Тёмный

Sharrow MX3 Prop on a Robalo R302 

BoatTEST.com
Подписаться 169 тыс.
Просмотров 29 тыс.
50% 1

BoatTEST recently conducted a test on the innovative Sharrow propellers, but due to popular demand, this one was a little different. We didn’t test it on a commercial boat, or a large catamaran, a massive center console, or a tiny bowrider. No, this time it was on what is probably the most average size, weight and category of boat out there… the Robalo R302.
Read more about our test here: boattest.com/n...

Опубликовано:

 

7 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 66   
@floridaoutdooradventures8981
It's good to see you Captain Steve! Welcome back -:)
@kfeltenberger
@kfeltenberger Год назад
I really like this technology but given that Sharrow's website says they have props for inboard drives, I would really like to see how these impact the performance on something in the 50-60' range or thereabouts. Outboards are fine...and if that's all they're going to focus on, that's ok. But if they offer something for an inboard, I think it would be a good test to see how it works on a distance cruiser or express cruiser.
@regressmenot
@regressmenot Год назад
I'm hoping you do a few more test videos on a variety of boats... Targa, Aquila, Beneteau. Would be interesting to see how well they perform on these types of boats.
@michiganengineer8621
@michiganengineer8621 Год назад
I would still like to see comparison numbers on a boat designed with inboard shaft drives. Say a Nordhavn, Hatteras or Viking
@connerw25
@connerw25 Год назад
Hoping the price comes down, would love to get one for my 115 Optimax
@mkp3824
@mkp3824 Год назад
There's an MJM 35z for sale at Vermillion yachts in Ohio that has the Sharrow props on the Mercury 300's. They get about 5 mph more at midrange speeds, from going 19mph to going 25mph at same rpm.
@switawivr6
@switawivr6 Год назад
I realize these are expensive but how does the pricing compare to any high-end custom props out there? Seems to me the engineering is solid and the pricing just needs to come down for the wider market to benefit from them. If Sharrow can score a deal with outboard OEM or even boat manufacturer to make an optional or upgrade prop for their most popular models that would be huge for this design.
@A5JDZK
@A5JDZK Год назад
It would be awesome if they were more affordable!!!
@surfstarcc1
@surfstarcc1 11 месяцев назад
Great test, im looking into these props. 👍
@lmyachts5238
@lmyachts5238 Год назад
Would the Sharrows work on a displacement power boat, Captain Steve?
@KamronFultz
@KamronFultz Год назад
I want to see them put one of these propellers on a tunneled hull boat like a Dargel or a Shallow Sport, and see how it does getting up in shallow water
@smannee
@smannee Год назад
I hope they start making an aluminum variant for small outboards 15-40 hp.
@jstefa2
@jstefa2 Год назад
yamaha licensed them fev months ago... i think they will become a standard option for all yamaha outboards.
@TeachMeTheGuitar
@TeachMeTheGuitar Год назад
A pair for the Silent Yacht would be badass.
@besearchingforwisdom6267
@besearchingforwisdom6267 Год назад
The Sharrow props have 6 blades effectively, and clearly more effective, and while the surface area of the blades are not apparently larger, the efficiency matches an increase in blade numbers. I would be interested in a test comparing the sharrow to a four five or six blade prop including the costs of each type. Good show
@w8stral
@w8stral Год назад
Uh, no: Most efficient, would be a single blade... but due to balance this is not a good option. One only needs more blades when one starts being impacted by cavitation due to excessive RPM to diameter ratio. So, lower the RPM and you will always be better, but this also makes a propeller with a lower optimum range of thrust. There is no free lunch. Sharrow propellers effectively eliminate the vortice loses and also increase the angle of attack effective at the tips so one delays cavitation at the tip while maintaining thrust. This is an ENORMOUS loss standard propellers have which it does not and why at mid range one sees the largest improvements as this loss is delayed significantly.
