another. Do any of you (who back-bite) love to eat the flesh of your dead brother? Rather, you detest this act, therefore have consciousness of Allah. Certainly Allah is the One who is Oft-Turning to you in repentance, the Merciful. (49:12). Fear Allah all of you