@alanploetz7100
@alanploetz7100 Год назад
I like the idea of the greater efficiency, both speed and fuel burn. Unfortunately, I'm not sure I'd get sufficient fuel efficiency to make up for the initial cost of the Sharrows ove the life of the engines.
@flacjacket
@flacjacket Год назад
The question isn't whether they would pay for themselves in fuel savings, it's whether the fuel savings would adequately defray the costs to the point you can justify it for the improvement in NVH, speed, time to plane, and low speed maneuverability and range. When you are spending $300k on a boat then $10k may be worth it even without the fuel savings for those other improvements.
@judithmikula7521
@judithmikula7521 Год назад
Would like to see a test on a bass boat
@jhelwig19781
@jhelwig19781 Год назад
Great video Steve! I’ll eat the $5000 cost to save fuel economy, have better performance, and simply exact more joy in driving a boat.
@adamdavis4690
@adamdavis4690 Год назад
Come on, I need to see a duoprop in action!!
@Drake5153
@Drake5153 Год назад
I'd love to see what range Sharrow has when it comes to performance, can they compete/cover the surface drive props?
@korndawggy1801
@korndawggy1801 Год назад
Would like to see a test on a 18-21 ft fishing/family boat if they make one for a boat that size.
@S.V.TeFiti
@S.V.TeFiti Год назад
Whats the story on a diesel outboard with Sharrow.? ultimate range?
@curtalden2223
@curtalden2223 Год назад
HEY CAN YOU DO A TEST OF THE MERCURY RACING 250HP MOTORS AND MAYBE THE 450's???
@stevey_z
@stevey_z Год назад
I want two
@Bubbles99718
@Bubbles99718 Год назад
2 questions: Boat Test is pushing this directly, what are the kick backs, if any? Seems there may be some. 2. If this was feasible Merc or another big player would have picked them up. Any offers in this area? What's the inside story on that? One way or the other. This has the oder of an infomercial about it
@BoatTEST
@BoatTEST Год назад
no kickbacks. we have always supportive innovators and believe this is one of those those innovations that finally challenges the regular prop. We like the prop and we will continue testing it for you all. they are now have a partnership with yamaha so we think it's not going anywhere.
@Bubbles99718
@Bubbles99718 Год назад
@@BoatTEST Thx for responding and the Yamaha connection is interesting, and helps to validate this. It's difficult to get credibility until either it takes off or a major player steps in.
@jstefa2
@jstefa2 Год назад
yamaha picked them up. they should be out soon.
@lewiswatchorn7239
@lewiswatchorn7239 Год назад
At $5k per prop, there absolutely must be a trial program so owners can try before they buy.
@elainepeng8848
@elainepeng8848 Год назад
What will these propellers change the calibration for joystick systems such as Yamaha helm master ?
@stevendavis7723
@stevendavis7723 Год назад
$10,000 for 2 props !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ooooffff
@michiganengineer8621
@michiganengineer8621 Год назад
closer to $10k each last I looked
@trappenator96
@trappenator96 Год назад
Can you test the prop on a Rossiter 20
@Clayshooter100
@Clayshooter100 Год назад
I'd like to see these Sharrow propellers compared to other propellers designed for fuel economy (such as the Mercury Enertia ECO). The Yamaha SWS ll props are good but aren't nearly the most efficient conventional propeller on the market.
@Bubbles99718
@Bubbles99718 Год назад
This is an infomercial, that's why
@Clayshooter100
@Clayshooter100 Год назад
@@Bubbles99718 Correct
@ronmolaro5085
@ronmolaro5085 Год назад
10K for Twins 😮
@robertneilson3819
@robertneilson3819 Год назад
5000 per prop??
@cesarpalmos8235
@cesarpalmos8235 Год назад
You say they have 44 different props, but they are completely custom made and blueprinted to your boat.
@planblaine8433
@planblaine8433 Год назад
At 5 grand y’all out y’all mind.
@codyepperson6796
@codyepperson6796 Год назад
how much they cost ?
@GavinKohAquascaping
@GavinKohAquascaping Год назад
From what I've read, it is about $5K each.
@alanploetz7100
@alanploetz7100 Год назад
I think they fall in the category of, " if you have to ask, you can't afford them."
@w8stral
@w8stral Год назад
@@alanploetz7100 Its a luxury boat... if you have to ask, you can't afford the boat, get a kayak.
@curtalden2223
@curtalden2223 Год назад
HOW LONG BEFORE THE ROI ON THE PROPS FOR A TWIN? I HEARD THEY WERE MAD EXPENSIVE. HOW LONG WOULD IT TAKE TO MAKE IT WORTH WHILE????
@chrisdabfabbott
@chrisdabfabbott Год назад
Price comparison?
@captainbobette
@captainbobette Год назад
A lot, in Canada it’s around 9000 each prop vs 1600 for an enertia prop
@chrisdabfabbott
@chrisdabfabbott Год назад
@@captainbobette Holy crap! That buys a lot of gas!!
@napalmhotdog4365
@napalmhotdog4365 Год назад
@@chrisdabfabbott if you have the boat for a long time and you use it a lot, it will probably pay itself back in fuel saved
@ianhood8081
@ianhood8081 Год назад
@@napalmhotdog4365 not to mention the reduced wear on the engines if you're running them at lower rpm's for the same speeds.
@MrMattMohler
@MrMattMohler 10 месяцев назад
300 gallons!? I know I'm poor, but dam....
@qiaozhang8321
@qiaozhang8321 Год назад
pricing incorrectly, this is just a simple item made of steels, once a model is set up (with CAD), massive production can be made easy.. The high price is blocking majority from buying it. If it is priced at fifteen instead of fifty, many will buy, and most of us will find it not worth it as it does not seem to help, thus causing lots of negative comments everywhere. Therefore, the pricing strategy is, selling for very high, only a few buys, for those who bought it, they will not admit their wrong decision.
@squirts1
@squirts1 Год назад
these read more like an advertisement than an independent test.
@paulswagelock5986
@paulswagelock5986 Год назад
I call BS. Look at the original review of the Robalo 302 from Boattest. In that article it showed 3500 rpm was 31 mph, but in this “comparison video” you claim the standard props only produce 21 mph at 3500 rpm and the special Sharrow pop does 31. Were you wrong back then or now……..
@ekbusdriver
@ekbusdriver Год назад
This is my only issue with these tests. Nobody, and I mean nobody, pushes the rpm’s to 3500 and hopes the boat will get on plane. Power up on plane and then come back to the rpm you want, and I want to see the Sharrows tested like that. I believe they are more efficient, just not as much as these tests show.
@davygravy7332
@davygravy7332 Год назад
@@ekbusdriver I like the concept of getting rid of the propeller tip vortex, but it looks to me like a modified 6 bladed propeller, and that should be more efficient. If there is less slip at RPM then you are accelerating the water faster which equates to more thrust. Moving the water at a higher rate also reduces the drag imposed on the boat, does not pull the stern of the boat down into the water as much, this would alow the boat to plane at a lower speed. But more blades are not as efficient at high speed.
@POKAIONTOP
@POKAIONTOP Год назад
The price is insane, its no way they are that much better. I mean the prop for my 115Hp Murcury is maybe 3-500 USD. So it has to be 3-10 Times better to be worth it. It almost feels like a scam to be honest....
@carlwestfall2006
@carlwestfall2006 Год назад
Price too High! Would sell 5x more if it was reasonable $2500 would be doable!
@Happy-Honkey
@Happy-Honkey Год назад
How much were you paid for this infomercial?
@slabslayer258
@slabslayer258 Год назад
Lol 😂
@JoseRivera-zi2ph
@JoseRivera-zi2ph Год назад
To expensive not affordable
@w8stral
@w8stral Год назад
You pay $100,000 on a boat and spend $5k on fuel... yet bitch about a propeller... on a luxury item... You sir, are an idiot
@camd5348
@camd5348 Год назад
This is total bs. Price is ludicrous. How about we see a price for normal man boats. And normal man tests. #outtolunch
@RLC2020
@RLC2020 Год назад
nice paid advertisement from Sharrow. How much is your credibility worth nowadays?
Далее
Sharrow Marine - Showdown in Paradise by BoatTEST.com
13:00
Robalo Factory Tour 2024 - Hosted by Randy Vance
11:47
The Unexpected Genius of Bionic Propellers
11:48
Просмотров 1,7 млн
FS Boat Review - Robalo R302
5:27
Просмотров 21 тыс.
Why is this Propeller Getting So Much Attention?
12:29
Testing the New Sharrow Propeller
8:09
Просмотров 12 тыс.